PCs

Geek Gifts 2009: Linksys DMA2200 Media Center Extender with DVD Player

Get multimedia anywhere in your home with the Linksys DMA 2200, but only if you have the bandwidth and the patience.

Want more reviews of tech gadgets and gizmos? Download the PDF of TechRepublic's Geek Gift Guide 2009.

The concept of a media center extender is understandable: take advantage of a wirelessly connected home to move multimedia from the PC to other appliances and display devices. Your Microsoft Windows Media Center PC becomes the multimedia server for your home. It sounds cool; all you need is what Microsoft has dubbed a media center extender appliance.

The Linksys DMA2200 Media Center Extender with DVD Player is one of these appliances. Once it is setup and configured, the DMA2200 will pull multimedia from your Media Center PC to a high-definition television. The promise is HD media from your PC, but the promise comes with a substantial amount of "ifs" that you should not ignore.

Specifications

  • Wi-Fi Standards: Draft dual band 802.11N, 802.11G, 802.11B (2.4 GHz and 5 GHz)
  • Security features: WEP, WPA, WPA2
  • Security key bits: 64, 128, 256
  • Number of Antennas: three antennas for 802.11N-DualBand 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz
  • Ports: HDMI 1, 2, Component Video, Composite Video, S-Video, SPDIF RCA+Toslink, Stereo, Ethernet 10/100 connector, Power connector, USB port for Service purpose only, 3 Antennas
  • Dimensions: 9.09" x 4.92" x 12.95" (231 x 125 x 329 mm)
  • Requirements: Certified for Windows Vista or equivalent computer with Microsoft Vista Home Premium or Ultimate edition, Intel P4 2.4 GHz or higher or AMD equivalent, 1.0 GB of RAM, 100 Mbps Ethernet connection) with CD-ROM drive and Internet Connection
  • Cost: $350 on sale on Amazon
  • TechRepublic Photo Gallery

What I like

  • Style: The Linksys DMA2200 looks good and will not interfere with the décor of most modern homes. The glossy black styling works well with the common flat-panel televisions.
  • Display: The image quality produced by the device is high definition and looks great on compatible television screen. The device itself is not the limiting factor when it comes to picture quality.
  • DVD Player: The built-in DVD Player is a fantastic addition for a media extender because sometimes you don't want to have to boot a PC just so you can watch a DVD. The player acts just like any DVD player, exhibiting the same qualities. The built-in player is neither better nor worse than a standard standalone DVD player.
  • Setup wizard: The setup wizard used by the DMA2200 made the configuration simple. The Media PC was seen right away and the initial connection was made and configured. The only problem was maintaining the connection.
  • Ports: The DMA2200 includes all of the standard video and audio ports as well as HDMI. Will all of these ports, it should be no trouble to find a connection cable that works with your television.

What I don't like

  • Clunky interface: I do not like the interface of Windows Media Center and that is the general interface used by the Linksys DMA2200. Clicking the navigation controls on a remote is just so inefficient and frustrating. This frustration is exacerbated by the slow response time of the DMA2200; clicks take a few seconds to respond, which means you often have to click the opposite navigation because you overshot your target.
  • Bandwidth requirements: While the DMA2200 promises HD video and audio, the reality is that unless you have a dual-band 802.11n router you will be receiving standard video and audio over a wireless connection. For a wired connection, you will need to be using 100Mbit speeds. If you don't have that much bandwidth you can expect dropped frames and pauses on just about everything you watch.
  • Dropped connections: In the three weeks I tested the DMA2200, I could count on the device to lose the connection to my media PC at least once a day. There was no explanation. Reconnecting was simple enough by just running the connection wizard, but it was darned frustrating.
  • Cost: The suggested retail price for the Linksys DMA2200 Media Center Extender with DVD Player is $450. Amazon has it on sale for $350. I think that is highway robbery. For the same $350 I could get a real computer to do the extending and get more control over the process and more consistency. The price should be more like $125 and even then I would not buy it, because the XBOX is now $199 and is a very capable extender.

Geek bottom line

The Linksys DMA2200 Media Center Extender with DVD Player does its job adequately as long as you have the highest wireless bandwidth available and don't mind having to reconnect to the Media PC at least once a day (always during a movie or show). But if you don't have the bandwidth coursing around your home, the DMA2200, especially at $350, is going to greatly disappoint you.

My best suggestion is that you hold off on buying any media extender until a more reliable and reasonably priced second generation of devices comes to market. A flat-panel television with Internet connectivity is likely a better choice. The Linksys DMA2200 Media Center Extender with DVD Player is just not ready for primetime yet.

Geek score (out of 5)

  • Fun factor: *
  • Geek factor: ***
  • Value: *
  • Overall: *

About

Mark Kaelin is a CBS Interactive Senior Editor for TechRepublic. He is the host for the Microsoft Windows and Office blog, the Google in the Enterprise blog, the Five Apps blog and the Big Data Analytics blog.

7 comments
Mark W. Kaelin
Mark W. Kaelin

I must admit, I have a hard time figuring out exactly what niche the media extender is trying to fill. I have old PCs lying around that can do what an extender does. I have the Roku for getting instance play off of Netflix. I can get an Internet connected television now. Where does the media center extender fit into all of this? There are other ways to accomplish what the extender is supposed to accomplish, aren't there?

umdivx
umdivx

The big thing about Media Center, for me anyways is the ability to turn a pc running vista or now windows 7 and turn it into a DVR. I have a dedicated PC (call it HTPC, home theater pc) running windows 7 ultimate. I have 10 tuner cards in it (4 ATSC, 4 NTSC and 2 QAM) tuners in it. I then have 2 TB of storage which is virtually unlimited hdd storage for a DVR. This pc is connected directly to my projector setup and I use this as my "set top box" replacement. Then on the rest of the TV's in my home I have linksys media center extenders that I can now watch live and recorded tv from my HTPC on any tv in my home. the great part though is the multi-room experience. So say I am sitting down to dinner, I am watching a recorded tv show from the night before. I start watching on one media center extender. I don't finish it, I pause it. I then can now go to my htpc in my basement on my projector, and click play and pick right back up where I left off. Meaning on any tv, I have the same user interface, the same single DVR solution, where is it all synced for each and every single tv. - Josh

lesko
lesko

I played with Myth TV on an old PC but its not as seamless as extenders. I find game consoles to be the best extenders, XBMC on the old Xbox being the best. The new XBOX is somewhat limiting. I have yet to play with a PS3 and its DLNA capability. For the price mentioned in the blog I would probably opt for the PS3 now you have Blu-Ray and a DLNA player which most NAS devices support these days

lazerousz
lazerousz

I'd say simply these extenders are meant for the less tech savvy. There are plenty of people out there who wouldn't know how to turn an old computer into an extender. They still have the options to purchase something like Roku or a connected television, but this might be easier and get them another dvd player rather than a whole new more expensive tv. For this device I'd say the normal users of this site are not its target, no matter how geeky it might seem.

Mark W. Kaelin
Mark W. Kaelin

Is this a wireless setup, 802.11n? Or did you use cables? I'm curious, because I could not get an HD signal with the Linksys Extender because of bandwidth issues.

Mark W. Kaelin
Mark W. Kaelin

I think you are correct that this device could be considered a non-tech appliance. But that is a problem because the wizards and all that hide any information that one could use to figure out why it keeps failing. As a non-tech device it fails. And of course, at CES, Linksys was touting it as a technophiles dream come true, which also is not reality. It fails in both markets. I think there will be a place for extenders eventually, but they are just not ready yet.

umdivx
umdivx

I have two extenders. I am using one extender on 10/100 switch, and using one via a Linksys WRT600N wireless router. The only thing is that I am using it on the 5ghz radio of the AP as 2.4ghz is just too crowded and too noisy to get a clean, stable signal. I also manually setup the speed, IE I set the channel width (bandwidth) to 40mhz, default is 20mhz. - Josh

Editor's Picks