Follow this blog:
RSS
Email Alert

Cracking Open

HP Spectre Teardown: Eye-catching, but overpriced ultrabook

Takeaway: The HP Envy 14 Spectre has solid hardware and a stylish design, but it’s significantly more expensive than other ultrabooks.

With not one, but two Gorilla Glass panels, the HP Spectre has more style than most ultrabooks on the market. But is this machine’s beauty only skin deep? In this week’s episode of Cracking Open, I show you what’s inside the HP Envy 14 Spectre, and discuss what I learned from my teardown.

Automatically sign up for our Cracking Open newsletter!

March 8, 2012, 10:52 AM PST | Length:00:03:47

View Transcript

Our HP Envy 14 Spectre test machine had a 1.8GHz Intel Core i7-2677M processor, integrated Intel HD Graphics 3000, 4GB 1,333MHz DDR3 SDRAM, 128GB SSD, and a 14.0″ Radiance HD+ LED-backlit display (1600 x900). It measures 12.88″ (W) x8.7″ (D) x 0.79″ (H) and weighs 3.97 pounds. As of this writing, an entry-level Spectre (with a Core i5 CPU, 4GB of RAM, and 128GB SSD) retails for $1,399 (US). Upgrading to a Core i7 machine with a 256GB SSD raises the price to $1,899. This is a full-featured ultrabook with a full-featured price. As CNET’s Dan Ackerman wrote in his review, “the HP Envy 14 Spectre is a bold experiment that largely succeeds, if you’re willing to pay a premium for it.”

Full teardown gallery: Cracking Open the HP Envy 14 Spectre

Cracking Open observations

  • Well-built and easy to disassemble: Despite its outer glass panel, which I discuss in more detail below, the Spectre felt sturdy and was well-built. HP used standard Torx and Phillips screws on the Spectre. And, most internal components can be removed and replaced separately. The user-accessible battery is also a nice touch, as are the easy-to-reach SSD and the second SSD slot.
  • RAM is NOT soldered to the motherboard: Not only can you swap out the storage unit, but unlike all the other ultrabooks I’ve cracked open, the you can also upgrade the unit’s RAM–as it’s not soldered to the motherboard. Unfortunately, there’s no way to get to the RAM chip without removing the motherboard.
  • Large and heavy for an ultrabook: The Spectre is a bit thicker and heavier than other ultrabooks. It’s a full pound heavier than Apple’s 13-inch MacBook Air and Acer’s Aspire S3. And, it’s only slightly thinner than the MacBook Pro.
  • Gorilla Glass lid concerns: While HP tauts the Spectre’s outer Gorilla Glass panel as tough and scratch resistant, which it probably is, it still concerns me to have such a large piece of unprotected glass on my laptop. I haven’t conducted any puncture or shatter tests on our machine, so my fears of opening my laptop bag and finding it full of broken glass may be completely unfounded. I sure hope so.
What's the right price for an ultrabook?

Internal hardware

Our HP Envy 14 Spectre test machine has the following hardware:

  • 1.8GHz Intel Core i7-2677M processor (E89391 01 IE7 / V148A962 / 2V146174A1703 SR0D2)
  • Intel BD82HM65 Platform Controller Hub (BD82HM65 SLJ4P E137B538)
  • 4GB Samsung 1,333MHz DDR3 SDRAM
  • Qualcomm Atheros AR5B225 WLAN BT card
  • 128GB Samsung SSD (HP P/N: 653509-001)
  • HP (SL04XL)14.8V, 58Wh Li-Ion battery
  • 14.0 Radiance HD+ Infinity LED-backlit display (1600 x 900)
  • NXP PN533 NFC controller (533 70 CT7812 02 02 TSD1422)
  • Synaptics T1320A Touchpad controller (T1320A 1133 AWOW127)
  • Quanta Keyboard P/N: AESPSU00010
  • Intel Centrino Advanced-N 6230 802.11a/g/n Wi-Fi plus Bluetooth card
  • Realtek RTS5209 Card Reader Controller
  • IDT 92HD91B Single Chip PC Audio System (92HD91B2X5 NLG YA11391 U28394M)
  • SWAP net 10/100/1000Base-T Single Port Transformer Module
  • AMIC A25LQ32A 32Mb Serial Flash Memory (A25LQ32AM-F 1142WD CC7E02)
  • Volterra VT1317SF (VT1317SF AP1104 1838528)
  • Volterra VT1316MAF5 (VT1316MAF5 AG1133 1843016)
  • Cracking Open HP Envy 14 Spectre: Texas Instruments TPS51461 3.3V to 5V Input, 6A, D-CAP+ Mode Synchronous Step-Down Converter with 2-Bit VID
  • Fairchild FDMC7672S N-Channel Power Trench SyncFET (F BBDAA FDMC 7672S)
  • ENE Technology KB3930 keyboard controller (KB3930QF A2 HH-N6GA9 AC-114321)
  • Parade Technologies 6414A GV1312 (likely a DisplayPort IC)
  • Realtek RTL8111 Gigabit Ethernet controller (RTL8111E B7H07G2 GB31L)
  • NEC D720202 USB controller (D720202 701 1146KV012G CHINA)

Get IT Tips, news, and reviews delivered directly to your inbox by subscribing to TechRepublic’s free newsletters.

Bill Detwiler

About Bill Detwiler

Bill Detwiler is Head Technology Editor of TechRepublic. Previously, he worked as a Support Tech and IT Manager in the social research and energy industries.

Bill Detwiler

Bill Detwiler
Bill Detwiler is Head Technology Editor for TechRepublic. Previously he worked as a Technical Support Associate and Information Technology Manager in the social research and energy industries. Bill is a Microsoft Certified Professional with experience in Windows administration, data management, desktop support, and system security.

Bill Detwiler

Bill Detwiler
Bill Detwiler has nothing to disclose. He doesn't hold investments in the technology companies he covers.

Transcript

>> Bill Detwiler: With not one but two gorilla glass panels, the HP Spectre is definitely one of the most stylish ultrabooks on the market but is this machine's beauty only skin deep? I'm Bill Detwiler, Head Technology Editor at TechRepublic and I'm going to crack open the HP NV14 Spectre.

Music

>> Bill Detwiler: Unlike the MacBook AIR, there are no tamper resistant screws holding the Spectre's case together. I began cracking open the machine by removing the battery cover and then the battery. Next I disconnected a few internal cables, removed all the external case screws, including two hidden under the units rubber feet, and removed the near field communication module. I then popped the bottom half of the case loose from the top half and gently separated the two, disconnecting a handful of ribbon cables along the way. Next to come out was the SD card reader, the headphone jack, followed by the solid state drive and the hard drive and volume control circuit board. The touchpad was the last component I removed from the upper case. Now moving over to the Spectre's lower case, I first disconnected the lids display and antennae cables, then removed the hinge screws and the lid itself. I then removed the wireless card, cooling fans, motherboard and power port screws and the motherboard itself. Lastly I disconnected the ram, power port and removed the cooling assembly. With that our tear down was complete. So what did I learn about the Spectre from our tear down? Well first, the machine is well built and relatively easy to disassemble. And I like the fact that most parts can be replaced separately. The user accessible battery is also a nice touch as is the easy to reach SSD. Now our test unit came with a single 128 gig drive but HP appears to have put a spot right above it for a second SSD. Not only can you swap out the storage unit but unlike all the other ultrabooks I've cracked open, you can also upgrade the units ram as it's not soldered to the motherboard. On the downside, there's no way to get to the ram chip without removing the motherboard. Also the Spectre is a bit thicker and heavier than other ultrabooks. It's a full pound heavier than Apple's 13 inch MacBook Air and Acer's Aspire S3 and it's only slightly thinner than the MacBook Pro. Lastly, while HP touts the Spectre's outer gorilla glass panel as tough and scratch resistant, which it probably is, it still concerns me to have such a large piece of unprotected glass on my laptop. Now I haven't conducted any puncture or shatter tests on our machine. So my fears of opening my laptop bag and finding it full of broken glass may be completely unfounded. I sure hope so. glass breaking The Spectre is definitely an eye catching ultrabook and as our teardown shows, it's well built, has solid hardware and is easy to work on. But it's also on the pricier end of the ultrabook market. As of this taping, an entry level Spectre with a Core i5, CPU, 4 gigs of RAM and a 128 gig SSD, retails for $1399. Now upgrading to a Core i7 and a 256 gig SSD, raises the price to $1899. This is a full featured ultrabook with a full featured price. For TechRepublic, I'm Bill Detwiler and this has been a cracking open of the HP NV14 Spectre.

Noise

5
Comments

Join the conversation!

Follow via:
RSS
Email Alert