Can porn spam be concidered Sexual Harassment to employees?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by ~omega~
Nothing so drastic would need to be done to terminate the employee. All of the states that I have worked in have been "at-will" employment, meaning that if either the company or myself wanted to terminate employment, the other party could take no legal action (of course, unless I could prove discrimination, but then, the burden of proof is on me.)
My point is this, simply. Unethical or dubious morals and Unethical managment aside, an incompetent employee would be fairly easy to terminate. YOUR FIRED! why? You were unable to perform your job duties satisfactorily.
A competent employee? Doesn't matter in "at-will" employment. Why? . The only merit your argument has for this one is avoiding unemployment benefits, but usually companies gather evidence supporting incompetence claims before terminating an employee.
by blarman
That type of attitude will get you a sexual harassment AND wrongful termination lawsuit (with possible negligence thrown in). The worst possible things you can do, in order are:
1) Fire her.
2) Ignore her.
If you fire her, you give her an ironclad case for wrongful termination (which still applies even in right-to-work states because it is FEDERAL law). You give her a substantial case for sexual harassment as she can argue that your permissive attitude led to a "hostile workplace."
If you ignore her complaints, you actually increase the probability of a sexual harassment suit because she will be able to demonstrate management's lack of proactivity.
The best way to handle it is to take her complaints seriously. Commend her for notifying them and then take action. Put her on the team for finding a solution (spam filter, etc.). This will not only eliminate any possibility for a lawsuit, but will make her feel better abou working for you.
Oh, and for any of you guys who suggested firing her, you are treading a VERY dangerous line of contributing towards a "hostile workplace." Permitting sexually related content that others fid offensive in the workplace is grounds for termination in the smart company because it lessens their liability for a sexual harassment suit. Most companies now have updated their employee policies to prohibit anything even close to sexual harassment as immediate grounds for temination. Be a man and respect women.
by sasiv
its got nothing to do with not respecting women, any calls from people saying fire her are because she is obviously someone who will cause trouble the first chance she gets....two or three emails and shes calling sexual harrasment, please.
and i think we need to clarify, obviously if you are doing nothing at all to block spam and let through explicit email subject lines to staff then you deserve to get sued. But any cheap filter solution allows you to block rude words and variation of rude words from subject lines. That therefore eliminates any need for her to feel harrassed.
Turn off the reading pane, show her the delete key and explain to her how spam works (she obviously has no idea). I dont think you need to set up a special spam fighting team and spend thousands blocking every last scrap of spam.....and commending her for threatening to sue you, gimmie a break.
Here in Australia porn spam meets prima facie requirements for sexual harassment but you would find it impossible to make a conviction. Most of the laws are written such that a conviction is only really possible if the harasser continues AFTER being told to stop by the victim and the management can only be hit if they do not take reasonable steps to stop it. No requirement to make the harassment impossible as it is recognised you cannot do that.
In the case of porn spam the victim would have to find the spammer and tell them to stop. then if the spammer is not an employee of the company you would have further difficulties.
In a case like this is should be easy for the employee to simply not open mail from unknown addresses. The matter now comes down to how much Internet access does the employee need to do their job.
I have seen one case of something similar in Australia and the company resolved the issue by instituting a filter on that person's mail box and computer that restricted all mail contacts to within the company - no ability to send or receive from outside. And they had no Internet access at all, the browser would only access the corporate Intranet site for corporate stuff. that person did not need to contact anyone outside at all, system was fine tuned to make it so.
by robcastaldo
Not to thread jack, but the McDonald's burn case isn't a great example if you're familiar with facts of the case, rather than the anecdotes reported in the news.
http://www.centerjd.org/free/mythbusters-free/MB_mcdonalds.htm
Back to the case at hand, if she were to file suit, you may be found liable. It depends on if the judge or jury feels as though you took reasonable steps/action to mitigate the harassing emails.
by dlmeyer9
coolrobc said: "Back to the case at hand, if she were to file suit,
you may be found liable. It depends on if the judge or jury feels
as though you took reasonable steps/action to mitigate the
harassing emails."
While this is true, the standard is much higher if the source of
the offensive emails is external to the company - outside the
company's control.
FWIW: if an employee raised such a complaint to me and, based
on TWO messages from an external source, threatened action ...
that would go into their personnel folder and would count
heavily against her come review time. Two messages from an
INTERNAL source would certainly warrant remedial action on the
company's part, as would two DOZEN such external emails ...
but TWO EXTERNAL emails? That indicates the person is a
problem waiting to happen, one the company cannot afford to
continue to employ.
by oz_media
Okay a bit strong maybe. At firt there were maybe a half dozen a week (at first), after a ew weeks it was down to perhaps 2 or 3 a week, and those are easily checked each day and also help to create better heuristic scans as they are added or deleted fomr the black list.
A goo dsolution utilizes several scanning styles, Huristic on the entire email,then keyword chek, then address/rbl check but none of these is the SOLE reason for declarig email spam, a weight from each test is given, once the total weight of the email reaches and exceeds YOUR predetermined level, it will be considered spam. If you want most to flow through at first, set the levsl high and sl;owly reduce them as the system trains itself based on what you want or don't want.
Most systems are flawed in that they determine what you ewant, every company is different and allows/rejects different mail, it should be something YOU train and YOU tell it what is acceptable and what isn't.
$4000.00+ is not unreasonable for such a solution.
by mgordon
"those are easily checked each day".
If you have to check quarantine every day, what real improvement have you made? That was the strength of Brightmail. When I first installed it, its filter rate was about 90 percent effective, but zero false positive in the first 60,000 spams captured. After that I just dropped all spam into the bit bucket and never looked at quarantine again. Now THAT is productivity enhancing. Brightmail also has rules-based capture, and I suppose between the two you could hit a very high spam removal rate but you also increase the false positive rate -- you must decide how much disaster it is to lose important email. Postini is probably the best but it is expensive and, once again, imposes a requirement to review quarantine. The whole point of anti-spam is so you don't have to LOOK at it.
You declare the cost to be $4,000; but does that include your time on it? Brightmail is quite expensive, so is Postini. Administering Brightmail was trivial -- out of the box and into the server, done. End of story; instant 90 percent removal. No bodda me with tuning rules every day.
by oz_media
Nobody is a full time spam deleter/scanner/ It is a system that neexds to be monitored and trained (hour a day max) for a few weeks, months until it is setup properly.
Nobody said you wouldn't get sales related email, I deployed it in a multinational sales office.
Yes the company can sue you, IF such a written company policy about opening such mail is applied. It is willful neglect of their equipment.
by oz_media
[i]"Your company CAN FIRE YOU FOR ANY REASON AT ANY TIME."[/i]
They can make up a reason BUT it must be valid also. In most cases, companies have policies and must offer warning in writing several times befroe a final dismissal. In such cases (the vast majority as shown by the peers here) such policies are set in stone and adhered to like gospel. It makes it a little harder to fabricate a reason for dismissal without written and formal proof to support your claims.
You are SO close but not quite, you are right in that they do need a "REASON" to fire you, well said; but just ANY reason doesn't usually cut it. Any VALID reason would be more accurate.
Now befre you go rabling on about the Good Ole US of A and how f***ed up your employment system is, how your totally inadequate government allows and compels your companies to treat your citizens with no respect etc.
I have spent many hours in US courtrooms listening and following MANY cases or wrongful dismissal. So it DOES happen and it happens quite often in a nation who loves to sue for just about anything you can dream of, including a free ride through life.
Yes, many very large companies get nailed on a regular basis for wrongful dismissal, it's the people such as yourself that just layback and take it that help companies succeed in treating US citizens like sh*t. Your fellow patriots can thank you for being a complacent lamb that fears having a voice in the real world.
And NOBODY, NOBODY at ANYTIME said anything about guaranteeing jobs to POS employees...well except you of course.
If an accountant is hired and is then subject to offensive email subject lines, it is no different than the secretary being subject to two guys talking about p***y all day long. The company MUSt take measures to stop it, now if you consider that as a POS employee, then that explains why you are just another POS employee yourself, you don't have the brains to be a POS boss.
by geezer51
by robcastaldo
"FWIW: if an employee raised such a complaint to me and, based on TWO messages from an external source, threatened action ... that would go into their personnel folder and would count heavily against her come review time."
... and then the employee files a discrimination claim based on the fact that you held her prior complaints against her for review.
Look, I agree that it's extreme, but this is exactly the type of situation that gets a number of companies in trouble.
If all she received were the 2 emails, from an outside source, this would probably never get beyond discovery. However, if she continues to receive the offending emails, and you do nothing about it, your run the risk of creating a "Hostile Work Environment". Just about anything that makes an employee uncomfortable, can be construed as harrassment, it all depends on how good a lawyer they get.
As long as you can prove that you made a reasonable attempt to stop the offending emails you probably don't have that much of a concearn. But you should follow up with the employee to be sure that she's comfortable with what ever the final solution is.
It's better to be safe than sorry...
by unclerob
You started this discussion 5 days ago, you've obviously heard enough from all of us who have participated in this query of yours to get started in a few directions.
I am very interested (you know I mean business when I started boldfacing words) to hear what you have tried out to help stop the spam from getting in this user's mailbox.
Have you tried installing some free software, or temporarily changing the email client, or have you spoken with mgmt to see what kind of support you can get, have you spoken with this employee to let her know that she has your support?
Please reply back when you have time and let us know what you've done thus far.
by danlm
Like bob said, Im curious how you have followed up on this too. There have been several sugestions that have been put forward that would you could do, even if you do have a limited budget. This would give you the we are trying to stop the spam with our limited resources argument. Hopefully, someone has followed up with the employee. It might be your place, but it's someones place to follow up with her. Id love to know her reaction if you are putting in place some spam blockers. If she really is a gold digger, or if this is all that she was after.
Lol, shoot. Worse case, use gmail. They have spam blockers. And it's free. Shoot, if nobody else will. Ill send an invitation so she can have it.
droolin
by sostermann
Early on in the discussion we made the decision to upgrade the sales departments e-mail client to Outlook 2003. We are going to try this out to see if it minimizes the spam to an acceptable level. In the meantime I have implimented Cloudmark antispam for Outlook Express. We are just using the free trial period to get us through until we receive the Outlook upgrdes and it seems to be doing a great job.
The employee seems pacified now ? it?s obvious that we are trying to accommodate her needs for a comfortable work environment. Although it must be noted that, for now at least, someone still has to monitor the spam folder for false possitives. Since this can?t be me all the time, the sale people are still looking at all of the spam.
by silentbob
by jacksdaddy1
by citiboi
I've managed a team in this situation before. Working for an Internet company you get approx 80% SPAM to certain alias email addresses. The emails can be offensive even to broad minded people. A couple of simple suggestions that we implemented to reduce the concern were to:
1. turn off the preview window for email - reducing the possibility of the user seeing offencive pictures.
2. Turn off HTML in email - pictures are then not automatically viewed when opening emails.
Both simple but effective ways of reducing the shock IF the SPAM filtering fails remove the offending emails.
by jwinborne
Hey, avoid all the legal hassles - I use this solution for all of my very small business customers.
Mozilla's Thunderbird email client has very good spam/junk mail filtering - it flat out works, and it's a free download.
Go to www.mozilla.com, download Thunderbird email client, install on each workstation [about 5 minutes each tops!], it will find your Outlook Express email settings & messages and import them for you, folders, messages-everything [you might have to import your address books, but that's simplicity]. In Thunderbird, click on "Tools / Junk Mail Controls" and configure them for each address book you may be using. Click on "Tools / Run Junk Mail Controls on Folder". It will create a "Junk" folder for each user, and if you create a simple rule [on the same "Tools" menu] to filter all your incoming customer orders automatically to a special folder, you will never loose any. In addition you can specify that all junk be held on your system for weeks if you like, just for insurance against the unusual message that might get missed and end up in the junk folder. It flat out works, and takes almost no time to setup.
by danlm
I am using Thunderbird, and I've never set up the spam filter on it. I like it a whole lot better then outlook express, and you just gave me a reason to like it more. Shoot, I don't even have outlook express installed anymore. I deleted it off completely. If I thought I could delete explorer, I would. I like FireFox better then bloody Explorer too.
I know that was off topic, but I still appriceated the info.
droolin
by jrwkprice
If I am not mistaken, much of the issue surrounds "reasonable atempts" at blocking the offensive material by the company. The onus of responsibility for a safe and non-hostile, comfortable work environment does indeed fall on the company. The company should be able to set up some sort of software and hardware based spam filtering. Yes, it is an expense for the compnay, but this exepnse is recapturable as a business expense come tax time. Once the mail is filtered, and the company maintains the filtering mechanism with updates, then the company has met it's requirement of making a reasonable effort to block the offensive material, even if all email is not filtered. Another issue for companies is lost revenue and profits from erroneously blocked email. As part of the company's email protocol, a person or group of people could possibly spot screen emails for this, but this would be another (and possible quite large expense for the company), but let's face, some emails will be missed or lost. However, the expenses from law suits due to not making a reasonable effort to block the offensive material are much greater.
Also, once the reasonable effort to block the offensive material has been made, the female employee and others need to be educated about the new email filtering program and policies. I am of the opinion (I am not a lawyer) that once the reasonable effort has been made, then the employees do not have a basis for a harrassment suit. Just my $.02 worth. PS- this is my first post here.
by npbwbass
Put up Thunderbird behind a Kerio email server running on SuSE Linux 10.0 and you have a very good little email system. I support seven email domains of mixed ?stuff? and this hasty quick fix on a site to replace an Exchange server that was coming apart has turned out to be a great combo.
The client does not want Exchange back. No problem I'll use it somewhere else. Kerio email server seems to be a good little product. It's Outlook connector works great and it allows you to do many custom things to prevent incoming spam including setting up TCP/IP address blacklist subscriptions and to add your own blacklists. The Web connector is excellent. Scalix on Linux is good stuff too but cost much more.
I'll stop now. I was starting to sound like an advertisement.
?Reasonable effort? by a company and all of its varied interpretations will make a legal case like sexual harassment from porn mail a crap shoot anyway you look at it.
by thestorys
Try running her account via
http://www.bluebottle.net/
They require mails to be verified. This probably cuts down on most spammers who are generally lazy people who won't both with
going through the verification service.
There are other services.
Also there is mailwasher pro which allows you to stop a lot of spam. You have several options like this.
Ohio is an "Employment at will" state, UNLESS the company has a handbook or policy manual that states reasons or actions that an employee can be disnissed for.
Now back to the issue.... Spam is a national problem affecting everyone, not just her. Explain her rights to report spam to the reporting agencies. If her problem continues, and she is still getting offensive spam, invest is an anti-spam software program for her computer. Let her computer be the test unit. If the software works well, keep it in mind when the next person complains.
Placing part of the responsibilty on her to report it and you to try and filter it, should prove to any court that you are making a good faith attempt to correct the situation.
by dw
I agree with the people who say that it is best to use available software or blocking options to make it clear that the company cares about fixing the problem-- but also sympathize with people who are tired of having a big part of their IT jobs be protecting employees from the Internet, especially when so many employees end up getting more spam by doing things that bring it on themselves (e.g. publishing their plaintext e-mail on the net, attempting to download "cute" programs that are really spyware, etc.). Some days I feel like the well-meaning-but-often-ignorant users of my own network are enough work and I'd rather not have to deal with protecting them from all the unscrupulous characters on the net as well.
What I did with regards to spam was to install RBL-type blocking software that inserted "this is possibly spam" type headers into messages, and then I can turn on the blocking for individual users if they request it (therefore I do not have to worry about most of the users losing real mail to false-positives). I also had strict Group Policies to prevent the installation of any spyware, basically reducing my spyware problem to zero. Then, whenever anybody requested spam blocking, I made them sign a one-page document explaining what spam blocking is, that no computer program can be 100% effective, that they can reduce their spam by not publishing their e-mail address or signing up for "deals" on the net, and that they have to check their spam filter for false positives every week or so. After they sign that, I turn on their filter.
I added the signed document step because many of my users expected that every single message will be filtered out, and none of their legitimate mail would be put in the spam folder (so they didn't check the spam folder and then got mad at IT if they missed an important message). My document stated up-front that the only way to ensure this 100% level of accuracy is to hire a human admin assistant to screen your mail, and then they understood that we don't have that kind of money or time. (Of course, by buying the latest products I could probably INCREASE my accuracy, but my experience has been that certain users will expect 100% accuracy, not 95% or 90%, and they will expect this despite not being conscious about where they share their e-mail addresses on the internet, so the advantages of a signed agreement still exist.)
Dave
by mgordon
I can think of only one absolutely sure-fire way to prevent spam from reaching employees- terminate all email services and remove the server. Block all email carrying ports, including 80 and 443, (web, secure web) so that nobody can log onto any web hosted, but external email server.
Spam _is_ email. It is distinguished by one characteristic only: It is unsolicited. Now then, please tell me how your magical system knows whether any incoming message was SOLICITED?
Conversely, you may find some of your employees are "soliciting" porn; whitelisted in other words, and marches right into your enterprise.
Stopping porn and stopping spam are NOT identical goals. I've used Brightmail, and it is very good -- its strength is essentially zero false positives; vital for a business! It lets through more spam than some other solutions but you'll never lose a million dollar contract in "quarantine."
Your solution sounds too aggressive to me; I'll bet that you have lost critical documents in quarantine -- and browsing through quarantine to find them is worse than no spam filtering at all; you are wading through 99 % pure spam looking for a needle in a haystack.
by mhambrecht
by mgordon
by silentbob
I whole-heartedly agree, boot 'em if you can. If the company does an adequate job of trying to "protect" her and she still complains... "there's the door"
I would not want to be at the board meeting where:
Mgt "Why is the new database project not completed yet?"
IT "We had to re-allocate the budget for an on-site spam filter so Janice wouldn't get so offended, which took up the money that we'd set aside for that new SQL Server the project needed."
Just my $0.02
by daveo2000
In a more perfect world the charges would be leveled against the sender. But what happens when you are the sender because your PC was infected with a mass-mailer's spam program? Are you at fault for not ensuring that you had "adequate" anti-virus and spam filtering software on your home PC?
As has been noted a couple of times already, it is the company's responsibility to make reasonable effort to provide a safe environment for workers.
So now the problem is to define "reasonable effort" and "safe environment". That is where the water gets really deep and really muddy.
by deepsand
for delivering offensive mail.
The employee in question obviously has unrealistic expectations of life, and is all too quick to expect others to take responsibility for protecting her from its ugly warts.
by mgordon
Beware anyone saying flat "yes" or "no". The law is whatever a judge and jury says it is.
A slightly longer answer is that the offended employee can certainly sue; and the employer can certainly defend. Risk factors include whether the company utilized common and reasonable preventive measures. If the employer failed to use any measures at all, I would say that a risk exists, probably greater risk in liberal New England states where employers are considered somewhat "in loco parentis", ie, your parents, responsible for feeding you, sheltering you from rain, snow, porn and poverty. Out west, juries are more likely to have a libertarian point of view that you can do whatever you want, but so can anyone else and you accept as a condition of employment the fact that you might not like your next door neighbor or the email you get.
It is the nature of BUSINESS to receive unsolicited mail. Think about it -- if a business cannot contact a client by email until a business relationship is established, and the client cannot contact the business for the same reason, how then shall that business relationship become established?
The answer is that the business must accept the initial (and hence unsolicited) contact necessary to create the business relationship.
by silentbob
Several factors that pop to mind:
First, was this e-mail address inherited from a previous employee (ie. accounting@thiscompany.com). If so, either a address change is warranted (costly in both $ and lost contacts).
Second, if the address is NEW then it is her own fault for being so liberal about giving out that e-mail address either by forwarding lame chain e-mails and jokes or signing up for every website she comes across using the business email addy.
Third, the company should have some spam/virus filtering in place either by IT or by their ISP, however this is impossible to make 100% bulletproof and still allow her to not have legit emails blocked.
Basically, if it's a old address, the company needs to make the effort to swap her to a new addy to shut her up or if it's a new address, she needs to go to through some very thorough technology training and the do's and don'ts of e-mail addresses.
by mgordon
In case the original author doesn't respond, I will -- the address generating the spam has been in use for many years (7 or 8) and is wanted to continue.
Culpability is what lawyers create in the minds of a jury. If the laywer succeeds, a new crime will have been created out of thin air, ex-nihilo.
A distantly related situation -- I am employed in the multi-family housing industry (apartments). About 10 years ago someone discovered a whole realm of legal action possibilities -- mold. It is EVERYWHERE. All you have to do is declare yourself offended, the Landlord must remedy the offense -- so says Oz_Media and he's not far wrong. Just read "el reg" (The Register, www.theregister.co.uk) for bizarre stories from all of the Queen's former colonies and the homeland itself.
But as we have seen with Patent trolling, even more money can be made by NOT complaining in a timely manner and wait for DAMAGES to accumulate.
by deepsand
In "at will" states, the employer need not show cause as grounds for termination.
In such states both the employer and the employee are free to terminate thier relationship "at will."
by mgordon
by mgordon
"If an accountant is hired and is then subject to offensive email subject lines, it is no different than the secretary being subject to two guys talking about p***y all day long. The company MUSt take measures to stop it"
A better analogy is a business that takes walk-in customers all day. At what point must the business "screen" walk-ins BEFORE the walk-in customer or potential customer reaches the receptionist? If a man walks in and is rude to the receptionist, it might be actionable in some jurisdictions, but it ought to be an action against the perpetrator, not the employer -- although I can easily predict an out-of-control justice system holding the business owner liable since ya gotta sue SOMEONE.
by mgordon
"Canadian employment law protects employees from bullish companies."
Perhaps that is why the United States is more or less de-facto ruler of the free world. Whether anyone likes it or not, government elevation of employees to something like miniature demi-gods does not bode well for business efficiency.
The obvious exception is when nearly all employees are hard working and honorable and business does not have to worry much about them. Vancouver, BC is quite a lot like other Pacific Northwest cities (I'm from that area) and the social situation is just not like the rest of the world. You just cannot export your ideas unless and until you can export your work ethic and culture.
Iceland is an example of a nation where social welfare works very well; but it is almost perfectly homogenous as to culture and race. You cannot export your ideas to the United States, or the former Soviet Union, and for the same reason -- a society that can barely be called a society with such extreme diversity of culture and value.
by mgordon
by mgordon
" You have to check the spam folder early on to catch new addresses"
Ladies and gentlemen, the whole point of this exercise is so that employees with delicate constitutions do not have to EVER look at spam. Any solution that requires a sensitive employee to inspect her spam is worse than the disease.
by mgordon
"One col thing is how easy it is to redirect and capure employee mail if you need to track it. I caught people sending resumes, passing off client info for lead cash etc. Great way to cull the herd."
What were you saying about bullish companies and the wonderful Canadian rights of employees? Email is so very easy to fake; maybe in Canada this is the way to get rid of someone.
by mgordon
"If your company's email system is influxed with offesnive email, the company MUST take measures to reduce the amount of offensive email it receives or else you CAN sue them for exposing you to such content."
Agreed, and is why my employer has been actively engaged in some kind of anti-spam for the past five years or so. Most of us here do not expect 100 percent spam removal; we simply need to be anxiously engaged in the cause.
But what's on the table is a company that does not HAVE a mail system. Simply telling them to get a mail system seems irresponsible without further knowledge. They *might* consider subscribing to Postini (as an example) but they have to decide whether the cost is worth the benefit. Apparently, until this employee started complaining, services such as Postini would have been considered "all cost and no benefit."
by mgordon
If you HAD read the replies, you would see that most of the replies are not about the actual situation at hand, but rather a lively discussion of spam control on a somewhat theoretical level.
Also, you err in placing too much emphasis on just one person's opinion (lawyers opinions are, well, opinions) and the EEOC. The "law" is what a judge and jury say it is; and that's a moving target, and we all know it. A lawyer's opinion exists so that you have someone to blame when it goes sour, but in defense of the legal industry, they exist to improve the "odds" of getting it right.
In sexual harassment, there is no "safe harbor." That "hostile workplace" we've been discussing can be just about ANYTHING.
What I am learning about Canada is that workers have even more power than in the states to wag the dog.
by mgordon
As an interesting side story, our anti-spam has a false positive rate of about 80 percent but only for a business unit doing housing rehabilitation. It seems that very few people in that industry can spell and they use worm-ridden PC's and Hotmail accounts that produce email looking like spam.
Because of this, we have made things WORSE for that business unit -- instead of one spam-laden "inbox" to read throughout the day, they must now read the inbox and the spam quarantine every day.
Business cannot lose email. Unwanted spam can cost $100,000 (says Oz_Media), but a lost email can cost hundreds of millions of dollars.
by silentbob
Well, maybe I should have used "liability"... too much Law & Order I guess :D
It being an inherited e-mail addy is tricky, especially one entrenched over such a long period. It seems he has taken the best route which is client-side filtering, however this brings up a very interesting issue alltogether. If a company takes sufficient measures to stop the spam, they should not be held liable for this. Spam is so agressive that even the best filters can't catch it all. I work at an ISP and we spend a good chunk of change keeping our filter servers updated but they still get through. IMHO someone just needs to slap this lady with a big ass reality stick... either you get all your sales emails with some porn spam or you risk loosing some potential sales because you can't act like an adult and ignore things that offend you.
While on one hand, I'd love to see this go to court so she could be made a fool of, I know the legal system here and just because it's porn the court would side with her.... le sigh...
by jacksdaddy1
This woman is a lawsuit waiting to happen. If she cannot utilize this contrivance to file a harrassment lawsuit she will find another. You can always find people who love to play the victim and can feel offended in the most innocuous of circumstance. Woebetide this company that keeps her. If there is the usual periodic adult banter in this office as there is in any office of people that get along well, she will be the skunk at the garden party.
It goes without saying that porn spam, like any other spam is the scourge of the internet. Despite the greatest of effort, some will get through. No company wants this sort of thing and makes every effort to thwart it. It is a most obnoxious time waster for the sheer fact that people have to take time to delete spam from their inboxes. There are some annoyances in life that one has to live with. As an aside, this company should make a greater effort to limit spam of for no other reason is that it is counterproductive to office efficiency. Suing for harrassment in this case is like a construction worker suing for tired muscles.
by jamas
I am not a lawyer but I have read nearly every reply here. As Someone has already said, this is a question for you company's lawyer.
As far as the manager goes, she may be trouble. Or maybe she WAS looking out for the company and her language was to say that someone else might consider it sexual harassment. I am sorry to say that she is probably trouble. But it really only takes a little bit of work to turn her around. Give her a little bit of attention by helping her with this problem and make her a part of the solution. Train her in the use of email use and spam filtering, then put her on the team to fix the problem company wide. And please explain to her that even with the best filtering it will be impossible to prevent every spam and scam out there. Hope it all works out!!!
-Jamas
by schwana
At last, you, the email Inbox, find yourself the latest idea pad for a workplace lawsuit. Didn?t catch one out of twenty vulgar spams a day? Bingo, you are now known as the Inbox Pervert, the latest punching bag in office politics. (The guy who likes to touch everyone on the back is now off the hook.)
Read more: http://www.iwantmyess.com/?p=55
by jamas
From what I have seen throughout this ordeal, they could use this as the beggining of a great project. That person who has to go through all this rigamoro[Spelling?]could create the standard for spam controls. Spam is considered by us as just a hastle, but for many companies it is a drain on their pocketbooks.
As for the whiny little baby, hey she may be a great person with no other problems. This whole thing may have been a huge misunderstanding. But, sadly, you are probably right.
by debbi.cooke
First:
Implement a Network use policy that CLEARLY states that while the company shall make "Reasonable efforts" to curtail "unwanted mails of a solicitous, nuisance and or suggestive, lewd, or obscene, natures" and that the employee agrees that the company shall be "held blameless and immune to litigation arising from or relating to said offensive or intrusive items" received by employee while working on behalf of company.
Require the agreement to be signed before the employee is granted access to the network. If they refuse to sign it, fire them and hire someone with a clue. It is NOT discriminatory, and as stated previously, most US states are "right to work" states and employees can be let go at any time for non-discriminatory reasons, which do not have to even be divulged...
... And MOVE ON. I am amazed how much traffic this non-event is generating.
by metro_au
Whilst employers need to ensure the workplace is a safe and non threatening work environment (at least here in Australia), they cannot be held liable for every possible eventuality.
Following from Bill's post, if there is a reasonable effort to remove offensive material (electronic and otherwise), as long as it is sufficient to hold up in court, then no problem.
by noyoki
What holds water?
Just implementing some free spam solution like SpamBays (sp?), SpamAssassin, etc? Hiring someone JUST to go through her mail? Hiring several people to go through and forward EVERYone's mail, except these have signed contracts stating that this is their job and they're okay with that? Maybe a total e-mail server software replacement? There were many suggestions tossed around here. Some more expensive than others.
Without defining what "reasonable" means to one of many judges, yet preferably cost effective and acceptable for the company... You might as well have asked someone to jump. And when they ask how high, you respond, "high enough for that person over there."
by noyoki
His profile says "Not specified" as a country. Meaning he either didn't specify (can you register without specifying?) or he's not in the US or Canada. Does it then matter what most US states are?
If you are basing assumptions on this, you should know that different countries have different ways of doing things.
by double debo
If you company is more than willing to afford the possible lawsuit from not trying to filter out spam then I say stick with OE.
Now on the other hand you can purchase OL2003 for $97.95 or cheaper if you buy volume licensing or as others have said use Thunderbird. Of purchase an email filtering program. Spamnet costs $40 per year and works great for OE.
Being an IT person you must do research to save your company $$ for other than just IT.
by wrlang
I agree with those that say the company is probably making its best effort and this is a nonevent that can't be successfully litigated.
I would seriously question the need for this manager if the person is going to get all hyper about something everyone deals with every day.
I would give the manager the choice. You can live with the inconveninece, or the spam filter is coming out of your budget. Take your pick.
by johnmcgrew
Long before most people had ever heard the term ?sexual harassment?, I could tell where this was going. At least back then, most people could at least agree on what it meant in an employment situation: A superior using his/her position of power in order to fulfill their own sense of sexual gratification at the expense of subordinates. The classic example would have been a boss insisting upon sex for an employee to gain advancement or even to keep a job. Few could argue against that.
The problem is that as soon as such cultural issues get codified into law, the politicians, activists, and lawyers all exploit it towards their own selfish ends.
20 years later, look where we have arrived at. So few sexual harassment cases anymore fit under the classical definition. Today, it?s mostly nonsense like we have here, where the emotional cripples get to define what is acceptable for the rest of us, and/or the opportunists seize the slightest nugget as their anchor for the big legal victory payday.
If anything, cases like this only serve as arguments as to why we need a ?loser pays? legal system in this country, where the loser of the case gets to pay the legal fees of the winner. Only then can people be safe from ?legal harassment? and the courts can focus their attention on the real cases of abuse.
I feel pretty comfortable saying that unsolicited pornographic e-mail can definitely be viewed as sexual harassment. Is the company to blame or liable for the end user receiving it? Surely not. It was noted that the company is doing what it can with a hosted mail system, limited resources, and a reliance on an e-mail-based ordering system. That shows that the company is making a good faith effort to block as much spam as it can, whether it contain mortgage sales pitches, prescription drug sales pitches, or porn.
In my opinion, the company has a couple of options:
-Take the mail system internal; use the mail server?s rules to filter out undesirable messages, and couple that with a good content filtering appliance (my company has had great success with Barracuda). Once you bring the new mail system online, upgrade your mail clients from Outlook Express to Outlook or another, more robust mail client. There are a lot of options out there covering the whole range of pricing from Exchange/Outlook and Domino/Notes on the pricier side, or a whole host of solid open-source projects.
-Make the move to an online ordering system. Even if you don?t have the orders dumping directly into your purchasing system, you would at least be able to set up an ordering web form that would e-mail the order to your company with a single e-mail address or subject line. That would allow you to set up better filtering regardless of whether your mail system is hosted or internal.
Best of luck to you!
by dcrum1
Your company must assume some responsibility for all electronic tranactions. And must prove (due diligence) in eliminating what it considers violations to it's policies.
If your company doesn't have an internet\email policy this would be a good time to create one. This would show that IT\Management is moving in the right direction.
Remember, you must prove you're doing everything possible to eliminate this matter or else the buck$$ stops here.
by dcrum1
Your company must assume some responsibility for all electronic tranactions. And must prove (due diligence) in eliminating what it considers violations to it's policies.
If your company doesn't have an internet\email policy this would be a good time to create one. This would show that IT\Management is moving in the right direction.
Remember, you must prove you're doing everything possible to eliminate this matter or else the buck$$ stops here.
by daveo2000
We have all seen the case where the whistle-blower was fired (or worse) because "the company" had much better attorneys. Or the individual who should have won (in polite opinion) employed a law-abiding lawyer and the opposition scraped the bottom of the lice barrel to find lawyers to simply win at any cost.
If the loser has to pay, then the small guy will never bring suit and the big guy knows it. Basically, that is how it was back in the good old feudal days.
Why don't we bring back the duel? That only required 4 people and the person that was "right" was the one who wasn't dead! The answer is pretty simple here too: The large company would simply have professional duelers on the payroll instead of the lawyers they already have on retainer.
by johnmcgrew
You can't deny the laws of economics.
If the case is good, the small guy can and will win, and lawyers will still fight for the case because there will be money to be made. In fact, companies that are in the wrong will be far more likely to settle, because the cost of loosing will be that much greater.
by daveo2000
Which laws of economics do you refer to? "The better product will win over inferior products" or "The better marketing plan will win"?
Don't get me wrong, I like the idea of the world you live in and I don't like the one I live in. Where I live, superior products regularly get overrun by inferior ones because the superior ones were made by the little guy and the big guy's marketing plan overwhelmed him.
But, could you help me understand this concept of "the case is good"? Does this mean that it is an open-and-shut case and it is 100% clear who is at fault? Does it mean that the public is 100% behind what one side believes and against the other? And, are you talking only of criminal court or would this cover civil court as well where the court has to determined the percentage of guilt to assign to the two sides?
I'm not sure how this would affect cases where a small group of "crackpots" think that something is bad for you and the company "educates" the public otherwise. Please explain how your idea would play out in cases like cigarettes and asbestos. What about agent orange, ozone, PVCs, PCBs, thalidamide and a host of other man-made chemicals that, until somebody files a suit in the face of insurmountable odds, nobody acknowledged were dangerous?
Are you sure that these cases would still be brought to court in your system?
SIGN ZEE PAPERS!!!
A network use policy and agreement to hold the company blameless while using their systems does hold up in court, and always has.
DO THE PAPERWORK RIGHT.
by jamas
I agree that this is a needed step in the process, however a piece of paper signed by her is not a magic bullet. A contract signed by two private parties does NOT change the LAW. If a judge thinks that this case meets the requirements for sexual harassment that piece of paper may as well be on a roll next to the toilet. In fact any time an item enters the court room all bets are off, the judge or jury could go any way they feel, even with total disregard for the law. This actually happens enough that most suits are settled outside court.
With that said, they need to get that piece of paper created and signed by every employee in the company. And just as Bill stated, do it right and do it fast. These matters should always be done with a lawyer. A good lawyer is worth their weight in gold, at least to a business.
-Jamas
by noyoki
> "I agree that this is a needed step in the process, however a piece of paper signed by her is not a magic bullet."
I agree. Especially since this is after she has already created the problem. The judge/jury may decide that the paper was signed under pressure of loosing her job, making the contract null and void. As opposed to signing it beforehand. (Which they can still make null and void, but a bit harder, as the knee-jerk reaction would potentially be: "well they warned you!".) It would potentially help the case, but it could also give a false sense of security.
A pity you're not anywhere near NYC, or I'd say use us! (I am an IT Manager (mostly sys admin/tech support duties tho...) for a law firm.) We do have specialties in both "employment" and "employment benefits" areas. One of the attorneys actually does some companies in Holland... But I'm not sure where you hail from, as TR doesn't say. (However I myself am not now, nor ever will be, a lawyer. Thus do not give advice on legal topics. :p)
by lando56
by noyoki
by jacksdaddy1
by jacksdaddy1
by sprdave32
by sprdave32
Hmmm, I never thought of that solution. Everyone should get Macs and all of the worlds spam would cease to exist. As would viruses and crashes and nuclear weapons...and...and...
God I hate Macs
Sorry I got carried away. You can use the inherent spam filter in any contemporary email client to filter out the crap (not just on a d@mn Mac.) problem is the user who has this sort of issue is not the sort of user who is capable of configuring client side filters. Users who would levy such a complaint in the context of sexual harrasment probably don't have a great deal of technical savvy in the first place. Thing is, my staff and I deal with users like this daily ...it's our job to train, support, and sometime pacify them. Moving right along...
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by markml
Get rid of private email: Hire some people to screen all email traffic in your company. That's the only effective filter. And while you're at it, you can keep tabs on your employees to make sure they're doing their job correctly.
And let's face it: There's a good chance that the spam is the recipient's fault, since often times it is caused by said recipient posting their email address to a mailing list, getting a trojan, etc.
by techrepublic
I'm a female who gets alot of sex spam at work. I have a ISP-based spam filter and I bought MailWasher Pro for my desktop. MailWasher Pro is good at filtering out spam. You might want to consider trying that out on the employee's desktop.
Second, what if you put in your employee manual that spam of any kind (sexual, drug, etc.) may be sent to an employee's email. It is their duty to thoroughly scrutinze all email headers and to not look at and immediately delete any ones the employee deems to be spam (or maybe forward to a company email address and have someone who doesn't mind the occasion "off-color" spam.
Lorane
by blarman
to a harassment claim or been involved in the legalities. ANY hesitation by the company managers to PROMPTLY address sexual harassment is a huge legal liability. You MUST treat ANY alleged harassment IMMEDIATELY and SERIOUSLY.
The excuses that she's just going to complain later on about something else are IRRELEVANT to the sexual harassment claim. The idea of using complaints of illegality to judge someone's usefulness to the business is absurd, not to mention explicitly forbidden by law (whistleblower statutes). The attitude of treating her as a liability is what perpetuates poor management mentalities.
The point of sexual harassment law is that noone should have to deal with it in the workplace AT ALL. Turning off the preview pane is an unacceptable solution because it does absolutely nothing to address the root cause - and in legal terms this is known as not just negligence, but gross negligence.
People do not normally bring up sexual harassment to pick a fight. They do so because it genuinely affects them and their ability to maintain focus on their work. Sexual harassment is a huge distraction because of the psychological effects it has. Do your business and its employees a favor and treat sexual harassment seriously, or trust me you'll end up on the losing end of a lawsuit.
by jsargent
You have to send a note to your manager advising him/her of the problem and also cc it to the lady. It is not your responsibility to worry of this is harrasment. If the lady talks to you tell her to talk to her own supervisor since you have done your best. (Personally she sounds like a bully but under no circumstances tell her that or speak to her in a bad way.) Politely and calmly tell her you have done your best, you understand her but there is nothing more that you can do about it. If she insists politely tell her that you have nothing more to say about it. After she has talked to you send another note to your supervisor saying what you did and said.
(Remember some people use words like "harassment" very easily. Don't worry.)
by jsargent
by johnmcgrew
...are those that see to it that when there is a demand, there will be someone to cater to it. If a case has merit and is likely to be won in a rational court system, then there will be a lawyer who will take it.
When I say "the case is good", I mean one that can be won. Simple as that.
And yes, the "crackpot" cases would be brought to court, but only if there is legitimate science behind them. And yes, that would likely mean that most cigarette and asbestos cases would be thrown out.
Ahh in the land of OZ there must be time for such trivial things.
British Columbia now is that actually Canadian or is it British?
2 Facts
1 I would be a Boss if I did not have to put up with P***ies like you. I used to be a Service Manager but I could not stand all the crying.
2 You can be fired at anytime for any reason in the USA. Sure you can waste your time in court, then no other company worth its salt would even want you around, no matter how good you were. As a matter of fact, once you go to the personnel office and compain about someone or something in your company, your career there is OVER. Anyway why would you want to stay at a company that makes you so miserable? Can't get a real job? or just don't feel like working?
by absolutely
by honuheroes
Forget the company you work for. I want to know about the Medical companies sending all these Viagra Spam emails talking about "Making her scream" I am getting constant Sexual Harassment emails about my Penis size and I think it is discusting. What is most discusting is they have no idea my age, How do they know I am not a child? But even as an adult I do not think it is ok for anyone to constantly sexually harass me for any reason. Yet every single day of my life my personal email is full of spam emails asking about the size of my penis. I want that to stop. Nobody has any right to send me any sexual explicit emails. So I could care less if my employer could be heald responsible for sexual harassment what matters more is can we take up legal action against the company promoted in the sexual explicit spam we recieve??
I sure would love to see a class action suite against these pharmaceutical companies that are responsible for who ever sent these Sexual Harassing Emails!! I would join that suite in a heart beat and I may be the first person to file a lawsuite against pharmaceutical companies for sexual harassing emails. I do NOT need any Viagra and I sure as hell do not want a million emails about it.
I want to see the People of the USA stand the hell up and take legal action against these pharmaceutical companies that think they can do what ever they want!!
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending