Discussion Locked

Did you hear about the guy who threw a shoe at President Bush?

0 helpful
52 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Really? He threw a shoe at the President? What a heel.

The shoe flew through the air on its wing-tip.

I wonder if it was the guy's sole decision to throw the shoe.

Maybe size DOES matter - a size 13 would have nailed President Bush.

I trust the guy got the boot from the press conference.

He was probably nothing but a loafer.

Maybe the guy was mad because of a presidential flip-flop.

I wonder if the guy sneakered in there?

Or maybe he was able to slipper by security?

Could the thrower be charged with assault with a deadly shoe?

These boots are made for throwing, and that's just what he did........

I guess he thought, If the shoe fits, throw it.

52 replies

by michael jay

that Mr Zaidi, tried to sock Mr. Bush with a shoe. To Bush's credit, I would like to have Bush on my team in a dodge ball game.

by tig2

I have to say that I was impressed by how both President Bush and the Iraqi President handled that situation. I was equally impressed by the journalists around the shoe thrower- they reacted quickly and got the guy to the ground before the Secret Service got there.

Throwing a shoe in that culture is a strong sign of disrespect. Mr. Bush simply observed that the shoes appeared to be a size 10.

The journalist should have considered that it would be the Iraqi police who would take him into custody, not the American. We have due process. They still have firing squads and little patience. And the journalist seriously disrespected both the American and the Iraqi. Will we ever know what happens next?

by jamesrl

Bush did exactly right. Instead of being indignant and offended (which I'm sure is what the thrower wanted), he was casual about it - the clip I saw had him saying it wasn't any different than a heckler. He also signalled the secret service to stand down.

In short, he used the marshmellow defense - soft and inoffensive. If you take offense at the insult, you give meaning to the insulter. He basically said to the world, this guy means nothing.

James

by tig2

A great defense in the face of something like that and exactly the right tone. But one not everyone can do as effectively.

The timing is interesting. Weren't they announcing the timeline to pull American troops out of Iraq? I can only assume that the guy doesn't want us to go but that was sure an odd way to say, "Please don't go!"

by maxwell edison

[i]The Brahmana Samyutta in the Samyutta Nikaya tells the story of an angry man who insulted the Buddha. The Buddha simply asked the man if people ever visited him in his home. Surprised at the change of topic, the man answered yes. The Buddha then asked if he ever offered to feed his guests. When the man replied yes again, the Buddha asked what would happen if they refused to accept the food? Who would the food belong to then? The man said that, of course, it would still belong to him. The Buddha then calmly and, I imagine, kindly said, "In the same way, I do not accept your insults. They remain with you."

by jamesrl

The translated text of what he said was something to the effect of "this is the goodbye kiss from the people of Iraq, you dog." On the second throw it was something to the effect of "this is for all the widows and orphans killed by your war". I'm sure the exact text is out there.

Truth is the guy knew it was the last chance to taunt Bush, and there were lots of cameras around. I'm sure he was hoping to get a reaction out of Bush that would make him look bad in front of Iraqi TV.

James

by dadspad

taking a shoe for the president? Should have been two agents flying sideways through the air, one for each shoe. The President had to duck. :D

by jck

if you watch the video, they come out of the door behind him and on the right.

Evidently, the Iraqi security people didn't grab the guy immediately. It almost looked like a reporter or something did from behind, then Iraqi security did.

And, it looked like the US Secret Service was kept in the back. I saw ( I think) 4 or 5 come out 5 seconds after the first shoe was thrown.

Scary though...they actually trusted Iraqi security to handle everything in front of the cameras.

by jellimonsta

see how quick Obama wants to withdraw US security/ armed forces from Iraq when it's his head with a target on it. :p ;\

by jamesrl

Questions for the Secret Service:

1. Shouldn't you have jumped in front of that shoe?
2. Shouldn't you have jumped in front of that second shoe?
(Second shoe = the one thrown after being removed from foot after first shoe was thrown)
3. Let's say people had three feet. Would you have allowed a third shoe to fly unimpeded?
4. While the shoe was in the air, were you like, "Oh, its just a shoe."
5. Same question about the second shoe.
6. Do you think this is funny, "Throw a shoe at me once, shame on--you. Throw a shoe--you throw a shoe, you can't throw a shoe again."
7. Is there not "protection training" for lunatics launching objects?
8. If not, do they tell you that if someone does throw (or shoot) something to be on the alert in case they want to repeat this behavior?
9. Where were you?

by oz_media

But there was dirty work afoot and I was tied up.

Max, that's frickin' awful but I still laughed out loud.

by tonythetiger

why it took the secret service so long to get out there, and why the camera didn't show if they had their shoes on :) :)

by jamesrl

Bush, when he was in Baghdad signed and angreement that had forces totally withdrawn by the "end of 2011".

Thats 3 years away, but these things take time logistically. Look how long it took the British to leave Basra once they committed to it.

Frankly, even if he wanted to pull the troops out sooner, it might not be possible to do it much sooner, if its done in an orderly, phased manner.

BTW, in Canada, our conservative PM committed to pull out of Afghanistan by 2011, at least out of the combat role. Training and reconstruction roles (and the security for them) would likely continue after that.

James

by jck

We can't pull out. Bush's people signed an agreement to go pull out over 3 years. I'm sure part of the agreement is training and (probably to-be-botched) construction deals.

Obama's hands are tied now, because Bush's administration negotiated a deal.

by jamesrl

Sure JCK, training and construction will continue past the three years, thats generally how these things work (see Yugoslavia, and even Vietnam).

Obama's hands aren't tied by what Bush has signed, he can do he chooses, when he is president. But tearing up agreements isn't seen as a good thing to do in general, so he would have to have a valid reason to do so, from a political perspective.

Any withdrawl, now or 3 years from now, needs to be co-ordinated with the Iraqi government if they want to avoid chaos. So figure 3 months to plan it, and it can't be all in one go. It might take 6 months to move all the troops out without straining the logistics of the air transport. Its not so much the people as the vehicles and materiel.

James

by t mike

at least I'm cracking up, don't stop now...
uhhh, can we vote for the best ?

by jdclyde

you are suppose to vote for the WORST... ;\

They always get the most groans.... :D

by jdclyde

Is jck trying to setup an ready-made excuse for why Obama will not stick to his campaign promises, and continue to try to find a way to blame everything on Bush.

Somehow, someway, it HAS to be Bush's fault, right?

I would bet we don't hear Democrats screaming about the "Illegal and immoral war" anymore.

by xnavydk

when the shoe is on the other foot.

No we won't he threw them both.

he will never know what its like now.

by bfilmfan

It was the "agony of defeat."

I was thinking of the scene from Austin Powers where the guy whacks him with the shoe and he says, "Ow! That really hurt. Who the hell throws a shoe?"

by oz_media

I pointed it out to a friend and said "Who the hell throws a shoe?" a la Mike Meyers, it's the little lines he has that really makes the movies he's in, not the big setups.

by jck

What we see is what I stated, jd; The Bush Administration signed an agreement with the Iraqi government that will commit the United States to a timeline of 3 years to pull out. It is FACT, not partisan speel. So, stop with your fanatical spin and attempts at trying to stir things.

It really is simple: it is a political catch-22 that the Bush administration has set for Obama to take ownership of in January.

If Obama's administration does not choose to stay in Iraq the 3 years that Bush has committed the United States to being there and the Iraqi government does not agree to an early exit, the United States is then seen as liars and untrustworthy by governments and will probably be spun by the radical elements in the Middle East as an even bigger "devil".

If Obama's administration does stay the 3 years, then sensationalist right-wingers like you will start with the "What happened to 16 months? See, he's a liar."

So, it's really a no-win now. The Obama administration was not given the choice to set their own terms with the Iraqis. Bush's administration took the liberty to decide what Obama's administration would be committed to for about 35 months of their tenure.

Kind of ironic, since the Bush administration did not move quickly to set this timeline until the end of his tenure as President. Don't you think?

And JamesRL, you're right. Obama could very well go "We're leaving early.", but that would (without Iraqi government agreement) cause even more political and social angst than what has been bred in that region by the Bush administration's operation of things in Iraq. Do you not agree that this wouldn't be a prudent move?

Needless to say, it's not going to make anything any easier for Obama's administration. But, that's pretty much what I would expect from any politicians.

by oz_media

The only shoe I'd throw at Bush would need you to pull the pin first.

It would make an interesting spin on the Whack-a-mole game at carnivals though. You have a big, heavy shoe chained to the machine and have to whack Bush as his head pops up, you could also add other cabinet members to really get your fill.

by Member 19291532

After that string of puns, now I understand why this is such a vile insult in the mideast.

I'm struck by how EXCITED the entire Middle East is that a dude threw his SHOE at the President of the U.S.

At the very least, it illustrates the vast cultural difference between the Middle East and the West.

"He threw a SHOE at him?"

"Yes! A shoe!"

"A... shoe?!?"

"Uh huh! Uh huh! Allah Ahkbar, a filthy, dirty, smelly SHOE!"

"Hmnn... and then, he got beat up by security?"

"Yes, yes, by the puppet regime bodyguards of the infidel occupiers. It was a shame".

"Maybe if he was wearing shoes, he would have been able to outrun them"...

"What? Wait... whose side are you on?!?"

They bring down the Twin Trade Towers, and they mob the streets dancing, they throw a shoe at President Bush, twice, and miss both times, and they mob the streets dancing...

I've got a great diversionary plan to keep the U.S. safe from terrorist attacks on domestic targets! We'll just put various U.S. dignitaries in a dunk tank, and let them throw their shoes at the target.

easily amused....

by jdclyde

is to see the treatment the dog would have gotten if that was still Saddam ruling the country. He would never have been heard from again, something the mindless rabble hasn't considered.

by jamesrl

To say that, and at the same time say that the US came to overthrow an evil dictator and bring democracy.

Saddam has been gone for 5 years now. The US intention was to bring a western style democracy.

James

by jdclyde

he is still alive. Because it is a "western style democracy" where people can protest and speak out without being tortured and/or killed.

Mind you, attempted assault on a foreign leader goes well beyond a simple speaking out.

Nothing disingenuous about it.

jd

This discussion is closed to new replies.