Family Values: Ownership Structure, Performance And Capital Structure Of Canadian Firms

This paper examines how family ownership affects the performance and capital structure of 613 Canadian firms from 1998 to 2005. In particular, the authors distinguish the effect of family ownership from the use of control-enhancing mechanisms. They find that freestanding family-owned firms with a single share class have similar market performance than other firms based on Tobin's q ratios, superior accounting performance based on ROA, and higher financial leverage based on debt-to-total assets. By contrast, family-owned firms that use dual-class shares have valuations that are lower by 17% on average relative to widely-held firms, despite having similar ROA and financial leverage.