Discussion Locked

Carly and her golden 21mil parachute

0 helpful
39 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

OK - so how do I explain business to my college kid. Carly Fiorina is 'let go', cause she didn't do the job she promised.

She got a nice salary, and as a parting 'gift', 21 million dollars.

Most of the rest of us are lucky to get 1 week of pay for every year we worked - if laid off. If we're fired, it's 'hasta la vista baby'.

How do you explain that?

PS - how many jobs could HP have kept in the US, for that salary plus $21 mil?

39 replies

by maxwell edison

.
Hopefully, by the time a person gets to College, he can think for himself and study a subject sufficiently enough to explain it himself -- even if he disagrees with it.

If my college aged son or daughter asked me why........, I would ask, you tell me?

Now an exception might be if I had an MBA or something. But I have a feeling you don't have an MBA or any business degree, and that you criticize "big business" in general, or else you wouldn't have asked such a question.

Hint: Maybe it had something to do with the contract Hewlett Packard entered into with her six years ago.

by mrafrohead

man, they shoulda canned her long ago.

I really can't tell you a single good thing that she did for that company.

Their customer service is beyond horrible, I can tell you that I will NEVER EVER buy from HP after having do do business with them about two years ago.

They tanked and I think that she's mostly responsible for it.

by amcol

Your condescending post is the reason I'm giving serious thought to moving on to another board, having spent a couple of very unsatisfying months on this one.

What's the point of jumping all over the poster? I thought I'd be communicating with adult professionals on this board, people who could manage to act with a minimum amount of decorum. There's no way half of some of the nonsense I've seen in too many postings would be said in a business meeting, or in a face to face discussion. Why do it here?

I'm especially mystified because according to your own profile you're at an executive level. Is this how you talk to your subordinates? Your peers? Your management? Your temps? Your contractors? Your family? Anybody? Why do it here? Because you're anonymous, perhaps?

I agree it's a somewhat naive question. OK, how about offering some constructive criticism or an answer that doesn't make YOU appear to be an arrogant jerk?

I come to this board, and others like it, to learn something. To add to the collective body of knowledge. To see what other people are thinking. To engage in constructive interplay. I don't have time for nonsense. Do you? Yet you and other posters like you make us waste our time reading things I'd sooner expect to see on uncensored_frat_boys.com.

It's not for me to judge. Do whatever you want. Which is just what I intend to do...elsewhere.

by maxwell edison

.
Sure, it might be a little pointed, but so what? I would probably call it blunt instead of harsh.

Point one: College isn't so someone can go home to daddy to ask about business. College is to get someone to think on his own based on his own study and research. The whole premise of the question sounded strange, and I'm rather skeptical of it for a variety of reasons.

Point two: Anyone who understands the first thing about business knows that CEOs in that kind of position go into it with a long-term contract complete with stock options and buy-out details.

Point three: The tone of the question appeared as though it wasn't really intended to seek an answer, but rather to complain about "big bad business". Quite frankly, I think people who constantly complain about how bad big business is doesn't deserve a polite answer since they usually are looking for reinforcement.

If you think my answer makes me sound like an arrogant jerk, I don't really care.

If you really want to see a "jerk of an answer", look at these (posted by the very person who asked the question):

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=163681&messageID=1678161

(Real "professional", isn't it?)

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=166332&start=0

(Stupid users? I hate it when support people call users "stupid.)

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=166273&messageID=1700147

(How's that for class -- or lack thereof?)

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=163476&messageID=1676555

(And a "blame America" type guy to boot.)

Actually, the guy deserved a "harsh" answer, but I pulled back a bit and just gave him "pointed". If I wanted to be harsh, we all would have known it.

Hey, bottom line, he asked a question, and I answered it.

You wanted "constructive criticism"? Well, that's exactly what he got; it was somewhat critical, and since the question was answered, it was indeed constructive.

But if, as you said, "It's not for you to judge", then why did you?

("Arrogant jerk" is not "judging"?)

by mrafrohead

Amcol, you really, REALLY need to chill out.

"There's no way half of some of the nonsense I've seen in too many postings would be said in a business meeting, or in a face to face discussion."

Speaking for myself only, yes, what I say you would hear in a face to face discussion, actually how I am here is quite toned down.

Board meetings are a whole other thing, but this is NOT board room.

"Is this how you talk to your subordinates? Your peers? Your management? Your temps? Your contractors? Your family? Anybody? Why do it here? Because you're anonymous, perhaps?"

This is how we are, how you see all of us here respond. It's how and who we are.

Speaking for myself, here's some answers.

Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, because it's how I am. Not at all, refer to the last answer.

"OK, how about offering some constructive criticism or an answer that doesn't make YOU appear to be an arrogant jerk?"

Look at your post, dude, you come in here acting holier than thou. Get over it. You're no better than anyone else, stop acting like it. If you can't handle how real people are in the real world, then pull up your skirt and go home. Grow some skin man. Buck up!

"I come to this board, and others like it, to learn something. To add to the collective body of knowledge. To see what other people are thinking. To engage in constructive interplay."

As do we all.

"I don't have time for nonsense."

Nor do we, but we do all have personalities, which is what you are seeing and coming across. We aren't the borg. We don't belong to a collective where we are all the same. You are dealing with different people from different areas coming from different walks of life that all have something in common. computers.

"Yet you and other posters like you make us waste our time reading things I'd sooner expect to see on uncensored_frat_boys.com." + "Your condescending post is the reason I'm giving serious thought to moving on to another board, having spent a couple of very unsatisfying months on this one." + "It's not for me to judge. Do whatever you want. Which is just what I intend to do...elsewhere."

=

Good Ridance!

Love,
Mrafrohead

by tbragsda

.
Sure, they must comply with the terms of the contract, but to point out this sort of excess is not wrong.

Not that long ago, the division between the exec and worker was miniscule compared to today, and they felt well compensated. What?s wrong with asking the question, where could have this money been used better? Its a drop in the buckett to HP, but crazy money for a unsuccessful exec.

Now, just my two-cents on the HP/Compaq subject. I loved both companies. I was not a fan of the merger idea to start with, and will be happy when they break back into three logical groups.

by maxwell edison

.
Don't get me wrong; I think Carly did a terrible job. But the comparison to the average worker is not really significant.

To see it in another perspective, she got less than 1/2 cent per share of the outstanding stock. And these CEO packages are almost always tied into the stock price, and nothing else

by amcol

My apologies.

I wasn't aware of this particular poster's previous track record. Thanks for the information, which changes my perspective.

Knowing that now, frankly I would have responded in a similar fashion (and have in other threads, probably even worse). Respect is earned...so is disrespect, and in this case I can't argue with how you handled it.

As I said, your profile indicates you're at an executive level, as am I. I believe those of us who have achieved a certain station in life and have the gray hair and scars to prove it should set an example for the younger and less experienced.

However, without doubt, with some of the trolls on this board sometimes it's just clobberin' time.

I made a mistake. Again, my apologies.

by maxwell edison

.
...for apologies. And don't go away either. Even though some of us (yes, myself included) sometimes let certain passions or frustrations spill over into our messages, in the long run, and on balance, most of the people around here are pretty decent. You'd be surprised at some of the messages I might read and want to unload on someone, but I just move on. (Or to see the messages I might read and really DO unload.)

Also, there are some messages I might post that might sound harsh or mean on the surface to bystanders, but the person for whom it was posted would recognize sarcasm or some friendly ribbing based on a history of conversing back and forth (but this was not one of those), and someone else gets offended. Oh well, it comes with the cyber-territory.

Tone and intent are almost impossible to get across in these messages, especially considering the wide range of nationalities, experience, education, tolerance for humor or sarcasm, etc. No matter how hard someone might try, somebody might take something the wrong way. So I suppose I don't even try to please everyone, so to speak, but rather just speak my mind and just let the cyber-chips fall where they may. Most of the time they stack up alright, but other times....

Anyway, no problem. As someone else ponted out in another thread recently, I can take it as well as I can give it. And I never take such things too seriously.

by tbragsda

.
As the packages get bigger, explaining them based on the last outrageous one seems like a bad way of justifying. Even worse, when the exec does, by most accounts, a less than steller job.

I'm not saying this case was exceptional, it was about par. Now what should the next falure get?

by av .

How can we ever justify paying CEO's the salaries that they get? It is just out of control and I would explain it that way. Morally its a no, though.

CEO's are absolutely paid too much money. They especially shouldn't be rewarded for doing a bad job. They should get nothing if they don't produce results. Carly Fiorina was an opportunist and an excellent example of this.

I would tell my college age kid to look beyond the money and decide to have integrity instead. It may not pay the same kind of money, but you can go home every night with a clear conscience. How much money do you need to live anyway? Millions?

We have to stop treating CEO's like kings. They are too greedy. If they run a company, their pay should be based on the results and it shouldn't be 20 times the amount of the highest paid employee.

I guess it is all about the money today, but I would like to see a return to values from the top down.

by maxwell edison

.
There are good companies, and then there are bad companies.

Good products, good intentions, fair dealings, good profits, and so on, are all among the traits of a good company - and everyone wins: the consumer, the employees, the investors, and the corporate executives. Hewlett Packard, Microsoft, Autodesk, ebay, General Electric, General Motors, et al, are all good companies. Where would we be without them? WorldCom and Enron were bad companies. Unfortunately, the bad apples give the good ones a rotten reputation, but only if you believe everything you read in the newspapers. The good companies, at least in the USA, outnumber the bad ones by a factor of many hundreds, or perhaps even thousands, to one.

A bad CEO can drive a bad company into the infamous ranks of the Enrons of the world. A good CEO might be able to turn it around, but would, most likely, avoid it all together. A bad CEO could take a good company off-course, but the nature of the company would probably keep it from being run into the ground. I can't really think of a good company that's been literally run into the ground by a bad CEO. You might be able to point to some airlines or telecommunications companies, but who can figure out the airline industry? And the telecommunications industry, ever since the forced breakup of AT&T, has had more mergers, buyouts, spin-offs, acquisitions, and sales than McDonalds has fries.

But combine a good CEO with a good company and you'll see profits soar. And contrary to popular myths, when corporate profits go up, so do the employment numbers -- and a number of other things. When a company is successful it results in better products, sometimes cheaper products, more employee productivity, more employees, more employee pay and benefits, better retirement plans, happier investors, and on and on. In such a case, if the CEO can make at least as much money in a month as Alex Rodriguez makes in an inning, who cares? Everyone down the line benefits. Pay the CEO absolutely nothing, and split the "exorbitant" salary among the employees, and they might get an extra few dollars a year. Would you give up a few dollars a year to be associated with a good company -- with a great company? What if the alternative was to keep the few dollars, work under a bad CEO, and work for a company that is taken off-track, or worse yet, run into the ground?

A good CEO can be worth his or her weight in gold. A company with the right leadership, vision, style, savvy, insight, connections, and so on, can result in a win-win for everybody. If a good company like Hewlett Packard has to gamble a few million dollars in their efforts to achieve that end, it's a gamble worth taking. And in the larger scheme of things, a salary of a few million dollars -- or even a few tens of millions of dollars -- is a drop in the bucket. But it's a drop that could result in a tsunami of benefit and success -- for absolutely everyone.

by jdmercha

"I can't really think of a good company that's been literally run into the ground by a bad CEO."

Pets.com, assuming you think it was a good company. If I remeber right, the year they filed for backrupcy the bonus monies paid out to the executive management team exceded the company's debt.

by jcrobso

This is true, but I think that the problem comes from the fact when a CEO fails they still get rewarded.
The companies proffits shrink or there is a loss, employies are laid off, some may lose there retierments.
But the CEO walks away with a large sum of money for basicaly FAILING to do the job they were hired to do!
Lets take Circuit City for example. Two years ago
the CEO didn't get his bonus, so he looked at how he could improve proffits, decide that the top sales people in the stores were making to much money so he fired all of them.
Now if you have shopped at a Circuit City and had to deal with the ones who didn't get fired, it maybe easy to doubt his decision. John

by av .

"Good products, good intentions, fair dealings, good profits, and so on, are all among the traits of a good company." I can't think of any companies today that would be considered good by your definition.

What I see are companies with selfish intentions, ruthless ambitions, shady dealings and no integrity. They have no respect for their workers and will dispose of them quickly if they need to turn a profit for that quarter. I'm talking about corporate America today.

In the year 2000, corporate executive pay was at a 531 to 1 ratio. Today it is at 302 to 1. In 1980 it was 42 to 1. Its ridiculous today. There are very few CEO's that deserve to be paid a king's ransom for running the company. Most of them are mediocre at best. I don't see any stars.

It is absolutely heinous to walk away with millions of dollars in salary and bonuses after laying off thousands of workers to turn a profit. Or better yet, ship all the jobs overseas, get a bigger profit for yourself and then make all the workers that contributed to the company's success over the years train their replacements or they don't get their severance pay. That is just despicable. It never used to be like that in the past; people used to retire from a company after many years of service.

Corporate America is so greedy today that the regular workers that contribute to the success of the company don't see anything but their regular paycheck, ever. They are always threatened with layoffs or outsourcing. They feel lucky to even have a job.

All managers receive bonuses of some kind, but the only people that truly benefit from the success of the company are the executive management. Most of them did nothing at all. Maybe some of them earned it, but very few. It just exemplifies corporate greed.

Its not only that. Corporate America is just a little too close to government for my tastes. They can buy anything they want and they always get it. Its a conflict of interest.

Carly Fiorina doesn't deserve anything. If she did a poor job and was a lowly worker, she would get nothing. It shouldn't be any different for a CEO.

Why aren't CEO's salaries tied to their performance?

by dafe2

Most CEO's & other key players negotiate all there fees up front. Although some of these fees sound outrageous others here mention the 'drop in the bucket' and it really is.

"We have to stop treating CEO's like kings. They are too greedy"

Most CEO's generate a lot of money and have a DIRECT impact on the economy and health of large corporations............

If you want to talk about greed & arogance think about how much some sports figures & celebrities earn and what REAL benefit they bring.

by maxwell edison

.
Whether it's a CEO, a sports figure or a celebrity, people should avoid falling into the trap of judging or begrudging others for what they earn. Of course they bring value, or else they wouldn't earn it. We might think that some baseball player isn't worth the big-bucks he earns, and maybe he's not, but in some way, he brings value to something or else he wouldn't get it in the first place. One player, for example, could increase attendance by tens of thousands of people per event. Sure, the ownership benefits financially, but so does the city in general, and so do other people. How many additional jobs, for example, might also be created (or saved) as a result?

And people don't consider what they might give back. Bill Gates has given, for example, almost a billion dollars to provide immunizations to kids around the globe. And that's just one of hundreds of different causes that he's given to. Look at the Tiger Woods foundation, and see what he's given back. Joe Montana, John Elway, Jeff Gordon, Wayne Gretzky, and scores of others who have made the "big bucks", they all give back to charities and/or their communities. Look at any "major league" city, and see how a number of the local sports figures give back to the community.

Sure, there are the exceptions. But on balance, most of them, in some way, not only provide value to something, but they give back as well.

by silvioandpauly

Let me guess - you're a pointy-head who enjoys putting others down or in thier place. Maybe you're one of those insecure people who rely on their pay, Beemer, $4.00 Starbucks, and other things to make them feel good?

And about the MBA - not impressed dude. Research has shown that most millionaires don't even possess one.

You're right about the post - it was meant more to discuss than anything, since nobody else commented. And the question was asked by my HS son. Take a chill pill dude - were you loved by your parents?

by maxwell edison

.
I guess you put me in my place, didn't you?

But you did confirmed my suspicions about the nature of your message - disingenuous and dishonest.

Pass the pill, please.

by mrafrohead

Stop pulling each others hair, or you'll both have to spend the afternoon in the corner with your "amcol", I mean "dunce" caps on... ;p

by amcol

But I've decided to take Maxwell's advice. I think I'll stay.

I guess my expectations of this board were unreasonable. The people who originally told me about it led me to believe I'd get intelligent dialogue, presented in an intelligible fashion. There's certainly a lot of that, but far too much blather as well.

You seem offended that I take offense to you. Methinks thou doth protest too much.

Say what you want, anyway you want...it doesn't bother me at all. As you continue to exercise your right to express yourself as the offspring of T. Rex and Knucklehead Jones, I'll exercise my right to pay no attention to you.

This is the part I don't understand. You actually do have some interesting, intelligent things to say. Why do you go so far out of your way to be obnoxious? Doesn't that require more energy than it's worth?

Before I'll believe you act in real life the same way you act in this board I'll buy that bridge in Brooklyn you're trying to sell.

And if you really do...I'd love to hire you. So I could turn around and fire you. I don't know where you work (assuming you do), or the kind of people who (you think) tolerate you, but you wouldn't last a nanosecond in my world.

by mrafrohead

"Doesn't that require more energy than it's worth?"

Actually, it comes naturally... ;p

"but you wouldn't last a nanosecond in my world."

Don't get to far ahead of yourself. I put people like you in check at least once a week. You seem to think that you're better than most. I don't understand why that is, but I have no problem knocking you off of that high horse you seemed to try to ride in on... Remember, you bleed the same as everyone else on this planet, you're no different than me or anyone else, or better for that matter.

"And if you really do...I'd love to hire you. So I could turn around and fire you."

You'd never get the chance, I'd take the job just so I could shove my middle finger in your face and walk!

I've had bosses like you before, as a matter of fact, one of them is still wearing a crooked pointer finger because he stuck it in my face. I ripped it backwards until it snapped. I doubt he'll EVER do that to someone again...

"But I've decided to take Maxwell's advice. I think I'll stay."

He usually does give good advice... I'd say 90% of the time it's well worth taking or at least considering...

by maxwell edison

.
I'm always right, man! Don't you know that by now?

I thought I was wrong once, but as it turn out, I was mistaken.

by tomsal

:)

Seriously, a lot of us folks like mrafrohead, Maxwell and myself have been around here for years. I have to say we all ruffled each others feathers on more than one (or 900) occassions. I got pretty heated before and pretty strongly disagreed with these guys from time to time. But strangely we all stayed and continue to seek each other's advice, appreciate the feedback we give other (or sometimes hate it) but there's some sick level of respect I think anyway that is maintained enough that we can violently disagree on something but we still just move on and go "ok next topic". I think that's pretty cool. I don't know too many boards where that kind of a community exists.

The regs on this board, are mostly blunt in honesty -- its rough to get used to at first because you think folks are just aggrogant SOBs at first until get to know them a bit.

Of course some folks are just sob's and we know who they are. lol.

by tbragsda

.
Some may be worth whatever a company can pay (Steve Jobs), others are not. The board may bet on a exec with the hopes that they preform, just like a baseball player may be a bet on his ability improveing over the years of his contract. Shareholders must accept the risk, or move on.

My point is constantly uping the ante does not get you better, just pays out more to the exec, or ballplayer or whatever. Would she worked for HP at half that?

The exec DO NOT necessarley have anything to do with creating the welth of the company. They dont necessarley deserve a suit case of money.

On the subject of "Giveing back". Why is this part of the conversation at all? To prove that excess prods some to give back? I expect everyone to "give" its just a matter of what we all have to give in the first place. Why jump up and down when someone gives away dollars that are meanless to them. Its so over the top, that they could never spend, give it away, and I should feel that they are more generous than me? I think not. When I give, it means that I cant do... whatever I would have spent that money on.

I don't have much time right now, but the question of philanthrophy is a intresting one for me. I think the stars of this world are not such great people.

by maxwell edison

.
Don't get me wrong. I certainly don't worship at the feet of "the stars". To the contrary, most of them are no more than mere legends in their own mind. But I certainly don't begrudge them for making the money they do. When you start trying to define "too much" and "for whom", it gets rather sticky. Besides, there are better things to focus on other than complaining about this person or that person, or this group or that group who makes too much money. If you don't like it, don't contribute to it.

Personally speaking, for the most part, I pretty much despise the Hollywood crowd. Not for the money they earn, but for their pompous attitudes. I don't watch their stupid award shows, and I wouldn't pay a plug nickel to see one of their movies. (Well, okay. I do, on occasion, pay to watch one or two -- but only once in a blue moon, and it better be a good one.)

by tbragsda

.
I started to do that, and you said it was meaningless. A exec that makes 100's x of what the avrage employee of the company makes is too much. The member of the board make decisions for what is "too much" and "for whom", and its not ?sticky?. The only recourse is for shareholders to sue the board for bad decisions.

Anyone remember SGIs problems with a less than advertised CEO? Trashed a company and walked. I would have to lookup his package, but whatever it was, he was not worth it. I can say with little problem that in that, and this, case that it was "too much" and "for whom" too much was paid.

P.S.
I was not speaking of Hollywood stars, but I agree. I never watch the awards, or care in any way about them. I don't know there names, and don't care to. Its not because of anything other than I just don't think its worth my time. I love moves, but never have watched a movie based on who is acting in it. I was speaking of Carnegie, Rockefeller, Gates etc.

by tomsal

1) She (as do most if not ALL "Fortune" level company execs do) had a contract. I'm guessing that her golden parachute was explain in detail -- in black and white in her contract.

2) Life isn't fair. It's simple, its a shame, and it's sad - but unfortunately its true.

If we all got paid soley on the importance, workload of our jobs, frankly I think Execs in most companies would get paid less than the managers under them, cops, fireman, paramedics, swat teams, etc. would make six figures a year and teachers would make at least twice as much as they do right now.

Ever notice how the lower you are in the food chain it seems the more work you do and as you go up the ranks it starts out at just directing people, then it goes to paperwork, then meetings get added in and once you are executive staff you just talk a lot at meetings, then play golf, go to your vaction home and the other time you run around and intimidate your staff a lot by screaming at them.

But life just isn't fair.

by silvioandpauly

You make good points too - I'm going on a tangent, but I think those animals getting millions to throw a ball are overpaid too. Hey - lets get some players from India to replace 'em. - LOL

What the heck was in the coffee I just had?

by tomsal

Outsourcing the jobs of our pro sports athletes to be replaced by India's work force.

I guess the traditional ball cap at baseball games would be replaced by turbans. You'd have team names like the "Raging Camels" and at consession stands you'd be able to get "extra curry with that".

;)

Disclaimer to those with no sense of humor...its a joke, if you are upset....get bent.

Later.

;)

by mrafrohead

Tom you got it...

We really are quite opinionated.

But the neat thing is this. WE are all (collectively) some smart mofo's and we all come from different walks of life. And what I don't know someone else will. But wait, I know it all, so I guess it's okay huh... ;p

Which means you will get many different aspects of points of view.

As for respect. I have to agree. I'll ask questions here because I respect the answers that I know I will receive. I've gotten to know a good handful of these guys (and a few chicks :P) and I appreciate the honesty and integrity that you will find.

As for the blunt honesty, dude, when you're typing this crap out, you have nothing else but to be blunt. I mean, there's no tones or any of that jazz, so you just say it like it is. Some people can't handle it.

And then there's Oz...

I'll just leave that one alone.. ;p **nudge nudge** oZZZZZZZ ;-)

Actually, I'd have to say this. If I were ever out with oz, and someone screwed with him, I'd have to feed them their face. He's kinda rough, but he's a good guy... ;p

Though, I am kinda upset that my thread made it to the front page. Of all of the important things that I've ever asked or posted, why that one? That one was REALLY more for the few of us that understand me and my warped sense of humor...

Though it is kinda funny that I have generated over 300 posts when I was expecing under 10... ;p

by rice8501

To whom it may concern

I really think if you are concerned then the concept of golden parachutes should be examined on a global level instead of singling out one executive. This is common practice and though I don't agree with it, I think if she was a man this would not have received as much attention. Frankly, it is much less than most men have received and many men did a far poorer job under great business conditions. I think she had the correct strategy but unfortunately business conditions have not improved at all under this President and the tech market is still under water. I also think she was battling a corporate culture problem that still exist today. Look how long it took IBM to make the transition to PC,Midrange etc because their culture was tied up in the mainframe business and people internally fought to keep things the way they wanted them to be to protect their own domains. It took longer than 6 years.

by silvioandpauly

You make some good points, although that male bald-headed Tyco exec was a schmuk too. I think it's Dennis something - the one with the million dollar toga party.

by tbragsda

.
Exec take advantage of perks, nothing new. The level and expence of these perks grows to a point that becomes a joke, like the party.

At what point would the Tyco guy stopped left to his own greed? Would this party become annual? It more than a discussion of how much it cost the company, its about what becomes accepted as the norm is outdone by the next.

Put another way, executives who have the privilege of say, using the company plane for a personal vacation, then use it to fly their friends, then there dog to a dog show, then out for a nice pizza from Chicago. We may say he took advantage of the situation. So when the next guy only goes as far as lending it out to his drinking buddys, we say "no big deal".

by markinoregon

The issue of executive pay is becoming what it is simply because worker pay has been flat for quite some time. When I graduated from High School in 1981 an unskilled or semi-skilled laborer could aspire to make $15.00 an hour. Two and a half decades later a lucky few manage to make that. It's actually harder than it was then to make that kind of money. In 1981 I lived in Seattle and $350.00 a month got a modest apartment, now that wouldn't pay for a room.

Several years ago I went back to school got a Bachelors Degree and some additional training in the computer field. I have $15,000 in student loans and I'm making $35,000 a year. It's likely in a few years I'll be making 2 or 3 percent more but that will be consumed by the rising cost of medical insurance. I'm expecting that I'm making the highest wage I'll ever make.

I grew up with the ideal that work hard and I'd get ahead. No clauses, no statements that I had to be self-employed, no requirements that I had to have a certain degree or a certain career. If I worked hard, which I do and have the references to prove it, my pay would increase. Obvously within the limits of my field.

The problem is, work hard and get ahead has become a myth in this country. Luck and being a smooth talker play a much higher role in making good money than hard work does these days. Because of that there are plenty of us out here in 'the real world' that are getting pretty tired of seeing these astronomical wage increases and severence bonuses for the top 2%. We're also getting pretty tired of these people whining that they don't make enough money. The hardest insult these top 2 percent spew is that we (working and middle class) aren't worth the pay necessary to survive where we live.

Henry Ford showed a lot more wisdom than the current line of executives. He paid his workers more than his competitors becuase he knew they were his consumers. The current line of rich have had it so easy that they don't understand. Ford was no friend of labor either but I'd trade him for the current crop of executives any day.

Keep forcing the working and middle classes to accept the pay for workers in India and China and taking the savings into profits and executive pay instead of lowering prices and our consumer economy will eventually go splat. What galls me is the people who are making these decisions won't suffer the consequences it's those of us at the bottom.

I heard a comment on a radio show sometime ago that the high executive pay was based on the risk a CEO takes if the company doesn't do well they will be fired. Thousands of working class people have lost their jobs to poorly performing companies and mergers than executives. Funny how that argument only applies to CEOs who get nice fat severence checks for thousands of times the minimum cost of survival.

Bottom line the cost of living in the US is higher than the cost of living in the areas big business is asking American labor to compete with in pay. At some point there has to be an ethic that the price of doing business in a region is paying wages that fit with the costs of living in the region. Walk through Target, Wal-Mart etc most of the products sold in these stores are luxuries. Part of the price of doing business isn't just meeting the cost of living it's also providing money to buy luxuries. Most of the products I see in stores I can live without. And when faced with the choice of putting food on the table or buying the latest and greatest way to brew coffee the food is going to win. What happens to the US economy when people can no longer afford all of the fluff? Are the top 2% going to keep Wal-Mart in business?

Want to see an end to statements like mine and AmericanVoter's? That has an easy answer, bring some pay raises to the rest of the nation. If I don't have to worry about medical insurance inflation, and the money for retirement and how to pay my mortgage and know I'll be making more in 10 years I could care less what the top 2 percent makes. Keep the pay of the bottom 98 percent stagnant and dropping and this issue will continue to heat up.

by markinoregon

I think executive pay is out of control and this bonus is just one example. It get's down to what is good compensation, and what's good for the country. We are reaching or have reached the point where the whole Wall Street compensation structure is hurting this country.

Ultimately the first issue should be what does it cost to live where the worker is working. Note if there is no way a job is economically worth this amount of money where the worker lives then the job should not exist in that region. Our economy is dependent on the sale of luxuries so this amount needs something added to it for the good of the economy.

Then something should be added for complexity of the job, compensation for training and stress. This will vary. In the past top executives were generally paid 100 to 400 times what the rank and file makes.

It's pretty easy to cut costs by dispatching top paid employees. It should be part of the formula for executive pay where a company stands in customer service, quality and market share. Cutting costs that ultimately hurt the company should earn an executive discipline or a dismissal, not a pay raise.

None of these suggestions can happen when we have a stock market that is obsessed with a quarterly bottom line and making a quick buck.

The current fear is pressure being put on railroad CEOs to increase profits per share. The quickest way to do that is reduce investment in infrastructure. Long term this will result in delays in shipments costing the economy and share holders of other companies. It also could become an issue in defending our country. If the infrastructure suffers enough we may not be able to move our troops fast enough.

For that matter the great race to off-shore technology jobs, what impact is that going to have on the future of our nation? Our national defense is based on technology and Intel among others has moved some of it's top labs to India and China. Keep in mind the engineers are Indian and Chinese not Amercian they have no loyalty to our nation. Our technology emphasis in defense was based on the fact that China can put a much larger army on the ground than we can. Thus we need a higher kill ratio to prevail. If they have the same technology that we do it's going to be difficult to impossible to prevail. We will have to hope the Chinese will settle for economic dominance over military and imperial dominance. Human history doesn't give that much of a chance of happening.

At what point does a call to service to our nation begin to become an issue in the current system? As a nation we have no qualms with asking people to give up their lives for the country. But we are having issues with asking people to give up money for our nation, foregoing profits for the good of the nation. Which is more valuable a life or money? Where most would answer a life, actions are saying money.

by devans00

Personally I think huge golden parachutes, in general, not just Carly, is the result of CEOs sit on each others' boards. Kind of like a "I'll scratch your back if you scratch mine" mentality. The community of Fortune 500 CEOs and board members is relatively small and a lot of the people know each other from school or working together in the past.

Board members can return the favor of huge compensation packages when one of their peers becomes CEO some place. That's why you read about payouts that have zero relationship to performance of the company or the person.

My $0.02

This discussion is closed to new replies.