Discussion Locked

America's plans for a hasty and complete withdrawal from Iraq

0 helpful
45 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Sorry folks, I cannot give you the URL for this article because it requires membership and password to access at foreignpolicy.com. So you don't get to see the pretty pictures that accompany the article.

Assuming the article is true -- I can't locate it at snopes -- then obviously America has no intention of moving out of Iraq EVER. If it is true, then Democrats would know about it also and presumably would also be anticipating a long stay in Iraq.

Over to you, whizkids:

A citadel is rising on the banks of the Tigris. There, on the river?s western side, the United States is building the world?s largest embassy. The land beneath it was once a riverside park. What sits atop today is a massive, fortified compound. Encircled by blast walls and cut off from the rest of Baghdad, it stands out like the crusader castles that once dotted the landscape of the Middle East. Its size and scope bring into question whether it is even correct to call this facility an ?embassy.? Why is the United States building something so large, so expensive, and so disconnected from the realities of Iraq? In a country shattered by war, what is the meaning of this place?

For security reasons, many details about the embassy?s design and construction must remain classified. But the broad outline of its layout says a lot about one of America?s most important architectural projects. Located in Baghdad?s 4-square-mile Green Zone, the embassy will occupy 104 acres. It will be six times larger than the U.N. complex in New York and more than 10 times the size of the new U.S. Embassy being built in Beijing, which at 10 acres is America?s second-largest mission. The Baghdad compound will be entirely self-sufficient, with no need to rely on the Iraqis for services of any kind. The embassy has its own electricity plant, fresh water and sewage treatment facilities, storage warehouses, and maintenance shops.

The embassy is composed of more than 20 buildings, including six apartment complexes with 619 one-bedroom units. Two office blocks will accommodate about 1,000 employees. High-ranking diplomats will enjoy well-appointed private residences. Once inside the compound, Americans will have almost no reason to leave. It will have a shopping market, food court, movie theater, beauty salon, gymnasium, swimming pool, tennis courts, a school, and an American Club for social gatherings. To protect it all, the embassy is reportedly surrounded by a wall at least 9 feet high?and it has its own defense force. The U.S. Congress has appropriated $592 million for the embassy?s construction, though some estimates put the expected building costs much higher. Once built, it could cost as much as $1 billion a year to run. Charles E. Williams, who directs the State Department?s Overseas Buildings Operations, proudly refers to it as ?the largest U.S. mission ever built.?

But, the idea of an embassy this huge, this costly, and this isolated from events taking place outside its walls is not necessarily a cause for celebration. Traditionally, at least, embassies were designed to further interaction with the community in which they were built. Diplomats visited the offices of local government officials, shopped at local businesses, took their suits to the neighborhood dry cleaner, socialized with community leaders, and mixed with the general public. Diplomacy is not the sort of work that can be done by remote control. It takes direct contact to build goodwill for the United States and promote democratic values. Otherwise, there would be no reason for the United States to maintain its 250-plus diplomatic posts around the world. The embassy in Baghdad, however, appears to represent a sea change in U.S. diplomacy. Although U.S. diplomats will technically be ?in Iraq,? they may as well be in Washington. Judging by the embassy?s design, planners were thinking more in terms of a frontier outpost than a facility engaged with its community. ?The embassy,? says Edward L. Peck, the former U.S. ambassador to Iraq, ?is going to have a thousand people hunkered behind sandbags. I don?t know how you conduct diplomacy in that way.?

It is tempting to think that the Baghdad compound must be an anomaly, a special circumstance dictated by events on the ground in Iraq. But, while it is larger in scope than other U.S. embassies opening around the world, it is hardly unique. Since al Qaeda bombed the American missions in Kenya and Tanzania in 1998, the State Department has been aggressively replacing obsolete or vulnerable embassies with ones designed under a program it calls Standard Embassy Design. The program mandates look-alike embassies, not the boldly individual designs built during the Cold War, when architecture played an important ideological role and U.S. embassies were functionally and architecturally open. The United States opened 14 newly built embassies last year alone, and long-range plans call for 76 more, including 12 to be completed this year. The result will be a radical redesign of the diplomatic landscape?not only in Baghdad, but in Bamako, Belmopan, Cape Town, Dushanbe, Kabul, Lom?, and elsewhere.

If architecture reflects the society that creates it, the new U.S. embassy in Baghdad makes a devastating comment about America?s global outlook. Although the U.S. government regularly proclaims confidence in Iraq?s democratic future, the United States has designed an embassy that conveys no confidence in Iraqis and little hope for their future. Instead, the United States has built a fortress capable of sustaining a massive, long-term presence in the face of continued violence.

Forty years ago, America was forced to flee a newly constructed embassy in Baghdad just five years after it was opened, when the United States broke off relations with Iraq after the 1967 Six Day War. Given the costs of the new compound, the United States would not likely part with its latest Baghdad embassy under almost any circumstances, including escalating violence. As much as the situation there may deteriorate?the fighting already includes missile and mortar attacks in the Green Zone?the biggest problem may not be the embassy?s security; indeed, it is the most impenetrable embassy ever built. Rather, the question is, with its high walls and isolation, will it be hospitable for conducting American diplomacy?

A City Upon a Hill

An embassy?s precise design is classified. But earlier this year, sketches of the massive new U.S. Embassy in Iraq surfaced on the Internet. Herewith, a brief tour of Baghdad, U.S.A.

Mission Colossal

The main embassy building will include a central atrium and a rear portion housing classified offices, including the ambassador?s. Hundreds of non-diplomatic personnel from dozens of U.S. agencies will work in the annex building. The two office buildings will house about 1,000 employees.

Battle Ready

Marines will provide embassy security and live in their own separate barracks. The embassy grounds will be surrounded by high blast walls, which are all that most Iraqis will ever see of the U.S. Embassy.

Home Sweet Home

Inside the compound, staff will feel right at home. The complex will include a shopping market, beauty salon, movie theater, and American fast food.

Compound Cribs

The ambassador?s private residence will offer the most comfortable quarters. Lower-level employees will squeeze into 619 one-bedroom apartments

45 replies

by jackofalltech

There is so much spin, dis-information and outright lies in this I don't know where to begin.
After what happened in Iran, I would expect an embassy anywhere in the middle-east (except Israel, of course) to be impregnable and self-sustaining.
Why are so many people in the U.S. willing (and even eager) to believe the propaganda of our enemies?
President Bush has said from the very beginning that in order to do this right, we must be there for a very long time. Isn't another democracy of free people in that part of the world worth some sacrifices?
And before you even ask, I have a son in the Army over there right now.

Ralph

by charliespencer

"Isn't another democracy of free people in that part of the world worth some sacrifices?"

Long answer: It's not worth all the sacrifices being made on the part of the U.S. military and none on the part of the Iraqi. From my viewpoint several thousand miles away, the Iraqi people are more interested in continuing hundreds of years of sectarian violence than in establishing a democracy. If they want a democracy, let them establish one themselves. Democracy can't be imposed.

And before you even ask, I was 21 years in the Army National Guard. I was mobilized in 1990 for Desert Storm but fortunately our unit was called up too late and the war ended before we shipped out.

Like you, though, I do believe the material jardinier copied is of very questionable accuracy.

by jdclyde

and colorfully discolored and extremely biased.

In a world with all the car bombings going on, are we not suppose to learn from our mistakes?

Having an embassy does NOT point at military occupation, it points at diplomacy with our allies in this case, and enemies in others.

by jardinier

Please visit the website from which I obtained this article:

http://foreignpolicy.com

Then I will be happy to hear your opinion as to the accuracy or otherwise of material published at this website. Only a small number of the articles are exclusive to subscribers, so you will have a good opportunity to assess whether this website publishes fact or fiction.

Naturally I would like you to point out anything that you consider is fictitious, and explain why.

by tonythetiger

[i]If they want a democracy, let them establish one themselves. Democracy can't be imposed.[/i]

That's kinda like saying that a woman who has been beaten constantly for years doesn't want out. It's true that there may be a kind of comfort in the familiar but that's not always a good thing.

by oz_media

A very good friend of mine has spent two of the last three years working all over the middle east. From his travels that take him all over, he said that there are VERY few people there who actually wannt Americans in Iraq and the vast majority despise Bush. Not just teh radical fundamentalists but the general publis who say they were so much happier before. How the repression stated in North America was not at all what it was portrayed to be. How most people lived happy and fruitful lives, until now.

America went where America wasn't wanted. The rest of teh world agreed it was wrong, your head puppet decided he knew better, which is pure BS. He KNEW there was no imminent threat to American civilians, he also knew there were no nukes befor einvading.

Americans are lead to believe that it was an ultimatum, it was not. The ultimatum was to use force to complete inspections, which were going on schedule and turning up nothing, much like the later invasion has shown. Instead of following plan, Bush removed inspectors and invaded the country.

It's simple, black and white, Bush lied and your brothers and sisters, sons and daughters, fathers and nmothers are being killed en masse because of your president's lies, end of story. If you can't come to grips with it, pull your head out of the sand and face reality, he's a warmonger that has killed thousands of Americans with a long term political agenda in mind, not your safety.

by jdclyde

with all the good the US has done for the world, yet so many today will believe anyone else BUT us.

It is clear than many of our efforts to help people are a waste of our time and have a very poor ROI.

by jardinier

to see that there are still some Americans who believe the war in Iraq was justified and beneficial. Can you please tell me who has been helped by the botched up invasion of Iraq?

What is even more amazing is that more than four years after the invasion, none of the members of the COW has acknowledged that the war was about [b]oil[/b]

Australia's Minister for Defence, Dr Brendan Nelson, recently mentioned the unmentionable word, but quickly retreated.

by jardinier

No doubt you also believe in the tooth fairy and father christmas.

Here is a comment from a personal email, from a Jewish woman:

I learned, living in Israel inside the Judeo-Arab conflict that you cannot bring people to live democratically if the majority of them are still living and thinking as Tribes. Islam in my opinion is now at the state of the Crusaders... they will need few more centuries to change radically thir way of thinking and therefore hopefully became a part of the normal world (us).

by tonythetiger

[i]they will need few more centuries to change radically thir way of thinking and therefore hopefully became a part of the normal world (us).[/i]

... to let them do whatever they want in the meantime, is it?

by oz_media

[i]Why are so many people in the U.S. willing (and even eager) to believe the propaganda of our enemies?"[/i]

Why are so many people in the real world unwillling (and even uneager )to believe the propaganda of the USA?

Because it is different than the news in other free democratic countries. Especially when two identical newcasts from inside and outside the USA are different because the US version is clipped and edited to remove any "unsavoury, or unsupportive reality".

Given that America...to be more accurate, the Republican Administration with puppet Bush at the helm, is actualy the enemy of the rest of the free democratic world, then what you are saying is why would any American believe what the rest of the world reports.

Now that's actually quite amusing, because the whole problem with US news is that it is heavily coloured and censored to only show favourable news about Iraq, or when unfavourable news is presented by right wing owned news stations with reporters from the left who are there specifically to make the left look warped and the right to be on the straight and narrow.

Why can't Americans choose to view news from around the world and see just how thinned out US news really is?

Don't believe the US is into propaganda? Even the white House admits it and has done since WWII. We have seen posts here of documents that mysteriously change and are 'thinned out' to remove any non supportive facts about America.

Get real, your news is as warped and biased as any. Learn to compare them all and seek middle ground.

by jackofalltech

You can't watch ANY american news (except Fox) without an extreme bias AGAINST President Bush and AGAINST any good news about Iraq. My son calls me about once a week from Iraq and he says they (the soldiers) are amazed at the lies the media tell and the truth they suppress. According to my son (in Iraq right now), almost all of the local people love the US and are grateful for their new-found freedoms. It is only a tiny fraction of the population (almost entirely composed of those formerly in power) who oppose us.

by jamesrl

Ok, here is a subject I can speak to.

The US embassy in Ottawa used to be on Wellington Street, right across the road from Parliament Hill. It was a nice looking building - old but fit in to the other historic buildings in the neighbourhood. The front door was right on the sidewalk of the street- tourists walked by constantly. The Marine guards (standard BTW at every embassy and many consular offices) stood out front in good weather, greeted you as you entered otherwise. There were large concrete planters installed on the sidewalk to ensure that no one could park a truck bomb right at the front door.

But in the 90s (before the Kenya bombings) a new embassy was constructed. It had to be farther from Parliament Hill because they needed more space. It had to have a high walled compound instead of a door right on the face of the building like the old one, to recognize the reality of the need for more security(Turkish embassy in Ottawa had been attacked and a security guard killed in the 80s. The turkish ambassador sprained his ankle when he jumped out a window to escape).

So naturally I think whatever they build in Iraq will have to be strong. If they intended on staying with 100,000 troops forever, they would be LESS likely to need such a strong embassy.

Critical thinking - you have to examine the source for everything you read.

James

by jdclyde

you should know by now you are not suppose to examine anything that fits in with your existing notions on things. Ask Dan Rather about that.

by jamesrl

Read an article about Rather suing CBS claiming he had been unfairly made a scapegoat.

I do challenge myself. I read the "American Conservative" at my father in laws house (Pat Buchanan's mag), I sometimes pick up Mother Jones, if they have an article of interest. I listen to CBC dwspite many biases I learn stuff.

And I'm not afraid to change my mind. Twenty two years ago, I supported the public funding of Catholic schools in Ontario being extended through High school, because that was the intent of the agreement in 1867 when we had the agreement for Canada to join together(they didn't have high school then, but if they had...).

Today, because we are much more multicultural, I think we have to either fund all faith based schools or none. And since I think that would erode the public system I vote for none. So despite some personal ties to the leader of the conservatives, and a long standing membership in the partu (30 years) I won't vote for him. I won't vote for his opponent either who favours the status quo - even though I supported that 20 years ago.

An unexamined life....

James

by jdclyde

is that there are still some that see it as more important to get political points and cast blame rather than find a solution to a problem.

Iraq is broken - fact.

Can not just walk away without mass murder taking place - fact.

Having Iraq a friend is better than Iraq and enemy - fact.

The US is not taking the oil as spoils of war, nor are we getting a discount - fact.

Just like the eco-nuts that go on and on about man-made global warming/cooling/shifts. They complain about everything but never allow ANY real steps to be taken to FIX the problem, which is a big part of why they have no credibility.

A retreat in Iraq is NOT in the best interests of ANY free country in the world other than political points against Bush, and only a complete moron will sacrifice so much just to be able to make SURE that this is a political failure.

by tonythetiger

Everybody is biased. You, me, everyone.

It appears to me that while the statement that an embassy is being built is probably true, and the cost estimates are likely accurate, the "reporter" imposes [b]his[/b] bias on the reader with his opinion of the "whys" of it all.

by jardinier

It is to be THE largest embassy of any country, in any country, anywhere in the world.

I am still waiting for someone to prove the article is fictitious. Apparently it is easier to just scoff at the article than to prove it is false.

Someone mentioned diplomacy. What is diplomatic about building a fortress that shuts out the reality of Iraq?

by tonythetiger

Which is all it is. The writer even alludes as much: "For security reasons, many details about the embassy?s design and construction must remain classified."

Oh, but HE knows all about it, right?

Again, it is a common practice among the media (and media wannabes), to insert two or three facts into an article to give credence to the notion, however outlandish, that they are trying to push on the gullible public. This is furthered by the fact that people who have been so duped have a hard time admitting it, and begin staunchly defending the notion so they won't have to.

This is right up there with human caused global warming as to its credibility.

by jardinier

Everybody except a few people whose view of the world is blocked by the walls of GWB's colon, knows the invasion of Iraq has increased terrorist activity.

You might also like to check with the one third of Americans who believe that either (1) the events of 9/11 were staged by the Bush Adminstration to whip up public emotion in preparation for the invasion of Iraq,or (2) believe that the administration KNEW what was planned but did nothing to prevent it.

Why is it that so many people are afraid to acknowledge that the invasion was all about [b]OIL, OIL, OIL, OIL, OIL[/b] and the establishment of a democracy was just a pipe dream?

Tony Blair is as culpable as Bush and Cheney. It was always only about [b]OIL, OIL, OIL, OIL, OIL [/b]

The exception among the members of the COW is John Winston Howard whose motive I firmly believe (you would have to be an Australian to understand this guy's mentality) was to have an opportunity to play in the "major league" and to be able to say: "George Bush and Tony Blair are my buddies."

However I heard an interesting comment today from a woman who has been a staunch Labor supporter for most of her life. She assured me that it was Howard's wife, Janette, who was pushing him because she aspired to be in due time the wife of the Australian Embassador to the Unites States.

by jdclyde

sounds like if we in the US would decide to completely revoke all of the special privilages that "Native Americans" receive based on it not being fair or consistant with the world today. Free college and Federal tax exemptions would be the first things to go.

When is a deal not a deal anymore? New people coming in does not, nor should it have any effect on existing agreements made.

While I don't know a lot of the details about that deal other than what you have said here and in a few other discussions, but it sounds like a deal was made that other benefited from, and now others are looking to go back on the deal because newcomers are crying no-fair?

by jamesrl

When the deal was made(1867), there was substantial tension between protestants and catholics in Ontario. There was widespread discrimination against catholics in Ontario. The protestant minority in Quebec had been promised their own school system, and Ontario did the same thing, only in reverse.

Today, we don't have discrimination against Catholics, at least for jobs etc, like we did in 1867.

As some in the debate have pointed out, in 1867 women couldn't vote either - should we have kept that?

So is it fair to pay for Catholic education, and not Jewish education, or Pentecostal or Muslim or whatever? The people coming in are actually split - some want all faiths to receive funding, some prefer a secular school system for all.

In Quebec and Newfoundland, both provinces that had separate school systems for faiths, they voted to abolish the separate systems for one unified public secular system.

James

by jdclyde

I am sure that women not voting was not a part of this agreement? If not, it has nothing to do with this.

People coming into Canada today are just crying because they were not in at the time of this deal. It has nothing to do with "fair" and everything to do with how negotiations work.

When the Indians/Native Americans had their land repeatedly stolen and treaties broken, it made our governments look bad and untrustworthy.

Ontario made a deal to get something they wanted, and the other side of the deal has been kept up. Is the Ontario government untrustworthy that it can disregard agreements?

We are looking at this from two different angles. You from the side of recent immigrants that are crying because they didn't get that same deal, I am from the side of someone that made a deal, and would expect the government to have the integrity to honor it.

Politically correct BS is ruining the world.

by tonythetiger

[i]Rather suing CBS claiming he had been unfairly made a scapegoat.[/i]

If it's possible for one to [b]deservedly[/b] become a scapegoat :)

by jardinier

The article describes the STRUCTURE and SIZE of the proposed embassy. Any opinions that may be read into this discussion are those of mine in the original post.

Could you please list the "two or three facts" which you consider make the article credible to these alleged gullible readers (like myself for example.) You have not made one factual statement of any kind in any of your posts, nor have you made any attempt to support your opinions. So you yourself completely lack credibility.

As for whether human activity contributes to global warming, nobody cares any more. It is universally accepted that global warming is occurring and what one reads nowadays is mostly predictions of the physical changes that will occur on the planet.

Perhaps you have not yet caught up with the fact that because of melting ice, Russia has staked a claim on portion of the Arctic by diving to a depth that was not previously possible.

[B]NO-ONE[/B] thus far has given one iota of evidence to discredit the existence and structure of this fortress-like embassy.

Anyhow you can look at the pretty pictures now:

http://thebestnewswebsite.com

It is the second article down.

by jdclyde

As it is the conspiracy nutcases that we were discussing earlier that are suffering from extreme retardation.

It cracks me up that the same hate filled crowd that calls Bush stupid or an idiot at every turn, turns around and accuses him of being the mastermind that pulled off 911.

Of course that many of our Democrat politicians had been saying exactly the same things that Bush did for a decade were all lying as well? That is ok, I understand that you didn't follow the US politics at that time, and how it would not be good for incoherent rants if you did.

Your time away from TR has not done much for allowing you to get much clarity on these issues. Maybe if you get out and follow some objective sites once in a while you would see that this is not Bush wanted oil so he staged 911 or knowingly allowed it to happen.

Maybe it is the fall of the journalist that has led you so far astray from rational thought? Or maybe because anyone that can sit at a computer now meets the low standards required to be considered a journalist?

by jdclyde

It is Man-made global climate shifts/warming/cooling. As they change the excuse, you have to tack it on.

I LOVED it when Denis Miller dug out the old report on how global COOLING was the greatest threat to us, and how they wanted to spread coal ash on the ice caps to raise the friggen temperature.

I think NY getting the worst case 20 inches in 100 years would be a GOOD thing. Clean out the rats. B-)

I also notice, living in Michigan, that for the last few years the Great Lakes water level has been LOW. How are the lake levels low with a great flood threatening the world?

by tonythetiger

that you are staunchly defending the notion :)

[added: I am not contending that the size, cost, etc. are either correct or incorrect. I am contending that the writer is passing his OPINION of WHY they are of such size, cost, etc. as FACT when they are no such thing!

If he were merely reporting facts, the article would have consisted of the second paragraph only. The rest are inflammatory descriptions clearly intended to steer the reader toward a certain mindset that he wants you to espouse. In your case, he was apparently successful.]

by tonythetiger

I just want to know how it is that we're supposed to give credence to the people who:

1. have gotten their predicted large number of hurricanes wrong twice in a row.

2. call for the removal of credentials of any of their peers who disagree with their doom and gloom predictions.

by jdclyde

Fact, they are building an embassy in a dangerous location, and are making it so that it can be defended.

Opinions and distortions: When people want to make a place sound sinister, they call it a "compound".

Opinion: the intent as to why we would build an embassy and what it means.

Why WOULDN'T we have an embassy there?

Why wouldn't we make it so it can withstand the blast of a car bomb?

Why wouldn't we make it so it can withstand an armed assault from both the insurgents and the Iranian soldiers that have been in Iraq firing on coalition forces?

Why would it not make sense to make it self sufficient so it could not be laid siege to?

Do you really think security measures are not needed?

Why do you CARE if it is [i]"It is to be THE largest embassy of any country, in any country, anywhere in the world."[/i]? What does this mean to you that is so mysterious? What is the evil intent of this? Where SHOULD the "largest embassy" be, and why?

[i]"And cut off from the rest of Baghdad". [/i][b]Should they have NO wall to protect them?[/b]

[i]"in a country shattered by war, what is the meaning of this place?". [/i][b] an open and leading editorial by the "reporter"? Where does this belong in the story?[/b]

[i]"Diplomacy is not the sort of work that can be done by remote control. It takes direct contact to build goodwill for the United States and promote democratic values." [/i][b] What is this alleged reporters qualifications in the field of diplomacy? Again, editorial instead of reporting.[/b]

[i]"Since al Qaeda bombed the American missions in Kenya and Tanzania in 1998, the State Department has been aggressively replacing obsolete or vulnerable embassies with ones designed under a program it calls Standard Embassy Design."[/i] [b]duh! Sure, again this rant thinks the embassy's should not be protected? Based on what expertise in security is this coming from?[/b]

[i]"Forty years ago, America was forced to flee a newly constructed embassy in Baghdad just five years after it was opened,"[/i]
[b]sounds like he has just shown even you exactly why it is being built the way it is.[/b]

Did you actually read any of this?

Do you really want to continue to claim that there is something evil at foot for the building the embassy with the ability to defend it's self?

by oz_media

I suppose he's trying to find cash to pay his mortgage in Colorado so he doesn't have to foreclose like everyone else.
Anyhow, I will steal a term he coined not too long ago. It's all "factopinguess".

The media that you don't believe is no more right or wrong than the media you do believe. That's the scary part, you simply don't know the truth because it has never been aired to you. Now THAT'S propaganda.

by jamesrl

.....unless you consider anyone non-aboriginal an immigrant.

One of my staff is 2nd generation Canadian. His family came from Holland after WWII. He sends his kids to a "Christian Reformed" church school, and pays fees. He wants to know why he has to pay fees and the Catholic kids don't. Same can be said for kids going to Anglican schools, and they have been around for 100 years.

Fair is not descriminating on the basis of religion, and we do. Seems you wouldn't mind getting rid of affirmative action right? How is that different?

Catholic school funding was a solution to a problem 140 years ago. Can we never revisit it? Good thing everyone isn't so hard headed, or both our countries would still be in the "prohibition" era.

And as I mentioned, many immigrants are arguing for not funding any faith based schools.

The deal was in the British North American Act of 1867. That document was replaced by our Consitution in 1983, and that included a Bill of Rights which agreed that there should be no descrimination based on religion(and a bunch of other things). That agreement at least was done by people who we elected(federal government and 2/3 of provinces). The two things would seem to conflict. In general the Bill of Rights trumps other laws.

James

by tonythetiger

a ten year old in most any of our (horrible) public schools could figure out that the number of Americans who elected GWB doesn't come to anywhere near half of the population.

by jdclyde

First, a lot of ignorant people don't vote (and deserve whatever they do or don't get as a result).

There are the convicted felons that are not allowed to vote (although the Dems seem to think these people would be a welcome addition to our voting base, because they are such clear headed individuals).

There are the minors that are not old enough to vote.

Funny how the first time around there was crying about how Bush didn't have "popular vote", but we didn't hear a WORD about popular vote the second time around when he DID have it. B-)

by oz_media

You were lead to believe they were preparing for nuclear war, that there was an imminent threat of chemical warfare from stockpiles of WMD's.

What is it that "they are doing in the meantime" that you feel must be stopped, stopped by an invasion and destruction of their country?

A friend workign in Iraq said the beaches were full of swimmers and sunbathers, girls are chased around like teenagers at a college frat party and life really isn't any different for most Iraqi's than it is here.

Then again, in America you have several thousand serial killers, a president much like Saddam who believes in citizens losing their lives in favour of US Political gains. HOw is that not seen as repressive from outside of America? Should the free world wage war on teh US becaise Bush is a danger to the rest of teh free world? Why not? Just because you are American doesn't mean you are immune to brutal dictatorship. He's got peoplelike you wrapped around his finger, I suppose that makes you a radical American who is set on seeing teh demise of Iraq.

Two sides just take some time to look inwards once in a while, mind yu I have yet to see an American look at America with any form of criticism. It's like a brainwashed society of conformists, so much for freedom and prosperity.

by charliespencer

"...he's a warmonger...with a long term political agenda in mind,..."

I think you give him too much credit. I think he just made a decision and is incapable of rethinking it to fit the changing situation.

by oz_media

I'll accept that, he is merely a puppet and parrot moreso than a leader of a nation.

I guess that should have been directed at the Republican party as a whole, they have been hell bent on taking Iraq and the rest of the middle east for decades now. Oh well, he who holds the smoking gun takes the rap.

by charliespencer

Why do you think we went after Saddam and not Fidel Castro, who has been in our back yard for almost fifty years? Why not North Korea, where the regime is just as oppressive?

by oz_media

As noted, the right has control of the left wing media.

I've posted names, companies, owners, CEO etc. before, Sinclair Broadcasting Group (SBG) is a right wing owned corporation that owns or controls the affiliates of most US networks, even those that are SUPPOSED to be left wing or are focused on reporting wild left wing news. The radical reports from the left are presented as wild eyed ranting, it makes it easier for the right to discount, thus making the right even more credible and seemingly not interested in spreading untruths. Credibilty by not saying anything, if the right does speak out, it looks absurdly ridiculous, moreso than the left wing rant-abouts.

It's like reverse psychology, they simply shut up and push the focus on the unbelievable, instead of just becoming more believeable themselves by reporting the truth.

That's old hat, we've had that one out in many a long thread here already. SBG controls the majority of US media and networks, I see it all up here to because most of our TV channels are US, but we also have a middle eastern channel, european news etc. So we can at least weight the varied stories and reports on the same issues. Many such reports show full video on BBC or Canadian news, the same video clips on the US networks are shortened and edited to remove the parts where the US actually looks pretty bad. As a result, you are left watching bad Iraqi's and cheering on the Bush as the boys in Iraq die for nothing.

by the ref

While I am against the war in Iraq and the inaccuracies that started it, it is not something that can be walked away from. It seems the US government can win an initial attack but has no clue on the ongoing rebuilding effort. More attention needs to be spent on working with the locals rather than taking an aggressive approach to the ongoing problems.

I imagine the locals have no better a life now than while under Saddam ? something that needs to be corrected before any of the countries involved leave.

Unfortunately, there is proof that Iraq had a nuclear program and bacterial weapons. The US government knew this because they helped supply some of the components / bacterial agents to Iraq. Iraq admitted having said weapons and committed to destroying them under the supervision of the UN after the first Gulf war.

After the destruction of weapons by Iraq it is my belief that the US government thought there were still unaccounted weapons based on the fact they knew what the UN witnessed being destroyed, and the knowledge of what the US (Government and companies) supplied(note: other countries were equally guilty of the supply of weapons or ?dual use? equipment). See for a chronology: http://www.iranchamber.com/history/articles/arming_iraq.php and http://www.counterpunch.org/dixon06172004.html

by the ref

was that if the US government went in with an admission of previous errors of judgment and a willingness to correct a previous mistake, the public perception may have been manageable. Going in of a slew of lies was never going to build the trust of any of the people involved on any side.

This discussion is closed to new replies.