Discussion Locked

Commuter Blues

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Has everyone seen that recent GM commercial where commuters stare enviously out of a mass transit train as a new GM car speeds past, driver smiling? The add claimed that by using a certain credit card, members would earn points toward a new car. Well, I wont even talk about how stupid one must be to attempt to purchase a new car by running up a credit card account. But anyone who lives in a populated area (such as the SF bay area) would quickly recognize the absolute absurdity of this commercial. Anytime between the hours of 5AM to 10PM it would be the car drivers that would be staring enviously out thier window at the train as it speeds past. How about those SUV commercials they show during football games, of people driving through the mountains having a great time. Who does that on a daily basis? Most of the time I see them parked on the I880 freeway on the way to San Jose. PDAs, cell phones, fancy pagers, (and at $>2.00/gallon)SUVs, who needs em. I just want to be able to (afford to) live within a reasonable distance of my place of employment. To make it worse companies are still building in these crowded areas (new Cisco facility in South San Jose for one). Yes, its true, we are not all silicon valley Internet entrepreneurs or senior executives living off venture capital and enormous bonuses. Couldnt we learn to manage our lives and our society better? Where are our priorities?

8 replies

by john connell

In your post you banish PDAs, cell phones, etc. but aren't those things capable of making the commute a productive time? Now, I agree that the SUVs might need to fall by the wayside, but the mobility tools? I know that mobile phones and portable e-mail devices like the Blackberry allow some people to conduct work-related correspondence during the dreary, traffic laden commutes. This puts the commute time into the work day so one doesn't have to leave at some absurd hour just to make it into work "on time." To me, this is a wonderful thing. Why not use the commute to your advantage?

by dksj

They are not a solution but part of the problem. How many traffic accidents are caused by drivers who have a cell glued to thier ear or are busy checking thier stock position when they should be paying attention to what they are doing? No, I believethat we as a society must decide whether we are willing to donate 2 to 4 hours a day of our lives to what amounts to societal inefficiency. What are the solutions you may ask? Encourage companies to build facilities away from population centers, andprovide the infrastructure for them to do so. Encourage finding ways for people to spend more time working from home or at satellite locations. Use technology to manage traffic flow more efficiently. And finally, people should realize that as a collective society we do have choices. Other countries that are even more populated are also much more efficient(i.e. Japan). Food for thought.

by john connell

Your point is well made about the distractions of mobile devices while driving. However, there are handsfree options available to make conversations during transit an easy, effective option. If I can leave the office and follow up calls during the commute--you can bet that I'm going to do it. I recommend a headset or a speakerphone for the car. Is there harm there?
Is it really a good idea to persuade companies to move out of populated areas and provide infrastructure to make that happen? Where I live and work, that spells out further development of precious farmland and wilderness.

Shouldn't me move inward to revitalize parts of our urban centers? If you create mass transit then you eliminate the distracted driver factor. You can type, talk, or read worry free. It means effective, efficient commuting that can be incorporated into the workday.

But, are people willing to relinguish there autonomous driving capability to a commuter train or light rail?

by txbluebonnet

I have one pager, two cell phones (one for work and one for personal use), two computers (a laptop at work that I bring home and a PC at home for personal use and my daughter)... Where does it all end????

I commute in from a small town North of Houston to my office in North Houston each day..... I would love to be able to work out of the house (and could easily) but I love the adult interaction too much....

Oh, well... never happy, always envious of the grass on the other side of the fence, you know????

by jdeguy

Indeed, do we continue with the "urban sprawl" concept ending up with 21st-Century walled cities of self-contained communities? Or get into revitalizing and re-engineering the cities?
The Europeans have tried to discourage driving by taxing fuels.Go to London or Paris and you will see clean, efficient underground services moving millions every day. And also cities that have ignored the automobile and have horrible traffic problems.
People will not give up cars because they provide a high degree of freedom and flexibility. But when that is not needed, they will use public transport that is clean, safe, timely and efficient. Cost is not the only factor, convenience plays an important role.

by ddickens

Some people adopt the idea that driving their own vehicle is a constitutional right and anything that keeps them from doing it is a leftist plot. They will demand new roads, as long as the roads aren't in their back yards. They will complain aboutgas prices, even though that is theoretically demand driven. They will fight any attempt at getting them into any type of mass transit. They will even demand that mass transit pay its full way, ignoring the fact that auto transit is also subsidized.

On the other hand, smart people will realize that a mass transit commute saves money and wear on the nerves. Furthermore, even if it takes longer in some areas, you can use the time to catch up on your technical reading and make phone contacts. And at the end of the ride you aren't stressed out.

by nettek

I couldn't agree more. I live in the king state when it comes to being crowded: New Jersey. Not only are there more people per square mile in NJ than any other state, it was recently published that we have more people per square mile than India or Japan. I commute 2.5 hours per day on major highways, and fear for my life daily as the 18 wheelers fly by and the SUV tailgates me at 70 mph while the driver is talking on a cell phone. Companies keep moving in, houses are going up as fast as they can cut the trees down, real estate is at an all-time premium, property taxes are through the roof, and the highways are bumper-to-bumper during rush hour (which seems to be getting longer). I'm ready to move.

Not all companies are setting up shopin crowded areas. I have a friend who just moved to, of all places, South Dakota. He took a CIO job with a fairly new company. He's being paid New Jersey money, has a 15 minute commute with no traffic, and bought a multi-acre lot with a house that would cost 60 percent more in NJ. The air is clean, the crime is low, and the people are friendly. Companies like Citibank, Wells Fargo, and Gateway have major sites there.

Now I'm not sure I'd like living in South Dakota, but there must be other areas around the country with similar qualities.

by ryan

I have a job in the North East Pennsylvania. I might not be making quite as much as if I lived in NJ or another High Populated area, but my cost of living is lower, I live 10 minutes from work, I can drive on roads where I might see 3 other cars on my way in. I do carry a cell phone and the disadvantages of not having all your conveniences right down the block can be a pain sometimes, I lived in Columbus OH for some time so I do know what I am missing. But even without the "NJ money", there are many things to be said about working outside the City. I wouldn't trade my low stress drive, safe streets, clean schools for al the tea in china, or money in a NJ Job.

This discussion is closed to new replies.