Discussion Locked

Does Gmail mean the end of private e-mail?

0 helpful
22 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What's your take on Gmail, Google's new e-mail offering? Do you feel the privacy concerns are well-founded? Do you think companies should discourage employees from using Gmail? Share your comments about the potential of Google's Gmail, as discussed in the June 7 Internet Security Focus e-newsletter.

If you haven't subscribed to our free Internet Security Focus e-newsletter, sign up today!
http://nl.com.com/acct_mgmt.jsp?brand=techrepublic

22 replies

by dave howe

It has long been known that most email is about as private as a postcard - every set of hands it passes though (or more accurately, every admin at every server) can spool off a copy for his later amusement if he chooses, networks can be sniffed, mailboxes hacked into, stored mail accessed or redirected by warrant (or in the uk, the correct internally-validated-by-law-officers form that no judge has or will see)

if you encrypt your mail for privacy, this will still work.
The rest of the time - does it matter? do you care if some robot process is picking over your text to create compatable email adverts? its not as if any real human sees or cares what your text is, as long as they can get paid for the googleads they can target more precisely that way :)

by bdulac

I have to agree with the author of the article and those that have stated that E-mail in and of itself is insecure. I believe the people who have objected the most to Gmail probably are not aware that the e-mail they are currently using could be read by anyone with a basic network sniffer.

If security in e-mail is such an issue then why not focus more on viruses and spam instead of what type of advertisement is directed at you.

by jeffs

A great quote from an InfoSec manager:

"If you put it in email, you might as well just write it on the bathroom wall."

I think that pretty much sums up the secured state of email.

by srinivasanth

Dear...........

I wish to know one thing about Gmail about which I am very hazy:

I do plan to take to e-mail and am ready for spam, junk mail and targetted ads. I suppose all I have to do is NOT to open my Gmail if I find it not worth the bother of ploughing through the INBOX.

HOWEVER WHAT I AM NOT CLEAR ABOUT IS WHETHER THIS WILL EXPOSE MY HARDWARE / COMPUTER TO ANY RISK OF AD INVASION OR ATTACK BY VIRUS OR SPAM OR TROJAN OR POP-UPS. I WORRY THAT THE OTHER MEMBERS OF FAMILY SHARING THIS COMPUTER WITH ME SHOULD NOT SUFFER DUE TO MY JOINING GMAIL. In fact it is THEIR computer and I am only a guest user.

Can you please clarify what / whether risk I would subject the computer to ?

Thanks.
sv
7 jyne 04.

by dave howe

as far as we can tell, no.

Google currently offer a standard google ad in the web interface (couple of lines of ascii text, obvious clickable link that goes where it says it goes) - and aparently will add the same as footers to email traffic accessed via smtp or pop3.

google have an excellent track record with their ads for preventing anything even resembling a dodgy practice, never mind viral links - all ads are plain text, the links are pre-vetted. In a world where popunder and "floating" ads are the staple of every evil spammer that sells a tower-banner to a site, google is a refreshing and non-evil breath of air :)

by srinivasanth

thx for the instant and helpful response. i do think it is upto the gmail users whether to use it or not; it wd not be fair to criticise google for making this offer affording willing participants i GB !

by keyguy13

You will have the same risk as if you used hotmail or yahoo for your free email. The difference is that with Gmail you will get 1 GIGABYTE of storage for your attachments and everything else. I think it is a more than fair trade off.

by Former member

Gmail is like any other so called free email service in that it asks you to give up some degree of precieved privacy in return for use of the service. As a Nework Administrator I don't allow use of any of these free email services on the company network. But, I see no need to be anymore concerned with Gmail as opposed to any of the other services. Until encryption becomes standard practice almost all email users are sending postcards, believing them to be private mail. Hey!! that's something these privacy guardians might want to work on.

by jimhm

Is any E-mail really secure - I don't care if its encrypted or not - like a cop once told me if a theif wants your car the only way they aren't going to get it is for you not to have one.

E-mail in a corporate environment is property of the corporation - Home Email - can be encrypted - but still can be hacked.

So Googles new G-Mail is just a service offering they hope to make money with.... Give the hackers a few months and G-Gmail will be hacked..

by patrek

Does anybody here remembers that Gmail was launched on April 1rst 2004?

Pat

by pertelote

Actually, you can get a GMAIL account now. It is by invitation only. I have one and so do several of my friends. As has been stated email is never private, this is just a fun toy for me not a serious work tool.

by novice008

I agree with Jonathan Yarden, it is your choice wither you want more junk coming with your emails. As to company discouraging people, just make sure the users know what there getting into, since some don?t read thing carefully, they see FREE and its ?Oh cool lets sign up? click though everything until done. By the way, does Gmail only scan the incoming mail? What about outgoing? Are non-Gmail users going to get a taste of the ads as well?

by k_stocker

What concerns me the most about Google scanning the email for content is how it is going to be affected by HIPAA. If a patient requests their medical or billing records be sent by email (we already do this to a certain extent), are we going to be violating HIPAA rules of any kind? Especially since right up front, Google is saying that they will be data mining. There are a lot of people out there who will just look at it as a "Free" service and get extremely upset if we have to say, "Sorry, HIPAA regulations will not allow us to send that information to you."

by larry the security guy

There are a lot of people out there who will just look at it as a "Free" service and get extremely upset if we have to say, "Sorry, HIPAA regulations will not allow us to send that information to you."

I'm not a HIPPA expert, but my company does comply with the financial industry equivalent. We developed an official position that protects records and prohibits delivery by email or fax. When someone requests such a distribution, we send them an educational packet and remind them that we cannot oblige them and explains why.

You might want to invite a HIPPA or JHCAO expert to your next board or management meeting to discuss the potential issues and develop your own official position and policy.

Yes, you will upset most of your GMAIL-attached patients, but so long as you are consistent with the policy and your education materials are effective, the complaints will ebb. The only patients that will continue to complain are those that complain anyway.

by bdulac

Larry has a point. I'll even take it a step further. If you're sending medical records through e-mail be careful. I support several doctors and medical groups and understand enough about HIPPA to realize that sending med. records through e-mail is just asking for trouble.

I would never reccomend sending personal and/or medical information over the Internet through e-mail. It's just not secure at all unless you use some form of encryption. I'm not sure exactly of HIPPA's stance on this but it would be worth looking into.

by jimhm

HIPAA regs permit Email between Patient and provider or payer as long as that message is encrypted. Now there are many ways to encrypt messages - HIPAA recommends PKI but there are other methods out there that could be utilized.

If Gmail permits - encryption through PKI or an alternative encryption solution than you will not have any reg issues under HIPAA complaince.

Hope that helps

by armando_diazdeleon

Big deal, so Google will scan our email. Like the other postings, who's to say no one else (MSN, Hotmail, Yahoo) don't do this? They just won't admit it, or be honest with the users. Sometimes I'm sure it is stated in their disclaimers, but who really reads those? GMAIL is a choice and if you would like to have the 1GB of email storage, then that will be the price you pay. It beats the 10mb or 3mb other free email companies give you. If you don't want it, don't use it. If you something private you don't want others to read/scan, don't send it to a Gmail address. Simple as that! Geez, people make a big fuss about the little things sometimes, we have a choice!

by alangeek

Contrary to what many people here have suggested, Google is not doing any data mining, which involves collection and analysis of data. They are also not going to be sticking ads in the middle of your mail.

Google's Gmail will only do a text scan of a message and display what it thinks are related ads, identical to the ads that show up on the right side of the page when you do a Google search. This will only appear on the reader's screen, and does not affect the message itself, nor any outgoing messages. They will not be generating any spam, nor subjecting you to spam, only minimal ads to the side of your screen. For a look at a sample page, go to http://gmail.google.com/gmail/help/screen2.html and see how it will look.

The people who are all up in arms about this non-issue have clearly jumped to drastically faulty conclusions without bothering to examine any of the openly available information about the product.

Frankly, I think I'd trust Google a lot farther than I'd trust a lot of other vendors. They have stated exactly what they plan to do. Just because other vendors don't say they aren't scanning your mail doesn't mean that they aren't. For that matter, we've seen plenty of vendors that state plainly that they will not use any of your private information and then immediately do exactly what they said they wouldn't. Google's just catching flak because they said what they plan to do.

by jeffs

I don't understand why it's not generally accepted that sending any amount of account information, let alone something as serious as medical information, in email is just a bad idea. Some companies have found better, more secure ways; such as providing a link in an email to a site that will offer the information over https. The company's server can then control exactly how the information is being accessed, and will have a log of who has been accessing it. Just seems to make sense all around.

by mekon

I must admit I do have concerns. Email is scanned for spam as a normal procedure by most ISP's, and we hope that's as far as that goes. But as for scanning it so as to personalise the sending of specific ADs, I dont know. I have the free version of Opera, the webbrowser and email clent. To get the free version you have to accept ADs, but you can choose whether they are random ADs or specific to the sites you visit. I'm allright with that, I choose specific ADs, and as it's only tech sites in the main that I visit , it's no problem. Not that I read them. When your on a site, after all your searching the site, not looking at ADs on one line of the browser. Another one. A certain download accellerator insists with the free version that you accept ADs, but having used it, and also Spybot S&D that searches for adware, you find that ADtrackers etc, have been inserted into your registry, and Spybot tells you that according to the terms and conditions of using the free version, they have the right to share whatever information they retrieve with whoever they want. This sort of thing I. Personally, am not into. I mean, there were 15 entries in the registry for trackers etc for this bit of software. This one went in the trash, and I got another free one (Stardownloader) free with no ADs. I think as a home user, you,have to make the choice. If you are the sort of person that leaves your door open, and dont mind strangers walking in and having a good look around, then go for Gmail. If you believe Private should mean Private then dont. They still check your email for SPAM though, all the same. The ISPs that is. Of course on the other hand, without advertising we would never know about new products. Whether it's some guy who's just opened a new hardware store, and is going round the neighborhood with his kids, posting flyers through peoples doors. Advertising in the local paper. Perhaps advertising on the radio even. Advertising is necessary, it's just the way it's done thats the problem. Dont get me wrong, I'm not having a go at Google. They have set up a really good search engine, but sometimes a new idea is'nt such a good idea, especially when the feedback starts coming in. As far as corporate users are concerned, personally I'd be very concerned. admittadly the sensitive stuff is encrypted, but it's so easy to send mail in plain text without thinking, and to have Gmail scanning it while it's on the wire. Thats one hell of a security risk. In conclusion, if your a home user and arn't bothered about outsiders looking through your drawers, Go For It. If you are security concious, Stay Away. I would'nt even give it consideration for corporate users, and no offense intended to Google for an idea that may not be such a good idea after all. Mekon.

by evgeny

Even if I choose not to use Gmail (not to obtain an account there, not to write messages to Gmail accounts, even not to accept messages originated from Gmail), I can not be sure that my messages are not scanned by Gmail system. The simplest case: I write to someuser@someserver.tld and that server forwards mail to someuser@gmail.com (or whatever Gmail addresses look like). I have no ways to trace it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.