Discussion Locked

Discussion: And, so the worm turns!

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

August has seen a rash of worm and viral Internet attacks. While Windows was the targeted operating system, the impact was felt in various ways throughout the entire network, from the largest conglomerate corporation to the smallest household computer.

Are attacks of this nature inevitable in this era of interconnected networks? Microsoft offers patches but they too often don't get applied ? do you as a developer believe that patching operating systems for security reasons should be mandatory because insecure nodes on the network are damaging to us all? Or does that solution create more problems then it solves?

Let's hear what you, the people who write the software that must deal with security vulnerabilities, think about worms, viruses, and Internet security and what can be done to make our interconnected lives better.

18 replies

by misceng

Having been forced to use Win XP (supplied with PC)I have kept it updated with the critical and recommended patches. Twice I have had problems with the PC immediately after an update. In the first case I found, by chance on the web, information that the update itself was faulty. A restore cured the problem and Microsoft later issued a corrected update. The second time the PC froze and I had difficulty keeping it running long enough to effect a restore.
Less experienced users would have been unable to recover so relying on Microsoft updating could be regarded as creating an unneeded danger. In such circumstances legally forcing updating seems unwise.

by ramon_rovira

Would any of us buy a car whose engine can be accessed and modified by anyone, even by bad guys? Not many of us would buy such car, but we buy computers that have exactly this same problem! And manufacturers of computers and operating systems don't do much to stop it. Probably it has to do with a marketplace, including users, that is not mature enough.

by ryaninbeirut

The sad fact of the matter is that we vote with our money and we as consumers keep voting for Microsoft. Either consumers, both business and private, will have the courage to say to hell with the madness and support other initiatives such as Linux, therein accepting some level of inconvenience while these alternative mature, or we will be left to continue to repeat the present, non less inconvenient episodes with the garbage from Microsoft. In this repsect I can't help but congratulate the city of Munich, Germany which has decided to make a radical change and purchase SuSE Linux, even with a Microsoft counter offer which was hard to pass up.

by frank.nimphius

You can make it harder for people to break into a system, but you cannot prevent it. Security is an ongoing process of measures and counter measures and there is no end in sight. If a hacker cannot come in through your hardwar, then he will come through one of your applications.

by mgte69

I read recently that Malaysia forced Microsoft to lower their prices (at least in Malaysia) by starting a program that promoted Linux. Money seems to be the only language Bill Gates understands. Unless users (especially big corporations and governments) threaten to shift unless Microsoft improves security, I doubt if they will do a good job.
Some time back MS Office incorporated a feature that warned users if a document had macros. Last week it was discovered that this safety check could be bypassed by a document. MS can't even properly check Office documents.

by mgte69

One thing that I very strongly disagree with is Microsoft's obsession with "ease of use" without a thought to security.
When asked why Windows seems more susceptible to attacks, MS claims it's because their OS is more widely used. I submit that virus writers target MS because they can spread their viruses faster and wider through MS products.
Melissa and ILoveYou spread incredibly fast because the viruses accessed the Outlook contact list and sent themselves to other users.
Granting that no user can be totally immune from virus infection, their systems should not be usable as additional launching pads.
I believe that a good OS can catch a program trying to access areas outside its program space and should ask the user if he wants to authorize this unusual action.
If Windows cannot do this, then I submit that MS is selling a product that is not suited for the enviroment is is being promoted for.

by donald

I can assure one and all if the Apple OS or Linux was positioned in the marketplace as MS Windows presently is -- and that if there was a Unix-oriented Bill Gates-type commanding, hackers would have long ago taken aim and shot holes through those systems.

It is my feeling that what we have happening today is not so much a case of Windows being an inferior system -- therefore prone to attacks -- but more of a two-fold situation: Bill Gates is not a well-loved man, and because of the viceral loathing many have for him, it is the 'duty' of malicious hackers to cripple and attempt to destroy what Mr. Gates loves most, Microsoft.

Any operating system can be attacked, infiltrated and destroyed if it is the center of attention for the world's hackers. If an arrogant claim has been made that a certain OS is the best there is and non-corruptible, then, automatically, invitations have been issued to all hackers to have a go at it -- let the games begin!

Keep in mind that whatever operating system exists, there are those people whose calling it is to try and destroy it, and/or use it to their nefarious advantage.

by nlynch_97

These are interesting times.

Microsoft's operating systems are seen by many as bloated and porus which leaves many opportunities for breaches. It is also an ideal target.

If it were not for Symantec and McAfee and similar efforts, Linux and other alternatives would be far more popular with the less technically ("normal users") inclined.

Microsoft's efforts to close the holes is reasonable but limited. Marketed to the "masses", the "masses" have neither the experiencce or bandwidth to keep their machine "current" or to restore functionality. Microsofts effort is late, but welcome.

For all-to-many, the Windows updates are simply too-little-too-late. A botched update is simply catastrophic for most "users". An infected machine is slow or unstable for most users. There is a widespread frustration world-wide because their systems do not work "right".

The "Web" is still a collection of evolving innovations and standards. In the efforts to achieve functionality and market, there will continue to be the opportunities for worms and viruses.

Does "IM" really mean "Instant Mayhem?" With ActiveX, DLL's, and easily hacked address books, quite possibly. With functional constraints, XML messaging, and a "standard" API that is not compromised by individual parties, it can "IM" be stable and safe. (keep "IM" in a sandbox)

Actually, right now is the ideal time to introduce low cost the Internet-ready workstations that were suggested a few years ago. If developed on a tight OS with secure applications, it would give the masses a real break from "fear, uncertainty, and doubt marketing", worms, and viruses.

Can we look to Embedded Linux, XML, and Java? Perhaps if the Linux system provider had better control over the hardware and made it simplier for the "local expert" to update, with external access for adding memory, we'd have fewer "customization" kills and compatibility problems. The drawback to Linux, of course, is a dead Linux system is very dead for "normal" computer users. (most "local experts" are best kept local)

An updatable "get-out-of-jail" PCMCIA "WebStation" program card, would make recovery much easier for most users. Knowing they have some resilience, users will be more comfortable with alternatives.

"Recovery Sequence of Operations"
1) Power on Machine (booting does not matter)
2) Insert Card which exposes a "Doit" button
3) Press the "Doit" button
4) Watch the Dancing Duke, Penguin, or whatever logo we put in the firmware.

Contrary to Microsoft propoganda, Java is secure by design. Most users do not know what Java is (except what Microsoft tells them), but will respond to slow load times. If loading classes by name is adopted for "extensions", then Java is vulnerable to attacks as well. (addressible)

Most users do not know what XML is (except what Microsoft tells them), but will respond to slow I/O times and bloated memory requirements. However, adopting XML for data will address the countless remaining buffer overrun breach opportunities in Windows and its programs.

The protection we have from the mayhem the current hackers provide mostly comes from the third party virus protection package we buy. These packages can not make the underlying operating system any better suited for widespread use. Nor, can these packages fix all infections or deficiencies.

This is where we are.

"Gentlemen, we are looking at a great opportunity."

by Mark W. Kaelin

This article suggests that the most recently discovered vulnerability in the Windows OS could be exploited by a new worm any day. Have you patched?

http://news.com.com/2100-1002_3-5074415.html?tag=cd_mh

(Note the line break)

This latest revelation goes back to the original question ? are such attacks inevitable? I hate to think that 20 years from now we will still be dealing with operating system holes, worms, and viruses. There must be a way to overcome these problems.

by nige13

As much as I am not a fan of Microsoft, there is, sadly, no way they can pre-empt future attacks. A large part of their OS's instability is due to their apparent need to corner too many markets. Windows is a jack of all trades but master of none.

On the plus side, stability and usability of Windows has improved over recent years and, although is still far from perfect, is still no less perfect overall than alternatives such as Linux or MacOS. What Windows lacks in robustness, Linux lacks in application consistency.

There will always be those with the cracker mentallity who spend their time trying to get the better of established systems, but are they doing us a favour? With each bug or hole found in a system comes a fix and a better understanding of how to improve the product. We are all still learning how to optimise an industry which is still in its infancy.

Basically, the Microsoft way is far from perfect but, for now, there is no perfect solution.

by esbi42

The industry may be young, by fault tolerance, risk analysis, and testing are not. It is a shame that such a new technology hasn't learned to apply the older technologies.

A batting average of 300 is great in baseball. But how good is (and will the consuming public accept) a 300 average in safely completed airline flights, or in correctly completed transactions in your checking or investment account? How about a medical procedure with a 70% mortality rate?

One possible solution would be to increase spending for testing BEFORE the product is released. Software companies (like Microsoft), when faced with this decision, cry that getting to market before one's competitors is more important than holding a release for testing.

I've been in this industry long enough to realize that the better purchasing decision is to wait for the more reliable product -- let the prestige (firstest, fastest and mostest) buyers do the debugging for the software companies.

I also have learned that having software that works is more important than having the latest version of that software.

It is a matter of economics. Reliable and bugfree software reduces worker downtime. Spending the necessary resources to guard against viruses and worms is cheap insurance against the possibility of catastrophic loss.

Has anyone done a cost/benefit analysis?

by ntcse

Maybe the perspective should be changed. While ongoing efforts to stop worms at the gate are worthy, we should limit what they can do when they get past the defences.

Why not give the owner of the computer the option to lock down certain files? If a program tries to delete or alter a file from the "locked" set, a popup appears telling the user what is going on and asking him if he gives the program permission to alter these files. When administrators need to make an update, they can "unlock" the file set by providing a username and password. While locked, these files will be read-only.

I disagree that it isn't the vendor's fault. After all, we can't change the operating system's inherent security, nor do we have time to do it. We have to pick a product and hope our choice was a wise one.

by jean-louis

The argument that Windows is a prime target mostly because it is by far the most widely used OS doesn't hold.

Windows has a quasi-monopoly on the desktop, but its market share of web servers is roughly equivalent to Linux.

Now malware targetting servers instead of clients always target Windows+IIS platforms. The reason for this cannot be simply that Windows is more widespread, so there must be some other reason.

Another argument that's frequently heard is that if users applied patches and implemented just a few basic security measures their Windows would be much, much more secure.

While this is generally true, it obscures a number of issues:

- updating the very day a new SP is available is definetely not a good idea as a number of initial patch releases have been known to be extremely buggy. While it may not be that big a problem if you work in IT, It certainly may discourage average home users from updating if doing it sometimes results in their computer not working as well as before.

- XP does nothing to discourage you from using root as your day to day working account.
Linux distros such as Red Hat or Mandrake force you to create at least one user account during the install process, and you get a ton of warning messages telling you to use root only when it is absolutely necessary, and to please diconnect from the internet if possible while you're doing it.

When you log in as root in Mandrake with a desktop you get a default red wallpaper that effectively conveys the message of potential danger.

XP gives no such warning , at least none that I have noticed yet.

Given the staggering amount of man-hours MS devotes to user-friendliness in Windows, this neglect of providing any noticeable warning against surfing while logged in as root is almost criminal.

The same is true for many of the security-related default settings.

by ianaaa1

We know eough about languages to design them to prevent most of the vulnerabilties we are experiencing.
Strong typing including of Abstract Data Types; run-time validation of passed parameters; pre- and post-assertion - should block most errors which lead to vulnerabilties.
As will better readability of the source code, better editors and build programs will block other errors.
Finally - what ever happened to QA/Code Inspection/Pair Programming?
Our commitment to old langauges - C: written in a hurry; C++: a hack; C#: a bit of a clean up. But we know better than this stuff.
Good programmers can move to another language in 10 days - make the change!

by john.thingstad

There are two classes of breakin's that predominate. Buffer overflow exploits and faulty setup. The first is much due to C's lack of buffer checking and periates all libraries that are written in C alts. I.e it is not enought that you write safe code if you can't trust your libraries. Unfortunately this goes for other languages that use C libraies altso. This is a factor most implementors forget. The japanese have a slogan "Do it right the first time". This brings me to the second category. To many peaple leave PHP passwords in files use excessivly elevated privilages and so on. Security and setup should not be added as a afterthough. Teach your employee's security issues up fron. Have a expert set up you linux server (You are not one of the .... that use microsoft servers?) securly. Disable all services and remove all functions you will not use. Use a dedicated ethernet connection for communication of if this is not possible SSH. Most will benefit from having a consultant who spesialises in that OS set up the sytem. They cost an arm and a leg but they are probably worth it if you networt teem lacks experience in setting up a system.

by dcox

You state that there has been a "rash of worm and viral internet attacks". The fact is that such attacks have been going on for quite some time. The only difference is that things are now impacting not just home users, but businesses of all sizes.

Most of the worm and viral outbreaks or "attacks" can be easily avoided by a few simple steps.

1. Implement stringent security policies that include the use of antivirus and anti-SPAM products.

2. Educate your users to the risks of electronic attacks, including virii, worms, hacks and the methods of deployment/exploitation.

3. Keep all systems up to date on all patches.

4. Implement a firewall technology that is independent of all workstations/servers - in other words, a real firewall.

5. Home users - Buy antivirus software and make certain it automatically updates itself every day (if possible, otherwise at least once per week). Also, routinely check to make certain the updates are happening.

6. If possible, configure the antivirus software to automatically delete the following attachment types (* is a "wildcard" portion of the name):
*.pif
*.vbs
*.prl
*.pl
*.com
*.scr
*.inf

7. Always use passwords that have both letters and numbers. For example, use pepperc0rn instead of peppercorn. Never allow accounts to use passwords that are blank (), repeated characters like ?11111? or ?aaaaa?, or easily guessed like ?abcdefg?.

Follow these steps and you should see a marked reduction in virii and worm related issues.

I strongly suggest using hardware firewall solutions in place of ?personal firewall? products. Remember, if you open a file that is an executable containing a Trojan and virus, it may be able to defeat your ?personal firewall? product. If you have need of a dial up account, then the addition of a ?personal firewall? is advised in lieu of a hardware firewall solution. Two that I suggest trying are ?HackerSmacker? (I believe by FarStone), and ?Portslock? (http://www.ntutility.com).

Regards,

Danny Cox
tips@tenbaset.com

by dcox

In theory you are correct.

The sad truth is that people in general (key words - IN GENERAL) are lazy. They want everything to work with little or no effort. They do not want to learn new things or have to think about what they need to do.

Most home users have little patience for what is involved in keeping a system maintained. Imaging the difficulty and pain they would experience having to learn a whole new "look and feel" on a computer. Sure, you can make it look somewhat similar, and it may even have many of the capabilities of the "other system". But, it is not identical!

People abhor change.

Trying to convince generations of computer (and techno) illiterates that Linux is as good or better than MS-Windows is like trying to make a newborn use a toilet - impossible.

As society becomes more technologically literate, such changes will slowly take place. Until then, consistency is the key!

Danny

by ge.goodman

Ok, and the users they sell to should educate themselves a bit; but see "laziness" above..

Most ISP's selling broadband in the UK don't even mention the absolute necessity of a good firewall/antivirus combination when using an always-on connection, I mean how irresponsible is that ?

I've got many friends in my town with broadband, some of whom know nothing about PC's except how to surf the net and send mail. Needless to say, I've seen all kinds of havoc on their machines, viruses and trojans left unchecked and unnoticed, etc, etc..

I accept Windows is still not perfect, sadly I can't play Age of Mythology under Linux and nor can I do any proper (read non-command-line) .NET development on it either, so I go on using XP. Anyway, Linux can be hacked too - it's just not as prevalent as Windows.

The thing is I'm reasonably clued up, I have a fighting chance of keeping my PC defended against the scum who lead such sad lives they have nothing better to do than cause misery for others. But what chance does a newbie have when the major ISP's don't provide security info about something so basic as a firewall ?

This discussion is closed to new replies.