Discussion Locked

Company Attitude Towards IT Managers

0 helpful
22 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I would like to know if the attitude towards IT Managers by upper management and other peer managers has changed over the past five years.
I have been involved in IT for over 20 years. In my experience and those of my colleagues, the attitude seems to be better in the last 3 years. Could this be the result of IT Managers educating themselves in business skills? Could it be that IT skilled people are making it to the upper management level/board level?
In my opinion, in the past, upper management are the ones to blame for the distrust that exists between IT and "the business"...how often have senior management thrown money at an IT problem in the hope that the problem will "go away". I know, when I was a young IT administrator, all I had to do was ask for a budget and the money flowed and it was duly consumed, no questions asked.
It's easier to train IT Managers in business skills than to train Business Managers in IT skills. There have been a number of MBA IT trained IT Managers popping up in the market. Could this be the reason for the attitude change (if there is one) in the past five years?

22 replies

by house

Both business and IT go together very well in my world. I think that nowadays, it is very important for IT to be represented all the way up the ladder to the senior management levels. It is also important that the executives in question also be from the IT industry.

The IT industry has taken quite a turn over the past 20 years. It used to be that IT folks were kinda like the people under the stairs. Now, with the saturation of our industry, people demand more from an IT potential than simple computer related knowledge. You need to be personable, have a strong sense of business, and you need to be able to make intelligent decisions without a bias for tech issues.

For this reason, there is a larger presence of techs within the ranks of management.

by secure_lockdown9

the business guys are always going to a bunch of back stabbing "dicks". as donald trump says, "get used to it".

yes - business is sucking up to IT when they see that that is where the money and power levarage are located. but once the tides turn - they will stop sucking up to IT and be "dicks" again.

classic case - i working during the dot com and ecommerce boom. they treated us like gold. but when their sales figures pointed ou tthat they were not going to make as much money and they counted on - they dropped us like a hot egg.

by dafe2

Was nothing but horse manure to begin with and so was the PC 'revolution'. LOL

by house

I've been flamed as displaying that "back stabbing" management trait by some of the one-day transients here at TR. Maybe there is some truth to that afterall. :)

by secure_lockdown9

true, but for many of us, the "dot com" and "pc revolution" was the start of a new career.

if it weren't for those 2 - we would probbaly be working some very manual/heavy labour/back breaking/steel mill job instead of sitting on our big fat ass all day.

by roger99a

I agree. I was digging holes and mixing concrete when I got my first IT job 10 years ago.

by packratt

Finding a steelmill job is about as likely as finding that pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. Heck, those are harder to come by than IT jobs.

by house

I've 1 of a 2 year CNC machining course behind me. I dropped that idea early when I saw the monotonous assembly line work waiting for me at the end. In that particular field, the jobs are there, but you are looking at quite a few years before you are sitting there designing, plotting, and programming.

Don't even try that "well I know this guy who..." - yeah, I know tose lucky few too. Those jobs are pretty rare though.

by dafe2

What I see going on is IT is now led by Finance.

We (IT) usually have a seat at Governance. Mostly in IT today you DO need a strong backround in whatever - Business/Industry/Commerce or Government.

The attitude change you see is simply a maturity in the industry, that is, slowly getting rid of techs that have no people skills or relevant background in the Business/Industry/Commerce or Government they are working in.

After all you do need relevant knowledge or skills to solve problems.

by johnnywatt

...for poor attitude towards IT. I recently wrote a letter after my the IT supervisor resigned, that whoever is put into position to direct IT, whether it is me (we'll see...) or another person, that the company must stop thinking of IT as a burden or a necessary evil to support individual department's desicions. We have departments that have ordered software without any IT's involvement. Of course, you can only guess how well that is going!

by hockeyist

...in a few years because business can blame IT without stepping on other managers toes...LOL

by pokerjohn

IT people are just like anybody else. In accounting, the ones
that understand the entire business and can communicate
become CFO's and sit at the highest level of management. In IT
it's the same thing.

The ones who think in term of US against THEM probably won't
be taken as seriously.

As far as departments buying software without involving IT,
what I've heard (as a former software sales person) many times,
that the IT guys treat some of the department heads so crappy
that they don't want to deal with IT.

There's always two sides of a story.

John

by johnnywatt

Really. I've don't have the attitude of US agaist them, it's just simply that. And I disagree with IT guys treating department heads crappy. I've always been more than willing to coorporate with all departemnts. The real issue is department heads looking at IT as having more control or too much control over their them. "Road blocks" is what one manager called IT. I guess because we like the idea of lower TCO and implemented security on our workstations. <- As an example of course.
But honestly, if the department heads feel crappy about IT, then there needs to be addressed. And, I haven't heard those needs yet.

by jon_baumgardner

I have worked in IT for 16 years. I am now Project Manager. I find that where there are mergers, there are IT people forced to make the business people understand that the reason there was a merger was to savev money. The only way to save money is to streamline operations. That means that all the business units have to have the same procedures and automation, integration and electronic commerce will cause the savings to happen. OF course defining the business rules and getting everybody to agree to them is painful but the requirement to do so comes from the CEO. Often times, IT is forced to gather these business rules in order to automate processes and in force the Business to think about their processes write them down, refine them and buy into the process.

This gives lots of power to IT.

by dc_guy

Another is that as the Paradigm keeps Shifting, the portion of a company's activities that are completely dependent on IT or simply now ARE IT (e.g. banking) continues to rise. You could hardly expect to run a business in the finance sector in this century without knowing quite a bit about IT.

Virtual businesses like e-Bay and Amazon are taking a huge bite out of the cash flow of more traditional companies. Being IT savvy has finally become essential to survival.

by dc_guy

Where have you been living, Tibet? The Internet exists because of PCs. Internet businesses like e-Bay and Amazon (quoting from my own post above) are revolutionizing commerce. I'd like to hear your definition of "revolution" if this doesn't qualify.

by dafe2

It was a sarcastic remark............certainly not directed at (Sec) but at all the c.rap that came with it...........such as those who got in whose only qualification was being able to breathe.

Certainly an of topic comment, but relevant in that the industry IS maturing and changing in more positive ways for those that see the larger picture. :-)

by binoy_hotmail

Since the world of business is changing rapidly, it is essential that the managers, including IT managers, need to adapt. Code optimisation & latest technologies sometimes take a greater importance than the overall business objective of that of increaqsing the value. As long as the manager keeps learning and adapts, the company's attitude will not be perceived to change.

by 4rd4fun

as an "IT Manager" I think it is our responsibility to understand as much of the business process as we can to facilitate growth. The more we are involved in the process, the more we can tailor our security and access to help the entity and thus making our IT department look better to top management

by jonas g

What I've seen overe the year's (26 and counting) is more and more emphasis from both sides on answering why IT needs money. What will it do for the business, in dollar terms, i.e. save costs, increase revenue, etc. It managers who can link IT changes to business initiatives get along much better with "upper" management, since they've learned to speak their language.

by victorthangadurai

One of the reasons could be that organizations and all its Managers depend on IT for their survival. With IT governance, corporate governance, security policies etc. IT cannot be changed or modified or upgraded as in the past. So the IT department and IT managers role in the organization is beginning to be seen as a good business enabler rather than a necessary evil.

by angry_white_male

IT needs to be factored into every decision that is made across the company. When was hired into my present position, the culture was that decisions were routinely made without IT's involvement - but expect IT to support it. IT does not have infinite resources.

Your IT head must be a strong leader who is respected by everyone from the Janitor to the CEO. A weak IT leader will be walked over left and right.

This discussion is closed to new replies.