I have brought this up before (including when it happened).
We had a single share for the dept. Each group had their own sub folder on the share, with it's own permissions. NOTE: there IS confidential data on the share.
Anyway, the IT group decided that (without warning) all shares should have 1 set of permissions, and should not have sub-folders with individual permissions. The share owner had transferred to another group, and never passed ownership of the share, however, still proclaimed that he had never received any notice that the share would be down while everything was transferred to a new server.
We were all surprised when the share was suddenly unavailable. However, we quickly found out why, I sent a notice to the dept. and all was OK.
After it came back online, everyone was able to work, so I never gave it any thought. However, almost 2 weeks later, I received a call from someone, that they were on the share and hadnt been in Legal for 10 years. I quickly found the problem (she hadnt been removed from the global group). Remedied, a new task -- go through the Global Group and look for other problems. However, while scouring the GG, I ended up in a netmeeting with someone, who should have access to a specific folder, but not others. This person stated that they had accidentally clicked on the wrong one (with confidential data) and it opened. Looking into it, this user had access to everything :0
so I had another user look, same thing :0
I looked at the permissions for the site, which should have been restricted at several levels with more than 20 GG's assigned at different levels and all at the top level. Furthermore, some of the folders were supposed to remain read only except for individual permissions. So, what did IT in it's infinite wisdom do -- assigned (not even authenticated users) Everyone -- read/write and all inherited permissions for all sub folders.
So, anyone who knew about the shares could access them unrestricted. Now, in Legal we often have outside council and business partners and they may have limited access to some of these shares :0 So, others did know about the shares (however we never got an access report for it.
Anyway, I spent half a day with IT telling me that they cannot do anything, nor can they restore permissions because it was now against the policy. After 5 people, I figured this was the wrong approach. I sent this up the management chain, while working the proper channels for IT, and I had decided back channels were needed as well.
Before I could get anywhere on the first 2 channels, I found someone that was willing to help (temp). He could not do much, but he was able to remove all permissions from the shares, and give me individual full control permissions.
Finally, something is starting to work, however, I had no idea what groups were assigned to what folders :0 So I had to spend a few days contacting people (and having them figure out who needed what access where) and re-did the groups -- so far, lots of downtime for the entire department, and lots of leg-work. During this time the management chain finally got things together and forced IT to help. However, they only agreed to do a bare minimum (make me do everything, and if I have problems, they may step in and assign permission). Furthermore, yet another new project -- within 1 month I had to split the sub folders to individual shares to stay in compliance with the new policy and transfer the data from one share to another (they wouldnt do a server to server transfer or anything -- the datacenter is half way across the country).
So, I spent over a day in the office and the entire weekend through a vpn re-assigning permissions (hours with some of the sub folders).
Finally, it was done -- permissions were set for almost all of the shares, however I still needed to find out about a few of them, but the main emergency was over and the dept was functional again.
overall, it took over a week and a half, and IT wouldnt even backup our share (old or new) and send us a copy, so I setup 2 systems to download the entire contents of everything right after I put it in read only (planned) and right before I ran the transfer (another weekend + more).
I never bothered to count the time it took from me alone, let alone each group in the dept + downtime because records or other info was unavailable. And this does not even bring up any costs involved if any data was compromised.
Edit: And all because IT screwed up and wouldnt help correct the problem. All they had to do was temporarily put the old server(s) back up until we created the new shares and had the data transferred server to server.