Discussion Locked

300 users, IT staff of 2. Need suggestions.

0 helpful
76 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

500+ employee company
300+ users (most are remote)
60 different offices in 4 states
2 IT people

Does something like Altiris or SMS make sense here or is it more headache than it's worth for just two people? We neglect a lot of things because we're stretched so thin, and one of those is patching/updates. We have to concentrate on outer perimeter defenses because that's all we have time for.

Another question, on a scale of 1-10, how crazy is my company for having only two IT people at this size? Don't even ask about whether or not I've tried to get more people on board. I've tried everything imaginable.

Thanks.

76 replies

by jterry

And not at what you haven't got. If you've got 300 users and most of them are remote and the company doesn't know by now that you need more help than 1. Your users are very experienced and are keeping up to date with patches on their own, or 2. They aren't reporting their problems (Most likely scenario). I have made up a Weekly Maintenance list for my users home PC's that lists all the updates and programs they need to run each week. (Such as Microsoft Update, Ad-Aware, Spybot, Microsoft Anti-spyware, JV16 etc) This might help in your case. I use St Bernards Update Expert at work to keep up with patching but in your case with everyone being remote it probably wouldn't work. If the company won't listen make sure you have everything in writing stating why you need more poeple and than start looking for a new job.

by jorgen.bryde

Every bit of hw, sw, settings and configurations. Change everything every four years, based on needs and requests (maybe you can allow minor sw updates once a year.)

Keep every computer identical at all times, and keep 10-20 spares at your location.

When it's time to patch, upgrade your spares, ship them out, get the remote PC-s in return, upgrade them, ship them out, etc.

A VERY strict regime is the only way to survive.

I think.

Oh, and LANDesk might help, if you prefer that.

Jorgen.

by Former member

jorgen are you crazy?
Swapping machines in and out for remote users
Doing the patching for all of them
That would just add to the already overloaded IT staff
I do agree with hardware standards but NO ONE has 20 spares of anything!

by craig.engel

Update Expert and SMS won't work very well for your remote users. Install VPN quarantine technology. Don't let them in if their feet are dirty.

by jdmercha

Two IT people should be able to support 300 computers.

Assuming -
- They only provide desktop support. No server administration, No training, No purchasing, No planning.
- All the computers are in the same general location

by rwalterk

Yes, two people should be able to support 300 PCs if your assumptions are true. I with that were the case.

Me = IT Manager (strategic planning, purchasing, project management, network and server administration, tech support).
My 1 staffer = Sys Admin (network and server administration, tech support).

300 users in 60 different offices in 4 different states.

by admin

...but have you really tried everything? I'm surprised management can't find the money to hire one or two entry-level techs? If the organization is so big but that bit o' money is such an issue to them, maybe you could locate the local community college and bring on a couple of interns who need the credits?

All that aside, I'd document *everything* and start putting out feelers for a new job...

by too old for it

... make sure your retirement nest egg does not include any investment in this company. The IT is spread way too thin and if either you or your SysAdmin leave, the company will be gone in 60 seconds.

by jtakiwi

That can manage your pc's as they are. Patch, Asset, reporting, av status, preventative maintenance, as long as they are on the internet, they would be fine. I assume you are resonsible for the WAN connections as well, you'd want visibility into that as well to be proactive as issues being piling up.

W/ the right maintenance program and defined support that you provide, 2 folks should be plenty to support them during normal work week.

by wornhall

Sixty offices each with one eighth to three fifths of an "office guru" doing the work your expanded staff should be doing. The office minimum is above one tenth of an analyst per small office.

So, 60 offices,((.12+.60)/2) 21.6 lost-gurus.

The 'lost' are the office angels doing the work usually assigned to true guru's which do the same work in half the time, thus you should have 10 to 11 more staff.

by pkr9

300 users. That means that if they call support ONCE a month, you'll have 12 support calls a day. With installations in 4 different states it is not unlikely that for a good portion af the month one person will be away travelling.

Unsustainable...

by deadly ernest

You are way understaffed for that and they have to either:

1. Accept they are screwed and not blame you for problems.

2. Hire several more staff.

3. Spend a lot of money on hardware and services to allow you to do the job properly.

4. Keep you guys as emergency techs and supervisors of an outsourced support service.

Best answers would be 2 or 4. But 3 could be manged by having dedicated high speed lines that connect all the sites to one gateway and build a decent secure gateway that provides DHCP, DNS, Internet, mail, AV, and monitoring services within its various servers. That way you can reduce all the other site hardware to PCs and routers. Set up a server that automatically handles patching and updates in the middle of the night and have everyone leave the computers turned on and logged off over night. Do different sites each night, should be able to set up a rolling weekly or fortnightly check. Then some remote monitoring and mangement of routers and you have most of it done.

by mark1diver

Your question implies that you have some specific problem with the client machines.
You ask about Altiris and SMS, SMS will require a dedicated team to build the scripts etc. If you dont have prior knowledge then don't bother.
Altiris is a great tool if you have a relatively small number of user platforms out there and plenty of server type resources and good bandwidth for image uploading. However it will require plenty of time for the original set-up.
Continuous data protection solutions may help.
One option would be to use a product like storactive. This would store all the desktop data and files on a central server, and provides continuous data protection. Each time a user connects their changed data is sent to the server. Files that are already stored are not sent/stored again. Basically you would be able to create a boot CD (or DVD) with the latest image up to the last connection before corruption or machine death.
Downside : 1) you need to get each machine connected to the local server to do the initial scan & upload.
2) Users need to connect to the newtork on a regular basis to transfer new & changed files.
Upside:
1)If a machine needs to be replaced it is possible to extract the user data and load it to the box.
2)Trusted users can restore their own files if they delete in error.
3) The time for each scan & Upload means that you cant do everyone straight away (the network would be flooded). So time to do the rest of the manic work everyday.
FYI The back end uses a database to hold the machine and user specifics plus a storage area for all the files.
If I recall you can do a 30 day trial on this product.
Mark

by jerome.koch

Yes,
You are stretched too thin. However, with the right configuration you can at least manage the desktop builds, workstation inventory, and patch management.Altiris can do most of these, and Windows Policy Packages can do the rest. Of course, this dosen't prevent daily calls for IT Support, new projects, Server maintenance, DR Planning etc...

by kattoon

We us Altiris to deploy standardized images, patches/updates, etc. It really works great for us because the Altiris pushes can be delayed/scheduled at a time when users are less busy. If your remote users are using VPN, you may be able to push the updates to them at that time (so they don't have to come to the office for the update).

We also use Cisco Security agent to monitor/block certain types of installs. The users hate it, but it keeps everything clean.

by jterry

The fact that not too many poeple are answering you says to me that they think the answer is obvious. Your companies management hasn't got a clue and you should be looking elsewhere for a more sane position.

by smurgymac

both of you take your holiday time simultaneously. Lets see them cope without you, then make your case for more staff.

just a thought

by mstoumba

I would be looking at Novell Zenworks and Novell Ifolder to solve your problem. Zen would keep your Workstations up to date and Ifolder would keep your End users data backed up so if something happens send then another computer , let ZEN patch the new computer and let Ifolder restore the users data. I just works.

by robbi_ia

If your hardware and applications are even somewhat standardized, you can create images using Zenworks, and if a user runs into problems, a new image can be pushed down to the user. Installation of applications can be handled using zen as well. I'm in a situation with 2 IT personnel for 200+ users in multiple locations. We provide helpdesk, hardware support, server admin, media support,security, and maintain the agency website as well... the only work that goes outside our office is warranty hardware repair. Yet we have plenty of time to do things like teach user technical training and offer technical seminars to the agency's clients as well. And Ifolder rocks!

by gooder

Be subtle ? one of you on hols, one of you goes sick. Even for only a day or so, just to see what effect it has. This is stage one of the strategy ? it?ll give you some idea of the impact based on how many complaints come in, and you can use this as an example when selling your proposals later ? ?look what happened when??

With users spread out like that, you will never get them to agree to an IT team at each site. So for your immediate peace of mind you should use some good centralised management and remote control tools ? Altiris is a good one to look at. This will help keep things up to date from a technical viewpoint.

Next, outsource the support for each site to an IT company local to that site. This is just for user support and so on, not the strategic stuff which is what you should be interested in. YOU, not the remote office, must maintain the contract to ensure the outsource company can be trusted and knows the boundaries they work within (you don?t want them fiddling with your PCs to ?improve? them).

If your company doesn?t want that expense, start planning regular trips out to each site as part of your ?relationship management? with your users. Then when those flights and expenses start to add up, point out the alternatives.

Make a strong business case ? listing the company/business benefits (NOT the technical ones ? they won?t understand those). List the disbenefits ? what could go wrong if you DON?T do this. Again, stick to what they would understand ? like loss of revenue, reputation, etc. Similar to a case for business continuity I suppose. If they ask what the return on investment is, or for you to quantify savings, ask them what the ROI on their insurance policy is and ask them to quantify the cost if they didn?t have one and something went wrong.

The situation your company has put you in is ridiculous. I hope they see your proposals as you doing what they employed you for ? thinking ahead, avoiding problems, doing what?s best for the company and it?s reputation. If they can?t see that, then as others have suggested ? look elsewhere.

by rabscuttle

You need to talk to them in their language, something Techies have not always been good at. Create a credible disaster scenario where they are losing buckets of cash, then save the day with a way out of the mess. If necessary, give them a tast of what could happen and cost it. Money is all in these situations and if you can't talk cash then you will never win.

by admin

I did something similar way back in the day to justify adding IT staff at a manufacturing company. I documented every IT request and compiled them weekly to demonstrate the amount of lost productivity due to issues that couldn't be addressed immediately because of short-staffing. According to the estimates I was able to compile, the lost productivity amounted to over 4 times the cost of hiring an entry-level tech to help run cables, install software and provide help desk support. The decision was made to hire a tech a week after I submitted my business case to the CFO. It's all about statistics and $$$ and cents. Translate that server downtime and lost client connectivity into real monetary values and re-present your case.

by ed the auditor

This is called SMRC (Saving Money Regardless of Cost) and it's a commonly found situation which will continue until the s**t hits the fan. What happens when one of the two people is on holiday and the other goes sick? Do you buy services from a provider to reduce the workload? As far as longer term sustainability of the arrangement: FORGET IT. Management is very corageous because they fail to understand the magnitude of the risk they are taking if the users do any serious computing. Good luck.

by plumley9

For imaging to help (Altiris or Ghost) the equipment would have to match - multiple locations make that very unlikely. Remember that the less time you have for individual care, the less individualization of workstations you can survivie. No help = no special setups = no special software = everybody gets the generic system. Share the limits.

by too old for it

We have a standard image, then use SMS for differences/patcfhes/upgrades.

Then again, we have about 20 people to make that all work.

by cgbullock

You haven't really told us what the 2 people are rsponsible for. I know some companies that have 1 IT person for more than 1000 users. The question I have is what are the 2 people responsible for, does the company have outside consultants do any big jobs or upgrades, or do the 2 people just "maintain" the current infrastructure. You also have to determine how may applications you support, do you have special applications or are you mainly dealing with office suites and web browsers.
Some companies justify skeleton IT staff due to the fact that they outsource and have service aggrements for some of their products and systems.
So again, I dont think there is a formula by saying X number of user = Y number of IT staff.
Good Luck,
Chris

by dawgit

"X number of user = Y number of IT"
interesting concept. I wonder if some-one has actually come up with some sort of idea on that. If for no other reason, than just cost effectiveness. Maybe not with X# of users, but with nodes & uses.

by pkr9

I once worked in a world-known shipping line, and we did the maths.
We found out that unless you had very advanced central administration - not just Altiris, Ghost or whatever, it came out about 1 fulltime IT person per 50 PC's. Some of these 'IT persons' were hidden and not listed as IT persons, but were hired as accountants, secretaries, engineers, HR or whatever, but spent time every day doing IT work. Naturally this subtracted from the time they could spend at the work they were educated to do, and paid for doing.

Much of the 'advice' they gave and work they did was by nature amateurish and based on what they did on their PC at home, which is a very different thing than a networked corporate thing. One of the reasons to use another OS at work, than the one people use at home. Users never crash mainframes, as they have no clue as to how it works, but stay with working with the applications.

by pkr9

1.
Find out what 'No IT' costs pr. hour in salaries, lost revenues, bad PR. Remember that the cost of an employee is about double the salary: They need a building, a chair, a desk, some equipment, insurance, pension e.t.c.

2.
Determine the cost to the company if you and your assistance suddenly disappear - plane crash, severe sickness or similar, and new staff/consultancy company must take over from scratch. Ask the company to take out a life insurence on the amount - it'll be real expensive.

3.
Find out how many people use time for IT support around the organisation. How many people paid to works as accountants - or worse engineers - are playing part time IT staff? It is absolutely certain that you have 'hidden' assistants, some of them giving dubious or plain wrong 'help'.

4
Face management with your findings, and DON'T go into technical discussions. Obviously they know very little of dangers to business, so they will know nothing at all about IT techinal stuff. Maybe they'll bring up their nephew and his great skills in IT. Cut them down and ask if they want amateurs to run the bussiness backbone, or tell them how good your son is a playing 'monopoly' or 'railroad tycoon', and ask for him being given a job as strategy planner.

You could ease your burdens with strict enforcement of group policies, central management of SW and patches, as mentioned by other posters.

If your SW can run on a central server (most likely yours runs on Windows) dump as many PC's as possible and run a thin client set-up. Thin clients needs a lot less maintenance than a PC, and users can't see any difference from having a PC. They can hear and feel the difference, as a thin client don't need a fan, and don't emit noise, heat or smell.

Your company might not know, but they have placed themselves in a dangerous position and shareholders should worry.

by blu97ram

I feel your pain. I am an IT admin myself, in roughly the same position you are in. Only difference is that my assistant is part time. Three days a week, and only in the morning. I work in an office that has 6 people in it. We support all machines and network functions in the office.This is not a bad deal, except for the fact that we are also a nation wide help desk supporting a very large retail chain that shall go nameless for this posting, but I am required to offer desktop, laptop, and network connectivity. The Desktop and LT support is full support at all levels Network connectivity is first level and some second level. For the most part the job just keeps us bisy, but there are days that I would love to cut the phone lines. I have asked for more help and was told to get someone, but every time I have an interview,and send the person to the next level, the answer is that the person does not fit the company image and they don't get hired.

by too old for it

So, how do you schedule your support calls, executive support, repairs and so forth to occur just when your PT help is there?

And you don't have final say on full-time help you need?

by blu97ram

I try to use my part time helper to do follow up on open calls that are software related, and take new calls that are at his skill level. This allows me to devote those mornings to making hardware repairs with minimual interuptions. The only saving grace for me right now is that our main customer recently rolled out all new equipment to their field users. After I got past the connectivity issues with the new equipment the dust began to settle some. Most days are just busy, others are pure torture. The main thing that keeps us afloat is the contract only requires us to be on call 8-5 EST M-F. But that does not mean those are my hours. (I wish!)

by blu97ram

I try to use my part time helper to do follow up on open calls that are software related, and take new calls that are at his skill level. This allows me to devote those mornings to making hardware repairs with minimual interuptions. The only saving grace for me right now is that our main customer recently rolled out all new equipment to their field users. After I got past the connectivity issues with the new equipment the dust began to settle some. Most days are just busy, others are pure torture. The main thing that keeps us afloat is the contract only requires us to be on call 8-5 EST M-F. But that does not mean those are my hours. (I wish!)

by blu97ram

I try to use my part time helper to do follow up on open calls that are software related, and take new calls that are at his skill level. This allows me to devote those mornings to making hardware repairs with minimual interuptions. The only saving grace for me right now is that our main customer recently rolled out all new equipment to their field users. After I got past the connectivity issues with the new equipment the dust began to settle some. Most days are just busy, others are pure torture. The main thing that keeps us afloat is the contract only requires us to be on call 8-5 EST M-F. But that does not mean those are my hours. (I wish!)

by rlevison

ok, All these people saying things like it depends on your work load and your people must be exp users are crazy! I dont care what your work load is or how knowledgable your people you just cant do it! You want to make a point to your management, the two of you should just call in sick 2-3 days straight. I think then management will wake up and hear your plea's for more help. If you have most of your staff remote then you need 24/7 support. I would think a staff of 10 with 2-3 part-timers for fill. I could go on but you probably have your hands full!

by steve.lewinsky

I think as a whole, most IT departments are understaffed. And being in this facility for 9 years now, we went from 3 IT staff here at one facility supporting 80+/- users, down to only myself now supporting 2 separate facilities with 125+ users and a intermittant night shift.
I like being busy, as it makes my day go faster. I also enjoy knowing that I came in as a Co op student, and they let my bosses go due to down sizing. In the overview of the position, If they let me run my facility as I feel fit, then I can support all the needs of the users and do it effectively. But when they start wanting reports, surveys, helpdesk tickets, this cuts into my time severly. I am currently in process of doing a facility wide rollout of new PC's, including migrating users from NOVELL, to Microcrap. (Sorry, but a MS admin doesn't understand how easy NOVELL is to admin in comparison. And I am dual cert so I am unbiased.)
I am able to roll out the new PCs and keep up to the regular user problems and network issues. And next month, a new version of Lotus notes!

by too old for it

I have a friend who used to be a one man shop. WHen the "requirement" for reports, tickets, yadda came in he chaned his voice mail to somethin like "I am not able to take your call now as I am generating reports, metrics and other busy-work ..."

Took exactly the CEO calling once before the rports were pushed back on the business side (who decided they were not [b]really[/b] that necessary) and a couple kids from the high schol IT program on staff.

Go figure.

by blitzsonik

You are definately headstrong for putting up with this to this point. I applaud you!

IN my humble opinion, I am afraid you are in a "prickely perdicament"! :)

On one hand, should you take the advice of those that say take a few sick days and something DOES go wrong, then based on the management you have described, it could backfire on you. I see one of two scenarios happening: 1) Management will blame you for whatever happens and use you as an example or 2) They say nothing and then you will be left to clean up the mess created by the void you left behind.

One the other hand, if you don't take the sick time and force management to see what you contribute, you and your admin will undoubtedly burn out over time and be spinning your wheels going nowhere. I've spent many a day running around putting out fires leaving absolutely no time for standardization, patch/asset/project management, all the while, management hasn't got a clue as to the choas that engulfs you!

Then there are those people who are suggesting software or scenarios to help fix your situation. The way I see it, you ain't got the time to take a leak, let alone install and configure a software or hardware solution to ease administration. Not to mention that if management isn't seeing the need for more staff, they aren't going to approve the cost of whatever solution you decide to implement. But then again, you need SOMETHING to ease your pain.

While I do agree with the posters who say look elsewhere, I also realize that it is not that simple. While the market is getting better, one cannot always quit and pick up another job on the way out the door and with a family, you definately cannot afford to be unemployed!

Unfortunately, I have no magic answer. While building your case in business terms is the first step, finding the time to do the research and then writing the proposal will be a challenge. I see a lot of late nights and weekends in you future.

Good luck with whatever you choose to do!

Blitz

by dr_zinj

Think of disaster prepardness from an HR stand point.
1. Can the company function if you or your assistant die or are incapacitated?
2. Can someone to come in and replace you on 24 hours notice?
3. Do either of you have critical, non-replicated/non-replicatable knowledge of your company's systems?

If the answers to 1 & 2 are no, or the answer to 3 is yes; then you're company's managers have a grave problem. Their company can fail due to your loss. While this is wonderful from an employment, salary negotiation standpoint, it is critically stupid from a management standpoint.

by techmail2

I recently left a 90 person scattered company (US and Canada) that has two IT people. They have several standard configurations for PCs (depending on the user's area - sales, development, etc) and the PCs come from the vendor with HP's Radia client installed. Each PC's configuration is defined in Radia (by PC name) and a new PC can be loaded in a matter of hours via a high speed Internet connection. Common data (new user package, schedules, health care docs, etc) is updated via Radia. Online backups of PC data are done between 2 and 5AM using an Iron Mountain product. The combination of Radia software installation and the Iron Mountain backup allows a failed PC to be replaced overnight by shipping a new PC and having everything reloaded online. The user calls/emails a support person who either ships a replacement from stock or contacts the vendor to ship a replacement (overnight in either case). The user will have everything restored back to the morning of the failure, so at most one day's work is lost.

Problem reports are tracked in a ticketing system (don't know which one, it was introduced after I left).

John

by systems magician

I am in the same boat as you except my only other location is in Asia where we have grown from 5 to 45 users. I have not set foot in that office or seen the faces of the people there and somehow managed to grow that office from ADSL to full T-1 with VOIP, all Windows XP-SP2 and current with Service packs. The computers where remotely setup from initial power on to end-user hand-off.
It is also an office plague with turnovers so the work just doesn't end. The Director of MIS is now just a figurehead.

The bottom line here is if you become successful at it, the management will not see the short comings of their decisions. I say document, document and let the chips fall where it will.

You are not going to win this debate if you keep things running because what they see is 2 people can do it. When will you have time to learn and for your personal life. It used to be that 1:5 was the ratio, I think now 1:20 is workable. Learn to say NO and lock down your desktops.

Good Luck

by net1tech

People like you are the reason IT sucks for so many of us. Companies love desperate insecure types like you. The more work they pile on your back the more you'll do. Do less work. Let things pile up. Let things NOT get done. One of two things will happen both of which is better for you. Either they will hire more help or they will fire you. The IT field is hot right now. There are good jobs everywhere. Only a very desperate fool would stay in a work environment like yours. The company gets richer while you get poorer both financially and mentally. Life is too short to "live at work" and toil in misery and fear while others enjoy their leisure life and become rich on your sweat. Remember Enron. There is no gold watch or pats on the back waiting for you at retirement.

by climenhaga

I was in your situation and I know how hard it is to see what your situation is. Everything ken said is right on point. This is a clear case of exploitation and if you don't stand up for yourself you are making the situation worse for all of us. Find an employer that does not exploit. You are not going to be able to change management at your current place. You've already set yourself up as the patsy. I can't tell you how much my life improved once I left the sweatshop I was at.

by leaf_fan

I was brought into the company I currently work for 7 years ago to help standardize and centralize IT services through Head Office.

I have:
1,000+ employees
150 users
20 offices throughout North America
2 IT staff.

I started by analyzing the core requirements, and noticing that most IT services could be served through one central office. Our Accounting, Order Entry, Shipping, all work best if run in one location, and not over a WAN Link.

To effect this, I have introduced Citrix and Thin Clients, for example. All remote plants use Citrix clients loaded on a Thin Client computer. No more patching headaches at remote plants that do not have a full time IT person on staff.

I then budget just over 1 employee salary for Consulting Fees, to bring in outside techs for items I can not do remotely. This covers all remote plants and offices.

This, in effect, reduces travel costs and overhead, as I do not have to visit these locations regularly.

Also, strict standards for laptops and desktops, where used, also help. By not giving Administrative control to anyone for day to day activities, virus' and such have less potential impact.

We couple that with strong AV protection at all layers, email, gateway, servers, desktops etc.

Also included is employee education. "If you are unsure, do not open the attachment, call IT".

By systematically going through best practices, assigning resources as necessary, and not overstaffing, I have been able to redirect overhead budget $$'s to automating our procedures and constantly improving our network.

My company is a $50M/yr company, with an IT budget of less than $500k for this year. That includes, salaries, communications (T1 lines, DSL etc), Hardware, Software Licensing etc.

We are also a Microsoft-centric shop, utilizing most of the new technologies as they are released.

Windows XP, Server 2000 and 2003, SQL 2000 and Reporting Services, Exchange 2003, IIS 6.0, Sharepoint Services, are our standards here.

Just my $0.02. Is it easy to run with a small staff? Not necessarily, and you need really good people to do that, and great support from upper management.

Also, your company's needs and business model have to fit that kind of environment, ie, Citrix and/or Thin Clients.

If you are a graphics and printing shop, for example, this model would not fit.

For us, luckily, it does, and helps me to keep a tight rein on my IT Budget every year.

by pkr9

I back Citrix and thin clients fully. It has been the future for several years and the office PC is as dead as the Dodo bird.

Instead of keeping Exchange, IIS, Sharepoint and other MS servers alive, I'd streamline even more and replace these with a single Domino server.

rgds,
Peter

by jterry

I only ask because if your company is dealing with sensitive personal information on your clients I'm waiting to hear about them on the news for the next Security information theft. Guess who the company is going to have for a fall guy?

by mindilator9

My company has 800 employees, 750 of which are remote users. About 100 of them are out of state. I used to do nothing but answer the phone, I would never get any of what I consider "real work" done. My users are some of the least computer literate on the planet. There are poor dying kids in Uganda with a windup computer that know more than my users. Now my phone almost never rings and when it does it's something I can handle within 10 minutes. I did not opt for the neglect-them-and-forget-them strategy to lower my phone calls. I and my network admin spend more time on our projects than on tech support these days. It is possible to efficiently handle many hundreds of users with a couple staff. I would personally like to see 1 or 2 more people on staff, just to be capable of doing even more than we are. But at this point, it's not necessary. I'm not staying late after work and my phone is not ringing off the hook. There are ways you can eliminate problems before they start so you have time to mess around with that new service or hardware you've been wanting to install.

by Member 25348569

that he wants to know [b]how[/b] you do it.

Given that you "did not opt for the neglect-them-and-forget-them strategy" then what strategy [b]did[/b] you adopt to make your users so happy?

by dawgit

I was thinking the same thing. ?:| Ok, tell us just how you do do that...
-or- it just sounds like more of that drivel from the 'One Minute Manager' Text Book. (The only sucess to that was the book sales).

by kiltie

Just as important as the "how" is the "what" did you do, that appears to be so easy to handle?

It suggests that either you are VERY good at your job, or that there isn't much to do in your job.

The poser of the original question was asking for suggestions for his situation, not yours, unless there are similarities, so do you have anything that may help?

Enlighten us my friend.

by ray

You seem like an ideal candidate for outsourced IT services. Chances are you'll get more for your money than hiring another IT guy. Decide which services or applications, would be best candidates for outsourcing and add others as needed.

by fieldy

I should imagine your management would give over more IT $'s if you presented them with failure documentation (and what it cost the in $'s). I would bet on there being a lot of issues and problems due to the lack of support that you have, so show them, make it a data driven arguement. Give them ROI's, TCO's etc.

If that does not work, pull the plug sit back and say "will get back to you-too short staffed to do this at the moment" - that always works :)

by audreyd

It might be remotely doable with a lot of outsourcing. Just what level of "tech support" do you do? Application support, hardware, networking, etc. How old is your system? Older desktops take a lot more support than new ones.
How sophisticated are your users? Can they do some things by themselves or are they computer illiterates. I'm in a 2-programmer shop where we do desktop support, server admin and database programming, but we've trained a number of users how to deal with simple problems themselves. Plus we outsource as much as we can.

by realgem

I'd say that they're barking mad. A company that size is doing substantial business. If one (i.e. half) of the IT department is on vacation and the other half calls in sick, they're sunk.

If it's just desktop support, as another post suggested, then two is ok. But, from your original post, you seem to be doing more than that.

by duckdive1

I have to agree with most people that have replied. 2 techs for the entire company seems unreasonable. But you haven't mentioned much about apps and infrastructure. I'd like to know how the offices are connected. High speed, VPN, part of the domain? What kind of problems are you having? If it is hardware, then buy better hardware with service contracts. If it is user issues, get firewalls/IPS with spyware protection, establish computer use policies, and train/provide online training materials for users. If the problems are with apps, then ensure you have support from the manufacturer, document any issues and get support, and run the most stable releases.

My suggestions:
1) Outsource most troublesome offices to local IT vendors
2) Consolidate most troublesome applications to Citrix servers at your office
3) Monitor all remote offices with simple software or service
4) Consider using Desktop Authority (Scriptlogic) to simplify settings (group policy)
5) As others said, standardize and use images. Consider using Acronis True Image
6) Establish realistic expectations for management and users. Possibly appoint a couple of application specialists from within the company that can assist with issues for specific apps.
7) Use a remote support application

If you don't have all 1-7 and the questions above answered with confidence, then I'm sure that it is a challenge. Keywords: outsource, services, companywide administration

by bluron

but before you rightfully cut my head off an shove it on a pole in front of your office, i was just trying to throw a little (sic) humour your way. if you ever have spare time, pepar a report comparing other companies of similar size and usage and how many it pros' working so that you may convince the powers that be (ptb) that they are at risk of it burnout. i wish you the best of luck and hope you can find a solution to your problem. ~;?- ron

by tommy orange

i have used altiris since we were at 20 people and 3 remote sites from about 2+ years ago and think it is the best thing since sliced bread. we are now 100+ users with nearly 20 remote locations.

depending on your standard operating enviroment would depend on if it is more headache or not. if you have a limited amount of PC makes and models then the number of images you need to create/ manage will be easier to manage. also you should get your software packaged so it can be deployed. once again, if you have a standard then this isnt too difficult.

my advice to you would be make sure your altiris partner is up to scratch ... my first altiris implementation by a "partner" was a mess and had to have altiris come in a fix it. also - if you dont have them already - implement standards for your hardware and software.

10 - to answer your crazy question - we have 100 staff and i have 7 IT people.

by elrsmith

I sympathize. If you intend to change things, I suggest you obtain an ally at a high level who understands enough about IT to know that this is a critical BUSINESS issue. Framing it as a business issue, and not an "IT" issue is important to get the attention of executives. I am assuming yours is a profitable firm that is growing rapidly and that the IT dept is lagging behind the growth. How does your dept contribute to the bottom line? If you were not doing this work, how would the organization suffer - framed in business results? What are the consequences to the business of under-resourcing the IT dept? Good luck!

by methatswho

I work for the Public School system. 2 Techs for 300 machines is a lot of people from my view. We have over 3,000 computers, 30 servers, 1,000 printers and all types of FAXes and scanners that we have to support to try to keep our students on the learning curve.

We have 3 computer techs, 1 Administrator and 1 Tecnology Director to hand out the support.

About 1/3 of the computers are from the last 2 years and are under warranty so we have Dell send their tech to swap out parts if we have problems with any of them.

300 machines to 2 techs...WOW where do I sign up?

by admin

I don't even know if your situation is even comparable to the OP's. I've done contract work for school districts before, and there's a general trend to bring in a lot of contractors to do the heavy lifting and train the staff. In addition, the school districts I worked with had support contracts for *everything*.

Obviously I don't know your specific situation, but ratio of techs to computers is not the only indicator given here. If you want a good comparison, how about taking the following into account:

Ratio of different configurations to computers
Ratio of different configurations to techs
Ratio of remote users to local users
Ratio of service contracts to computers
Ratio of contractors to workload
Ratio of support incidents escalated to external contractors to support incidents handled by internal staff
Ratio of servers to staff
Comparison of private sector requirements vs public sector requirements

Of course there are many more indicators that can be used, but (number of staff):(number of computers) is a very superficial statistic that doesn't mean all that much on its own.

by jterry

When his machines are down his company is losing money. What is your response time in a school system? Next Week if possible?

by methatswho

The only items that are out sourced at the initial network setup I.E. pulling in the Cat5 and set up of the switches. We have it all on our shoulders; including trying to get the people out there trained on Network usage and local profile backups to the network.

Response times varies greatly. We are given some work that is "do it right now" or "it can wait".

Our ratio is still 3 people to 3,000 computers. As I said before 300 to 2, where do I sign up?

by gurnmonster

Do you need remote support software? NetSupport Manager can help with some of your problems. Good luck and yes, it sounds like you either do need more staff or you need to outsource!

by databaseben

Obviously, your great employer has much resources except for your department. There may be some preception that being an i.t. guy is easy money by your management. Time to role up your sleeve and put a squeeze on their "jewels" Ask for a raise or extra employees for your department, or else....

by proph3t777

I support around 200 people both in branch locations (15 of those) with around 30% users working from home offices or remote sites. I am responsible for a SBS2003 server here at head office running exchange with 30 staff including the owners, managers and support staff etc.

I run the support desk, setup new machines coming onto the network, roll out our private network, do remote setups and support, printers, phone systems, VOIP, video conference system, backups, handle all leasing and purchsing of hardware and software. I handle all IT area setups when a new branch is opened. I also manage an off site mail server. I work with outsourced coders developing our corporate software, and provide all support for that, new users etc etc etc etc....Did I mention there is only me? No one else at all helps me...ever.

To make it worse I was asked to go through a pay evaluation as I hadnt had a pay change since the company had 20 people in it and 3 branches. Now the company is 10 times larger and the pressure and responsibility is rediculous. I am working almost 60hours a week some weeks. I was thinking that my pay evaluation would mean it goes up...but it was lowered by 26%.

What should I do, and what should I be getting paid for what I've said I do above???

by keoniana439

Bro, you need to get out, quit and find someone who understand what you go thru everyday. How do you plan for recovery and apply IT strategic plans if you focus on technical support all the time? You need to get another job, in another place period.

Ted

by ibanezoo

Good to know my company is not the only one like that. We are 3 guys with a staff of over 800 at 15 locations spread across 300 miles, plus customer support. When we ask for more people we get threatened with being outsourced. The way we deal with it is to just hire our own outsourcing for certain projects. We promise to get to everything, we just don't promise when.

What makes us feel better is when the CEO is bitching and whining about his email not syncing or whatever petty thing and we have a server freaking out we get to bring up the fact that we could help him, but we don't have anyone able to get to his office right now and he just has to wait... which is usually met with "but I'm the god damned CEO!!!!!!!!"

Not sure why we all still work here. We have scheduled syncronized quitting days in the past.... just wusses I guess...

by derek.guilfoyle

Have you considerd Citrix and Active Directory publishing standard apps to dumb terminals for all users, patches and updates then just need to be maintained on servers. Number of offices seems unrealistic in relation to number of employees (8 per office?).

by admin

You've already stated that you subcontract out 1/3 of your computer repair work. You also subcontract out the hardware set-up and initial configuration. Five folks to babysit 3,000 computers is not bad, as long as you have all the same or similar configurations, you outsource all of the upfront work, and the business you're in is not in the business of making money.

It would be interesting to have better metrics to compare, like the number of remote users vs. local users you support out of the 3,000.

by dave.clark

Yep, supporting remote users is tough. Do your users connect over VPN or do they usually just connect to the Internet? If connected straight to the Internet, simply enable Windows Automatic update. If connecting over VPN, look into Microsoft WSUS. WSUS is essentialy Windows update but your in-house admins maintain the server, they can download patches to the WSUS server then test and approve the patches for deployment, You have granular control of patch deployment by creating groups so that you can deploy patches only to specific groups of users if you wish. WSUS will also patch MS Office products.

WSUS can resume the patch downloads everytime the user connects to the network. WSUS allows your Admin to generate reports showing the patch status of the systems it manages.

WSUS is also free.

So far I've addressed only patch management, Most AV software already has an auto update feature that can be configured to pull updates from the Vendor's site or your own server, or even multiple locations.

A well thought out repeatable approach to most of your tasks is not out of reach, you already know what the most common problems are, go out and grab the low hanging fruit first, then attact the smaller problems.

by rwalterk

I didn't see much activity on this thread after the first few days and hadn't checked it since. I was amazed to see all the responses and have read them all.

First of all I want to thank everyone for the informative and candid responses. There's lots of good suggestions here and technologies I can look into.

To answer some of the questions some of you had:

* All of the remote sites are connected via managed VPN from one vendor. It's expensive, but then again the provider manages everything right down to the routers on site. There's no way I'd have time to manage the individual connections and vendor relationships with all of the different broadband providers.

* We use Citrix heavily. The remote PCs do have MS Office installed locally but all other productivity apps are run via Citrix. We've done our best to make the PCs basically just thin clients + MS Office. If a PC breaks to the point of needing repair, we overnight them a brand new machine (we use Ghost for imaging) and have them ship back the old one for reconditioning.

* Management is not opposed to spending on technology when there's an obvious productivity or financial benefit. For example we've transitioned away from tapes and gone to online backup; we have a huge SAN parked at a colocation facility and all backups are done over the wire. It's an amazing system. We've also got redundant application servers for our critical apps (data is replicated hourly) at that same colocation facility in case our building burns to the ground. Unfortunately that spending does not include personnel.

* Since I'm the highest ranking technology person in the company, my responsibilities include strategic planning, purchasing, budgeting, project management, etc. I just spend far too little time on these issues since I also have to assist my Sys Admin with day-to-day support and maintenance duties.

* The volume of generic support requests isn't too bad, 6-7 per day on average, but that doesn't include project related calls. We are in the midst of transitioning to a new ERP system and will also be moving our office in the next few months.

* Yes, I'm going to start looking for a more sane position now that I've been here for a few years and have built up a solid chunk of time as an IT Director. The experience has been positive in many ways but I am seriously burnt out.

by giledwin

I was thinking the same thing. I would give my left arm to have one spare, much less 20 spares.

by techiemikee

Requisitioning 20 spares in a 300 user environment is a good way to get fired or passed over for promotion.

300 users can be supported by a 2-person staff. I'd recommend a contractor for as long as you could get away with. I've found companies that will hire contractors for large deployments only and wind up extending their contracts indefinitely. It is a good way to ease the budget heads into proportioning more money. Accounting departments like the non-fixed costs associated with contractors and you can ask them not to come in when the budget runs low without having to go through the lay-off process.

To lesson the workload you could give an administrative assistant or even the receptionist the restrictive rights that allow the ability to reset passwords.

Buy good business class machines that come with a 3 year warranty and retire the machines when the warranty wears off so your time spent replacing hard drives and other parts that are known to wear out in time is minimized, and you have the manufacturer's support for your end-users to call when you are unavailable.

Tighten security on the workstations and laptops so that the damage users can do is limited.

Create Ghosted Images on DVDs so that endusers can restore the machine back with all the company applications when they do screw it up.

Determine your most common problems and compose automatic fixes in batch file.

Learn how to do unattended installs on Service Packs, Hotfixes and other Microsoft Products.

Automate everything you can one or more of the following, Perl, Python, VB Script, Kixtart anything that will allow you consistent results, quick plain-text modification and can be repeated on each and every machine. Some of those language will require a compilor to create executables that will run on all the machines, but they have a syntax that can be learned easy and deployed more quickly than VB, VC++, etc.

When possible create programs that will allow the user single click upgrades, they put in a CD or download a program, click on the custom application and the upgrade or fix is done automatically for the user. Provide written step-by-step instruction, otherwise you'll be trying to relay instructions over the phone, if you're talking about repeating the same tasks times 200-300 machines, thats a lot of time spent on the phone.

by sr10

An IT staff of 2 could work, if (and only if) they are not expected to provide the level of service that another company gets with an IT staff of 50.

For example, since you have 60 offices and only two people, there won't be anyone to sit with the remote users and help them get connected or overcome some of the bizarre Windows problems that have to be seen to be believed.

Be explicit about what will not be done. Then it's a business decision whether to live with that, outsource functions or staff up.

If you can't set expectations and have the business live within its means, then you have a strategic decision to make. They can only fire you once, but they can make your life a living hell as long as you allow it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.