Discussion Locked

Are all ATX Power Supplies the same?

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Good Day to all:

I am troubleshooting a PC (ACER,P2, 128mb, 8gb), It was about more than 3 years old. Then as normal routine, I try to use the pc but it did not boot up and NO sign of POWER at all.

The PC was perfectly working before, then promptly now it is dead. I opened it up and came up with these diagnosis:

1. Defective ATX Power Supply.
2. Motherboard gave up due to its oldness.

That is why I came up with the question, Are all ATX Power Supplies the same? Is it a universal statndard?. Since this computer is a branded one (ACER) and over the warranty . I opened it, then as i went deep inside the hardware systerm I found that the WHITE wire does not exist comparing it with the other(New) ATX Power supply.

The White I ampertaining to is a single wire from the power supply (box) to the end terminal of the 20 pins plug. The Old ATX Power Supply (used by ACER) HAS NO WHITE WIRE, but the New ATX Power Supply HAS A WHITE WIRE connected with the plug.

Any experienced individual out there who can prove that all ATX Power Supplies are the same or vice versa.

Thanks.

4 replies

by timwalsh

The short answer to your qestion is No, ALL ATX power supplies are NOT the same.

Although there is an ATX standard. However, there are several variations on this standard. Also , realize that the ATX specification has gone through several revisions. So unless you compare two ATX power supplies that purport to meet the same specification version, they are likely to be different.

Interestingly, the ATX specification includes NO white wires (although it does include a gray one).

For more info, take a look at this web site:

http://www.formfactors.org/

by thechas

I guess that I have yet to see a PC "standard" that is even close to universal.

ALL PC standards evolve over time.

An excellent example is SDRAM DIMM memory. Take 6 different PCs and 12 different 128MB DIMMs, I would be surprised if all DIMMs worked in more than 2 PCs.

I have 2 "ATX" power supplies that will ONLY work in a Dell PC!

Since no government agency (in the US) is enforcing standards upon the PC industry, they are free to use any non-copyrighted term in the manner they choose.

Chas

by tomsal

Tim stole a great deal of my thunder on this one. ATX is in and of itself a standard, ironically enough there (as stated earlier) multiple variations that it isn't impossible to run into a situation where you find an ATX power supply that doesn't work with a particular mobo.

That said - I'll admit the situation I just described should be very rare and you should only come across this with one of the "big boy" manufactures like Dell, Gateway, Sony, IBM, etc. -- they love making things proprietary wherever they can. However outside of those situations -- its really been unheard of for me building my last 4 or 5 DOZEN systems to have incompatibility issues with an ATX PS.

The quality of power supplies is definitely not with the big boy retailers - their PS, in general are junk. Not to mention they are generally way UNDER powered (200 - 250 watts, is NOTHING).

On my home built systems 450-500 Watt is the weakest I go.

The variable speed controlled smart fans are something the cheapo power supplies don't have either.

by guruofdos

If as you say it is on the end of the 20 way connector, then it could be pin 1, pin 11, pin 10 or pin 20. The ATX standard for the 20 Way Molex connector defines these pins as

Pin 1 = 3.3v
Pin 10 = 12v
Pin 11 = 3.3v
Pin 20 = 5v

I would probably infer that as it is present on one PSU and absent on another, it is one of the 3.3v wires. As Pins 1, 2, and 11 are all 3.3v and all ajacent to each other, and as they are normally commoned on the motherboard half of the connector, I would imagine that the white wire you describe is not a feed wire TO the mobo but a 'sense' wire FROM the mobo and may possibly be used to determine whether or not the PSU is connected to the motherboard. i.e., if the PSU is NOT plugged in, then the white wire cannot sense 3.3v present on the ajacent pins and therefore may possibly disable the 5v SB line which normally provides the permanent 5v feed used for keyboard power-on. Obviously if the PSU is not fitted to a system, there is no need for the 5v supply to be present, even if mains power is applied. Just a thought...and I MAY be barking up the wrong tree, but that seems a possible scenario to me! On the other hand, as it IS an ACER machine, and they make their OWN mobo's...it may be used for someother esoteric function only implemented on an ACER!!!

This discussion is closed to new replies.