Do undegraduates with experience stand a chance to get hired?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by stuben1
by rknrlkid
the degrees you have make you more valuable in your environment.
The biggest complaint I hear is that the "IT pros" know LOTS about computers, but NOTHING about the industry. Knowing HOW the application fits in your particular industry is VITAL. As far as the employer is concerned where the rubber meets the road, how does that application/system you are promoting help him/her complete his/her mission?
This is where the horror stories come from about IT people without a clue. IT supports the industry, not the industry supports IT. The fundamental mistake of many in the computer field is that they consider themselves the front line, not the support. In order to support, you must know more than just your own technology, but the industry too. I have friends who specialize in systems administration for hospitals. They specialized themselves where they can meet the needs of the industry.
For the person who is truly learning, NOTHING is wasted. IMO a degree OUTSIDE of computers is more valuable than one ABOUT computers, because you will have a broader base to work from.
by desertwman
by comptech3
by bobmarquardt
by quest4
by ohsolost
by damfman
by jkstill
The assumption that a person with a degree will be a more rounded person is pure hogwash.
I have worked with a number of people with CompSci degrees, many people with or without any degrees, and people with or without any certifications.
It has been at times surprising to learn of the level of education of some individuals after working with them for awhile.
Some very bright people that I have worked with have had degrees. Also some people that were somewhat less luminent. I have also worked with some outstanding people that oddly enough, do not have a degree. As with the degreed, there are also some that don't shine too brightly.
None of the preceding pieces of paper offer any guarantee that the individual is more than marginally competent. And that statement may be generous.
A degree is valuable for getting you an interview.
After that, an individuals drive, intelligence, curiousity and ability to build relationships with coworkers are what makes an individual a valuable employee.
The last attribute mentioned is actually the most important.
by red_wolf9
Following that logic, you should go to a general physician for brain surgery, because a Brain Surgeon is to specialized and can't adapt to changes fast enough.
There was no "luck" in my getting hired. I have no college degree and no certifications, but my hiring manager wasn't so foolish enough to toss my resume in the trash (they like PROVEN track records). One interview and I was hired, guess even us "illiterates" can speak to managers in a professional way. Ever notice that it's the people that went to college that perpetuate the myth that only college grads are good enough to employ (only if you too wasted tons of money can you be as smart as me).
In closing while you were busy learning (book learning) and partying, I was busy doing (real world deadlines) so I could support my family. You know what the acronyms PhD and MCSE stand for don't you?
PhD = Piled higher and deeper
MCSE = Must consult someone experienced (don?t get me started I have tons more on this one)
by tony1865
Trying not to be too critical here. Your synopsis was filled with grammer and spelling errors. Hard to believe a college graduate would make these simple mistakes. I am certified in my field and continue to progress, my boss would never accept communication in the form that you submitted on this subject.
You state "So a person with a degree when hired has a broader view of everything hence can modify develop and think of other ways to solve the problem after he got to learn what the company is all about.i.e,what is expected of him."
Question, how could you have a broader view of everything when you haven't logged day one in a corporate IT environment? Are you going to draw on your vast classroom experience when the mail server craps out and you have hundreds of customers calling for immediate action? I don't think college is bad, it is a good way to start a career in IT, but it is not the only way. People with certifications have to work harder, learn to adapt to new and changing challenges, and also stay current with changing technologies. Most certified people do it because they love it and not just for the bucks. Most college people I have seen (not all) have a hard time with change, and believe that their way is the only right way. A little arrogance (or a lot) on occasion. After 5-10 years a college degree doesn't hold a candle to experience and continuing certifications.
by dew812
Better educated or better prepared?
It never ceases to amaze me how some folks place more value on an individual who has a college degree more so then an individual who does not have a degree but has relevant experience. You would think that an individual with a college degree would know how to use proper grammar and spelling. Yet, I see college graduates who fail in this area more often then they should. Maybe spell check doesn?t work on their word processor. Does it take a college degree to fix that problem? There in lies the quandary about college graduates. Maybe they just spent too much time partying, socializing and having fun instead of learning and applying what they?ve learned! Those skills are certainly necessary to take with you into the work place; however college is not necessarily the only place available to acquire those skills.
An individual who may not have had the opportunity to go off to school for 4 years may have learned another valuable attribute called responsibility developed through real world experiences. Imagine having to buckle down and deal with issues and circumstances that directly impact your personal life or the lives of the individuals that you care for. In this environment folks develop skills that are often not learned in school.
What is the real issue here? Hiring somebody who is better educated or hiring somebody who is better prepared to do the job?
That?s why you have interviews to go with the resume!
by len.rogers
by silari
Many, many self-made millionaires do not have degrees. Why? Being consistent with what a group of individuals believes you should know and think awards the degree. Self-made millionaires can think out of the box. Degreed individuals, think one way -- even with a broad knowledge base, innovation in thinking makes a difference.
So to wholesale say degrees make a difference is wrong. To say that individuals that know how to be successful will probably have a degree is correct. You can also argue the point that a degree has little to do with success. I have seen many people with degrees that have a difficultly deciding which way to roll out of bed.
So the bottom line is success is determined by the individual not on level of education or certifications (remember the saying good students learn in spite of the teacher). Continuing education and certifications would be an attribute of a successful person (read good employee).
by chug
As a followup to the original question in this discussion thread, for people with degrees, how about a Bachelor's degree vs. a Master's degree? Looking for feedback mostly from people who might do hiring or have been hired based on these critera.
Is a Master's degree really any more desired by employers compared to someone with a Bachelor's AND years of experience? Perhaps an MBA for management positions, but other than that?
by steve ingham
I have found in both the IT world and the Highway design and construction field that engineering competency is not related to reading/writing ability. Indeed, I have generally observed an inverse relationship. It is the rare individual that can write as well as design/build.
About 20 years ago, I read that large banks such as Morgan-Stanley preferred to hire Liberal Arts majors because they demonstrated better problem solving abilities. They could teach thinkers how to program, but they could not teach programmers how to think. Do they still prefer Liberal Arts majors?
by silari
Many, many self-made millionaires do not have degrees. Why? Being consistent with what a group of individuals believes you should know and think awards the degree. Self-made millionaires can think out of the box. Degreed individuals, think one way -- even with a broad knowledge base, innovation in thinking makes a difference.
So to wholesale say degrees make a difference is wrong. To say that individuals that know how to be successful will probably have a degree is correct. You can also argue the point that a degree has little to do with success. I have seen many people with degrees that have a difficultly deciding which way to roll out of bed.
So the bottom line is success is determined by the individual not on level of education or certifications (remember the saying good students learn in spite of the teacher). Continuing education and certifications would be an attribute of a successful person (read good employee).
by lhjr1947
by kktm123
by kelley_moore
During my twenty plus years of experience, I have tended to hire the person with the experience no matter what their educational background is.
If I am looking for an entry level person, I look at both their educational background and their past work experience. I based by decision on their work experience, educational background, and how they do in the interview with the questions asked. For example: will this person fit into the team and fit with the direction of the company.
by red_wolf9
I proved my skills to several consulting companies and let them drop resumes to HR managers. This requires even less action by the HR rep because they assume the candidate has been "vetted" by the consulting company. My experience allowed the consulting company to recommend me highly, because of my proven track record.
I also find that people (like me) how love learning everything about computers can learn too. In fact, I try and learn or figure out something new everyday. Many of the college grads I work with seem to think learning stopped when they graduated. Sure they have proven that they can be taught, but far too many think they already know everything. I don't have time to sit around and teach someone that can lean, I prefer to employ people that already know how to do.
If I'm looking for a manager (someone one that thinks up ideas, but isn't the techie that delivers them) then college grads are great. When it comes to "grunts on the ground", those guys better be experienced.
Since I have held every job from level one helldesk to project manager, I'm currently responsible for Internet connectivity for the entire USA (and Canada) for an International company. I think that makes me more "well rounded" then someone with a BS in IT (which is exactly that)! It?s my passion for computers that keeps me learning everyday and that is what makes me a better employee. I didn?t have to graduate from college (although I attended one) to obtain my passion. I sat down in front of an Apple II in 5th grade and haven?t stopped learning since.
by gsquared
Personally, in 28 years in IT, I've found that people with a degree in computer science generally can find the On button, but not much more, till they have some experience.
People with experience but no degree tend to either have very specialized skills that they are very good at and no skill at all in other areas, or have a wide degree of skills but no strengths.
There are college degree programs (was in one myself for a while) that include, in a 4-year period, as few as 2 or 3 classes on actual computer use and system set-up.
The drawback to the uneducated but highly experienced person is that many of them think they know a lot about subjects on which their data is all 3rd-hand rumors and "I have a friend who read an article about a guy who interviewed someone ...". They are experts on their field of strength, and they think the expertise covers related fields on which they really don't have enough data to make sound judgements.
But all things considered, I'd rather have an experienced IT person with no degree than a degreed IT person with no experience. I can give an experienced person jobs that take advantage of his expertise and avoid his areas of ignorance. The average college grad with a degree in computer science (or related degree), if it doesn't involve simple tasks like sending an e-mail or browsing the web, usually requires complete training on everything. No strengths to give work to.
Of course, the best is a person with both education and experience, who recognizes his own areas of inexperience and expertise and who is willing to take the time to teach himself new skills when they become necessary. Those, unfortunately, are almost as rare as honest lawyers.
If you want to be a Network Admin, or other tech job, job experience counts for more. But, consider the following:
1) Economic recession. When there are fewer jobs and more candidates, those with the degree AND experience have a higher chance of actually landing an interview. It won't be an either/or. And you never know when that will happen in your career. It happened to me. I'd missed every single layoff in my career until post 9/11 when my company folded. And nobody would even talk to me without a degree. And yes, I have a great resume. I am now back in school at 46.
2) Do you intend to become a technical manager? Any time you consider management as part of your long term goals, you really need to consider a degree. Before I lost my job, I was a Director in my company. I went much farther than most would without a degree, but would never have been considered for a VP position without it. If you want to be a manager, and want to be able to jump companies as a manager, many companies won't even talk to you based on you resume. You can ONLY make that kind of move, typically, without knowing somebody there to get you that first interview. A degree gets your resume high enough in an organization, without sponsorship, to be seriously considered as a candidate.
Bon chance!
by mlayton
If you have a chance to get the degree now, get it now. In addition to economic recession, remember that your own life situation can also change and maybe at 46 you will not have the opportunity to return to school, for financial, health or familial reasons.
The bottom line is that there are success stories in all camps, but few will deny that education opens more doors (gets your foot in the door to more places - gets the resume past more HR people - gets the extra money) than not having the degree. Sure, you can get through doors without a degree, but in the long run, if you have the opportunity to give yourself an edge, go ahead and take it.
I totally agree with you.
"You MUST look at the individual instead of being lazy and only looking at a piece of paper."
I was a welder for 19 years until a corporate buy out eliminated my job. I went to a local community college and loaded up on all the IT courses but never got back to finish my Associates.
I also agree with the person who posted about "luck" playing a role. I missed out on some jobs because I didn't have the sheepskin. I am in a job now that I love.
You need to find a person during the hiring process who is not afraid to tell you that they do not know how to do a specific task but is willing to do whatever it takes to learn. I was able to convey that during my interview and took an entry level job. I say communication skills and the "want" to learn is more important than the sheepskin.
Why was The Computer Guy from Saturday Night Live so funny? Because he was so (unfortunately) true to form.
by jdbooe
by blueknight
I'll take verifiable experience over education. Not that education isn't worth anything, it is, but if you have a couple of good candidates with about the same experience level, then education may be the tie breaker. Education alone isn't the deciding factor for me, I'd rather see good, rounded experience.
I spent the first 16 years of my career without any degree. Everything I knew, I learned on the job, but back then companies were willing and able to provide OJT. I eventually went back to school and got a dual AA degree in Computer Science and Business Management.
My experience is what has gotten me every job I have had. Although not in management these days, I am still asked to consult in the interview and hiring process. Education alone to me is like someone having only a CNE for example. Sure they're certified, but it doesn't show they can DO the work.
Get all the experience you can and cultivate good references for when you need them... and don't burn your bridges.
BTW... 8 years ago, I was hired into my current position at age 47. Age discrimination IS alive and well - unfortunately. In the end, it was my experience that got me the position, so keep at it.
by dean0
There was a study conducted which led to the Dreyfus Scale of Skills Acquisition. In essence it showed that the only thing that can take you from Novice, through Advanced Beginner, Competent, and Proficient to Expert, is experience.
My own experiences dealing with developers and other IT professionals seem to confirm those findings. Based on that, unless I am looking for a novice I will look for the candidate with experience.
BTW, there is a very good reason why medical doctors go through internships and residencies, and don't jump right into practice after all that education.
by chasster
HR has an excellent opportunity to violate many moral and legal issues by using the internet as a form of obtaining (requiring) certain information to be provided.
The webpage provides the ultimate filter, HR does not have to face the person, for any reason that they reject them nor provide any explanation or be held liable for biased operation.
The only filter not being used is race, well I can?t say that for sure that the internet forms are clear of that bias.
If you learn whom someone is you do so over time, not 7-seconds.
Ever try to get several HR people to agree on what a resume should look like, try doing it with a resume that spans several decades, international experience and many levels of responsibility. The information will flip-flop back and forth between one HR person to the next and each will claim that they know what they are doing and that the other HR person his their own style.
You?d think that if they were interested in anything other than collecting a fee that they would look beyond the 7-second time to understand what experience is available to pass on to a hiring manager.
HR in its current state does well to pass along a non-experienced person that has worked at one or two jobs all their life, after that HR is pretty useless in ?matching? experience with a hiring manager whom can utilize talent.
cheers,
cs
by nicknielsen
Nobody has the time to actually read 5k or more job applications for a position. HR uses the paper status to reduce the number of applications they must deal with. No degree? Gone! No certification? Gone!
So much for a good majority of applicants! It doesn't matter that the perfect fit for that job may have been in the discards. They only know that they now have a manageable stack of paper for the people who really know what the terms and expressions on the CV or resume mean.
by sublimedaze
Not every undergraduate has "only" a certificate. I have no certificates, no degree, but I do have over 20 years experience. I know more than some of the kids graduating today will ever know because everyone's worried about specialization. If I can step in, do the job and do it better than some kid who's still wet behind the ears, would you rather still hire him because he's got a pretty piece of paper that the ink is still drying on?
Yes, certifications have lost their appeal in the last several years because of the mass amount of MCSE's cranked out by cert mills. This is also why MCSE correlates to "Moron Confused (by) System Errors".
The question here is experience versus degree, not certification versus degree. There's a huge difference, and you'll find yourself very restricted by your opinion. Opening up to experience is sometimes a manager's best option.
by ebreder
by imit
by acp2g
Regarding experience versus education, a person should be hired based on their ability to perform the job needing filled, regardless of education or experience. Hence, all aspects of the job must be considered beforehand when posting the job.
If you need a person with technical abilities who will need to interact with management, then those are the qualities you look for, regardless of education or experience. I believe you get what you look for, therefore, be careful what job qualifications you post for a position you want to fill.
A thought to consider?.. Did you realize that the majority of replies to this discussion in favor of hiring persons with degrees over experience were unable to write their thoughts with directness and without misspelled words? Interesting.
by vawwkayaker
I totally agree that a degree does not = more value. In my generalize opinion, degrees are more about the displine of learning. Sure you capture knowledge, but really your purpose is to prepare you for the future, which is continuous learning. Certifications are more about acquiring and mastering specific skills and concepts. Both add value, although one has the potential for broader and long-term benefits, but don't fall into the misconception that a Certificate is a blue-collar trait. I have a non IT degree, IT related certificates, and IT work experience. I use/used each of these at different points in my carrer. Oh yeah . . I can talk and present to management as well, but I did not get that from a degree. I got it from my wife. (i.e. you don't get social skills from studying).
Mike
by leonard_aj
by -bw-
A perfect synopsis:
You are going on an airplane trip and you have two choices for a pilot, one pilot has never flown an airplane but has passed every book-given test and scored high on all the achieving indicator marks. The other pilot has never taken a class or read a book but instead has been flying airplanes for 20 years and thousands of logged hours.
Who would you select as your pilot?
Thus the logical answer would be the pilot with the actual experience, however it has been my findings that United or AA would be more interested in the ?book smart? pilot, as well I have seen this in the IT industry over the last 5 years or so. I have actually worked side-by-side with MCSE?s who couldn?t change a hard disk drive in a computer and have CNE?s drop networks like a bad habit, but hey, they are getting the jobs because they can simply read, retain and test ? not because they can and have done the work!
Illogical!
by robotech
Just had a recruiter call me who couldn't tell the difference between a phrase on my r?sum? indicating my work experience, and the company that I last worked for.
Pathetic, how do they evaluate people? In 2002, I saw a job posted on CareerBuilder.com that said, "Six Years Experience on Windows 2000 Active Directory", as well as degree etc.
Unless one is a time traveler, that would certainly not have been possible.
People get silly over degrees and certs, instead of considering someone's real world experience. When new technologies are introduced, they are taught to telecom/data employees in 5-day courses.
A university lecturer reads the white paper and then teaches it as if he invented it. I know, because in college I used to help some of my lecturers explain things that I already knew from real world experience.
Nevertheless, many recruiters continue to call for interviews people who have degrees and certs but no real ?in the trenches? experience, then the companies say that certifications are useless. That's not the problem; the problem is with the recruiters!
I've realized that when companies do their own interviewing/hiring instead of outsourcing to a recruiting company, they tend to put more emphasis on how quickly a future employee can be of immediate benefit to the company. With that in mind, they tend to focus more on experience and certs, rather than a degree (which is usually obsolete in IT by the time you graduate).
There are some people who say that the degree shows that one is disciplined enough to study, blaah, blah, blaah. But that only applies in the case of a kid who just left college.
I will hire anyone over 30 years old who has tons of experience, rather than a 22 year old with a college degree. The 22 year old knows how to study and retain, while having his expenses covered by Mom and Dad; but the 30 year old knows how to juggle a full time job, certs, family, bills, new technologies etc.
Who do you think will adapt more easily to a new job?
by tcube_0
by vawwkayaker
Imagine the world if Bill Gates had stayed at Harvard (or was it Yale) to get his degree. How much would he be worth? How much would YOU be worth?
I guess having and not having a degree really does make a difference . . . but which has more benefit ??!!
by jheath
by jheath
by k-jac
My $CDN 0.02,
Bottom Line: It Really Depends On The Person
My motivation comes from the challenges in presenting, selling and delivering on my knowledge and expertise in a degree-biased world. I have done so successfully for over 27 years. I love it even though the lure of a MBA in IT is strong at times.
In the pursuit of bona fide paper credentials; I find there is a lot of effort and time expended to get one, to un-learn what you have learned in your experiences, to reapply what truths you have discovered and to remain fresh and relevant. For me, that prospect is not efficient. I rather focus my efforts on keeping fresh and relevant.
I believe the intrinsic qualities and traits of a well rounded IT professional are also the basis of a free-thinking, entrepenuerial problem solver; one who lives constantly in the intractable and thrives.
While I don't need to validate my person through a total university experience (and subject it to the way somebody else thinks), I have participated in adjunct studies with a few good institutions to get the information I needed to do my job. I do hold a diploma from a technical college as well. That is also where I began to think on my feet and for myself.
If you believe in yourself (how you were created and what you are to become) and you have a vision and a dream to follow, then a degree may be superfluous.
Tempis Fugit -- Time Is Money.
by sjefwa
by pajavaone
The value of a degree will vary from company to company, so it's difficult to make generalizations here. But I can tell you about my recent hiring experience, and hopefully you will find this helpful.
Back in the Spring, I received many resumes in response to an opening for a senior Java developer. In screening the many resumes, I only looked at skills (if listed separately) and the most recent job or two. I was looking for real experience with specific technologies and didn't care about a degree.
I then conducted phone interviews based on technical questions ("how" and "why" questions to show if the candidate knew how to apply technical knowledge). Those that did well were brought in for in person interviews with managers and senior developers where evaluations were based on both technical and personal skills/qualities.
In all, we never cared about the degree that a candidate had. Those who did the best were generally those with the most real experience. This is not to say that a degree is not worthwhile; it just wasn't really a factor when WE hired.
The candidate we ended up hiring is a skilled developer who has been a good match for the position so far. And, in case you wondered, she has an undergraduate degree in mathematics.
by robert
Like alot of working stiffs i agree with red and lot of the others, a degree is good but what you know is alot better. I started 16 years ago in this field for a reseller that did every kind of thing with micro computers you can think of, from soddering on diods and/or capscitors for a memory upgrade to multi platform/topology networks.so if you think because you went to school you will get the job you are only part right, it takes dedication and self perseverance to get any where in this field.
ps. along with alot of hours after hours.
by thumper1
I have had a lot of experience with those "Highly educated" techs. One of them holds the record for the most money written off in a 30 day period. Never hired one out of school that didn't need a minimum of three months re-training before we could re-classify him as "Not Dangerous", much less start generating revenue.
Needing a tech badly, (As opposed to a bad tech) I hired a guy with no education except a high school diploma and four years of hands on experience. Started making money for us immediately. Those highly educated guys are great, right up to the point where you hand them a screwdriver.
I have neither certification or degree, only a long history of quality IT performance. On top of this I have strong interpersonal and communication skills. Meeting the demands of management in preparing white papers and presentations does require some education, however each is attainable through educating yourself in what your clients require.
I guess what I am getting at is that it is the ability of the individual not what is written on a piece of paper - and the confidence to sell it.
by drkgfx
by murdo
I have been reading the responses to this conundrum we seem to have in the IT industry - to degree or not to degree, what is the answer?
Well first let me point out that I am a 56 year old pro without a degree. I started in 1969. Taught myself IBM 360 assembler and cobol. Have been consultant, programmer, systems analyst, manager, etc.
I have always been comfortable with my level of expertise. I know when I am in deep water and need to be saved or assisted through a swamp full of aligators.
Being in this comfort zone has allowed me to hire and work with people who know as much and in most cases, more than I do. It didn't matter if the individuals I worked with had degree or not. It was important to me that they were competent in the field, confident in them selves and that there was mutual respect.
Having a degree does not make you more intelligent! It provides you with a base of knowledge to work from, a way of thinking and it shows that you have "stick-to-itiveness" or drive .
From the ramblings of the "hire-only-a-degreed" IT pro, I get the feeling that they are either elitest or not sufficiently comfortable with themselves.
There is no way a new university grad can have the knowledge and experience of a person who has worked in the industry for any given period of time, degreed or not degreed.
I beginning to ramble as well... This is a hot topic for me because I have run into it quite often. Especially in the last 10 years.
Cheers, Newbutold
by smcgirk
by myron_s
Here is my lived through view of the problem.
I'm literally self-taught (pity about my grammar and spelling, but give me space, I just come home from a mentally hard time managing a network) and ended up working in the company I'm now at.
Reason? A more educated person (roughtly the boss's words) put up more barriers and problems that he ended up becoming a pain.
Finally, I take over and give the entire network a major make-over. Now it's working as sweat as it can ever be and is working with the staff, not against the staff.
I'm at the point where I'm at home most of the time and not at the office. A good innovation is broadband. I'm at home, but still sat at my desk in the office. Actually, I can be sat at ANY desk with a computer on it, but I'm still at home.
For the majority of graduates to make it, better treat the situation like learning to drive the car. First you learn the basics and then satisfy the examiner. Once you've passed, throw the heyway code book out of the window, becom inventive, be a people person, be inventive, so what others want when it may not necesserally be what you want to do.
Most times going by the book slows you down enough to let a competitor beat you to the finishing post.
How do I know this? Done this many times. I end up the being instrumental to getting the orders and the cash? The educated lot end up getting blown out of the water.
It's not just about technology and procedures . . . Many times these two are just such a major pain in the ass!
There, my penny's worth, inc. bad grammor and spolling to boot!
by kwright
by frobinsn
I personally believe its the person not the accreditation. Experience and certifications are valuable and can't be beat. However to get thru the door (HR) and get a higher pay bracket if your just starting out or have few years expereince then the degree will give you the edge unfortunately. I have met both good and bad from both sides and my opinion is if you can get a degree, take it. I have had people with MSc'c work with me who were complete jokers and guys who worked there way up who are absolutely brilliant. There are other things that you'll learn as a result like proper techniques to do things and other disciplines that you may just be better at.
My 2 cents....
by thebooch
by crake
by bj_terrell
I have been in IT for over 20 years. I have a degree in Music and never had any computer classes in college. Since college I have obtained many IT certifications, and over 20 years have logged more hours in IT classes and seminars than the time I spent in college. I began using a computer shortly after I graduated in 1983. I have managed huge IT projects and at one time had over 27 IT staff reporting to me. Education is important but I will always hire a seasoned veterian, or what I call a field trained IT soldier who has been on the front lines, over a college graduate with little or no expierience. My suggestion is that a person who wants a degree in IT today, mix their time between the class room, and working or interning with a company where they can gain the technical skills needed to find an IT job. It has also been my expierience that colleges are normally 2-3 years behing current technology. In IT where everything is changing at a phenomial pace that is a long time.
I hope this helps!
by artman11
I've been in IT for more than 20 years, most recently with a heavy emphasis in technical management. Of the most talented programmers I know and have known, 75% have unrelated degrees.
What I need in a programmer are reasoning, analytical and problem solving skils and the ability to relate to the real world. These are a lot harder to teach than programming languages.
I must also admit my bias. I am a self-taught programmer with a degree in Philosophy.
by dwright
by tigertim
I have a diploma and not a degree and many years of experience. I've worked with people who have degrees. Some are very good and others are not.
In a previous job, the management rehired a former employee solely on the basis of his computer science degree. He was useless. Even the other degree holders in the company couldn't fathom his qualifications. He would frequently ask me how to do programming in C as well as other mundane tasks.
On one occasion he disabled the company's firewall and virus scanner so he could download a file from the net. The result: a virus hit our LAN and we were down for two days while the IT department and I repaired the damage.
When I was employed by a government department, I frequently "held the hands" of fresh undergraduates who hadn't a clue of what to do. Ironically, they looked down on me and my co-workers because they had degrees, while we only had diplomas + experience.
To be fair, my colleagues who have degrees have stated that a having a degree does not necessarily mean a smarter or better employee. It's basically the individual.
by jnbtz
I have been in the industry for 12 years. 2 with the private sector, 4 in a non-profit organization and 6 in state governement. I have an associate degree in advertising design. It does not exactly qualify me for the IT industry. I have A+ cert as well as my CNA. The certs always came down to the employer wanted the peice of paper, but it was the work experience and the knowledge of working on many networks in many environments that got me in the door in the first place.
If the hiring entity needs the skills you posess and you have the personality to sell yourself at an interview (a fair indication as to how well someone may do in giving a presentation) you will be the person hired!
by lopaka
by tahiti16
by brian
by brian
by eriksblues
stand up infront of executives and give a presentation is your concept of IT work?
you little mind never work in systems, you have the mind of a secretary
by rknrlkid
Unfortunately, like always, there is an "us versus them" mentality on these boards. I and others have written numerous times on this subject.
It is never either/or. Any job seeker must face certain realities in the business world, and one of those is the value of degrees and certifications.
I will comment this time on one thing that I partially agree with from the posts. A college degree is absolutely essential. However, a COMPUTER SCIENCE degree in my experience is a poor degree. These are the individuals who must be led by the hand. In almost every computer science department I have looked into the curriculum was so out of touch with reality that it was useless.
I know that many will disagree, but the best bet to me is a) GET A DEGREE, PERIOD, and b) get the degree in Business Arts, Business Management, or, if you have already started working on a degree and are most of the way done, FINISH WHAT YOU STARTED, regardless of the major. ANYTHING but Computer Science. Ultimately, all anyone cares about is if you have a degree, not what its in. Finishing college shows that you can actually complete something important that you start. All corporate cultures irrationally worship the value of a college degree. Even if you hate going to school, get the degree to check the block if for no other reason. If you want to be a "well-rounded" person, the degree to get is one in the liberal sciences. Its interesting to note that when you do a job search on "Human Interface Developer" (i.e., graphic user interface designer) the degree requirment is Behavioral Science, not Computer Science. That is because a GUI has nothing to do wtih computers, but everything to do with how people sympbolically interact.
Everyone without a degree wants to point out how Bill Gates is so spectactular and he dropped out of college. I think the biggest mistake Bill Gates ever made was not finishing college. (After all these years, you could have finished!) Be that as it may, Bell Gates is the EXCEPTION, not the RULE. None of you are Bill Gates. You are YOU. Be YOU. Read a few of the biographies of Bill Gates, and you will see that a) he had very advanced mathematics and engineering knowledge, even in high school, and b) he lived, ate and breathed computers. Most people who claim the Bill Gates story do not have his background. So it is an invalid comparison.
As I said on a different thread, reality is that you need a degree PLUS certifications PLUS experience.
by pickleman
> Overall, mixing your knowledge and
> skills with faith in God will get you
> the best results.
Right. I'm sure God will be the deciding factor as to whether or not you get a particular job.
by pickleman
> however the lack of proper grammer and spelling
> If both of these indiviuals worked in my
> organization I would never allow them to
> present anything to management.
What orgranization would that be, "grammer" boy?
As most have said, it depends on the individual.
HOWEVER - here's why the person with experience is generally a better choice: 1.) The background/certifications that they have were earned the hard way. 2.) They weren't simply guided through the motions of education(college). They wanted it, went after it, and got it themselves - nobody gave it to them. 3.) Many of the people who do NOT have a degree, appreciate thier position, and understand how hard it is to get a job, thus they are more inclined to perform. 4.) Finally, I have known many "educated" folks (two who worked as my assistants)who really struggled with technical things, even though thier degree, or certification said they could do these things.
The answer: Pick someone based on what they've proved they can do, not based on what that piece of paper SAYS they can do.
by kkurnia
IMHO: You can't expect too always hire somebody that have had experience, because then there would be no place for freshmen. You'll simply just wipe out chances for somebody to prove themselves.
But, I agree that a degree doesn't give us the skills that we want, but more into our passion towards technology that matters. I know people that has a degree but (just like you said) struggle thru technical things. but I also know people with the exact same background that turn to be briliiant and fast learners, regardless of grades that they've got when they were in colleges.
I have a degree myself, and what I feel about my UNI times; I feel that I've got well rounded foundations to move forward, especially with real-world projects that we had in UNI. I believe I've got my first job partially because I have a degree. But most importantly in our career path, especially in IT are continous learning and passion about the technology itself. A degree I think will help us open the door, but the rest is entirely up to ourselves.
But, too some stage we have too have a little bit of faith for the educational systems. It shows at least that the person who got thru the UNI degree has commitments to finish what they started. And of course it is up too us who do the interview to judge if someone is really worthy to be hired or just a paper based technologist, who knows nothing except for the certificate that they bring.
by norman9
A college degree is a rite of passage in the business world. Regardless of what the major or degree is in, it demonstrates (in theory, anyway) that the person has a fair amount of overall intelligence and the discipline it took to graduate from college. It used to be that a high school diploma was the big milestone, but the world of work evolved to where it wasn't enough. The college degree is now what the high school diploma used to be. Even a general Liberal Arts degree carries the "college graduate" aura of an educated person.
It's not an either/or deal....experience and certifications AND a college degree go a longer way together than either by itself toward making you an attractive prospect. Also, certifications BY THEMSELVES don't carry the weight they used to. It's one thing to take a course and cram for a certification exam, but that doesn't count as much without on-the-job experience anymore. Except maybe at poor school district, non-profit organization or similar where they can't offer a lot of money and will hire someone lower on the experience scale. I'm a 54-year-old college grad who changed careers to the IT field four years ago, by getting my A+ certification and having 15 years of computers as a hobby. I started at $17,500 as a tech in a school district to get my foot in the door and build on-the-job paid work experience. I'm now at another school district making a lot more.
by klinberg
Greetings. I prepared an article on this subject a couple of years ago that might shed some light on the subject. See:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5100-6317_11-5047673.html?tag=search
I run the School of Technology at Capella University, so I'm biased with respect to education or experience. I think many people need both, but it's so important to find a GOOD school.
by csaunders
It all depends on how you sell yourself in the industry. I have taken most of the Microsoft Windows 2000 courses, some CISCO & a few of the new ones for Exchange and Windows 2003. However, I do not hold any certifications or degrees and did not attend any 2 or four year programs.
I have had 10 years of good employment and expierience in the industry now. I have been hired each time becuase I am confident in what I do and learn very quickly. I also make sure to sell this in the interviews and when I ask why I was hired, the reponse that I get indicates I did a good job of selling myself.
I found early on that I learn from the instruction environment but I am not a test taker and that a lot of the material (although useful for reference) really does not apply to the real live environment becuase of custom software, hardware and network topology.
All I can say is..... make a good effort to sell yourself to potential employers!
by techrepublic
by sbracken
Education is important but experience is far more valuable
in the real world. Education proves you can learn but it is
not a guarantee that you can think creatively. Many
managers will only hire based on education or certification.
If their hires fail to perform these managers will say, "it
wasn't my fault, the guy had all of the credentials". All of
my successful hiring was based on 4 ?A?s? Attitude, Ability,
Aptitude & Adaptability.
by oz_media
Perhaps certs will give SOME employers a way to choose staf, but not all employers need certs and studies.
I was hired for an IT position with NO prior experience, No IT certs or anything.
They just wanted my capabilities, not expriences.
I have a good prove track record for fixing companies and have friends in important places. This gets me work over and above almost any applicant anytime.
You track record is FAR mroe important than your education, however there are still companies out there who believe certification is a requirement for staff, not drive or ability.
by jhagen
by womble
Folk
There are a number of issues that need adressing
1/ the first problem in getting a job is to get past the Recruitment agency filters. When there are 400 applicants for 1 job, you need to ensure that you can passage through the initial filtering stage, an especially important point when going through career change. A good recruiter is able to account for experience but there is a large number out there who take the easy option of prequalifying for degrees
2/ the proportion of degree qualified people has grown from 2% of the population in 1970 to 30% now. Where people used to go to technical colleges, and night school to get technical quals, now it is expected that you go to university. This has resulted in a large portion of degree qualified people who are unable to find work without experience. Their alternative is to return to university and upgrade to a higher qualification is often resorted to.
3/Good managers are also able to manage this by trying for a well rounded team. By mixing and matching, you are able to increase your preformance significantly. When recruiting they generally look at 3 criteria
Can they do the job? Experience or Quals or a mix can prove this
Will they stick around to do it? It costs to recruit.
Will they fit into my team? This is the hardest to measure, and is usually based on if the manager believes the candidate has empathy with the team (Thats why you get teams of people who all seem similar, even if they come from different bacgrounds)
I hope that this illuminates the issue
by ohiois
I agree that a degree can show a persons commitment and dedication to a particular career path. However, I strongly disagree that it is proof of public speaking skills or even intelligence. I work with several people who have Masters Degrees and a couple who have doctorates that are incapable of communicating a sensible voice mail or e-mail. I am sorry to say that two of these people are in our IS Department.
On the other hand, there are a few of us in IS that have only experience to fall back on. We are the ones writing our manuals, teaching end users and making presentations to management and the board of directors.
In my opinion, education should be worth something. Considering the astronomical costs today for a decent education, there should be an end reward. However, if you are going to pay someone for their knowledge, make sure they have the necessary skills to communicate it.
by nigel2
Hello there all those who avertise for a job candidate to have 1st or a 2:1 . Sorry to dissapoint you but I had my wide knowledge before the degree I got 5 years ago. Also I got a Computing Bsc 2:2 but many of my peers who I helped got higher degrees than me although they did not even really understand the subject, they were just good at sitting exams. Incidently recently I sat a technical test related to coding I beat those with higer degrees than me hands down. Contact this guy :-
George Hillier
Senior Consultant
Alan Morris Recruitment Ltd
020 8417 0656
if you dont beleive me. My 2:2 is worth more than most 1sts now, partly becuase the standards are falling and so many students are cheating anyway.
Kind regards,
Nigel
by recruit.gov
by it-guy
by bizman
Brian makes some very good points. Let me add some to each of his.
RE: >> I would usually rate experience as the more valuable side of the equation as it does imply exposure in real world situations.
I teach at a community college, as well as work as an IT professional. I relate pretty well to my students, and I try to go beyond the text book and relate some of my "real world" experience to them. When I need to learn something new I usually look for someone like myself, who is a working IT professional, who teaches part time. My frustration with many IT instructors is that they are professional instructors, not IT professionals. For that reason, I don't think anyone can say for sure that education alone is enough. There is a value in experience that seldom is duplicated in a training enviroment.
RE: >> I tend to pass on "overly certified" candidates.
This remark has me thinking a bit. Do you only list a few? Do you guess on what you think they are looking for? Are you saying that if I had several unrelated certifications on my resume I would scare you away? What is "overly certified"?
RE: >> Lastly, those going through school tend to get lofty expectations regarding salary that cause them to ask for salaries that are beyond pratical.
This is not just a post dot-bust issue, I saw this 20 years ago when I was applying for jobs going up against newly graduated college grads. I was already in the field a few years, and had a good idea for the going wage for techs, only I was working for a small company and was looking for a shot to work for a larger one. As I would chat in interview waiting rooms, I would hold my laughter as I would here new graduates discuss the minimum they would accept. I don't think it has changed much in 20 years. There are many good companies out there to work for, if you are willing to start at entry level job, and work your way up the ladder.
Maybe I'm showing my age, and my own personal bias, but I think it is harder for someone like myself, who has been in the business for many years, to jump jobs.
The bottom line answer to the question, Do undegraduates with experience stand a chance to get hired? I say yes, absolutely.
Learning really is life long. And I think anyone in technology understands that. If you can get some full time experience, while you work part time on your education, I really think that is the best of both worlds.
by harvkim
I've read enough to know that experience cost more and its harder to beat the person right out of college for the money positions. They can be retained for less money overall. The seasoned IT pro can usally take in more options and apply the new options faster because the seasoned IT pro is always looking to improve network and system performance. The book smart college grad usally comes to the IT pro for pointers and help or they say I know more because my school says so. This is coming from experince where I work.
College is great but I was turned in a different direction i.e. get the certs and experence first then apply it to college courses. I find that the common sense of the field helps me and my employer. Good luck to all.
by gaijinit
I have hired and worked with both graduates and non-graduates, and see no difference in the levels of ignorance or skill in either category (but definitely the grads score higher in the arrogance and playing politics categories), it all comes down to the individual, and I personally lean to the guy who made it on his own - decided what field he wanted to work in, got his certs (or just experience and a proven track record), and really wants to do the job.
WTF does 'Philosophy 101" have to do with IT? There is so much time wasted in getting a 'generally well-rounded education' attending courses you will never use again and partying hearty instead of working in your field.
If I need my IT people to make formal presentations, then I should make note of their abilities in that direction either in the hiring interview with some extra questions or by observing their documentation and work habits.
Not all IT people may be suitable for standing up in the boardroom making a presentation, but having the college degree doesn't guarantee such talent either. I have seen poor penmanship, spelling and stage fright from people with degrees just as much as from the 'uneducated'.
The only differences I have observed is that usually the college grads are quicker to come up with smokescreens such as "I'm too busy to worry about things like that, I leave it up to my secretary". Well, la dee da!
Making visual and oral presentations is a skill that can be learned after someone is hired if he/she is going to need it.
Give me the hard-working self-achiever who loves his work, not the ones who feel the world owes them a favor for gracing it with their divine presence.
by knd911
by gjanes
I am a high school drop-out, a tech-school drop-out, and a corporate executive. I have the pleasure of working with an IT professional with a 4-year degree - this individual has trouble remembering how to get home. I have worked with tech-school graduates who cannot carry a conversation in real-time... try to decipher one of those emails.
Base line on this is that education is a wonderful thing. The question is what one does with that education - is it a waste of time and money or does it add value to the indivuals natural talents?
by gjanes
by lnair78
Dear All,
I was going through all the posted replies and was wondering how good are my chances in IT under my current qualification. I'm pasting my resume along with this post. I would appreciate replies for all you gentlemen.
Thanks
Latesh
MY RESUME:
RESUME
Latesh P Nair
VishwaGram Info Marketing Services Pvt. Ltd.
3rd Floor, St. Patrick?s Complex, Brigade Road.
Bangalore ? 560 025
Karnataka
India
lnair78@yahoo.com
Phone: +919886714503
Experience (Total 4 years)
Manager ? IT
12/2002 - Present VishwaGram Info Marketing Services (P) Ltd., Bangalore
Job Description:
In charge for total IT infrastructure (Systems, network, telecomm, websites, mail servers, web designing, small application building for in-house use).
Incharge of Entire Indian operation for promoting and implementation of Collect Calls and Credit Call Calling Service throughout India.
Systems Administrator
1/2001 ? 12/2002 NetERP India Pvt. Ltd. Bangalore
Job Description:
Support For Hardware: Installation and troubleshooting of hardware problem: Intel PI ? PIV, IBM AMD systems. Printers (Inkjet Jet, Laser, Dot-matrix), Scanners.
Support for Software: Operation System:
Installation and troubleshooting of software (Windows9x/Me/NT/2000/XP, UNIX. Linux, Solaris.
Was actively involved in Software installation and troubleshooting of:
Apache ? Tomcat, DBAnywhere, Javawebserver, and Oracle 8i on Linux Mandrake/Red hat.
Achievements:
? Designed and upgraded the Network from HUB network to unmanaged switches serving 70 clients at 100 Mbps from 10 Mbps. Interconnectivity between two office buildings.
? Designed and upgraded network from MS windows NT 4.0 Server Domain to Windows 2000 Server serving all the concerning clients to MS Windows 2000 Professional. Successfully configured Active Directory.
? Installed and configured cross platform between MS Windows 2000 Domain and Linux.
? Automated Backup configuration for all clients on the server. And from server to CDWR, Tape Drive and Zip Drive.
? Antivirus installation and automated antivirus updates for all clients in the same network through the Server.
? Implemented Security Policy Which included Intranet Security, Antivirus Policy, Internet Policy, Backup Policy, and Software Licensing.
? Installed and configured Windows 2000 Exchange Server/ Qmail for Intranet Mail Services.
? Installed and configured Winproxy (Internet Proxy Server) with Firewall.
Hardware Engineer
5/2000 ? 1/2001 Galaxy Software, Bangalore
Job Description:
Support For Network and PC?s, Servers, and software. Was also Incharge for IT- Security.
Service Engineer
1/1999 ? 4/2000 Turning Point Computers, Bangalore
Job Description:
Hardware, Network & Software installation and support on call services.
PI Ship (6 Months)
Job Description:
Incharge for Machine Room, support for systems and support for students doing project works on C, C++ on UNIX Platform/ Windows NT.
Education:
? Sun Solaris Introductory Courses ? Certification
? GNIIT (2.5 Year Course)
? Language: C++, VB, VJ++, HTML, DHTML, MS FrontPage.
? RDBMS: Access, Oracle, Sybase MSSQL
? Application: MSOFFICE Full Suite.
? 10 + 2(C.B.S.E Board) - 1998
References:
Arvind Thimmaya ? Vice President, Galaxy Software
Email: arvindkst@yahoo.com
Francis Lobo ? Director,Vishwagram Info Marketing Services Pvt. Ltd.
Email: flobo12@yahoo.com
Additional Information:
Gender: Male
Nationality: India
Mother Tongue: Malayalam
Date of Birth: 14/10/1978
Personal Strength: Honestly, Positive Attitude, Sincere, Hardworking
Personal Weakness: Emotional
Known Languages: English, Hindi, Punjabi & Malayalam
by gperreault
Let's face it, IT folks fall into one of several categories:
Wannabe - This person has been working with computers in his/her garage and fancies himself the next Bill Gates. Frequently has helpful ideas ...if only you'd give him access to the router. He doesn't know jack.
Nick Burns - From SNL- this is an arrogant (degreed or not) person who lauds his skills over everyone. He takes delight in his cleverness and always works with "idiots". The non degreed variety never misses an opportunity to belittle college graduates and executives or make them feel stupid.
Paper Tiger - Once hired one of these. You name it, she had it. Must have had the entire alphabet behind her name. Didn't know how to install RAM. Currently teaching MCSE classes.
Snot Nose - Kid right out of college who thinks he has an entitlemnt...to big bucks. May have graduated Magna cum laude, very bright, but leaves a path of destruction in his wake. Knows it all, doesn't listen, and frequently unable to find his car in the lot after work.
The professional - This person has a capacity to learn. They frequently have a degree, but it is not a prerequisite. They have the intellect and capacity to be adaptable and learn new skills, generally the first time around. They are proactive. They have people skills and are good communicators, providing quality service to both the secretary and the CEO. They are committed to a vision and recognize their role is one of servant leader, not a Tech God.
Hope that clears it up.
by kyuso
This question seems to indicate a need to get a full-time job without graduating. If you have experience, then getting a degree will be very beneficial.
Getting into the job market without a degree is risky in the long run. You may get into the market easily when there are demands for your specific skills, but it is not easy when the time comes to move up the ladder, since the type of job that requires specific skills without a degree is quite limited for growth.
Of course, it depends on other factors. When the market is very lucrative and that specific skill happens to be in demand for a long time, or you happen to be someone who is very self-motivated and learns fast and can survive for years, or you can make it rich on your own, then it's a different story. But that is not a norm in IT.
by nirmaldey
I guess experience teaches you a lot more than your degree. In fact if you compare an experienced undergraduate with a newly graduate I would any time hire an individual with experience of at least 1 year. However, if you compare an undergraduate with experience and a graduate with same experience I would try and evaluate and hire the one who meets my requirement and has better capabilities. Once you are employed all that matters is how and what you have contributed to the organization and how and what you can achieve in future.
Be in touch Dhiraj.
by ammaina
I am an undergraduate in a graduate infested organization, but I dont think anyone except the HRknow coz I work very hard and I beat my graduate colleges in sorting out IT problems.
The only problem will be to get a new job, someone has to commend you.
Hard work pays
Sort by Trending