Discussion Locked

Clash of ego's.

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am a new manager, having been promoted from a senior technical role. Today I had my first man-management challenge.
I had to mediate between two of my programmers. The first, (Lets call him Mr A) one of my team for about 5 years, very experiencedand good at his job, but also arrogant, rude and abusive. The second, (Mr B) a recent hire is also quite 'Self confident' but keeping a lid on it because he is new.

Mr B was taking over a project from Mr A, and they had run through it once with Mr A in control and Mr B taking notes. The next time, Mr B did the job with Mr A watching. Mr B made a couple of mistakes (Largely caused by his inacurate notes). Mr A writes him some additional notes, and he runs through it again.
Again Mr B makes the same mistakes, and Mr A, losing his patience by now, tears up Mr B's notes and tells him to use the notes he has been given. Mr A then storms off and the both spend 10 minutes at opposite ends of the building cooling off.
Having noticed this washappening, I immediatly went and spoke to Mr B. I asked if he was OK, and he insisted that he needed some time to 'compose himself'. I then went and spoke to Mr A. I told him that I realised that Mr B could be frustrating sometimes, but that he was new and Mr A should lay off him. I also told him that tearing up his notes was out of order.
I then went back to Mr B and explained that Mr A was often rude, arrogant and abusive, and that he was like that with everyone from the cleaner to the MD. I told him that I had known him for 10 years and Mr A had always been like that and I didn't see any likelyhood that he would change. I told him that it wasn't personal, it was just his way and that he should let it run off him like water off a ducksback.
Anyone think I handled it well? Anyone think I handled it badly? Anyone had similar experiences?

9 replies

by road-dog

Just because Mr. A has gotten away with abusive behavior in the past will not protest the company from liability should he step over the line in the future. In fact, this may be construed as a known problem not addressed in a timely or effective manner by management, guaranteeing liability.

I suggest a meeting with the two defining your expectations of them relating to business goals and behavior. Include a pep talk on the new guy relating to "getting it" faster.

Then send off the new guyout and clearly and concisely explain to Mr.A that his treatment of his coworker is unacceptable, and that he can consider this his first, last, and only verbal warning. His next step will be written documentation with HR as building a case for dismissal. If he destroys another employee's notes again (or any other COMPANY PROPERTY), he will be escorted out of the building by security and terminated without delay.

This is not the environment to tolerate prima donnas and huge egos. If Mr. A's actions cause the company a huge lawsuit, any benefit he has made to the bottom line will be erased.

I also might talk to HR and see his file. If he has been warned in the past by previous managers, you might have to nail him now. Failure to do sois lack of leadership on your part.

Find out if your company covers anger management classes in your benefits package. If so, order Mr. A to attend immediately.

by timwalsh

There will always be personality clashes in the work place, and there will always be minor squabbles (and sometimes major ones) between employees.

One problem EVERY manager faces is whether to let the situation resolve itself or to get involved.

One the one hand, the minor stuff USUALLY ends up resolving itself. Employees generally resent anyone else interjecting themselves into a problem either they could have solved themselves or didn't perceive to be a problem to begin with.

On the other you NEVER know when a situation such as this can quickly get way out of control.

I would agree whole-heartedly with using road-dog's process if I detected a pattern of escalating squabbles between these two employees, or if I detected that the new employee was not handling the interchange well. From road-dog's response, it sounds like he's "been there, done that" before.

Personnally, I might have just stood back and watched to see if the situation repeated itself before taking any other action, or maybe just told the new employee that Mr A was always like that and that it wasn't personal. I might also have asked the new employee whether he wanted me to get involved.

But that's my take on the situation based solely on what you explained above. You were the man on the scene and you called as you saw it.

I would definitely keep an eye on the situation. You might want to discuss this particular event with both the HR folks, and your boss, to get their "spin" on whether you handled the situation correctly from a company point of view.

Unfortunately, I have found that there tends to NOT be any one perfect cookie-cutter response for a situation such as this, and you have to just call them as you see them.
Good luck with your new position.

by jkaras

Road Dog's assessment was pretty much on target, however both A and B need to be in the room to witness the good and the bad points of both sides. The reason is this, there is no sugar coating, no favorites, no room for missinterpretation. One issuethat I had when I had my first encounter as a new manager with a counceling was " oh, now he's mister big man,.. I remember when he was a nobody, power's gone to his head." The reality that I understood was that even while trying to be the friend you will still get the criticism. It's tough as you aspire to be the opposite of the boss you hate, only to realize that at times you have to have the heavy hand or there will never be any respect given to you if mishandled the situation showing weakness. One thing is for sure though is that you need to put Mr.A in his place, on the basis that that type of behavior is not acceptable no matter what the reason, tempers flare/stress, and we are all human but you have to spell that out specifically aswell as encourage Mr.B to improve his "game". Good luck with you, I trust that the management picked you for your people skills as well as your competency.

by firstpeter

The only thing I'd add is that you DO NOT want both in the room when you're explaining the good/bad of what happened.

First rule of management: Praise in public, criticize in private. If you have both in the same room and are criticizing Mr. A,you're putting him in an uncomfortable position, ON TOP of criticizing his behavior.

In addition, by keeping them both in the same room you get to the "he said/she said" behavior, and both will get defensive. Your comments need to be directed to the person whose behavior needs modification. The issue needs to be that person's behavior, NOT the specific situation (the behavior was the problem, not the fact they were working together and one wasn't getting it). With both in the room you're inviting a "it was HIS fault" argument on both sides, and it makes it extremely difficult to talk to one on his behavior.

Unless you're looking for one (or both) to resent you, I strongly suggest you take them both into a private office/space individually and explain what needs to be done to each of their behavior.

Good luck!

by jkaras

Paul, I get your tactic but when I managed, it was dominatly women. Yes, the fur flew in the heated exchange as women let it all hang out in an arguement, not trying to be shovenistic. Regardless of favorite/veteran or what ever factor suspected by the two both, in the end of the confrontation each new exactly where and what I would/wouldnt tolerate in private away from peers. I merly had to maintain the control because usually what they were angry about at eachother wasnt what they were arguing about in the first place, Yes it was uncomfortable but neither felt the one up on the other and actually in the end they would always become really close friends and yes it was the same with men, they tended to hold the grudge for a time longer. The object is to prove that your not biased. There is no right or wrong answer only in this, just how you handle adversity. It's tough being a manager and regardless of the caliber of employee, they will still fight with one another over the silliest reasons, some gain understanding to the other, some merly play nice to keep job while harboring hatred, either way it's gunna be a rough day at work till you get home and crack one open, alcohol that is...LOL

by thechas

As far as the immediate conflict, you handled it as well as most effective managers.

Now, you need to decide if you need to go further.

If this has been an ongoing problem with Mr A, is it documented in his personnel file?

If not, you need to discuss this with your supervisor, and the HR manager.
Set a clear threshold level for Mr A's behavior.

Then, sit down with Mr A, and discuss your expectations of him in the work environment.
Advise him that the work environment can no longertolerate abuse of other employees.
Make it clear that the next time he steps out of line, that he will receive a verbal or written reprimand.

Often, a few days off without pay can work wonders to adjust an employees attitude.

Just make sure that you follow company procedures and document everything.

Chas

by jackofalltech

I was once in a similar situation, however, I was Mr. B. As it turned out, I knew more than Mr. A did and he was not interested in continuing his education because he thought he knew it all. To this day, I still don't understand how he kept his job - even after he threatened another employee with physical harm.

You MUST put a stop to this NOW! Tell your Mr. A that technical knowledge is no longer enough and that if he can't deign to mingle with the common folk he will be out of the door.
Ralph

by scarecrow71

Thanks guys, I didn't think I'd get so many responses so quickly!

I agree that Mr A needs to buck his ideas, but I certainly don't think official warnings would promote such a change. I may have over stated his attitude with the word 'abusive' but he does have a problem, and one that has to and will be dealt with long term.

As far as the togather/apart argument, in the immediate aftermath the decision was made for me, Mr A stormed off and Mr B stayed put meaning I could deal with them immediatly and seperatly without starting a fresh slanging match between them.

At the moment, everyone is friends again, and Mr A has a weeks holiday coming up so I can use the time to try to bring Mr B up to speed in a more condusive atmosphere.I plan to take no more action immediatly other than to monitor the situation. Mr A's attitude has concerned me in the past, but without any management muscle I couldn't do anything about it. His problem extends not just to his co-workers, but to hissuperiors, his subordinates, and customers alike. His favourite catchphrase is 'I hate people', and he does, without exception, but he needs to understand that he has to learn to put on a happy face every now and again.

by scarecrow71

Also, I had forgotten to mention that I did casually mention what had happened to my MD (next in command) giving him a rundown of what happened, how I handled it, and that all is ok now but that I am planning to keep a close eye on the pair of them.

This gives me backup and reassurance that my handling of the situation was satisfactory.

This discussion is closed to new replies.