+ 0 Votes as much as i love Matt Smith PurpleSkys 1 year ago I loved David Tennant more. His Doctor was more dramatic where Matt's is more fun. I don't remember the old Drs all that well, but it would "float my boat" if one of the sci-fi stations over here would rerun them for me . I do think that sometimes as much as the story may be about the Doctor, it's often more about his companion. I loved Rose, Billie Piper, as David's companion. And with Amy, Karen Gillan, as Matt's, she keeps him in check so to speak. I also can't wait to see what all happens with River Song, Alex Kingston; she's not a companion but there is definitely a potentially good story brewing there.