7 replies
by mr.wiz
by mckinnej
My old, slow, small drives keep plugging along year after year, but the newer, bigger, faster drives seem to rarely make it through warranty. Granted, I don't buy anything with less than a 3-year warranty, but still...I expect better.
My theory on this is the high performance of the new drives has pushed them to the edge. The manufacturers are packing more data into smaller spaces and operating all of it at speeds that were unthinkable just a few years ago. I think a good analogy would be a race car verses an old Chevy. The race car will break more often (preventive maintence being equal) because of how it is operated. It routinely runs right on the edge of disaster. Conversely, the old Chevy plugs along rarely even coming close to the edge of its operational envelope, so it lasts for years.
Maybe the answer is to not buy the fastest drives on the market, but to buy something slower with more mature technology. The problem with that is the nature of your business may require the speed, so you have a no-win situation.
by mckinnej
"They constantly run." That makes a huge difference. Did you know that a regular lightbulb will burn for years, sometimes decades, before failing if it is allowed to burn continuously? This is also true of electronics. They tend to die during the turn-on surge. The on-off nature of most home systems works against them in this regard. (Of course, this doesn't account for platter/head/or other physical failures.)
"Could it be that SCSI drives are longer lasting and better built?" I think so. They also cost more. These drives are industrial strength and you pay for it. There is more evidence to support this. Did you notice that the standard warranty for the consumer "shrink-wrapped" drives dropped from 3 years to 1 year? That happened a few years back. You have to buy the up-scale drives to get a decent warranty. Seagate has a 5-year warranty on their best drives and I just bought one. Ask me again in 3 years how its holding up. :)
Hampton, VA...you must be at Langley. I did 3 years there back in the 80's.
by rkahler
Mark,
I don't think you mentioned whether or not you are using RAID so this information may turn out to be unhelpful.
The type of drive used for SATA depends on whether or not the controller supports RAID. I just read recently that if the controller supports RAID, then the drives need to be RAID capable whether or not you actually use RAID.
There are SATA drives that are non RAID specific. The reason is that the use of a drive on a server is different from that of a home system. The error correction that is built into a server specific drive is different from the error correction that is built into a home (workstation) specific drive.
If the controller doesn't match the drive's capability, there may be issues with the drives.
I believe this information is correct. Please excuse me if I'm inaccurate. As I said, I only recently read an article on this topic.
Bob
by x-marcap
I suspect that in the AC draft, with PMs on machines, the new drives would be more robust than their predecessors. Today the biggest problem is heat.
Our systems are smaller tolernces are tighter, the airflow is reduced. The rooms no longer have to be air-conditioned to have a PC in it...
The point is we are spinning drives faster, and using more data. How many drives are really badtracked from the factory?
How many people badtrack their drives?
I have a 200MB SCSI from 1988 witn SCO xenix on it.. It is still running.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Storage posts
Sort by Trending