Reorganize vs. rebuild
Fragmented indexes can be "unfragmented" in two ways: They can be reorganized or rebuilt. Reorganizing an index causes the reordering of the data inside of the outermost data pages and will compact the index. No additional data is added to the index for the reorganization, so the index may remain somewhat fragmented. The operation doesn't take a lot of system resources and may occur while outside processes are accessing the table that the index operates on, so it is said to be an "online' operation.
Rebuilding an index essentially drops the desired index and creates a new one. Any fragmentation that was in the older index is removed, and the logical ordering of the new index matches the physical ordering. Due to the fact that the index is removed and recreated, outside processes are not able to access the table and performance can suffer. In fact, other processes will not be able to lock the table at all while the index rebuild is occurring. This is a major hindrance of rebuilding indexes.
Online index rebuild
SQL Server 2005 introduces the ability to rebuild your indexes in an online fashion so that other processes are able to access the table while the rebuild is occurring. Because you can access the indexes during the rebuild, you are not limited to only rebuilding indexes during off-peak hours.
To accomplish this, the database engine takes some special actions to rebuild the index and to allow access to the index at the same time. The original index will remain available to users for reading data and data modification. Row versioning is used to allow for transactional consistency. During the rebuild, a new index is created that mimics the old index. Any data modifications that alter the original index will also be applied to this index by SQL Server during the rebuild. This new index is not read from at all -- it is write-only. It is essential that you have enough available disk space to accommodate the data for the two concurrent indexes during the online rebuild. While the rebuild is taking place, SQL Server uses a mapping index to determine records to modify in the new index when modifications occur in the original index. Once the rebuild process has finished, any queries or data modifications occur to the new index, and the original index is dropped.
The process to rebuild an index online is not much different than the typical rebuild process; however, there are a few ways to accomplish the rebuild. One way is to simply drop the index using a DROP INDEX statement followed by a CREATE INDEX statement. Rebuilding indexes in this fashion leaves the table without an index until the index is completely created. For this reason (and a number of other reasons), dropping the index and recreating it is not recommended.
The CREATE INDEX statement can still be used to rebuild an index if the DROP_EXISTING option is used. This feature allows the definition of the specified index to change, and it allows the DBA to change the location of the index to another filegroup or partition.
The ALTER INDEX statement allows for the rebuilding of the clustered and all nonclustered indexes on the table. The drawback with this statement is that you cannot change the index definition. Both of these statements have options that will build the index online.
The following statement will rebuild the clustered index (which is on the SaleID column) on the SalesHistory table. The existing index will be dropped in the process, but it will be available during the operation because the ONLINE option is specified.
CREATE CLUSTERED INDEX cl_SalesHistory_SaleID ON SalesHistory(SaleID) WITH(DROP_EXISTING = ON, ONLINE = ON)
This statement is very similar to the one used above, but it changes the actual index definition to include an additional column. The index is still rebuilt in the same fashion.
CREATE CLUSTERED INDEX cl_SalesHistory_SaleID ON SalesHistory(SaleID ASC, SaleDate ASC) WITH(DROP_EXISTING = ON, ONLINE = ON)
Using the ALTER INDEX statement, I can rebuild all indexes on a specified table. The ONLINE syntax remains the same as the CREATE INDEX statement. This new syntax replaces the DBCC DBREINDEX statement used in previous versions of SQL Server.
ALTER INDEX ALL ON SalesHistory REBUILD WITH(ONLINE = ON)
This statement rebuilds the clustered index on the SalesHistory table. The ONLINE option is omitted, which means that the table will not be accessible during the rebuild operation.
ALTER INDEX cl_SalesHistory_SaleID ON SalesHistory REBUILD
This statement is the same statement as above, but the rebuild will be performed online, so operations can continue to be performed on the table.
ALTER INDEX cl_SalesHistory_SaleID ON SalesHistory REBUILD WITH(ONLINE = ON)
The ability to rebuild indexes in SQL Server 2005 is a fantastic new option. If you rebuild your indexes online, you must ensure that you have enough available disk space to hold the index that is being created along with the preexisting index. After the rebuild operation, the old index will be dropped. Also, rebuilding indexes online takes a significant amount more time and resources than just rebuilding the index. This is usually a pretty good tradeoff since the table will remain available during the operation.
My next article will show how you can use SQL Server's new dynamic management functions to analyze your indexes' fragmentation levels so that you can determine when to do rebuilds.
Tim Chapman a SQL Server database administrator and consultant who works for a bank in Louisville, KY. Tim has more than eight years of IT experience, and he is a Microsoft certified Database Developer and Administrator. If you would like to contact Tim, please e-mail him at firstname.lastname@example.org.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Get database tips in your inbox
TechRepublic's free Database Management newsletter, delivered each Tuesday, contains hands-on SQL Server and Oracle tips and resources. Automatically subscribe today!
Tim Chapman is a SQL Server MVP, a database architect, and an administrator who works as an independent consultant in Raleigh, NC, and has more than nine years of IT experience.