General discussion

Locked

Is a Router Overkill?

By info ·
Hi all,

I am doing a network install along with T1 installers. I will be
setting up a router/switch and client/server network for about 20 or
so users. The one T1 line will be shared for voice and data.
They will be supplying on their side a adtran 612 csu/dsu(with
built-in router) that will connect via ethernet to their 12/24 port
switch.

From their, I will plug in to a port on their switch and connect to my
router of firewall. From their connecting to my own 24 port switch.
What would be the reason to go with a Router like a cisco 1841 sec/k9
as opposed to a Cisco Pix appliance (506E). I'm sort of split between
the two. VPN capability will be important among other things like DHCP.

Thanks,
Ben

This conversation is currently closed to new comments.

6 total posts (Page 1 of 1)  
| Thread display: Collapse - | Expand +

All Comments

Collapse -

Two different devices

by -Q-240248 In reply to Is a Router Overkill?

The firewall - I would not use unless you specifically need a firewall. First of all, the interfaces are completely different on a firewall, and routing is much better using a router. The FW was not designed to be just a router, and with the security settings on a FW interface, you have to use ACLs to get from the low security interface through to the higher interface, so it's a little burdensome to manage. If you just need routing, just get a router. It can do VPN as well.

Collapse -

Do I Need a Router?

by info In reply to Two different devices

I'm not an expert on T1, so please bare with me, I might have some elementary questions.

So, if they are supplying a csu/dsu with a built in router, do I need my own router and if I do what would be it's purpose?

Collapse -

If you are getting a CSU/DSU with a built in router, probably not

by jmgarvin In reply to Do I Need a Router?

It depends on exactly what's going on with it and how's it's managed.

I'd go with a PIX, for security, and if you need a router, you can always buy a cheapy one (you only have 20 users).

Good luck.

Collapse -

You don't need a router

by -Q-240248 In reply to Do I Need a Router?

If they are supplying the router, you wouldn't need another one unless you're planning on some internal subnetting. If this T1 is connected to the Internet, a pix would be a good idea.

Collapse -

Router Recommendations

by info In reply to You don't need a router

If I am to go with a router, does anyone have recommendations on a model. I prefer to go with cisco products, but I would be willing to take other suggestions.

This router would basically be used for NAT, DHCP, VPN, firewall. The office will have 15 computers, server running 2003 server & shared printer.

Thanks

Collapse -

Astaro Firewall

by Brooklyns Finest In reply to Router Recommendations

I recommend the Astaro Security appliances for all security purposes. check out their website
www.astaro.com
the 120 or 220 is ideal for NAT, DHCP, VPN, firewall, different subnets, multiple ports, etc...

Back to Networks Forum
6 total posts (Page 1 of 1)  

Hardware Forums