Ubuntu compare

Ubuntu 13.10: It just works

Find out why Jack Wallen thinks that Ubuntu 13.10 is a solid, reliable platform that just works. Do you agree?

ubuntu-13-10-saucy-salamander.jpg

I've been using Ubuntu for a very long time. I was one of the few in the media who adopted Unity as my primary desktop interface. In fact, I've grown so used to Unity that I have trouble finding any form of efficiency in other desktops. So, naturally, when a new Ubuntu release is about to be unleashed upon the world, I grab a beta and install it.

The hype surrounding the upcoming 13.10 (Saucy Salamander) was fairly significant. Leading this charge was the much-anticipated switch to Xmir. Well, thanks to a few show-stopping issues (such as dual-monitor support), Xmir has been pushed back to 14.04. Is this a big deal? Yes and no. Yes, because Xmir will be a major change to the sub-systems of Ubuntu. No, because Xmir must be faultless when released -- otherwise, the backlash will knock Canonical back so far in the past that they'll have a hard time recovering in the eyes of the Linux community.

Beyond Xmir, the biggest change from .04 to .10 is the much-maligned inclusion of Smart Scopes. What are Smart Scopes? Let me explain it in the simplest terms as possible.

When you open your browser and begin typing a string of characters, you know how that browser will make suggestions for you based on search terms, location, and history? Smart Scopes brings that same functionality to the desktop. I've run some tests on it, and it's pretty incredible. Search for nearly anything, and it will return results based on a number of criteria. Want to know the location of a restaurant in your area? I conducted a search for my favorite Mexican restaurant, Bazos, and an entry appeared in Smart Scopes (Figure A). Click the entry to get the address or open that entry in a web browser to get more information (and even reviews).

Figure A

Figure A
My favorite place to eat listed in Smart Scopes.

I get it, there are people out there suffering from apoplectic fits of terror because Smart Scopes is an invasion of privacy. This is no different than what your web browser is doing. So, unless you constantly run your web browser in Incognito mode, all those search strings are saved and compared anyway. And the truth is, why wouldn't you want your search results based on your preferences and behavior instead of some generic algorithm? Personally, I don't mind my search results being quantified and qualified, so long as it constantly refines the search results based on my needs.

Smart Scopes isn't limited to seeking out search results from the network. You'll be happily searching for anything and everything on your local (or locally attached) drives as well. With this inclusion, Smart Scopes becomes one of the single most powerful search tools available.

Of course, if you don't like Smart Scopes, you can turn them off. Here's how:

  1. Click the Settings launcher
  2. Select Security & Privacy
  3. In the Search tab, turn Include online search results to Off (Figure B)

Figure B

Figure B
It's easy to turn off the Smart Scopes feature.

With all of that said, let's step away from the arguments for or against search privacy and let me explain exactly why Ubuntu 13.10 is the perfect desktop for nearly any user.

The install was fresh from the latest daily build. During the installation, I included third-party software, updates, and was even able to authenticated to my UbuntuOne account. The install was incredibly simple (as most modern Linux distributions are), and at first login, everything was smooth.

What initially struck me about Ubuntu 13.10 is how everything worked out of the box. There was no need to install codecs to listen or view various multi-media files, flash worked, and everything was ready for average, daily computer use. You could work on office documents, set up your email account... you name it. But that has become the standard operating procedure for Ubuntu. 

So, what's different? Honestly, not much. However, what little difference there is should go a long way with the average user. Probably the single most important thing I've found is that a lot of the little quirks and oddities are gone. There are no longer any strange errors that randomly pop up to cause confusion and disdain among new users. Windows don't artifact or stall, the Dash is very responsive (as is Smart Scopes), and the compositing is smooth and effortless against your CPU. Also, the bug is resolved that plagued the Dash when trying to use the arrow keys to navigate through search results.

Ubuntu 13.10 just works

I would go as far to say that Ubuntu has done to the desktop what Apple did with hardware/software -- it developed a clean, solid convergence of pieces to create a cohesive whole. Although that whole has ruffled some feathers, Ubuntu 13.10 should go a long way to smooth them out. How is that possible, considering how many users have turned their back (thanks to the Wayland kerfuffle)? 

Outside of Smart Scopes, there are no major changes. There's little excitement on the desktop -- it's still the same old look and feel. Oh sure, there are tiny tweaks here and there, but overall, 13.10 and 13.04 look the same at first blush. Under the hood? Same thing. You'll find a new kernel (3.11) and a few other tweaks, but nothing to cause the cheerleaders of the world to frustratingly toss their pompoms in the air.

Instead, Ubuntu 13.10 is a refinement of something that was already there and polished. There are no show stopping or curtain call worthy new features --  just countless tweaks here and there that make the whole system run smooth and fast.

The final release of Saucy Salamander is set for October 17, 2013. You can get a copy of the daily build or wait for the release date. Either way, you're going to get a solid, reliable platform that just works.

What are your thoughts about Saucy Salamander? Share your opinion in the discussion thread below.


About Jack Wallen

Jack Wallen is an award-winning writer for Techrepublic and Linux.com. As an avid promoter/user of the Linux OS, Jack tries to convert as many users to open source as possible. His current favorite flavor of Linux is Bodhi Linux (a melding of Ubuntu ...

14 comments
carlsf
carlsf

Have they fixed the install from ISO to a HDD with UFI bios??

orionds
orionds

My experience with the beta of Ubuntu 13.10 has been overall better than previous versions. I have been trying Xubuntu 13.10 and love how snappy and stable it is.

My one gripe is that I can't "port" it to other hardware PCs. By port, I mean make an image of the install using Qt4-fsarchiver and then restore it to a partition on another PC, update grub, reboot, change the host names, and edit the fstab file to point to the new swap and that's it - one size fits all. The problem this time may be the layer that Xfce puts on top of Ubuntu. Up to login everything runs fine, but once in, the display goes awry - no mouse, no panel.

I do not know for sure yet what's the cause and searches have not given me a solution. It could be specific to Xubuntu as this is the first time I'm trying it. This might mean, if I intend to stick with Xubuntu, to install different hardware separately. In the past, I did one install using Lubuntu, installed Gnome fallback and used the one image for all my PCs, notebooks and netbooks.

Despite this, I am amazed at the stability of the beta compared to the past, even the full releases. And, yes, it works straight out of the box. Some software have yet to support 13.10 e.g. Ubuntu Tweak but this should be resolved soon after the "full" release. I really like 13.10.

nsleasy
nsleasy

I've worked with Linux as a DBA and SA since 2001 and I've found the recent releases of Ubuntu to be among the best desktop environments.

Unfortunately, Linux, Windows and Mac all have annoyances and battery life is the Achilles heel of all Linux distributions for the desktop.  I'm back to running Windows 7 on my laptop because it uses far less battery than Ubuntu.  I can get about 5 hours of battery life running Windows, with appropriate power settings.  With Ubuntu 12.10, I'm lucky if I get 2.5 hours -- even with TLP installed and the display dimmed as much as possible.  There are no options to tame the wireless drivers that come with Ubuntu, from what I can tell.

Until hardware manufacturers start supporting Linux in a serious way, I'm afraid Microsoft and Apple will always have better power management options.


extremeskillz
extremeskillz

Love Ubuntu and works well all my hardware perfectly. Unity is by far the best and most efficient desktop I've used ever and i've been a Windows advocate for years. I took the dip with Ubuntu 11.04 and watched this OS blossom to where is today. I used it as my primary OS and to manage my day to day IT operations which is mainly Windows and Linux servers. I have no gripe with Windows or MAC or Linux. They are tools and I find Ubuntu the better of the tools I use.

russ
russ

I love Ubuntu.  I'm a Linux sysadmin.  When I started at my current job, they asked me if I wanted a Windows PC or a Mac.  I told 'em neither.  I wanted a desktop box on which to install Ubuntu.  Got a lot of funny looks on that one.


I've never warmed to Unity, but then, I'm totally happy with the Windowmaker desktop.  I've been using Windowmaker for about 10 years.  I've used it on Solaris, Fedora and of course, Ubuntu.  Fast and easy to customize.  Does everything I want it to.  So all this noise about Unity, pros and cons, are irrelevant.  I couldn't care less about Xmir or whatever it is, just so long as I can keep using Windowmaker.

mark
mark

I am considering installing this onto my linux workstation at home. If it is any good, I might just keep it on the system... otherwise, I am going to be looking at something else.

techrepublic2
techrepublic2

I've been using unix/linux since the early '80s and I have yet to find a single release from anyone that "just worked". I will be totally amazed if, when I install it, 13.10 "just works".

amnio
amnio

Of course you find any and EVERYTHING which comes from Canonical and Mark Shutlleworth JUST ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! There are NEVER ANY PROBLEMS...EVER! Except for those pesky individuals who are not ubuntucult members.

Mark Shuttleworth can do no wrong; he is the saviour of the world; the sun rises and sets in his rear end.

YOU ARE ZDNET, IN CANONICAL'S HIP POCKET.

Again, it would be nice if anything you said about Canonical were believable, but you do--to your very  great discredit--work for ZDNet. And are a bona-fide UbuCult member. Or is that, "zombie"?

How many 'Edge's did you buy? Guess you don't put your money where your mouth is, huh?


Kool-Aid, anyone?

mogoredmax
mogoredmax

Having downloaded most new versions of Ubuntu over the last few years I have always found something that did not work - I confess that I do not have Jacks experience of using it as my main desktop and so have not persevered but always felt let down by one or two key failures either at install or shortly afterwards especially with a dual boot set up. Still, I am willing to try again when the latest version comes out.

Regards

hengels
hengels

@nsleasy I have two laptops running Kubuntu and Ubuntu 13.04. Both laptops are reaching a better battery life-time than with Windows 7. But that you do not get out of the box. I had to invest one day research and work for learning how to configure the OS for a great battery life-time. The learning curve is steep and you have to deal with the command line a lot but this learning process you do only once in a life-time. Although both laptops are cheap standard stuff I can now develop websites with my IDE and run Apache, MySQL etc. and work 8 hours uninterrupted until the battery dies.

p8riotx
p8riotx

@extremeskillz  I have been using Ubuntu since 11.04 as well.  You are right in saying it has blossomed.  I have not missed MS for one minute and have never looked back. As the OS continues to develop, I am more and more impressed. 

james.vandamme
james.vandamme

@amnio Give it up, Mr. Ballmer. Pack up and leave and spend your retirement enjoying Windows 8. Or throw some chairs around.

p8riotx
p8riotx

@mogoredmax I have used Ubuntu exclusively since 11.04 and have installed it on five different machines from four different manufactures without any problems other that the minor glitches mentioned in the article.  A quick search on askubuntu.com has always solved even those little glitches.  Sorry you had trouble and I'm glad you're going to give it another chance.  Best wishes to you!