You're right to a degree but I've found plenty of reasoned debate to be had in plenty of the Win 8 and MS surface threads so far. Unfortunately it is shot through with reactive negativity which sort of kills interesting conversation on the topic. If (you) feel negative about (it) then tell us why and lets explore that. Not a single one of us will have all the answers, hence why stuff like this helps and can be interesting..
I suppose until the majority of us have really had a chance to play with Win 8 in our own environments we won't be able to effectively see why we should upgrade. As the launch passes and more and more people give it a crack this may become more apparent and a debate had.
Keep Up with TechRepublic