Discussion Locked

Deliver with a team that lacks required skill set and abilities

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I want to know how a project manager can deliver a project successfully if he has got a team that lacks the required skill set and abilities? Let us assume that Project Manager does not have the option of replacing the team members for reasons beyond his control. What the project manager should do in order to get the best out of the team while keeping the higher management informed of the gravity of the situation and its impact on the completion of the project?

13 replies

by tony hopkinson

Programming is an ability, .net is a skill set.
Admin is an ability, Windows is a skill set.

If they don't have the ability, then their existing skill set is a moot point.

All in all a damn silly question. Only two answers, find another job, or get the team trained.

by khan.ovais

Skill can be defined as ?the ability to perform a technique with consistency and control with minimum effort?. A skilled swimmer is somebody who is able to swim fast using good technique to enhance their speed. Ability is innate (someone is born with it, or they learn it throughout the early stages of their life). Examples of specific abilities are hand/eye coordination, flexibility and speed; you either have these things or you do not.
[source: academicDB.com]

In our case ability would be to analyse requirements, propose a better design etc. Skill would be as you mentioned, the tools and techniques.

Do you think hardwork can substitute or neutralize ability, provided the team is trained to excel in tools?

Also I believe no question is a silly question except the one which is not asked :).

Good day

by tony hopkinson

Anyone can learn to program or to analyse, whether they can be 'natural' at it, is something you and they will have to discover.

Until they are given a chance, how will know.
I mean their could be a great gardener, or general or statesman buried in you, unless you try to be one how can you say there isn't.

As I said you can give up now, or let the team try.

If you do the latter, then you are going to have to be very careful about managing expectation and not losing sight of your role in your efforts to help them do there's given of course you have all the requisite skills and abilities.

Do your team agree that they are lacking, how do they think they should address the deficit?

by dr dij

See if you can convince management to spring for about $100 per employee. You can claim student and get it even cheaper.

Some of your employees may be willing to pay for it themselves as they are the ones also benefitting from training, and they can train in other technologies not related to your place, so they can make more money.

Use this for each employee to join either the acm.org or ieee computer society (computer.org). Sign up and you have instant access to their thousands of online courses.

mindleaders.com is another site, slightly more expensive. Probably about $250 per year for a group of tech courses package. I like them better as they ask questions after every few course pages which keeps you focused and trying to remember (take notes).

Both computer societies have thousands of online self paced training courses included with the yearly membership. You can browse the course catalog of each before you join.

The ACM just recently switched from thomson Net-G to skillsoft. (catalog at skillsoft.com)

and the IEEE uses Element-K courses.

They also have online quick summaries of software, e.g. 40 or 70 pages of quickly how to do whatever the topic is.

And online books on computer topics, either oreilly books or books24x7.com subset.

Courses include:
project management

microsoft topics
C##, vb, .net

databases
oracle, db2, sql server

programming languages
java, php, perl, etc.

web development

graphics programs

but you can browse the catalogs yourself.

These courses take time (2 hours to 17 hours or more depending on course). and there can be dozens of courses on a topic. The best way is to run one course a day (or in the evening when you get home). Keep plugging away at learning.

Also for any topic there are websites that have free material you can read, some have tutorials.

Good Luck!

by labrat636

To automate or "dumb down" some testing processes for underqualified (read not very technical) personnel. I am in a secondary market enterprise that depends on low paid semiskilled and unskilled workers. So I have to tailor some of the processes to their level. It is difficult, but not impossible. You will, unfortunatly, have to do more work than you probably should. But try to learn everyones strengths and weaknesses, and then delagate tasks to those that can best handle them. It may also require some extensive micro-management, of which I am not a fan. Good luck!

by $dunk$

I'd suggest hiring a technical lead. They can lay the groundwork that can simplify the tasks for the less able team members. If your team really sucks, then a good technical lead can usually pull the job together on his own (especially on just a 4 person job) and assign the busy work and really simple tasks to the other team members.

If hiring a skilled technical lead is not an option then, unless your project is not very difficult, I don't believe you have any hope of successfully completing the project successfully or on time.

P.S. If you hire a technical lead then do your job and let them stay focused on the technical aspects of the program rather than dragging them into the view-graph engineering and status meetings simply because they know more than you. It always amazes me how often managers interrupt the worker-bees in order to answer questions whose answers are readily available with an ounce of effort on the managers' part.

by wayne m.

I would take three steps; reduce the scope, increase the team skill level, and extend the schedule and budget.

The first step I would take would be to see if I could simplify the project to match or at least be a closer match to my team's capabilities. Remember, almost any interesting project will be slightly beyond the current skill set of the team.

The second step, if the skill issue remains as a high risk item, is to enhance the team's skills. This can be done by training or by hiring or by both. Also make sure the team has the top of the line tools to use and necessary development and test environments. High skill teams can get by with less; lower skill teams will need all the help they can get.

Lastly, I would extend the project schedule and budget. In this sort of environment, them team will inevitably take a wrong approach and have to completely back track and start over. This may happen several times, but what the team lacks in skills will have to be made up by a combination of luck and new found experience.

Remember, that once you have the team, it is up to you to get the best out of them. Do not spend any time "keeping the higher management informed of the gravity of the situation and its impact on the completion of the project". This will be the surest way to undermine the effort of the team. The best approach is to identify successes on the team and continue to negotiate changes in scope, schedule, and budget to benefit the team.

by khan.ovais

Wayne,

Do you think taking those steps would guarantee the success of the project or something closer to it?

I am not sure whether I can get an approval on the extension of budget/schedule from the upper management without keeping them on the similar wavelength regarding the issues project is currently facing.

I truely agree with what you have said regarding the team involvement and learning. Even if the project fails we will have something positive in the form of a poor team turned into a better one.

Good Day

by wayne m.

I don't anything can guarantee the success of a project under any conditions. The best approach is to maximize the efficiency of the team and accurately communicate what is possible.

With many projects, what is feasible is highly subjective. It is difficult to persuade someone of what can and cannot be done due to the lack of available information. The best approach I can recommend is to ensure that something of value is delivered at the end of the schedule or budget.

During the project, the most effective way to communicate progress is to deliver in several short iterations. This provides tangible evidence to upper management of what the team has accomplished as well as an indication of what they might accomplish by the end. I also recommend prioritizing tasks so that the most important are completed earliest. Plan for multiple intermediate milestone deliveries.

During the project, work on communicating to management: that your team is working efficiently, what your team has accomplished, and, based on the above, what is realistic to predict for the team to deliver at the completion of the schedule or budget.

by dr dij

with project management, you parcel out the tasks in chunks they can do in a day or so.

monitor these, and you'll see who can complete and who can't for specific areas. This will help give you an idea who can do what and who needs help / improvement.

plus with version control software (some such as subversion is free open source) checking in these modules and building the system (with tests for the modules) will show you who's code works and who consistently makes modules with errors.

And I hate to promote XP (extreme programming) which I think is largely bogus, but if someone can't do something, you could pair just this person with someone who can (temporarily).

They will slow down the person who knows how to do that task but this will help them learn. You can keep them with the other person just long enuf to learn skills.

by khan.ovais

Thank you for sharing your responses to such a case. From all the feedback I have recieved, the course of action I have decided to undertake is following:

Towards the team
- Micro-manage more than expected
- Technical assistance from outside the project on temporary basis / XP
- Make the team feel valued by working closely and empowering them. Even if the project is doomed, it will help develop the team members in certain areas. Something to add to the positives.
- Selective appreciation [http://ahmedayub.wordpress.com]

Towards Management
- Augmented Risk Reporting
- Reducing project deficit by reducing the project cost

Thanking you all again.

by tony hopkinson

important.
A lack of confidence on your part will get transmitted.

In some ways not being able to buy in new people might make the job easier.

I was in a team where management didn't think we had the skills to do the job, we felt it was hard but doable.
They drafted in contractors, switched technologies, lost all the business knowledge
and went bust.
Admittedly we would never have made the deadlines, but they set them without any reference to how they were going to be achieved anyway.
Like the Dr says, start small lots of phases, build confidence on all sides in small achievable increments.

by wayne m.

Please do not buy into the PMI PMP mantra that a project that does not complete all of its scope is a failure.

As indicated above, go with an iterative approach. This way you can assure that the team will deliver something at the end of the schedule. Make sure the team performs at its ability level and has something to show for its efforts. Having something of value at the end of the project is never a failure.

In no circumstances should you let the team believe the project is going to be a failure. If you truly believe this is the case you will need to walk away before the start. There is nothing more dispiriting than to be working on a task with no hope of success. Try to define some success criteria for you and your team so that you all can feel proud of what you do accomplish, even if upper management does not initially buy into it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.