Discussion Locked

Defragmentation

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Based on use found Diskeeper best for defragmenting a hard drive,and even much faster
Not even Norton speed disk can do what D-Keeper does,let us not mention Xp"s

9 replies

by timwalsh

Interestingly, in case you didn't realze it, the defrag utility in WinXP is essentially a watered-down version of Diskeeper.

Open the XP Disk Defragmenter; go to the Help menu and choose "About Disk Defragmenter;" You will see that this utility was developed jointly by Microsoft and Executive Software (the developers of Diskeeper).

by djent

Diskeeper is also the safest. Norton does some system files while booted that Diskeeper does only at post boot per MS KB recomendations.

by jhgoh

i heard that frequent defragmentation will harm our harddisk,is it true???

by djent

Most of my customers defrag servers nightly and desktops at least weekly. Harm is done by the defrag utility not the process, therefore my choice of Diskeeper. Many business apps are databases, every chane of data causes a rewrite of data and fragmentation. Failure to defrag slows data access to a crawl and jepordizes recovery of data should unplanned shutdown occur. I see no risk to frequent defragmentation and certain problems to not doing so. Diskeeper has proven reliability and is my first choice for that reason.

by ghayes

"Diskeeper is also the safest."

Diskeeper uses Microsoft's defrag APIs (provided as part of Windows). ANY defragmenter that uses Microsoft's defrag APIs is absolutely safe. This includes the built-in defragmenter, Diskeeper, PerfectDisk, O&O Defrag, Vopt, and Defrag Manager. There is no single defragmenter that can claim to be "the safest".

Under NT4 and Win2k, SpeedDisk does NOT use Microsoft's defrag APIs.

- Greg/Raxco Software
Microsoft MVP - Windows Storage Management/File System

Disclaimer: I work for Raxco Software, the maker of PerfectDisk - a commercial defrag utility, as a systems engineer in the support department.

by jhgoh

thanx djent...but im not clear of something..what do u mean by "Harm is done by the defrag utility not the process..."..does it means that... the defrag utility does not harm the process but other things???

by djent

Norton defrags NTFS page files during runtime, MS warns users not to do so as the drive could be scrambled. Diskeeper defrags page files and MFT files at boot before the OS is loaded, avoiding corruption. The process of defragging is always benificial and harmless if done right. Go to execsoft.com and browse their support pages, there is alot of good info there, subscribe to the news letter.

by mcseman

I have tried several defrag utils and decided to use Perfectdisk by Raxco (www.raxco.com). Not only does it run faster that Diskeeper but it does everything Diskeeper does and more. It even defrags your hiberfil.

mcseman

This discussion is closed to new replies.