5 Good Qualities & 5 Bad Qualities
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tech-trend
Not to be cruel, but I have to tell you, based on the couple posts you have made here, that you would not be invited back for a second interview. I have encountered many folks who had the skills but lacked the personality needed in the work environment. You might have a Masters in CIS, carry a boat load of certs and know your way through the Windows Registry hives like the back of your hand, but if you come off as a cocky, arrogant geek on an ego trip, the trap door is going to open under you.
Your resume tells me that you meet the necessary requirements of the job and gives me some expectation that you could do the job. The interview is to fill in the blanks and answer more specific questions that further determine if you are the best fit for that job. Part of that is further assessing techinical skill, but I'll argue that the lions share of the interview is designed to evaluate your soft skills. Are you truly a team player? How do you respond to difficult situations, crisis, construtive criticism and disagreements, etc?
If you need some help with that list of weaknesses, here's something to chew on: A cocky attitude makes me nervous and I don't want my network servers managed by an admin that exhibits a know-it-all, risk-taking, I'm-the-best-there-is, the-user-is-inferior manner. I'd rather take the Kia than the Benz in this case.
Someone who has the right attitude, enthusiasm and work ethic can be trained to fill in those tech shortcomings. If you have the tech capability but lack the soft skills then I'll move on to the next interview because that ego could cost me a whole lot more than paying for cert training. I would recommend "How to Win Friends and Influence People" by Dale Carnegie and "Seven Habits of Highly Effective People" by Stephen Covey. These are good places to start for everybody.
So, you may hate me now, but maybe you will thank me later. If you have the right attitude you will get (and keep) the job and employers will pray you never leave.
Sincerest Regards
by heavener
by jardinier
While my professional experience has not been in IT, obviously similar criteria would apply in any profession.
After being out of my profession (journalism) for several years, I scored a job ahead of applicants with much more experience than myself, because the boss liked my attitude.
Once having won the job, there was no problem in catching up on those few lost years of experience.
Hahahahahah
THAT is very good..........If I was hiring, I would hire you due to your response ( and qualifications of course)......To me that shows courage....wits, honesty, and cretive thought.......
by k2dadio
by oz_media
Yes.
Well if you only get 10MPH you get to take tha car back as it was blatantly sold under false pretenses.
If you are asked to list weaknesses you must, in a positive and aware way.
Selling a car is very different and the rules are an extremely fine line, I've sold cars, but crossing that line leaves you nowhere to run when it is returned a week later as it hasn't lived up to expectations.
You don't have to tell someone it has terrible mileage, but if ASKED you MUST be forthright.
The analogy you gave was close but this isn't about what you have to divulge and what you don't nor is it about the morals or ethics involved.
This was to address an old question some employers still have the haul to ask.
I personally don't have a problem listing my weaknesses as I am aware of what I am strong in, if I am not strong at somethnig, I will consider it a weakness. It doesn't have to be some miserable personal putdown. Something as simple as, my typing is poor when I type at speed or don't pay attention, get too tired etc. is a very honest and aware situation that is EASILY improved and someone can just as easily overlook this as a weakness. The idea is to weed out the guys who evade the question or don't think they have flaws.
I think it is more psychological than qualifying.
I agree with both of you, but the 5/5 question is completely subjective. You *can* emphasize your strengths to divert attention from your weaknesses. But when pressed, you must provide a truthful answer.
However, I liken MPG for a car to a necessary, hard skill of an employee. You have it, and there is a value associated with it. To say that your MPG is different than it actually is is a lie. To say that I know Java application development when I barely know JSP is a lie.
But the 5/5 question is different. It's more like asking (and yes, there are probably holes in my logic) "What are the 5 longest trips this car has made?" or "How fast was this car going the 5 times it's gone as fast as it can?"
by pmleo
by mr.blueman
Guess what? The company I had an interview with is one of the largest IT companies in North America and..........They asked that very question. I gave the answer listed minus a few words from being a bit nervous but it helps to be prepared. The interview went well and we'll see what happened. I found the behavioural questions easier but do prepare for those as well with many examples.
James: I saw your encouraging note just before I left - thanx.
by geekchic
Classes would be a great idea and I have been to a few regarding handling "conflicts" and one "first time manager" class. But it is very hard to get 8 hours of instruction from a booklet, and an instructor who is there to sell you more of their company's stuff and then be able to apply it later. I reread the books (and my notes often) and look at sites on the the internet like HRtools for information and our HR guy is pretty good at listening to and answering my dumb questions.
Unfortunately, our budget has been significantly cut over the last two years and training money is all but gone the way of the dinosaur. (Except of course for the chosen few!)
I did find your 4th statement interesting because (embarrassed) that is what I used to do...bam...ask questions. I have learned to become more relaxed and I kind of float around my list of questions as the conversation heads in that direction. The nature of the jobs that I hire for are the "rotating door" type. They are in and then promoted (quit, fired, disappear and not come back) and they are gone and I start over again. I have filled one particular job 3 time since October of 2003.
How do you feel about administering skills "tests" to potential employees? I have been giving that a try lately and am getting better qualifed people (who quickly get promoted onto other things, but at least they are good while they are here!
Thanks for the info...I am willing to learn!
by jimhm
For some positions they are a great tool and very subject tool to get to the hear of the answers. The question is how soon does the person know if they did good or bad on the test.
But that is a good tool for a number of positions - and is generally accetable by most interviewees ...
Isn't management fun - When I was in management - my first boss did the best thing first thing sent me to a 5 day course which covered interview and conflict management - out of state and it was great. Then sent me to Dale Carnegie - and Tostmasters - gave me a good all around skill set.
Sorry to hear your budget is that tight - Interviewing skills are hard to learn OJTing them.. Ouch - that hurts...
Best of luck - but I would use that tool will help get better canidates and weed out the BS and save you time.
by minabird
by zooble
"Who in their right mind will answer-truly, to a question that will hinder his possibilities of getting the job?"
Those whose top priorities countermand being dishonest. I answer every question honestly, as it
a) Gives me piece of mind
b) Adds to my relationship with my employer once the job starts
c) Enables me to say in an interview that all my responses are 100% true and accurate - which puts me a cut above the rest (you?).
Also, because of the above I never add those "smart" "BS" comments.
I must say that doing that can definitely hinder getting a job (and I am out of work right now). But I consider that they don't value honesty in their corporate culture which ultimately costs money, or they miss out, or that someone is better than me.
And on that last point, I am so cool with that. I want the best for my customers/employers (yes, I honestly want the best), and so missing out on a job is at worst a bitter/sweet experience.
However, I can take this stance because I am good, and I can earn a livable income (on the side & contracting) because of the above - even without a "job".
I will do what is best for me [in the long run]. I consider being dishonest now as costing me a lot of money (and character) in the future because of where I know I'm going to end up, and who I need to be.
Stephen
PS - I know this puts me at poles with the common job application process, and probably will earn some flames, but hey - I'm free. Are you?
by geiger
by jardinier
Although he is not interviewing people for jobs, his interviewing technique is brilliant.
He just makes his guests feel at ease, so that they naturally open up and reveal personal things which they may never have revealed to a more aggressive interviewer.
So to put the boot on the other foot, just be yourself and answer any question straightforwardly.
Would you really feel happy to work for someone who expected you to give an unrealistic description of yourself and your skills/experience?
by jmollink
by elwoos
by stevegantt
by plf86
by stubby
And it's worth repeating, why would you want to give an interviewer a reason not to hire you?
It's not a matter of giving them a reason not to hire you, but about you being able to honestly admit that you do have shortcomings - be they technical, relational or some other form. These are not always reasons not to hire you. Agreed, if you tell them you have a chronic sickness record and always work to rule, then those are reasons not to hire. However, if you state that your man management skills are not the best and then instantly qualify that with a "but I'm doing xyz to improve them" ... you have answered the question and shown initiative in providing a potential solution. And what employer doesn't want initiative?
An old mentor of mine once told me (and I've never forgotten it) "Never bring me just a problem, but instead bring me the problem and a potential solution you have thought through. We may not use your solution but it does show me that you aren't complaining just for the sake of complaining."
I now look after 7 staff and when it comes to their appraisals, I expect them to be honest about the failures of the past year and how they have learnt from them and I also expect them to have thought about what can be done to resolve any outstanding issues.
So, to re-iterate. It isn't about giving reasons not to hire - you'll do that all on your own without saying a word, but it is all about honesty and integrity and being able to admit you aren't perfect. None of us are.
by oz_media
"How is this car in the city?"
"How is this car on the highway?"
Now you MAY have some real hot braking issues in the city but you can evade it by saying it runs fine in the city and the mileage is great.
Now if the customer asked what are the weaknesses when driving in the city, "Well, the brakes can get quite hot, but that is quite normal for city stop-and-start driving"
You haven't hidden anything, you mentioned the weakness and have discounted it as being irrelevant because it will not effect the car's performance.
by anom_amos1
The reason for the five questions is not so much a reflection on your ability to do the job and get on with people but a reflection on the recruiters and interviewers inability to choose the right people to start with.
Finding the right person is an art or skill which not many people in the position of HR manager or recruiter actually have.
So they use cheats:
The cheat is to simpley scan your resume into a database the search for key words from the job discription they have been given (not many people can write a good job discription either )
The second cheat is to use Psychological testing to determin your personality type and theoretically your ability to fill the role according to the employers requirments.
This testing is subtle in how it works and ques to what is actually bieng asked is not so much what question is being asked but how it is being asked. So beware ! Giving a pat answer that you think sounds good may do you more harm than, either being honest or a straight out lie !
So here are the cheats :
1: Put the words in your resume and cover letter that are in the job discription.
2: Read the thrasing the words used and the theme of all the questions before answering any one question.
This way you can answer honestly but you can also shape your answers to what is actualy being asked.
And remember many companies and organisations have a culture of superior incompotence !
What that means is they claim to wish to have the best and brightest but only as long as you don't out do me ! In other words an incompotent manager will not higher anyone smarter and more able than them selves for fear of being shown up or their job taken. So Identify this before you go into the interview and during the interview.
Clues are ; Overly officious, dressed too messy or over dressed, has to look at their files a lot,
Askes probing questions but seems uninterested in the answer, Picks a key word in your conversation and goes off on a tangent, uses buzz words but has not clue to their meaning, every thing you say is over their head.
Remember all this and you'll even be able to fool the FBI profilers because once you understand what the real question is you'll know how to answer it accordingly
by maddogdba
Boy and how true!!!!
In my last position, the Senior DBA who had final say on the database hiring team, was turning away some seriously skilled applicants. The rest of us on the database team, who also sat in on the interviews would favored some of these candidates, were surprised at those whom he rejected and the couple that he hired. It seems he couldn't do much about those of us already there, but he made sure new team members were not in a position to 'expose' his short-comings. This guy was cert heavy and promoted by management for that reason. The rest of us knew that without Quest?s TOAD, he could barely log in the databases at the correct level. In the meanwhile the program analyst knew the score and their project managers found that their complaints fell on deaf ears, started bypassing him and made sure change requests went to those DBAs that knew what they were doing.
On the other hand, it shouldn?t surprise me but I still am taken back by the number of recruiters whom get my resume but never actually bother to read it or any requested cover letter. They want to send me on an interview for every 'keyword' discipline, whether I qualify or not. It is no wonder companies do not want to work with placement agencies.
When I am asked about my worst quality, I usually tell them (depending on how the interview went to that point) that I sometimes have trouble sitting still in one place for too long, and that if I am thinking about how to to solve a problem, I am not always 'present', at a meeting or in a conversation. Of course the latter can be a reflection of one of my best qualities, I am very good at abstract problem solving.
1) I simply can't deal with people who think my career in the Marine Corps was a "waste of time".
2) Ditto for young kids who think they can acquire my years of experience in 5 years at a 4-year college.
3) Same for people who think I should only make 10 rupees an hour.
4) Recruiters/interviewers who read my resume (principally WinTel) and start asking me about a Novell/Linux/SCO UNIX position they need to fill make me wonder what IS coming out of college these days.
5) The manager of the local Acloche IT franchise who told me I had better consider a career in office admin at low pay because she had lots of those jobs, and "you'll never get a job in IT anyway" pretty much turns me off of agencies who are "IT shops too".
6) My blood pressure heads for the ionosphere when the guys from CitiFinancial call every time I update my reusme at dice.com to see if I want to sell insurance.
7) Ditto for the local nursing recruiter who seems to think that every IT guy really wants a career changing bedpans because that is where the "need" is.
(ooops, that was 7 ... pick your favorite 5)
by cln
by cwhyte
by sparkie_ig
Well, I have to disagree with the chap who said that the "weakness" does not matter.
Assuming that you are aware of your weakness...then why would you not want to address it/them.
The possibility of the Weakness coming around and biting you in the arse far outweights the possibility of you being able to work on it to lesson it or to bury it completely.
Heck, this is probably one of the things in our lives that we CAN control for the most part and don't know why anyone would not want to...for their own benefit and depending on what the Weakness ...for the benefit of those you work with/around.
just my 2 cents...
(anyone know where the term "my 2 cents worth" actually came fromand what it means.....i can let ya know if you desire.....
by sparkie_ig
Well, I was accepted to 4 law schools but could not afford to go to one. But I did work in several pro bono law clinics. This is what I learned :
If you open a line of thought, can support it with examples if needed and can then turn it around on the other party....you will be seen as an excellant thinker on your feet, prepared, and solid overall. How I incorporate this is ( been outof work since september) anyway...I usually ask What do they want to see from the successful candidate within the first xx time period.
I then ,dependant on their answer work my way into statement of being very good at interactions with a wide range of people and being able to assertain their level of knowledge on the topic, their at ease factor with computers etc...
I can usually do this in the first ten min. of talking with someone. Along with that is working in before they ask...Strong ability to learn apps or systems etc..quickly. I really would be a student for life if i could be....i let em know about CBT courses I am /have taken to stay abreast of new items in the field.
As for weakness...yes this has to be honest, from a previous review or interview etc....My weakness is actually a product of where i was born and spent time growing up. If I am committed to a project or am trying to be heard about the fact that we are losing 23 million a year due to this "XXX" problem and no one is taing me seriously....and then it actually caught on and the HMO did in fact pay us the 23 mill. Anyway...I can be taken the wrong way...rather than passionate about a topic or commited....coming from Texas,Oklahoma & Missouri...I talk with my hands, a have a solid voice for a female. about an Alto or so....but I have had folks go to their supervisor and say that I was Yelling at them....but my supervisor know that that was simply how i talked...so I let them know this weakness and express the fact that I have indeed been working to reduce this.
Right now the marketis tight here in glendale arizona...so if anyone knows of an opening for soemone with Healthcare IT and Programming Business Analysts or sys Analyst....with VB,SAS,Crystal, PL/SQl etc....why not drop me an email at sp4rkie1@aol.com.....many thanks and i hope this helps.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending