Discussion Locked

Bill Gate America Love it or Leave it

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I can't beleive this guy. Bill Gates has made his fortune off US citizens who support Microsoft only to give Techs in this country the final slap in the face by telling congress... "we just can't get the same standards of developers from the US that we get from India" give me a break. It makes me sick. I'm hoping that boomerang karma slaps this hypocryte right in the face. Got my fingers crossed. So next time your out there looking for a tech position do us all a favor... buy american.
So much for free trade. More like J1 slave labor to me. Thoughts?

6 replies

by drowningnotwaving

http://www.news.com/8301-10784_3-9892046-7.html?tag=tb

Interesting in reading (some of) the responses on the news blog.

Extremely few actually question the validity or otherwise of his claim.

Most were the usual voracious "keep our jobs for us".

There is no thought whether the long-term consequence of encouraging India or China to build the full-on centres of excellence around their "A-Grade Post Graduates" either exists as a real long-term threat and (if it does) should something be actually done about it?

edit farkin keyb0ard!!

by mjd420nova

More like don't want to pay for good help. Why should US companies pay Americans a good working wage when they can outsource the work to other countries that only pay one third the wages and can bull$hit their way through the job? I have thirty years experience working on computers and all manner of electronic devices and no one wants to pay for those skills when they can find an immigrant to fake their way through the job for one third the price. What is the end result? A PO'd customer that junks their old stuff because they can't find anyone to fix it when it breaks. The only resort is to sent it back to the mfgr who wants to charge an arm and a leg and takes six weeks to fix. Then they send you back a refurbished unit that isn't even your original unit. Buying American will keep most of the money here, but the service industry has been replaced by script reading idiots located in other countries that really have no idea what they're doing.

by drowningnotwaving

mjd your argument in the short term and long term, looking at the area of skills and experience you have, is valid and must be very scary. As it was and remains with auto-workers, steel workers etc etc et cetera.

Gate's argument in the longer term is significantly more scary than yours, IMHO.

If top class post-graduate talent is not brought and kept within US borders, then it WILL find work somewhere. What is more, the infrastructure will be built around the talent.

It is one (very difficult) thing to lose working jobs to the cheap hordes across the border. I am not sure how to really contest it in the long term.

But it is another significantly more scary thing if, in the long term, the larger multinational organisations move huge amounts of their [b]advanced R&D[/b] off-shore. The longer term implications of that are enormous.

IMHO, That is what I get out of Gates' position.

My interest is that, despite the rhetoric on this and other similar threads, this is not a uniquely 'American' problem whatsoever. (Edit OOOPS I didn't mean this thread on TR, I meant the news thread and the responses to it!).

by ksady

This Big Biz I have my money Bill Gates attitude has hit all US industry or lack thereof. I used to work in Manufacturing now there is relatively little mfg. what I developed once save the big 3 auto makers a million and a half a year. That's small change now that the plants are in China and Mexico since NAFTA. It seems to me that the key principal here is to remind all sectors of all businesses including IT that to keep america strong we need to Buy American, Employ American and support america.
I have some advice for Bill -- move to India and I'll buy Firefox.

by martinopereznyc

Let?s place the supply and demand for highly skilled workers in an accurate context. Anyone who cries about a shortage of skilled workers without any reference to the level of compensation being offered is being intellectually dishonest. Microsoft, Oracle, IBM, etc. are simply refusing to compensate tech employees at a higher, market-clearing equilibrium level. In the interest of honesty, Bill Gates, Larry Ellison, et al should be precise and explain to their scores of laid off employees that their high wages were one of the key factors that harmed competitiveness in a global economy.

This discussion is closed to new replies.