There have been many versions of IDE over the years, and all the numbers and specifications can be a bit intimidating when you’re trying to select the correct drive for a particular system. In this Daily Drill Down, I’ll answer some of the most common IDE questions and decipher the standard’s acronyms and specs.
Why worry about IDE standards?
Today’s IDE subsystems are capable of achieving phenomenal data-transfer rates, up to 100 Mbps. In order for you to make those high speeds a reality, however, all three parts of the hardware equation—the drive, the ribbon cable, and the motherboard or I/O card—have to support that transfer rate. Unless you understand the IDE standards, you won’t be able to ensure that you’re getting the highest possible transfer rates from your hard disks and other IDE devices. So if you’re unsure about the difference between ATA-2 and UltraATA, or you don’t know what kind of cable a UDMA/100 bus requires, keep reading.
What is IDE?
Integrated Drive Electronics (IDE) is a generic term that refers to a disk drive with a built-in controller. The controller for the drive is built in to the drive unit itself rather than on a separate board. Back in the earliest days of hard-disk technology, the hard disk and its controller were two separate pieces. With an IDE drive, however, the drive controller is part of the package. You’ve probably noticed that a hard disk has a circuit board strapped to the bottom; that’s the integrated drive controller. With an IDE drive, when the controller goes bad, the drive is toast as well.
IDE was a real revolution in PC technology when it first came out because it meant that drive makers did not have to ensure that their drives were compatible with a particular controller standard. As a result, they could develop higher performance drive/controller combinations that spoke their own proprietary language. While today’s motherboards provide IDE connectors, the IDE controller is actually in each of the drives. The motherboard merely communicates with those controllers. The same is true for any I/O card you might add to a PC: It merely adds more IDE connectors and lets the motherboard talk to them.
Is IDE the same specification as ATA?
Is IDE the same specification as Advanced Technology Attachment (ATA)? Well, yes and no. It didn’t used to be so, but nowadays, for all practical purposes, they are synonymous. ATA is also called AT Attachment, a reference to the fact that the ATA standard was originally developed for AT computers (of which the 286 was the first model), rather than XTs.
There have been three different versions of the IDE interface over the years:
- XT IDE (8-bit ISA): This was the original IDE standard for XT computers (8086 models). It used a 40-pin connector.
- MCA IDE (16-bit MicroChannel): This was a proprietary standard developed by IBM for its MicroChannel Architecture PC bus; a great idea that failed miserably in the marketplace and quickly became obsolete. It used a 72-pin connector.
- ATA IDE (16-bit ISA): This is the same 16-bit ISA, originally developed for the 80286 system, that is still found in systems today. It uses a 40-pin connector, but not the same type as the XT IDE.
Each of these types of IDE used a different cabling, so you couldn’t mix and match them on the same bus. Of the three, only ATA remains; the other two are obsolete. So when you hear people talk about an IDE drive today, you can bet they’re referring to an ATA drive. The other two standards have been dead for at least 10 years.
What is EIDE?
EIDE stands for Enhanced IDE. There are two ways in which the term EIDE is used in the industry. One is to refer specifically to an ATA-2 or ATA-3 type drive. (See the section “What are the different types of ATA?”) Another is to refer to any IDE drive that conforms to any ATA specification other than the original one—in other words, ATA-2 or higher. So when you see EIDE in a drive specification, you can’t really assume very much—the term has become almost as generic as IDE itself.
What are UltraATA and UltraDMA?
These terms are interchangeable. Both refer to a specification for improving hard disk speed. UltraDMA is often abbreviated UDMA; in this Daily Drill Down, I’ll use UDMA for simplicity’s sake. PC manufacturers will often use Ultra ATA in their system specifications, but rest assured that it’s the same as UDMA. There are actually three different specs: UDMA/33, UDMA/66, and UDMA/100. You’ll learn more about them in “What are the different types of ATA?”
What is SMART?
SMART stands for Self-Monitoring Analysis and Reporting Technology. It’s a standard for predicting the likelihood of impending failure for a hard disk. The software originated at Western Digital and was later integrated into the ATA standard. You enable SMART support in the system BIOS. It’s used by drives of the ATA-3 standard and above.
SMART checks a drive and establishes a threshold for its performance in several areas. It can then notify the user when any of those measurements falls below the performance threshold, possibly signaling an impending drive failure. Some of the factors it checks are head floating height, data throughput performance, spin-up time, seek error rate, seek time performance, and drive calibration retry count.
Some utilities, such as Norton Utilities, provide a SMART status indicator as part of their Windows-based controls, but this is not really necessary. If SMART detects a problem, it will pass an error message to you through your operating system, so you can back up your important files before your hard disk fails.
SMART is different from the active disk-checking utilities that you might run, such as ScanDisk or Norton Disk Doctor. These utilities check the logical organization of the file allocation table (FAT), followed by an optional physical check of the disk surface. They do not monitor any of the drive-performance factors, such as the number of times that the drive has to retry a certain function before it succeeds. In addition, these active utilities must be user-initiated, either manually by running a program or automatically using some sort of scheduling agent, such as the Task Scheduler in Windows 9x. So you really need both SMART and a disk-utility program such as ScanDisk for best data-integrity assurance.
What are the different types of ATA?
An organization called the National Committee on Information Technology Standards (NCITS) sets the standards for ATA, so that all drive and PC manufacturers have a common set of rules to work from. NCITS has come up with six versions of ATA over the years:
- ATA-1: The original ATA was ATA-1. It was developed in 1988, a few years after SCSI came out. It introduced the 40-pin connector and ribbon cable, as well as the master/slave/cable select configuration options. It also provided specifications for signal timing for Programmed I/O (PIO) and Direct Memory Access (DMA) modes and Cylinder Head Sector (CHS) and Logical Block Address (LBA) drive parameter translations. Another great feature introduced in ATA-1 was the Identify Drive command, which the BIOS setup program could use to auto-detect the drive specifications. With earlier hard disks, you had to manually set up the drive type in the BIOS program, either by a numeric drive type or by entering the number of cylinders, heads, and so on. On ATA drives, however, the drive can send this information to the BIOS setup program upon request.
- ATA-2: ATA-2 came out in 1996. It added the capability to use other storage devices on an ATA interface, not just hard disks. It also allowed for faster PIO and DMA transfer modes, support for PC Card (PCMCIA) drives, and support for power-management schemes that allowed the hard disk to spin down after a certain period of idleness to conserve power (especially battery power on a laptop). And finally, it defined CHS/LBA translation for drives of up to 8.4 GB. Other names for ATA-2 include Fast-ATA, Fast ATA-2, and EIDE. Not all vendors agree, however, that ATA-2 is really EIDE.
- ATA-3: A minor 1997 update to ATA-2, ATA-3 added support for SMART technology, added a security mode for password protection, and eliminated the 8-bit DMA transfer protocols. ATA-3 drives are also referred to as EIDE.
- ATA-4: This 1998 revision introduced UltraDMA (UDMA), with transfer modes up to 33 Mbps. This is commonly referred to as UDMA/33 or UltraATA/33. UDMA/33 operates at twice the speed of the fastest PIO or DMA mode. To take advantage of it, your motherboard or I/O card must support UDMA/33 or higher. UDMA/33 uses Cyclical Redundancy Checks (CRC) to ensure that the data being written is correct. ATA-4 also introduced support for an optional 80-wire, 40-pin ribbon cable that helped cut down on noise resistance (cross talk) and integrated the AT Attachment Packet Interface (ATAPI), which had formerly been a separate standard. This allowed CD-ROM drives, tape drives, and other removable storage devices to work under a common interface standard.
- ATA-5: This standard, introduced in 1999, offered UDMA/66, providing transfer modes up to 66 Mbps. The only glitch (and it’s a minor one) is that you need an 80-conductor cable to take advantage of the higher transfer rate. If you have only a standard IDE cable, the drive will operate at UDMA/33 speeds. The drive automatically detects the type of cable in use. Again, the motherboard or I/O card must be capable of UDMA/66 in order to get the top speeds. By the way, the card has only the normal 40 pins. The extra 40 wires are grounds placed between each data wire to provide shielding. In theory, the normal 40-pin wire could work if it was of sufficient quality and shielded, but it’s not cost effective. Note that the 80-conductor cable is much more delicate than the standard 40-conductor cable because the wires have to be finer to fit in the extra 40 wires.
- ATA-6: This is a brand-new standard in 2000, offering UDMA/100 with transfer rates of up to 100 Mbps. As with ATA-5, you must have an 80-conductor cable; otherwise the drive will revert back to UDMA/33 performance. And again, the motherboard or I/O card must be UDMA/100-capable; if it isn’t, the drive will revert to the top speed that it does support: UDMA/33 or UDMA/66.
How does rotational speed fit in?
Some drives are advertised according to their rotational speed—that is, the speed at which the drive spins its disks or platters, in revolutions per minute (rpm). Generally speaking, a higher rpm means higher drive performance. An rpm of 5600 is typical of a UDMA/33 drive, while an rpm of 7200 is commonly found on UDMA/66 drives.
Because a drive advertised as 7200 rpm typically comes with an 80-conductor ribbon cable, you might get the idea that the two factors are somehow connected. Not so. A 7200-rpm drive will operate at 7200 rpm regardless of the type of ribbon cable it uses. The rotational speed is a separate factor from the UDMA mode (that is, the data transfer rate). A 7200-rpm drive, however, is generally a much better performer than a 5600-rpm drive in terms of seek time (the amount of time the drive takes to get to the data) and often in actual transfer rate. Increases in data density could conceivably result in a lower speed, higher density drive that has a faster transfer rate than a lower density, faster speed drive.
Can I mix and match ATA versions in a system?
You can mix and match ATA versions in a system, but you might cheat yourself out of the best performance. Whenever all the conditions are not met for a particular level of ATA performance, the drive drops back down to the performance level that the entire subsystem can mutually agree upon. (Each IDE connector on the motherboard or I/O card is a separate subsystem.)
Suppose, for example, you have a brand-new UDMA/66 drive. In order for it to function at UDMA/66 levels, all of the following must be true:
- The motherboard or I/O card must support UDMA/66.
- You must be using an 80-conductor ribbon cable.
- There must not be any other drives on the same cable that have a lesser ATA specification.
If any one of those factors is not in place, the drive will still function, but not at UDMA/66 levels.
That last item on the list—the requirement that the device not share a cable with a device of a lesser ATA specification—can be a real kicker, especially in a system that’s full of IDE devices. If your motherboard has only two IDE connectors and you have four IDE devices you need to use, you might not have a choice about the hard disk sharing a cable with some other device. If the highest UDMA performance is important to you and another device on the chain is slowing things down, you might want to buy a separate I/O card for some of your IDE devices so that the UDMA/66 hard disk can be on its own cable. If you absolutely must put a fast drive, such as an UDMA/66 drive, on the same cable as another device, choose a CD-ROM drive rather than a lesser hard disk, and make the lesser device the slave.
How can I maximize IDE performance on an existing system?
The key to maximizing IDE performance on an existing system is to identify the bottleneck in the system and then eliminate it. Your first step should be to identify the motherboard’s native IDE support mode. Does it support UDMA/33, UDMA/66, and/or UDMA/100? Perhaps the documentation will tell, or perhaps there will be something in the BIOS Help about it. The chipset on the motherboard determines this; for example, the Intel 810e and 820 chipsets support UDMA/66, while the Intel 815 chipset supports UDMA/100.
Next, check the drive that you want to use with it for the same support capability. Check the BIOS under IDE devices for the model number. If that fails, look on the outside of the drive for a label that might provide a clue or look up the drive’s model on the manufacturer’s Web site to get its specifications.
If your motherboard is going to hold the drive back (for example, a motherboard that supports only UDMA/33), consider adding a high-speed PCI-based IDE interface card that matches the capability of the drive. Don’t forget, too, that you need an 80-conductor cable for UDMA/66 and UDMA/100.
In this Daily Drill Down, I discussed the many versions of IDE and sorted out their numbers and specifications. I also answered some of the most common IDE questions so that you can choose the correct drive for a particular system.
The authors and editors have taken care in preparation of the content contained herein but make no expressed or implied warranty of any kind and assume no responsibility for errors or omissions. No liability is assumed for any damages. Always have a verified backup before making any changes.