Discussion Locked

As an independent contractor, would you ever take a W2 job again?

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
There are both pros' and cons' of being an independent contractor or a salaried employee, but in my personal opinion, I'd rather be an independent contractor due to my unpleasant experiences working as a salaried employee and being subjected to stupid corporate politics and incompetent managers. As an independent contractor, I have no obligation to become "their corporate slave", and can bill for every hour my feet are planted at their facility. The tax benefits are also great, because I can deduct travel expenses, meals, office supplies and equipment, as well as educational material for my own professional development. The downside to being an independent contractor is the instability and having to find new sources of income once your contract is nearing its termination date, but the freedom to work on multiple projects and establish professional relationships far outweighs anything else. I don't like to play corporate politics, and as an employee, one has no choice but to deal with the corporate crap that our managers would shove upon us, or risk losing one's job for insubordination or some other lame excuse that the dopes in HR can slander us with. As an independent contractor, I have noticed that I command more respect and treated more like a professional than if I were to be some corporate slave working long hours and not getting paid for it. Yes, the demands of a consultant are far higher than a salaried employee, but the rewards and respect as a professonal are clearly visible. Why have many corporations forgotten how to act human and praise their employees for good work? In my past experiences, the only time managers would talk to us was when there was an outage and users were screaming bloody murder. Rarely would we get a pat on the back for a job well done, or commended or recognized for outstanding achievement. This reminds me of the movie "The Island" where we are all looked upon as mindless clones that are controlled by a higher authority and must not challenge or question what it is we do or why we do it. Corporate culture, in my opinion, has degraded into a finger pointing pass the buck game, where managers cover their own asses by sacrificing their subordinates and not taking the blame for their own incompetence and poor management skills.

23 replies

by tony85

I have recently joined the staff of one of my customers on a part time - 2 days per week basis. I normally spend one day (Tuesday) at the HQ site and the rest of the time is spent at remote sites, or working remotely, spread over the week.

Yes, it is a lower rate, but there are benefits to both sides

1) I get some guaranteed income - enough to pay the basic bills

2) They get more work for the money they pay out (and because of the business they are in - healthcare, in the UK - there is a tax advantage of me being an employee rather than a contractor)

3) Flexibility is agreed on both sides

4) It keeps me far enough from corporate politics, and because it is not my only income, if I really want to, I can walk away

5) I can actually do the job better - there are lots of little IT things - time to show people how to work better, for example, organising etc. that it is hard to justify if the clock is ticking at a chargeable rate. Thus I get more job satisfaction in being able to do things without worrying that it looks like I am creating work for myself.

6) The company has better continuity for its IT support - they had no in house expertise - probably no-one who could even install Windows, let alone run a server and several remote sites.

I entered into this position after supporting them for 15 months as a contractor, so both parties know the other well - both strengths and weaknesses.

Until coming to this point, I would have agreed completely with you. However, I do now have a better work/life balance and have both independence and being part of a good organisation.

by apotheon

In the US, at least, it's pretty damned difficult to find an employer who will make such an arrangement. In my experience, there are only three options for professional, non-entry-level IT employment:

1. pure consulting work, hired for a specific project, able to pursue other projects with other employers at the same time

2. pure contract work, hired for a specific period, and probably contractually obligated to contract with nobody else during that same period

3. full time employee, salaried, contractually obligated to not only work solely for the employer but also bound by a noncompete clause in the contract that can make it difficult to get another job within a few months of leaving that employer

You lucked the hell out. Congratulations.

by frank.vrba

want part time, contracted support. My daughter and I have a partnership that mainly supports small businesses with contracts. We have three hospitals (at which we ARE the IT dept with a total staff budget exceeding $130,000 during fiscal 2007), several schools and libraries, and other individual places. I've been asked multiple times over the years if we would take on new clients. The answer is mostly no because there's not enough competent workers for us to hire. We have 6 employees now and it seems we are always in need of someone else for a short time and if we could find a good person, we'd take on more work.

It's much more of a problem to find workers that are worth hiring then to find the work for them to do. It seems that most people think they have to work for large corporations because that's where the money is. It certainly is but small businesses have money too, and they can't justify or afford any IT employees. We have contracts that are for a specified number of days per week and some that are 'on call' or as needed. If they need something, we go. This has worked very well in small towns but I see no reason why it won't work in cities too. We have clients in Omaha, NE. We've never advertised in 10 years.

I know the work is there because we see it all the time. Most people who do this on there own think just because they are now in business everyone is going to call. Why??? With that attitude they will fail. Start up part time, talk to people and don't be afraid to tell someone what you do and ask if you can talk sometime about how you might be a fit for their situation.

by chris_g2

out there that value their staff. I have had experience of working with both types of management. When I was a manager myself, I made a point of "catching people doing things right" and acknowledging this by sending them a letter, or giving them movie tickets or a meal voucher (depending on what I was thanking them for). My present company is very good about caring for its staff and work/home life balance.

by techexec2

The kind of arrangement you describe is just not done in the USA. Corporations typically want your exclusive service for many reasons including keeping their secrets from competitors, manipulating you, and controlling you.

Example: Years ago, while doing contract work, I contacted a very large company that I found out needed some help. It was a "part time" task that would require about 25 hours per week for about 3 months. My skill set was ideal for the job. I went there, interviewed with the supervising and hiring manager, and got the job on the spot. He called me the next day. His manager overrode him and chastized him because I actually had another client at the time (fully disclosed in the meeting). His manager wanted complete and total control over all of his people, even part time temporary contractors.

This attitude is not universal but VERY typical in the USA. Many managers want to dominate you and intimidate you. That is just not possible with a contractor who has other clients.

Contracts typically contain non-compete clauses that keep you away from their competitors for 1 year. They also have non-disclosure clauses that keep you away from certain direct competitors FOREVER. And, they will SUE if you go to work for any of those and get you FIRED over it.

So, consider yourself very fortunate. You situation is NOT typical. In fact, saying [i]"it is possible to do both"[/i] is almost braggin'! ;-)

edit: typo

by navy moose

Actually, I wouldn't have been that polite. If I was an independent contractor on a small project and the client attempted to tell me I couldn't work on other projects for other clients at the same time. I would have told them where to go and four or five ways to get there. I wouldn't care at that point about burning bridges.

I had a manager with a company who told me I couldn't get a part time job to supplement my income. I told him he has no business telling me what I can or can not do with my personal time.

I am currently starting a part time photography business and my manager is nothing but supportive of it. He's even offered to help with the webpage.

I firmly believe in standing your ground and not letting rogue managers run roughshod over you.

Navy Moose

by bob.dont.spam.me

While I would not consider myself a true consultant, I know that I would never go back to a Salaried position.

A year ago I started my own company for pay purposes, but since then I have acquired two long term contracts (+3 year) with different companies. Even though I am in the same office sitting at the same desk nearly every day I am removed from all the bull that I used to be subject to. I give them professional advice and if they choose not to follow it and their system goes belly-up, well that's not my fault!

Office politics?? Never again!

Not to even mention the Tax benefits! I get pay substantially more than I use to, but even if I was paid the same, the tax benefits really make difference.

by vtassone

I completly agree with the post. After putting up with the A$$ kissing and brown noseing in the corporate world for a number of years I am happily on my own. I fell into (what I feel) is the perfect job for me. I contract with a local dialup ISP to take the support calls from my home. I have a nice office set up. This gives me a steady income to start with. I also do PC repair in the same office. Mostly virus and spyware removal. I can work on up to 6 machines at a time. I charge a flat rate of $45.00 for machine cleanup. I know thats a low rate but I get repeat buis. and alot of referals. Not having to fill my gas tank every other day and all the tax breaks more than makes up for the "big bucks" I used to make! The only disadvantage is I don't know when to quit. I find myself working 12 to 14 hours a day. Not that I have to, It just seems to happen. I don't like watching a clock. Don't even wear a wrist watch. Oh, and the ISP customers don't even know that half the time I'm aswering the phone in my underware ;-)

by nocubes4me

Through no planning or request of my own, I wound up taking a position that was listed as independent contractor, although I have an agreed salary and compensation package.

Thinking that the tax forms had been mis-submitted, I checked with HR and my VP and found that they created the position this way specifically to provide the added tax benefit.

For what it's worth, I'd suggest discussing an arrangement like this wherever it's legal to do so. We paid about 25% less in taxes last year.

David J.

by why me worry?

They cannot call you an "independent contractor" if you are on their payroll on W2 and they are withholding taxes from you. If you are indeed an independent contractor, you will be billing them on an hourly basis and getting paid the gross amount of your invoice, as I am currently doing. During tax season, you will be issued a 1099 by them stating the total amount of gross income you earned. Every fiscal quarter, I go see my accountant and file an estimated tax return and send a check to the state and federal gov't of my estimated tax bill. By next tax season, I will know exactly how much I owe more in taxes or if I am due a refund, but my taxes are my own responsibility, not the people who are paying me. Having said that, the company cannot call me their employee, as I am not on their payroll, they are not withholding taxes, and am not receiving any benefits from them, other than a bi-weekly paycheck for my billable hours and exposure to new technology. If they are attempting to deceive the IRS by misrepresenting your working status with them, then they can get seriously screwed and so can you if you end up having to pay a huge amount in taxes.

by nocubes4me

I worried about all of the above, but both the accountant we use and the tax attorney we consulted assured us that the designation associated with my status was accurate and allowable. I'll have to dig up last year's stuff to share the exact designation, but it's not "independent contractor".

Made for weird taxes the first year, but overall, I like it. Like you, I am responsible for both reporting and payment directly.

The health benefits are purchased by us directly, but through a group plan with larger influence than we'd be able to access if we approached a carrier independently as a family.

by the weekly geek

There are certain parts of my anatomy I would put into a blender before I went back to work for a business. In the late 80's early 90's I worked at Lockheed/NASA. Too much tax payers money wasted. From 2000 to '03 I worked for a plant as 1 of two IT people responsible for 4 plant location and no contractors. Talk about owners skimming profits and punishing the laborers. Nope, I don't lie, cheat or steal or put up with those that do. I will be an independant IT guy helping small businesses so long a the LORD allows.

by silvergreen

I have been a W2 contractor for a long long time. I tried a 1099 arrangement once, but that one just came to me automatically. The W2 contracts are pretty easy to find. I put my resume up and the agencies start calling me. It's stressful, but I guess you could say that it is a numbers and skills game. Once on a assignment, can work there for the months alloted, make serious cash and take enough time off to take care of personal interests. I do dislike corporate politics and stuff like that, like others here. And I do want to work for myself, but haven't tried it yet. I am afraid to charge twice the amount of my W2 rate. Should I just put a web site up and market myself over the internet? Or would I have to join networking groups and sell myself, not to mention deal with the BS involved in that as well. I know how to work the interview but I am not a sales person by heart. How to start? Thanks.

by hforman9

What makes you think that being an independent contractor saves you from politics or people? I've been both. As a contractor, you still have to report to someone at the customer. The guy may be an idiot. Politics? I've seen where they use the independent contractors as shields or targets. After all, you are a contractor; therefore, you are dispensible.

Also, people have the impression that, as an independent contractor, you are making "the big bucks". Therefore, you now are part of the us vs. them attitude. You make more money so the employees are jealous and are always ready to pounce when you make a mistake. Also, they have unreasonable expectations based on the amount of money you make.

The other thing to always remember is that your compensation may seem like a lot, but you may not have the ease of getting increases. You may not have paid vacation, sick or holidays. Retirement plan? Medical insurance? (Do you get the benefit of group rates?).

I almost wish I was an employee, so I can sit there, keep my head low, don't do too much work and leave everything to...contractors.

by jim e

I have worked for some of the biggest SOBs on earth. Now I work for me and I must admit that I am the biggest SOB that I've ever worked for. My excuses fall on deaf ears and I make myself work even when I'm not feeling well. As for stupid... I have a very lumpy and sore forehead from all the times I smack it when, too late, the better answer comes to me.

But, before I would ever return to working for another company or someone else I would rather go peck poop with the chickens!

by tony hopkinson

Course I'm in the UK, so salute the logo isn't as prevalent over here.

Essentially I did it because I was ending up being marginalised. Income was dropping so I could n't afford the time out or the cost of updating myself.

Applied for a contract that would give me a chance to refresh part of my skill set, and they offered me a permanent role.

Ended up being better off financially and they are going to bring me up to date (C# .net) and make me part of a huge potential achievement which would prove I can do it.

Hard to beat really.

Word to the wise, while the going is good, invest in keeping it going good.

by navy moose

Back in late 2002 I had to take a 1099 contracting position, this was after being out of work for eleven months and new to the IT field.

I will never do 1099 contracting again. I got bitten by the IRS and state DOR for taxes owed. I was making $25 an hour, but I couldn't afford health insurance, dental insurance, nor could I afford to contribute to an IRA. I was driving over 80 miles round trip.

It was hard affording to pay taxes. Turns out I calculated the estimated tax wrong. I couldn't afford to have an accountant look at it for me.

As much as I dislike corporate politics. I would much rather be a W2 worker any day of the week.

Navy Moose

by apotheon

That's not enough money for contract work. At all. Remember that when you're contracting the people paying your rate don't have to pay all the accounting, tax, benefits, and other associated fees that they pay for permanent employees. You can charge more than twice what they're paying their salaried employees and still cost them less than those regular employees would cost.

Then, once you've realized all that, think about the fact that they wouldn't be looking for a contractor if they could get the expertise they needed out of one of their regular employees. As an extraordinary requirement, they're willing to pay you an extraordinary expense. You're not ripping them off by charging three times the rate they pay their salaried employees: you're charging them what your services are worth, and you're charging them enough to make sure you can survive until your next contract.

If you let them pay you less, it's they who are ripping you off -- and you got ripped off.

by navy moose

This contract assignment fell into my lap. Like I said, I was out of work for most of 2002 and the tech market in Boston was non-existent with my skill level at the time.

I got a call from an officer I met from a different unit at drill a week earlier offering me this gig. He told me how much they could pay, it was pretty much non-negotiable.

My unemployment was running out, and I didn't have much else to turn to. I learned more in six weeks at this place, than I did in 2.5 years at my previous job, which was in academia. It was a personally satisfying assignment where I was exposed to great technology, and co-workers who were very much team players. Financially it was tough, but the experience I gained got me into my current job.

I get calls from recruiters, and I tell each of them I won't look at a contract unless it is W2 with health, and dental insurance as a minimum.

Navy Moose

by techexec2

I appreciate the sentiment. But, I also think you need to choose your battles carefully. You know...Not everyone who helps you is your friend...Not everyone who hurts you is your enemy. The poor manager who hired me [i]for one day[/i] was embarrassed and every bit as much a victim as I was. I felt bad for him. I never met his boss, but I have always pictured him as a 300 pound oaf.

Best of luck on your Photography Business. The state of affairs in IT work in the USA is not good anymore. Onshore rates are going to be kept low by corporations and the congress (H-1B visas). Offshore rates are going to be too low for Americans effectively forever. Diversification like you are doing is a very smart move. Try to make it so successful that you [i]have to[/i] quit your IT job just to have a life. It's always better to have too much work than not enough.

All the best to you.

Moose Photography -- When You Look Good, We Look Good(TM)

by navy moose

I'm a SysAdmin and I'm very nervous of long term career prospects. My job can easily be outsourced to India or China with only a caretaker to push a button when the server goes down.

I have an MBA but I know I will be hard pressed to find decent work when the economy takes another nose dive.

I would like nothing better than to have enough work to work fulltime as a photographer. I have met a few people who succeeded in doing this.

I have the name of the business down to two choices, you guessed the second one :-) Thank you for your kind words.

Have a good day and good luck!

Navy Moose

by rayjeff

Still be a salaried employee. I see that this post is over two years old and many things have changed in the world since then. Over a year ago, I was working as a salaried employee. For medical reasons, I had to resign my job. for over a year, it's been VERY HARD to find another salaried job. So far, the only jobs knocking at my door on a consistent basis is independent contracting jobs.

While I enjoy the freedom and the actual work that I've done, in reality because of this type of work's nature, I do need a more stable type of job. This is very contradictory because I am also an university student working on my B.S. degree. I've always been able to schedule my jobs around my classes and vice versa as a salaried employee. I don't know...it just all depends on a case-by-case basis for anyone to decide. But for me, in 2008 going into 2009...while I enjoy independent contracting, the "security" of an W-2 is what I need. :-)

This discussion is closed to new replies.