Discussion Locked

Do I need to look for a job?

0 helpful
51 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I used to work for a software company that wrote a proprietary financial and clinical suite. I recently took a job as a network admin at a management company. They have alot of pirated software loaded on their computers and have asked me to continue the trend. They don't want to hear anything about copyright violations. Do I need to look for a different job?

51 replies

by jlemmon

I went to work for a small company that had 1 licensed piece of software installed on 55 PC's. The first time I told management of the serious situation, they blew it off. Next I put down on paper the cost of legally licensed software compared to the cost of getting caught and paying the fines associated with it. These fines could have put our company under. That day I had to uninstall the software on 54 PC's. I have found that management needs to see $$$ in black and white, and a little re-education in business ethics. If this doesn't work, do you really want to work for a company that doesn't want or will not do the right thing?!

by clwclark

In order for me to have some numbers I to put on paper I need to know how much fines are. Were talking about 80 computers all with Office 97 PCA and Virus software. I have only seen about two licenses of each. There are even a few OS loaded without licenses. When I first brought this to their attention they said that they had licenses and that the former consultant was responsible. I contacted him and he informed me that they asked him to load the software and that they would pay for the licenses later. Can I be held accountable if this company is fined? I really like this job and hate to look for another especially with the economy like it is.

by packratt

You will be held accountable to some degree... whether it's the company claiming that you were responsible and heading after you to recoup some of their losses when fined or them just firing you as a scapegoat and then you will have some difficulty finding another position irregardless of the economy.

Mostly, you have to hold yourself accountable to yourself in the end. No matter what the other consequences would be IF caught.

Good luck.

by jda-cpa

I recently attended a seminiar put on by the Detroit Chapter of the Institute of Internal Auditors on Software Piracy. According to the presenter at this seminiar, the dollar amount has just been increased to $250,000 per unlicensed piece of software. The BSA (Business Software Alliance) website at www.bsa.org has further information on civil and criminal (yes criminal) penalties for using unlicensed software. If the company does not want to change after showing them the numbers, I would find another job and seriously consider turning them into the BSA.

by stevendkane

As long as you create and date a document to your superiors informing them of the licensing issue your free and clear. As an IT dude all you can do is strongly suggest.

by xpertdragon

License issues are serious business these days, and Microsoft especially is cracking down on companies that abuse licensing and copyright laws. I agree with Steve, in that you pretty much have to document that you are aware that a lot of licensed software is being stretched across the company with only a few accountable licenses.

Is Software licensing a part of your current job function? Are you responsible for getting quotes on Software packages from Microsoft retailers/distributors and other software companies?

If you are, you just may have to be very strict when it comes to purchasing future licensing. Get a proposal for your immediate supervisor, or whom ever you report to, and tell them it is going to cost such and such to obtain 10 licenses for all 10 machines the software is going to be installed on, and be firm, but fair about it. Expalin the benefits, and effective pricing in volume license purchases, and emphasis the legal severity of abusive practices.

I have the confidence you will get results, and respect for your efforts in cleaning this all up. I realize you can't go around cleaning up all illegal installs, though auditing packages could help you with this, and you will eventually replace a lot of pirated software with new upgrades or replacement software over time, or at least assure it is done that way.

Hang in there!

Paul M. Chavez

by isys

That's where you are caught. It doesn't make sense to document your employer's piracy because you are also making the case agianst yourself. See an attorney to verify it. As to sources for piracy consequences, see www.networkcomputing.com and search Techweb for software piracy. Plenty of scary stories about the BSA and their earlier incarnation as SPA. The article that chilled me the most was here:

http://www.nwfusion.com/news/2001/0219piracy.html

All it takes is one disgruntled current or ex- employee to drop a dime. And, worse, if you can get management to pony up the bucks to get legal, make sure you do it quietly. Some of these stories talk about how the company was getting legal (true or not) when they were caught. I understand your reservations with the bad economy and all. If in your shoes, I would keep my resume current and keep scanning the classifieds.

by fluxit

The way the software police work is that there is a group of lawyers that specialize in this area. Usually a someone becomes disgruntled and reports the company to this group known as the Software Police.

Once the lawyers assess the situation usually asking for some kind of proof, documentation or other credible information that the company is in violation, they send a threatening letter. In short, they offer to audit the company and settle out of court or they threaten to supeana the records and then go for disclosure after filing for court.

Also individual companies agressively pursue violations as well. Autodesk has been very active at this.

Your company is placing themselves at risk for a lawsuit and not managing this well. In part, software companies have also been inconsistent in thier efforts as well in order to get market share. Especially Microsoft who has a policy of allowing software to be installed at home and at work on the same license.

I once had a issue where a vendor was selling software with a $200 markup. I purchased a trail copy from another source and wrote a memo to file that it was a trail for 30 days. Then vendor came in and saw the copies installed on 30 machines and immediately reported us to the software police. They hit us with the saloon door swinging behind them and even had a vendor representive but had no leg to stand on. Since I had a sales contact at the company working with me on the trail.

In the end I bought 70 copies ofthe software and fired the vendor.

by fluxit

Do not quit. Do this
1. Document each software package and version in use.
2. Document each installation.
3. Validate the type of license. ie per seat, site, or concurrent users.
4. Go to accounting, locate the invoices, and document what is on file.
5. Assess in your best estimate what is really needed to support operations.
6. Write a memo to the company and cc to file your findings.

Do not worry about fines or penalties as these are dependent on the judge, state, and local laws or what is negotiated between the lawyers.

You have no personal liability unless you are an officer of the company. The worst case is you become a scapegoat and are let go. Your memo to file is adequate cover for you and you may find that what you thought was a violation really was not. The exposure of the company is minor and can then be managed.

by fluxit

As an employee you are not liable for the company's actions unless you are an officer. If you are found criminally guilty of something then the law will deal with you not the employer. This would be like violating a copyright and selling the companies software for your gain.

The employer could sue for civil damages but is highly unlikely because most people do not have deep pockets and no judge will leave anyone destitute and a burden on society. They prefer people be self-sufficient.

If you are an independent contractor hired to manage licensing then you could be liable and should have insurance to protect you.

The worst case is you may get fired as a token of them doing something but that does not happen alot too. A firestone mechanic did not put all the lug nuts on after changing a tire on a car. A leg panty hose model got into the car and drove off. The tire came off after she reached speed, spun around, and got hit by a truck destroying her legs. She sued, won, and the mechanic never got fired.

If you put a memo to file you will protect yourself and if you get fired - SUE! Most likely you will win. Alot of these companies are closely held and many business owners are clueless about this stuff. Most closely held business owners are interested in lining thier pockets and become blind to anything else. Most of them have no leadership or management experience.

by maxwell edison

Here is a quote from a reputable source on the subject:

"Finally, software piracy is illegal. Unlike retail theft, innocent bystanders are held accountable; IT professionals who manage a department where software is quietly pirated could find themselves on the wrong side of the law."

http://www.softwarespectrum.com/productservices/softwarepiracy.asp

If you'd like to bet a few (thousand) dollars, I'll be happy to find more sources stating that the Network Administrator (or similar positions) can indeed be held lawfully and legally responsible if they knowingly participate in software piracy.

Ask yourself this, Why would he/she not be responsible for breaking this law just because he/she is not an officer of the corporation? What if a legitimate import/export company was involved in smuggling drugs into the U.S? What if some network administrator was helping them do it? Would that administrator be handed a "get out of jail free card" when the company got busted? No way. He/She broke the law, plain and simple.

However, (unlike drug smuggling) with software piracy, I will admit that (in most cases) it would be very unlikely the administrator would be held responsible. But it is possible.

Maxwell

by fluxit

I said unless you commit a criminal act you are not liable. The point of being an officer is to be held accountable. The fact that you appoint someone to manage licensing does not dilute an officers responsibility to have a program in place and responsibly manage it.

The company can try to sue you for damages but they are accountable. If you fail they will probably fire you before they sue you.

by fluxit

I believe I remarked unless you commit a criminal act. Purpose of an officer is meant to be the one held accountable. He cannot delegate his responsibility. He can hire people to assist him and put in place programs to ensure that things are complied with. He can also leverage a civil suite against those he charged with maintaining the program but mostly he will just fire them.

by fluxit

Finally, software piracy is illegal... This is nothing more than a statement with no substance. What is it referencing?

FL law is vague. They discuss railroad, aircraft, communications, and maritime piracy. Under Florida law, 815.06 Offenses against computer users, applies to people not on employer computers.

Under vicarious liability of the US Copyright Act, an employer is liable for acts committed by its employees when those acts are within the scope of their employment duties. Othertheory of liability is the doctrine of contributory copyright infringement, whereby a party who does not do an infringing act but who aids or encourages it is liable for the infringement.

I cannot find where it is criminal for the employee working within the scope of his job. The employer is always liable and may in turn attempt to hold the employee acountable under civil law. It a long shot though.

Document wrong doing in a memo and put it to file to protect yourself.

by fluxit

You have seen it and I said that it would be a long shot. The company had to show gross negligence or intent on the employees part. That is difficult. I would be curious to see this case? Please forward the state and case number.

Black listing a person? Is this McCarthyism in Technology? The only outcome legal is that the judgement is reported to the credit reporting agencies. Even at that many employers would not even consider it. Heck I had an employer hire a guy with 2 felony counts of brandishing a fire arm and a bankruptcy because they did not want to pay anyone and they were even the type to sue. Another company had employees stealing money from them in the $10's of $1000's. They just fired them with no law suit criminal or civil.

by maxwell edison

A company is no better than the people running it. (Can you say Enron?)

If the company is doing dishonest things, then the people running the company are really the dishonest ones. A person is either honest by nature or not. If someone will cheat a software vendor (i.e. the people running the software company), they've shown that they're capable of cheating anyone - including you and me. In addition, look at the software piracy laws. If a Network Administrator knowingly participates in software piracy, he/she could be held equally culpable.

I might suggest you put together a presentation for the company management showing all the implications and ramifications of software piracy. Not only are they running a huge financial risk, butalso the reputation of the company is at stake. The potential fine for illegally copying software is $100,000 AND 10 years in jail for EACH instance. Are they willing to put the company (and your future, by the way) in that kind of risk? Would they like to see a headline in the local newspaper that read, "ACME Management Company Settles for 1 Million Dollars in Software Piracy Scheme"? Would they like their customers to know that?

Do your presentation in nonjudgmental and professional manner. Show that your intentions are to look out for the company's best interest. Invite all the "major players". Cover all the bases. Use power point presentations, slides, handouts, whatever necessary to cover all the bases. Educate yourself thoroughly. Make some suggestions for viable solutions.

If I were in your shoes, and if they still refuse to comply, I'd respectfully resign.

Maxwell

by ferocious

How many people went through that place before you because of those practices? Disgruntled employees can contact the business software alliance at www.bsa.org and shut them down. You are an accessory after the fact if they get audited, since you knew about it. If they can't shape up, you better ship out!

by maxwell edison

This organization consists of LAWYERS, LAWYERS, LAWYERS and more LAWYERS. They represent many software companies, but they get NO MONEY from those software companies. Where do you think they get it? They get their money from the settlements made by violating companies – companies like ACME Management. The software company, in turn, gets their money from the subsequent purchase of the necessary licenses - at FULL RETAIL PRICE.

Last year the BSA embarked on an extensive advertising campaign in my area. For about six weeks there were radio spots day and night on all the major radio stations inviting disgruntled current or former employees to turn in companies for software piracy.

Stay tuned for their next advertising campaign coming to a theatre near you.

Maxwell

by maxwell edison

http://www.isaca.org/prsofte.htm

"IS managers who fail to protect against software piracy have been held accountable by the SPA and are legally liable for damages, even if they were unaware of the acts of piracy."

"and are legally liable fordamages"
"and are legally liable for damages"
"and are legally liable for damages"
"and are legally liable for damages"
"and are legally liable for damages"

"Many business managers are unaware of the severe civil and criminal penalties that can be imposed on their organizations if employees are found to be illegally copying software or using software that was illegally copied elsewhere," said Patrick Stachtchenko, CISA, CA, international president of ISACA and partner, Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu, Paris, France. "Their organizations could potentially be liable for significant monetary fines or jail time for convicted employees."

"monetary fines or jail time for convicted employees."

"monetary fines or jail time for convicted employees."

"monetary fines or jail time for convicted employees."

"monetary fines or jail time for convicted employees."

"monetary fines or jail time for convicted employees."

Maxwell

by maxwell edison

http://www.mcdonald.com/articles/swp.htm

(REMOVE SPACES from the pasted URL.)

"In late 1992, Congress passed an amendment to Title 18, United States Code, instituting criminal penalties for copyright infringement of software."

"A civil action may be instituted for injunction, actual damages (including infringer's profits), or statutory damages up to $100,000 per infringement. Criminal penalties for copyright infringement include fines up to $250,000 and jail terms up to five years, or both."

"The United States Government has been an active participant in protecting the rights of copyright owners. When the Business Software Alliance (BSA) conducts a raid, Federal Marshals or local law enforcement officers also participate. Federal Judges have shown their intolerance of copyright violators by handing down increasingly large damage awards against infringers."

Maxwell

by maxwell edison

"...actual damages (including infringer's profits)..."

Do you realize what this means?

If a company earns 10 million dollars from using pirated software, the civil damages "could" include that $10,000,000.00

Another bottom line: The potential risk is simply not worth it.

Maxwell

by mlayton

If you are talking about Microsoft software and hold Microsoft certifications, and the fines (or discovery) is brought about by Microsoft or an alliance that includes them, it is entirely possible for them to revoke your certifications. This is true of some other software companies too, but you have to review the paperwork and agreements around your certs to see if they are affected.

by mrafrohead

Would you like them to steal from you???

If they will do this to other people and companies, what's to say that they won't do it to you...

Not to mention, if you go along with it, you're JUST as guilty...

There is no job in the world worth compromising your values or beliefs.

Think of it like this, if you and your friend go out, and your friend decides to rob a bank and you may not have helped, but were there and knew about it and left with him, you're JUST as guilty... The same thing applies here...

Sometimes, doing the right things in life are the hardest things to do, but they need to be done.

Just remember... What comes around goes around. If you do leave, things may be tough for a little while, but it will be repayed better in the long run;)

mrafrohead

by fluxit

You made a good point and I think people should be more prudent before making a decision to leave. They should conduct a reasonable fact finding endeavor. I would hate to see someone leave because of an emotional belief the piracy is ongoing only tofind out that a site license applies.

by zlitocook

It used to be vary easy to get away with using one copy on all computers. But here in ST.Louis there has been a commercial on tv and radio. That prompts unhappy employees to call an 800 number to report thier company. The company holds the IT personas the wrong doer and still has to pay the high fines. Just dont misuse software.

by fluxit

Those attorney ads are of the same genre as the smucks who bleed auto accident victims with neck braces and wheelchairs.

You know everyone IS held personally accountable for environmental crimes whether at work or at home. How people are in jail or suffered fines for pouring engine oil in a sewer? And many of you may be guilty of that. Do the police issue infractions for polluting? How many of you xeroxed a book from a friend and did not buy it? Are any of you in jail for that copyright violation? Is kinkos being sued?

by karthikeyan umapathy

Well them what will happen to whole company

if they listen good for you or else quit and find another one.

I won't be in company which doesn't have good business ethics, because i know that company is not going to survive

by fluxit

When you interview for the job you should be able to discern the ethics of the company.

by fluxit

Most states have the laws in plain language online. Federal Laws are called Code of Federal Regulations, CFRs. Online resources are not always current.

Most of the time the CFRs tell the States to establish laws regarding a topic. At times they actually set the law.

This issue comes under copyright infringements not piracy. Actual law may vary from state. Nonetheless, the overarching copyright law is consistent throughout every state.

CFR: http://www.access.gpo.gov/nara/cfr/
FL Law:http://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes
In general: http://www.findlaw.com/casecode/

I think there is a lot of garbage out there on this topic as service companies and attorneys want to make money so they use scare tactics and ambiguous language.Once again the best way for technology people to protect themselves from any potential legal issue is to document the concern in a memo then cc it to file.

To ensure notice is served send the memo via registed mail but this could be seen as threatening or hostile action. If your company has a document control system use it and serialize the memo or establish your own serial logs for your memos. This adds crediblility to the memo.

by fluxit

I think many of you need to really sit down either with an attorney or research on your own the actual laws then assess your exposure or risk.

I think most will find unless your state has some kind of off the wall law that your exposure is limited to any criminal acts you commit. You do not see the employees of Enron being held accountable for the actions of the company. Sure they are unemployed and the ones having stock are out of the money for now.

You always run the risk of having someone sue you under civil law but that does not mean they will win. By memorializing your concerns you can protect yourself. This is why large corporations are doing away with drawers and routinely come through with carts requiring you the throw everything out. It is those darn memos that kill them.

by fluxit

In the future, the industry itself will remedy this issue. Software retail sales will go away. You will not go to Compusa and buy a box with a authentic seal on it.

Software will become collateral to a service you purchase. The software will download to the local appliance via the internet. You may not even be involved in this and you may never even know that it happened.

In short, illegal copies will be virtually impossible. The bigger problem would be telecommunications piracy (cy-jackers) and hackers.

by mrafrohead

And that will be the day I unplug my machine. NEVER will I allow another company to store my information on their computers with my knowing of it.

Sounds a lot like the whole .NET joke...

Scary, scary stuff.

It'll be 2020 and I'll still beusing Windoze 2000 Service Pack 85...

by maxwell edison

There is a "bottom line" to which you should look for your ultimate guidance. Moreover, it doesn't matter if the issue at hand is software copyright infringement (a.k.a. software piracy), or whether or not the IT manager would (or could) be held accountable, or if it's the way the company treats the customers and/or employees, or whether or not "everybody's doing it", or if it's the way a company manufactures their widgets (by perhaps using sub-par materials), or whatever the case may be.

If the company behaves in a way that violates the values on which you base your life, you simply won't be happy. And only you can define your values; no one else can do it for you. And everyone's values are uniquely their own. If, for example, one ofyour life's values is true and total honesty, you simply won't be happy at a company or in a business that lies (or stretches the truth) to the customers. (This used car was ONLY driven to church on Sunday by a little old lady.) They may be wonderful people who really mean no harm, but if it's something you just don't feel comfortable with, or if it's something you wouldn't do yourself, ultimately you're setting yourself up for even more disappointment.

That would be the kind of job that would be the underlying cause for those unexplainable migraine headaches. You simply have to surround yourself with things and people that fall into line with your values. Anything less is cheating yourself. Anything less is settling for less. Don't settle for anything less than that which you expect of yourself.

(By the way, I wouldn't want to play golf with that guy. He probably uses the foot wedge, creative addition, and selective memory.)

Best of luck,

Maxwell

by fluxit

You are in control at all times. Its the choices you make that count.

I will make the point that every job is a risk. You need to weigh the circumstances and discern your direction. In the mean time, document what you believe is wrong doing.

by maxwell edison

"Your Honor, if it please the court. I suggest that I should not be held accountable for this crime for the simple reason that I documented the fact that I disagreed with my bosses' actions in committing this crime. I let them know, in no uncertain terms, that I objected to their actions, and that they were breaking the law, as I knew it to be. In addition, I made sure that my boss had a copy of that documentation, and I even requested that a copy be put in my employee file."

"Well, er, uh, yes sir, I did continue to participate in that illegal activity."

"Well, er, uh, yes sir, I did help them carry out this crime."

"Well, er, uh, yes sir, I did know it was wrong."

"Well, er, uh, yes sir, I did realize it was illegal."

"Well, er, uh, no sir, I did not report this observed illegal activity to the proper authorities."

"Bu...bu...bu....but but but...."

"Bu...bu...bu....but you honor, it is such a victimless crime."

----------

"Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, have you reached a verdict?"

----------

What was the crime in the above scenario?

It doesn't matter, does it?

Regardless of the crime, would you want to be the defendant?

This one is a “no brainer”

Maxwell

by fluxit

There is a bottom line in all this. Be proactive, identify the shortcomings, and notify the decision makers. After you pay your dues it is up to the Company / Officers who are accountable to make the right decisions not you. These people are the board of directors, CIO, COO, CFO, CEO, and controller most often. in other company charters it is the owner.

Memoralizing your findings and maintaining journals is what is called into evidence if you get into trouble. Your journal is yours and must be bound, no pages missing with every page numbered, multiple ink colors, entries must have dates and time in order to be admisable in court. Put only pertinent facts, events, and no opinions. Nothing that you do not want others to see.

Always smile never argue, even if you think they are wrong. I had a graduate class that taught us to fight for what we believed. They wanted to see heated debates and forceful delivery of ideas.
That will get you fired today. Everything has to be sugar coated and you often have to act like a dumb blonde in front of your boss in many ways. People today tend to hire only people dumber than themselves.

Unfortunately, in technology there is a high concentration of creative people with IQ's between 120and 160. Technology people tend to develop global pictures and see things about a business that others have difficulty seeing. This is threatening to a seat-of-the-pants COO who worked his way up from janitor or a CFO who has traditionally had exclusive power but now must share that with the CIO or even some techie who could effectively halt the company.

by packratt

You are saying that I was right but that you still say I'm wrong because you think employers (companies) will or can not sue you as an employee responsible for information technology when they are fined for software piracy?

Well.. I am right, they will at least fire you and black list you, at worst they will take you to court and will sue you to garnish whatever wages you may be able to get in the future and the judge will let that happen because the court doesn't care if you're poor so longas nobody else garnished 25% of your wages yet.

I've seen this happen before, don't be so naive.

by prefbid ii

Documentation may not be enough, but it needs to be part of the start. I was in a large company that was audited. There was enough employee turn-over that just about anyone could have "turned the company in". By the time the audit was finished, the company "owed" $250,000 to Microsoft because the company could not produce the licenses. However this descrepancy was reduced to almost zero when we did prove that "total dollars paid exceeded the calculated total of total dollars that should have been paid". To keep from going through the audit again, we started doing a lot better job of managing our license records. We actually found that we were buying too many licenses.

by packratt

Documenting license purchases is important and advised.

Yet these tow are discussing doubleohgod's proposal that you document that you told management about software piracy when there is no attempt to purchace licenses as a way to cover your buttwhile not doing anything else to correct the unethical and illegal activity that you are aware of, and as such, now complicit in.

There's a bit of a difference there.

by fluxit

IT often comes under the controller who makes purchase decisions. By writing the memo to file you are identifying the shortage of licenses and puting the company on notice. If they fail to act the weight is on them not you.

If you have purchase authority that is great go buy the licenses but most do not.

I worked for a company that gave me $15k signature authority but I could not just spend the money. I had to write appropriation request. Upon approval I would issue the purchase order and sign for up to $15k. I wanted to buy 90 licenses for WRQ terminal emulation software. But the controller would only let me buy 15 licenses a quarter. But the operational need was beyond that and I had to make a judgement call in order to sustain the operations and over installed by 5 licenses each month paying for the licenses at the end of the quarter rather than the beginning and then installing. I ensured that memos to file were written and it was clear to management of the exposure we had.

to-date I have maintained my memos in case anything comes back haunt me. In fact, I was an operations manager for aircraft maintenance facility at one time. I could go to jail any time in my life if one of those planes crash due to maintenance malpractice. The memo to file and journals are how you save your butt.

by packratt

You're trying to tell us what?

That just because what you are doing is unethical and illegal that you can keep on supporting that activity by not doing anything about it and ignoring it just because *you* don't *think* that you will be held responsible?

So, according to you it's ok to do unethical things or support unethical activity through inactivity just because there is a good chance that you won't be held accountable?

Thank you for affirming my distrust in humanity.

Anyways, let's just say that it was a friend of mine that was fired and then sued when her company was fined several 10's of thousands back when it was still the SPA. It was in Eugene OR back in the early 90's if you have time to look it up, I sure don't.

by packratt

I really should know better than to think that others could be picky about whom they work for when I cannot do that either. I did force this issue twice before and I suffered greatly for it twice. One was over licensing, payroll theft, and bill padding practices and the other time was over harsh treatment of immigrant workers. I ended up out of both jobs as a result and blacklisted to a degree and this was hard on my family for a quite a while.

So, when you have no choice, then file those CYAs and hope that will be enough if the hammer comes down.

This discussion is closed to new replies.