Lots of people have asked me whether I think Microsoft will put the Start Menu back in Windows 8 before the final release. Of course, I'd like to believe that Microsoft would come to their senses and say that it was all a mistake to remove the Start Menu, but I don't think that's very likely. In fact, not only is the Start Button gone from the Desktop, but when you click in the place where it used to exist, you get the Metro Start screen. Windows 8 is designed with Metro as the starting point, and we'll just have to get used to it -- or will we?
Fortunately, I have discovered an Achilles' heel in Microsoft's evil plan to do away with the Start Menu. They may have been able to remove the GUI part of the Start Button/Menu, but they can't remove the underlying structure of it without crippling the operating system's backward-compatibility support for pre-Windows 8 applications.
In this edition of the Windows Desktop Report, I'll show you how to take advantage of this chink in the armor and revive a classic version of the Start Menu.This blog post is also available in a Slideshow Photo Gallery.
Note: Keep in mind that this technique is being written for the Windows 8 Consumer Preview and the features I will discuss here may very well change between now and the time the operating system is actually released.
The underlying structure
When you install any standard Windows application in Windows 8, the operating system redirects the installation procedure to create a tile in Metro. Even so, the installation procedure is designed to create folders and shortcuts to the application in the directory where the Start Menu lives. In the case of Windows 7 and Windows 8, that directory is C:\ProgramData\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu. Since that directory still exists in Windows 8 for the sake of backward compatibility, you can take advantage of that fact along with the Taskbar's Toolbar feature to revive a classic version of the Start Menu. Let's take a closer look.
In order to create your own Classic Start Menu in Windows 8, you'll use the Toolbar feature. This feature has been a part of the Windows operating system for a long time, and it allows you to create Toolbars right on the Taskbar.To begin, right-click an empty spot on the Taskbar, hover over Toolbars, and select the New Toolbar command, as shown in Figure A. (Take note of the Lock the Taskbar command; you'll need to use it in an upcoming step.)
Access the Toolbars submenu and select the New Toolbar command.When you see the New Toolbar - Choose a Folder dialog box, type the following path in the Folder text box, as shown in Figure B.
Type the path to the Start Menu folder in the Folder text box.To continue, click the Select Folder button. You will then see the Start Menu Toolbar appear next to the Notification Area, as shown in Figure C.
The new Start Menu Toolbar will appear next to the Notification Area.
Populating the Start Menu
At this point, your Classic Start Menu contains the Programs menu and Windows Update. The Classic Start Menu also provides links to Documents, Settings, Search, and Shut Down. Fortunately, you can populate your Classic Start Menu with all these links. To do so, you will need to create shortcuts on your desktop and then move them to the C:\ProgramData\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu folder.Documents: To create a shortcut to Documents, launch Windows Explorer, which will open to the Libraries folder. Then, right-click on Documents and select Send To | Desktop (Create Shortcut) command, as shown in Figure D. You can repeat this step if you want to put Pictures, Music, and Videos on your Start Menu.
You'll use the Send to | Desktop (Create Shortcut) command to create some of your shortcuts.Control Panel: To create a shortcut to the Control Panel, select Desktop under the Favorites list in Windows Explorer. Then, right-click on Control Panel and select Create Shortcut, as shown in Figure E. You can repeat this step if you want to put Computer and Network on your Start menu.
Right-click on Control Panel and select the Create Shortcut command.Search: To create a shortcut to Search, right-click on the Desktop and select the New | Shortcut command. When you see the Create Shortcut dialog box, type the following command in the Location text box, as shown in Figure F. Be sure to include the colon at the very end of the command.
Be sure to include the colon.
To continue, click Next and save the shortcut with the name Search.Shut Down: To create a shortcut to Shut Down the Computer, right-click on the Desktop and select the New | Shortcut command. When you see the Create Shortcut dialog box, type the following in the Location text box:
To continue, click Next and save the shortcut with the name Shut Down.
When you create these shortcuts, Windows 8 appends "- shortcut" to each one. You can rename each to remove the unnecessary words.At this point, launch Windows Explorer and navigate to the C:\ProgramData\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu folder. Next, move all the shortcuts from your Desktop to the Start Menu folder. Because this folder is a special system folder, you will see a Destination Folder Access Denied dialog box, like the one shown in Figure G. Select the Do This for All Current Items check box and click the Continue button to proceed with the Move operation.
You will have to click the Continue button to proceed with the Move operation.
Of course, you can put the shortcuts to any of your applications that you want to appear on your Start Menu in this folder as well.
Moving the Start Menu ToolbarNow that you have created the Start Menu Toolbar, you'll want to move it the left corner where the Start button used to be. Right-click on the Taskbar and select Lock the Taskbar to remove the check mark. Once the Taskbar is unlocked, hover your mouse pointer over the Toolbar handle, just to the left of the "S" in Start Menu. When the pointer turns into a double-headed arrow, just click and drag the Toolbar handle over toward the left corner, as shown in Figure H. As you do, drag the handle slightly under or over the icons on the Taskbar in order to get the Start Menu Toolbar to its new position.
When the pointer turns into a double-headed arrow, just click and drag the Toolbar handle over to the left corner.
When you position it, you'll see all the folders inside the Start Menu folder. To hide them, click and drag the Taskbar handle next to the Internet Explorer icon to the left to cover up those folders. Now, right-click on the Taskbar and select the Lock the Taskbar command. When you do, you'll notice a slight side effect -- just an edge of the Windows Update icon appears; however, it is nothing to worry about.When you complete the operation, you will have your own Classic Start Menu in Windows 8, as shown in Figure I.
You can create your own Classic Start Menu in Windows 8.
What's your take?
Will you put the classic Start Menu back in Windows 8 Consumer Preview with this technique? As always, if you have comments or information to share about this topic, please take a moment to drop by the TechRepublic Community Forums and let us hear from you.
Greg Shultz is a freelance Technical Writer. Previously, he has worked as Documentation Specialist in the software industry, a Technical Support Specialist in educational industry, and a Technical Journalist in the computer publishing industry.