Thank you.
You are right about the emotion thing.
I am the DNS administrator for the organization I work with. Our DNS structure is quite complicated. Even my asisstant manager who have 12 years of working knowledge in networking have some trouble understanding our DNS structure.
Now, the situation. It was in a meeting between our team member, a software consultant and a data centre provider. The software consultant just started to work in contract basis with us. His job is to support, maintain and upgrade an enterprise level application system for our students (we are private university). During the meeting he and my manager suggested (without my knowledge) to move all of our DNS to the data centre provider.
Now, I'm not going to explain to you how our DNS structure is, because it would probably required a long article just to explain it.
So, anyway, after I have explain it to the network engineer from the data centre provider, they did not have the capability nor the expertise to host special DNS for our special kind of environment.
Eventually, I found out my manager was the one who suggested to the management so that we host all of our DNS to the data centre provider. And his way of "outsource policy" is not something new. For him, it better to outsource because he want to keep his ass. However, from my experience, it is not difficult to administer DNS. My concern is that if we outsource our DNS to the data centre or to any other third party, we might have to change the way the user accessing the Internet.
The thing is during the meeting, after I told them that it is not possible nor logical to host DNS at the data centre, the software consultant said (with arrogant) "can, everything can be done, they (the data centre provider) should be able what, we have money, we can pay you as long as you can do it". Well it was not the money, but from history record there was other DNS consultancy company who tried to find solution to host our DNS, eventually they back out after I explain with facts and showing some output to them.
But, anyway, what the software consultant had said that made me piss off, really, piss off. But fortunately I managed to keep it to myself. However, after that, I send an email explaining why the DNS could not be outsource. As a result, we were called by our IT manager for an internal meeting (without the software consultant). During the meeting he stress out the importance of team work. I don't see the point of stressing the importance of team work because as far as I'm concern, the suggestion of outsourcing DNS was not discussed with me at all before the assistant manager submit proposal to the management. It does not matter whether the assistant manager or the management who decided to outsource the DNS. What matters that if related to DNS, it *must* be discussed with me as I am the DNS administrator, I am the one who setup DNS in the first place according to DNS protocol, not according to my own rules. You cannot just simply use your own rules in setting up DNS, because I did that when I first tried to learn setup my own DNS in 2001 and I can't even access my DNS even from within the same LAN.
Although what you suggest are quite true, but do you think that trust should also matters ?