Follow this blog:
RSS
Email Alert

Cracking Open

Boogie Board Rip Teardown: Overpriced and a few features short

Takeaway: The Boogie Board Rip is a solid e-writer, but two missing features and a relatively high price keep it from being a perfect pen and paper replacement.

If you’d like to ditch the paper notepad for a digital device, but don’t want a full-blown tablet, an e-writer may be the perfect gadget.

The Boogie Board Rip electronic writing device has a 9.5″ LCD. According to the manufacturer, the unit’s 8MB of internal storage is capable of storing “200 typical images”. The rechargeable Li-Ion battery is rated for 60 days of standby time and 1 week of typical usage. The Boogie Board Rip measures 11.1″ (H) x 7″ (W) x 0.5″ (D) and weighs 11.5 ounces.

In this week’s episode of Cracking Open, I show you what’s inside the Kent Displays Boogie Board Rip, and discuss what I learned from my teardown.

March 1, 2012, 8:11 AM PST | Length:00:03:46

View Transcript

Full teardown gallery: Cracking Open the Boogie Board Rip

Cracking Open observations

  • Thin and light, but sturdy: I was surprised by how thin and light the Boogie Board Rip is. At half an inch, it’s a bit thicker than your average tablet, but not by much. And at 11.5 ounces, it’s much lighter than any of 10-inch tablets I’ve cracked open. Despite these characteristics, the electronic writing device felt surprisingly sturdy in my hands. I never once worried that I would break it.
  • Unique, flexible LCD: Developed by Kent Displays, the Boogie Board’s screen uses cholesteric liquid crystals, which allow the screen to retain and image without power. And because the Reflex LCD is made from plastic, it’s both rugged and flexible.
  • Stores ~200 notes: The Boogie Board Rip has 8MB of internal storage. According to the manufacturer this will let you keep about 200 images (saved as PDFs) on the device. Beyond that, you’ll need to transfer them to a computer.
  • Can’t review stored documents on the device: Once you erase a saved image, the only way to see it again is on a computer.
  • No wireless sync: Another disappointment, you can’t sync the device wirelessly. Using the included USB cable is easy enough, but a bit cumbersome.
  • Overpriced: The Rip version of the Boogie Board is relatively expensive compared to low-end tablets, which offer a lot more functionality. At $129, it’s only $70 less than the Amazon Kindle Fire and Barnes and Noble Nook Tablet.

Automatically sign up for the Cracking Open newsletter!

Internal hardware

Our test unit had the following hardware.

  • 3.8V 830mAh Li-Ion Polymer battery
  • Texas Instruments MSP430 MCU (12A8D7T G4 M430F5529 REV E)
  • ISSI IS62WV2568BLL PowerSaver Low Power Asynchronous SRAM (2M 256Kx8)
  • Winbond 64Mb Serial Flash memory (8MB)
  • 9.5″ Kent Displays cholesteric Reflex LCD
  • Pen input system antenna (BTM-P097)
  • Waltop WA2006 Pen-Input Technology IC module
  • Texas Instruments SN74AHC4066 Quadruple Bilateral Analog Switch (HA4066 15K G4 ACCF)
  • Waltop MCU1086 A3A5A

Get IT Tips, news, and reviews delivered directly to your inbox by subscribing to TechRepublic’s free newsletters.

Bill Detwiler

About Bill Detwiler

Bill Detwiler is Head Technology Editor of TechRepublic. Previously, he worked as a Support Tech and IT Manager in the social research and energy industries.

Bill Detwiler

Bill Detwiler
Bill Detwiler is Head Technology Editor for TechRepublic. Previously he worked as a Technical Support Associate and Information Technology Manager in the social research and energy industries. Bill is a Microsoft Certified Professional with experience in Windows administration, data management, desktop support, and system security.

Bill Detwiler

Bill Detwiler
Bill Detwiler has nothing to disclose. He doesn't hold investments in the technology companies he covers.

Transcript

>> Bill Detweiler: If you'd like to ditch the paper notepad for a digital device but don't want a full-blown tablet, an e-Writer may be the perfect gadget. I'm Bill Detweiler, head technology editor at Tech Republic, and I'm going to crack open one of these electronic note-taking devices, the Kent Display's Boogie Board Rip.

Music

>> Bill Detweiler: Opening the Boogie Board's plastic case wasn't difficult but did require a little finesse. To begin, I removed the four external torque's T6 screws. Then using a thin metal tool, I popped loose the front cover from the back half of the case, taking care not to break too many of the small plastic tabs that hold the case together. Once inside the device, I detached the battery and stylus antenna connector from the motherboard. I removed the LCD and motherboard assembly, removed the battery, and removed the stylus antenna. I then separated the motherboard from the LCD and removed the LCD from its plastic holder. With that, our teardown was complete. So what did we learn from our teardown? Well, first, I was surprised by how thin and light the Boogie Board Rip is. At half an inch, it's a bit thicker than your average tablet but not by much, and at 11 and a half ounces, it's much lighter than any of the ten-inch tablets I've cracked open. Despite these characteristics, this e-Writer felt surprisingly sturdy in my hands. I never once worried that I would break it. Now the next interesting feature is the LCD. Developed by Kent Displays, the Boogie Board's screen uses colosteric phonetic liquid crystals, which allow the screen to retain an image without power, and because the LCD is made from plastic, it's both rugged and flexible. Another nice feature of the Boogie Board Rip is the eight megs of internal storage. Now according to the manufacturer, this will let you keep about 200 images, saved as PDF's, on the device. Beyond that, you'll need to transfer them to a computer. One thing I don't like about the device is the need to use the included stylus. Although any hard-pointed object, even your fingernail, will create an image on the LCD, the device can't save these lines. This is because the Boogie Board Rip uses a large antenna to detect the position of the stylus as it moves across the LCD, not the pressure of the writing instrument. After using the Boogie Board Rip and cracking it open, I can say that I like the device. It's well built and works as advertised, although it's not really designed to be cracked open. Yet, it still has three significant limitations that keep it from being a great note-taking tool. First, there's no way to view previously saved images on the device. Once you erase a saved image, the only way to see it again is on a computer. Second, you can't synch the device wirelessly. Now using the included USB cable is easy enough but a bit cumbersome. Lastly, the Rip version of the Boogie Board is relatively expensive compared to low-end tablets, which offer a lot more functionality. At $129, it's only $70 less than the Amazon Kindle Fire and Barnes and Noble Nook tablet. If the Boogie Board Rip was under a hundred dollars and had the features I just mentioned, it would be my note-taking tool of choice. As it is, I'll stick with my tablet. For Tech Republic, I'm Bill Detweiler, and this has been a cracking open of the Boogie Board Rip.

Music

2
Comments

Join the conversation!

Follow via:
RSS
Email Alert