Discussion Locked

An intelligent critique of the United States' energy policies.

0 helpful
54 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

[b]Dumb as We Wanna Be[/b]

By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN
Published: April 30, 2008

[i]It is great to see that we finally have some national unity on energy policy. Unfortunately, the unifying idea is so ridiculous, so unworthy of the people aspiring to lead our nation, it takes your breath away. Hillary Clinton has decided to line up with John McCain in pushing to suspend the federal excise tax on gasoline, 18.4 cents a gallon, for this summer?s travel season. This is not an energy policy. This is money laundering: we borrow money from China and ship it to Saudi Arabia and take a little cut for ourselves as it goes through our gas tanks. What a way to build our country.

When the summer is over, we will have increased our debt to China, increased our transfer of wealth to Saudi Arabia and increased our contribution to global warming for our kids to inherit.

...

Few Americans know it, but for almost a year now, Congress has been bickering over whether and how to renew the investment tax credit to stimulate investment in solar energy and the production tax credit to encourage investment in wind energy. The bickering has been so poisonous that when Congress passed the 2007 energy bill last December, it failed to extend any stimulus for wind and solar energy production. Oil and gas kept all their credits, but those for wind and solar have been left to expire this December. I am not making this up. At a time when we should be throwing everything into clean power innovation, we are squabbling over pennies.

These credits are critical because they ensure that if oil prices slip back down again ? which often happens ? investments in wind and solar would still be profitable. That?s how you launch a new energy technology and help it achieve scale, so it can compete without subsidies.

The Democrats wanted the wind and solar credits to be paid for by taking away tax credits from the oil industry. President Bush said he would veto that. Neither side would back down, and Mr. Bush ? showing not one iota of leadership ? refused to get all the adults together in a room and work out a compromise. Stalemate. Meanwhile, Germany has a 20-year solar incentive program; Japan 12 years. Ours, at best, run two years.

...

While all the presidential candidates were railing about lost manufacturing jobs in Ohio, no one noticed that America?s premier solar company, First Solar, from Toledo, Ohio, was opening its newest factory in the former East Germany ? 540 high-paying engineering jobs ? because Germany has created a booming solar market and America has not.

In 1997, said Resch, America was the leader in solar energy technology, with 40 percent of global solar production. "Last year, we were less than 8 percent, and even most of that was manufacturing for overseas markets."

The McCain-Clinton proposal is a reminder to me that the biggest energy crisis we have in our country today is the energy to be serious ? the energy to do big things in a sustained, focused and intelligent way. We are in the midst of a national political brownout.[/i]

The complete article:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/30/opinion/30friedman.html

54 replies

by jamesrl

In general, I'm all for tax cuts. But I also like taxes that relate to consumption.

If you chose to drive a hummer but only occasionally, versus drive an old out of tune beater that pollutes like crazy, and drive it high miles, a tax on vehicles doesn't help. The tax on gas does. It encourgaes people to use less gas, and lets them figure out how. And one presumes that the more gas one consumes, the more wear and tear they put on the road infrastructure.

I have no idea why the big oil companies have tax credits. When I see record profits, I wonder why they get your tax dollars. Stop giving them credits. But don't tie it into a tit for tat thing. I'm not sure subsidizing solar is a good idea either. If we pay full price for something we know the real value.

James

by danlm

a 7 dollar an hour job?

I'm not being a smart a$$ here with this, but this is one of my primary arguments against the hydrides...

Whats the average age of a car on the road today? 20 years? 10 years? 15 years? Used cars is a huge business. Why, because the people that buy them can't afford a new car. Well, other then the ones that buy used beamers or such because they appreciated that year and model.

But, hopefully you see my point. Until someone realistically both technically and politically address's how the alternate energy vehicles are going to reach the people of less wealth... Then this is just spitting into the wind as far as I'm concerned.

And tax's on gas are just making it worse for people that already can't afford to buy a better millage car.

Dan

Damn, I didn't butcher the words this time so bad that F.F. spell check couldn't find anything close...

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]But, hopefully you see my point. Until someone realistically both technically and politically addresses how the alternate energy vehicles are going to reach the people of less wealth... Then this is just spitting into the wind as far as I'm concerned.[/i]

Bicycles and biodiesel public buses are also both powered by alternative fuels.

by jamesrl

My van is 6 years old, and I will hopefully drive it another 5 or so years.

Hybrids are not the only solution, they are the sexy solution that people pin their hopes on.

But people can do inexpensive things to get better mileage out of the cars they have.

Air is free, and most cars drive around with one or more tires underinflated. This costs gas, and shortens the life of tires. The estimate is that even slightly underinflated tires can cost you 10%. Imagine if we all bought 10% less gas.

Air filters - many people never check them, filters are cheap and a clogged filter also robs you of mileage.

My car tells me when I need an oil change -the MPG actually drops. But many people ignore that.

If you can't afford those things, you can't afford a car.

And you can also be more careful about choosing the car you drive. I drove a car even with three young children, until they became big enough to have too crowded a rear seat. I see a lot of people driving older caddies etc, who could easily spend the same money on a smaller more efficient vehicle.

I lived without a car for years, I didn't expect to own one when I was making minimum wage. I realize not everyone has access to transit - I did.

My thoughts on taxes on gas (and they are higher in Canada) is that if we have to have the taxes from somewhere, I'd rather have it attached to gas, where it becomes an incentive to save, than to general income tax.

James

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]I'm not sure subsidizing solar is a good idea either. If we pay full price for something we know the real value.[/i]

I'm still ticked off at all the "national security" rhetoric that was invoked with falsehoods, to open ANWAR and to ferment [b]corn[/b], both for special interest money, not for national security.

The long-term, and only workable solution is to keep all corporate money out of politics, absolutely. Sorry I misspoke, subsidies are a stupid suggestion. I think "targeted tax cuts" are, also.

[i]But don't tie it into a *** for tat thing.[/i]

Right.

by forum surfer

bu then again one of my hobbies is building fast street cars. I already pay an excise tax on my tires because evidently they are too large. Truck tires are bigger (and get worse gas mileage!), but because the tire size on my car is only on exotics or hot rods (315/35 18) I am forced to pay an excise tax. I just don't think raising already extremely high gas prices is the answer. That really hurts the lower class more than anyone. Hurts me too! For the record I get 25 mpg out of a supercharged 522 rear wheel horsepower v8 piece of american iron and I'm cleaner than the factory version of my car according to emmission tests...even though most of my car modifications are not CARB certified. Of course drop the hammer regularly and you get 5 mpg...but that doesn't happen often.

Next thing you know someone will want to tax my gun collection! I already have to pay a $50 tax on my dog's testicles because I don't have the heart to get him fixed. If I fix him my pet tax is only $10. But I like my testicles so I assume he does, too. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you...lol.

In short I'm paying excise on taxes on my boat, my tires on car, my dog's testicles and now they want an excise tax on my gas? I'm sorry...but I think this a tax that will only hurt lower and middle class people. Instead let's start taxing the upper class for crying out loud. It's time they sweat for a living and worry about their future just like the rest of us $@#% it!

by boxfiddler Hot topic

'we' wanna be dumb. Thanks for that.

Thomas Friedman is often a voice of sanity in a world that is clanging with utter madness.

by santeewelding

You scale to a height where the invocation of some(thing) larger at work becomes absolutely and sufficiently necessary.

The hubbub you leave below while attending to the larger may reveal Friedman as just another moving datum point.

Capability challenges.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Proper attention to the hubbub below attends the larger Whole properly.

etu

by danlm

In there, it said most manufactures had a warranty of 10 years which was good. But they also gave some idea's what it would costs to replace those batteries... Now, I don't remember the exact amount.... But it was in the thousands. If these cars(hydrides) go on the used car lots. Potentially, they will only have a couple years left in their battery life spans. Again, a cost factor. Thus, why I like ethanol more... I don't see a high maintenance fee(battery replacement) which I do with hydrides. If I'm wrong, which very well may be the case. Great, this will be one time I'll be happy to be wrong.

No, I am not trying to stop move to hydrides.. I am just trying to point out some things that will make it hard for the common smuck(me) to own one.

Truthfully... I would like some type of converter to be developed for existing cars. Or some type of alternate fuel/energy source to be developed that is affordable that can be used on existing vehicles. Allowing the full population to move over at once, and not in a migrated cycle.

Dan

by $$$$$$$$$$

[edit: these videos are over in maxwell's (corn) ethanol thread]

Or, you might want to wait until I've had the time to try it on my own car.

:D

Anyway, the device is basically just a set of electrodes in a sealed container of water. A bit of cheap plumbing from the top of that bucket sends the gaseous output to the air intake. As I understand it, this improves the combustion of petroleum because the more rapid combustion of hydrogen helps "crack" the long -ane molecules, which is normally so slow that engines are timed to fire before TDC. The videos over there explain it better.

by danlm

I need to change the air filter.. I knew I was due for an oil change, was going to do it this weekend. I forgot about an air filter change.

Thank you.

Dan

by boxfiddler Hot topic

it's not the age, it's the maintenance. All of our vehicles are 10 years or older with multiple hundreds of thousands of miles on them. While they look kinda cr@ppy, we maintain them properly. They run great, all the anti-pollution devices work properly, and we're not running down the road leaving a trail of black smoke behind us.
Cr@p but new cars are expensive.

by charliespencer

First, it's 18.4 cents. When the price of gas has double over the last couple of years, what's 18.4 cents? I saw two gas stations on my way home with a price range wider than that. I don't often think of McCain as pandering directly to the electorate, but this is one of those cases. Personally I think Congress should INCREASE it to 25 cents, mandated for highway maintenance and repairs. At this point, what's 7 cents more?

Second, if they suspend it for the summer, one party or the other will start screaming that it needs to be permanent so they can claim they cut taxes around election time. Those opposed to making the suspension permanent will be falsely accusing of wanting to "raise" taxes, just like those who want to letting the Bush tax cuts lapse on schedule. Allowing a rollback to end ISN'T raising taxes. If my boss gives me a bonus for three years and then doesn't, he hasn't cut my pay.

by locrian_lyric

True or false:

Do taxes go up after the rollback? TRUE.

as to the other points.

the federal tax is only part of it. the state taxes add quite a bit more, depending on your state.

FURTHERMORE, other factors causing the high gas prices ARE:

-Ethanol mandates: account for a good chunk of it (don't have the figures in front of me)

-Custom blends for the states cause refineries to stop production, retool, restart.

-Lack of refineries exacerbate the above.

-The fact that we can't use the oil shale, we can't drill off of 85% of the us coastline, we can't drill in ANWR and the environmental regulations have crippled any expansion of drilling or refining.

by charliespencer

I have a '94 Nissan Sentra that gets the same mileage it got when it was new. I assume if the mileage isn't going down, the emissions aren't going up.

As James noted, one of the biggest factors is one of the cheapest - proper air pressure in the tires. A good tire gauge (one with a dial, not a stick) will run you seven or eight bucks. That and 75 cents at the air pump will pay for itself in a month.

by jamesrl

I can only think of two chains in my neck of the woods that charge, and one of them charges 50 cents and it goes to charity. The other charges a quarter - come up to Canada and enjoy cheap clean air. :)

Surely there is lots of free hot air in Washington, and during the primaries they are gracious enough to share it.

BTW loved the pictures of Hillary in the F250 and chatting with the guy pumping gas. Everyone deserves a new experience now and then.

James

by boxfiddler Hot topic

charge for air as well. We use one of those mini air compressors that plugs into the cigarette lighter. Handy dandy little device. Got one in each vehicle.

by dadspad

Last time I will do it too! They do not need to be refilled as often, but there are too limited places to fill the tires up. I would rather have air and maintain the tires myself. I just fell more confident if I am in control of my tire pressures.

correct pressure in tires gives better gas mileage and longer tire life. Tire alignment is right up there with tire pressure.

by locrian_lyric

with the computerized systems we have in cars now, it's outdated, less than useless and it's only remaining function is to reduce milage and power.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I can't remember their name, but there is a (non-profit?) org that loans materials for defense against speeding tickets. A neighbor recommended them by name, which I forgot, once when I mentioned having received a rather hefty velocity-based fine. Anyway, they might be persuaded to organize advocacy for that, on cars newer than 199?, and made in ???

by locrian_lyric

As it was explained to me, they know full well that the CCs are useless, but don't want to be labeled as 'polluters'

by dadspad

None! A hydrogen powered vehicle produces H2O. This would reduce the weight and power restrictions now put on our transportation.

by dadspad

that has been one of my concerns for years. All anyone does is talk. Yes, I know that Califonia has the "highway of hydrogen" and I acknowledge that is, at least, a begining. Car makers have said they are working on hydrogen cars for a long time, nothing but future models are shown. Oil companies say they can't sell hydrogen until they have buyers. Aaaarrrrgh!!

I would like the government to put in a law similar to converting to Leadfree gasoline.

Yeh! Thats it! In 5 years every auto manufacturer selling autos in the US must sell a minimum of 1 hydrogen vehicle to the public, also in 5 years all major distributers of gasoline (gas stations) in metropolitan areas, must have 50% of stations dispensing hydrogen. Then in 10 (15?) years 80% of all vehicle sold in the us must be non gasoline propelled.

Oh well, just dreaming. As long as our elected officials are heavy investors in the Oil industry, oil will be king. :(

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Yeh! Thats it! In 5 years every auto manufacturer selling autos in the US must sell a minimum of 1 hydrogen vehicle to the public, also in 5 years all major distributers of gasoline (gas stations) in metropolitan areas, must have 50% of stations dispensing hydrogen. Then in 10 (15?) years 80% of all vehicle sold in the us must be non gasoline propelled.[/i]

Especially around LA & San Diego, the expertise is brimming over to make electric & hydrogen-powered cars feasible, to lower-middle income residents. What lacks is sufficiently large-scale commitment, to entice the many, relatively small, high-performance auto specialists to slightly modify the focus of their specialization.

by dadspad

I just don't understand why there is no media push or high interest in the population on hydrogen propelled vehicles.

Biofuels are only a stopgap, at best. There are many starving people in the world, right now!! I think food production is better used to feed hungry children than to put in transportation. Seems just wrong to put a machine over children.

But that is just me.

by ic-it

is that the implementation of hydrogen seems geared to the distribution/profit system currently in place. This bites for at least two reasons. 1. It will be dangerous to fill/drive around on tanks of hydrogen. and 2. It will remain more expensive than necessary.
I like the idea of the self-generating HHO plans (like you have pointed out before), but fear that they will quietly go by the wayside in the push for hydrogen distribution stations.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Good grief... I am just way too short today.

edit: if you stick around?
edit again: finally got it. OP way off base so altered. Mostly.

by santeewelding

I did not kid you about craft. I do not kid you now.

Specially when I slip into monosyllabics. Marvelous, the effect, is it not, when what otherwise would do for the quick transmission of the daily and the ordinary brings now thinking to a crawl, with edits, on attention to the Extraordinary.

More, to keep it up front and not to bore; to challenge like you have never been.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Barring that which I perceive as out of the ordinary for you, I take you quite seriously.

by santeewelding

There is no quarter in knowing this, that, or some other thing, as here all about would make it so, strident absolutelys coming to mind, 'ceptin when you can get them to pause.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]There is no quarter in knowing this, that, or some other
thing, as here all about would make it so, strident
absolutelys coming to mind[/i]

But this:

[i]'ceptin when you can get them to pause.[/i]

... is not an absolute. When one's facts are in order, as
you can plainly see with a modicum of diligence, my
"stridency" is far less. The "correlation" you suggest is
spurious, or false outright.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Well, santeewelding?

[i]From: boxfiddler
Subject: re: That's a fact...
Message:
"There is no quarter in knowing this, that, or some other thing, as here all about would make it so, strident absolutelys coming to mind

But this:

'ceptin when you can get them to pause.

... is not an absolute. When one's facts are in order, as you can plainly see with a modicum of diligence, my "stridency" is far less. The "correlation" you suggest is spurious, or false outright."

Do you not think that santee would have spelled and punctuated your moniker correctly if he were specifically referencing you? I ask, because it appears that you have studied him briefly and appreciate him slightly.

boxy[/i]

by danlm

They don't want us to be successful beating this.

Sorry, I am so anti media anymore... They ignore facts in their stories, they down right do not include all facts in most of their stories. The are completely biased in their reporting.

So, again... I apologize... But it's till my feeling about the media. They don't want us to succeed.

Dan

by $$$$$$$$$$

I mean, we both know they're wrong, and can explain as
much to an interested audience. Therefore, ____?

by santeewelding

I knew I saw prints. Looked for all the world like those of a tiger, paused and circumspect in spite of burning bright.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]It will remain more expensive than necessary.
I like the idea of the self-generating HHO plans (like you have pointed out before), but fear that they will quietly go by the wayside in the push for hydrogen distribution stations.[/i]

I suspect only homemade projects like those will motivate industry to do anything at all. Having not yet led, they will either have to follow, or get the hell out of my way.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"mplementation of hydrogen seems geared to the distribution/profit system currently in place"
"but fear that they will quietly go by the wayside in the push for hydrogen distribution stations."

Not just hydrogen implementation either. The technology exists such that homes, condos, apartments, businesses, etal... could be self-powering. But as long as that means that no money flows steadily into the coffers of a provider the technology will remain overly expensive and difficult to obtain and implement at the user level.

In the meantime, providers of current technology and fuel/s for that technology will continue to suck up the money of the user with no attention to the fact that the future of their own children and grandchildren is at stake.

by $$$$$$$$$$

50% gasoline price increase since last year has "the users'" attention. The iron is hot.

Right now the proposed suspension of the measly $0.184/gallon gas tax is making Hillary and McCain both look silly, even to their fans I think. Just two facts need be known to fully understand that the short-term solution to energy for vehicles is to cut Archer Daniels Midland out of the United States' budgetary and legislative agendas, absolutely, permanently, and immediately.

For the long term, experience suggests that the best general assumption is that "corporate interests" are probably the cause of any widespread use of energy-inefficient technologies.

1. The ratio of energy provided by burning corn ethanol to the energy required for its production is 20 times less than that of ethanol than switchgrass.
energy gains:
corn: 0.25
switchgrass: 5.0

5.0/0.25 = 20

2. The United States has only been using corn to produce ethanol because of the unprecedented amount of corporate political donations from Archer Daniels Midland.

Biodiesel from Something Called 'Jatropha'

Switchgrass Ethanol vs. Corn Ethanol

The Root of The Evil: Corn Ethanol Deception

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Jatropha the only one new to me. Been bitching at my Reps for several years about switchgrass in preference to corn.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Finally finished editing.

I think I'm going to start my own blog.

I have no desire to stay on-topic, or even in the vicinity, of computer tech. It's nice that off-topic chat is welcomed, but I dislike that it's considered off-topic. I'm taking this to fora where this is the primary topic. 'Later.

by ontheropes

It would be interesting to see what an unmoderated blog of yours looks like. Please let me know if you start one and ffs, if you do it, have one that has an RSS feed so I can keep it on my toolbar. I've got a whole rant about that but I'm keeping it to myself for now.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I found one environmentalist website that looked excellent as a source of information and for making contacts with like-minded people, but I don't have the URL handy at the moment. I want to discuss energy policy & science, mostly. I'm also interested in the Ron Paul Revolution -- putting government back in its Constitutional place & size.

I'm going to have a full week or two at work, so don't expect it soon, but do expect a PM telling you where I'll be leaving my virtual fingerprints for the next few months, or more likely, years.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I was not asking santeewelding. I was asking you.

"Do you not think that santee would have spelled and punctuated your moniker correctly if he were specifically referencing you?"

My estimation of you is obviously flawed. I will not bother your inbox again. My apologies.

by $$$$$$$$$$

"As you have often pointed out to others I was not asking santeewelding. I was asking you."

if ( wikipedia_citations > 0 )
{
grade = "F";
}

This discussion is closed to new replies.