Discussion Locked

Certifications - What are they worth

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am myself a MCSE in Windows NT, and i say this with pride because i know i can manage a Windows NT network, really manage it. I fought long and hard, and only took the exam when i knew that i was smart enough to pass it. And i did, including TCP/IP and Exchange server 5.5.
Allong comes a former colleague and he reads a few braindumps, reads the books too, and read some more braindumps. He goes and takes the MCSE in four months. I know him and know that he sometimes doesn't know how to add a new user. The man is not good with computers, but because he was good at remembering he could pass the exams.
I know this is an extreem case, but none the less true. And i wonder what are my certifiction worth, because im not that proud anymore.
I know that someone will call me bitter after reading this, but i really am not, because i have the great job, he doesn't.

3 replies

by ebob

... if I am looking at 2 candidates, one with a certification and one with experience, I will almost always take the experience over the certificate. Of course, a 3rd candidate with both will be very impressive. I can verify the experience myself, and the certification says that they know at least a few things outside of their experience.

I find the "paper MCSE" thing very annoying. Apparently, MS is going to be addressing this in their cert. programme for XP. I sure hope so. But they're notalone. I ran into a guy with a CCNA who did not know how to power up a router(!). Fortunately with the Cisco programme, you cannot progress further without real-world experience. CCNP/CCDP cannot be obtained from books and classrooms. And CCIE requires it.

There are lots of other cert. programmes. All hiring managers owe it to themselves to understand what iot takes to get that paper.

by drandall

He may have been able to fluke through the NT 4 track, but he will be in trouble when it comes to upgrading his certification in the Windows 2000 track!!

by fahaddayala

I don't think with win2k it is very posible to be a paper MCSE and I hope that the hiring managers realize that and give them honor.

This discussion is closed to new replies.