Discussion Locked

Does this IT manager need certifications?

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Let's take a fictional IT manager who started at the bottom and worked hisway well up the career ladder. However, this manager is now facing a possible layoff. He has the experience but not the certifications. What is your advice for him? How well do you think he'll fare in the new economy without those certs? Send us some mail and let us know or post a comment to our discussion thread.

15 replies

by worker bee

This manager will need the certifications unless he has a strong network that can get him a job through personal referrals.

Experienced IT people know that certifications mean little, but HR people and higher level managers still worship them. It does not matter how good you are if you cannot get past or bypass the gatekeepers.

by gtm

I am that fictional manager. The certs are needed to get anyone take your experience seriously.

by pizarrod

One of the things that should be considred by hiring people is the fact that a certification might not gice all the "know-how" needed to be an IT Manager.
An IT manager who started at the bottom and worked his/her way up to career ladder will have a better understanding of how all the IT pieces go together. He/She will know how to put all the pieces together to make IT works for a company.
Certification do alot but the don't assure any success...

by pnevai

I would say, NO you should not need to get the certifications. When ever I was looking for an experienced individual, certifications were a non issue. I only cared about certifications when looking for a entry level individual, some on with NO provious work experience!.

Certifications typically prove nothing. All they prove is that you took the time to go to classes and do not show how well you are at real world applications and if you can "think on the fly"

With the proper resources anyone can find a soultion to a problem, but only years of experience can teach you how to recognize problems before they manifest.

There are so many more variables to being good in the tech field, and book knowledge while necessary will not replace years of hands on experience. Showing that you have done the job, done it successfully and can contribute in a team working environment is far more important.

But getting back to the real wold where your resume is screened for key words by many people who do not know a byte from a bite, your resume needs to show certification jargon. If you do not have this then your resume will be tossed in the dumpster faster than you can say boo.

So a neat trick to avoid this is to put on the resume a listing titled Certification Equivelents:
and under it list your applicable expereince with products. For example if you have been in the IT industry for any length of time include A+, if you've configured Cisco routers for over 5 years then CCNA is good.

Note you are claiming Certificate Equivelence not the Cert. Yet this trick will at least help your resume past the screeners and into the hands of the hiring manager who at least can see if your past work history makes you valuable and not just acromyms on a sheet of paper.

by mrafrohead

Most of the certified people where I work, come to me to ask me for help.

I have none, and don't intend on getting any. I'm self taught.

I hope that says something about certs. The only thing they're good for is to get past the beasts in HR, or to freshen your breath.

Mrafrohead

by gmuscle

I agree with many of the previous post on the Certs not showing real knowledge. I am the fictional Manager that is now out of work and while I have more than 13 years as a IT Manager I get no reponse from companies without Certs. So I will be trying to complete my Certs as soon as possible just to get into a new job.

by it-pm

In dealing with recruiters and HR on both sides of the interview table, I have found that certs are extremely important tools in marketing and selling yourself. From a marketing perspective, recruiters will search resume databases for certifications. If you want your resume to be in the search results, then you need to have the certification. From a sales perspective, an HR manager may not understand the difference between PASCAL and C#, but he/she can process the letters ?MCAD? very easily, which makes it easier for you to close the deal.

It is also important to understand the role of certifications in the industry in which you are seeking work. If you are seeking work in an IT consultant company, the company requires a certain number of certified employees in order to maintain their company certification with their vendor partners. It is also easier for the company salesperson to sell your services if you have demonstrated knowledge through certification. Additionally, I have seen several government Requests For Proposal (RFP) that stipulate certification requirements for personnel that are bid on the contracts. The company that can satisfy these stipulations is more competitive.

Once you are in the door, no one cares about the cert. The person writing your pay check wants to know if you can solve his/her problem. You can?t say, ?No, I can?t create a web enabled SQL database, but check out my MCDBA!? If you do say that, you won?t be on the job long.

Competent IT people are usually no-nonsense folk and have no interest in the sales and marketing game. But if you are looking for opportunities to demonstrate your competence on the job, you have to market and sell yourself first, and the certs are the tools that facilitate this.

by ross.bale

I have over 10 years IT Experience, and have MCSE qualification, my current employer is training me to Citrix CCA Qualification, Checkpoint Firewall 1 Admin Quals and probably Cisco too. I am aiming to progress into senior IT management - what other "key skills" should I look for to make the jump from tech to management - I am thinking of "soft skills" such as communication, presentation, project management and/or degree but would strongly welcome some help in the right direction. Many thanks in advance.

by itguyy

I would be seriously concerned about an IT manager that had tons of certs but no college, especially management and business classes. The US Gov's Business stats page states that the best IT manager, director and above jobs go to those with MBA's on top of whatever IT skills they have.

Certs are nice, but if you're going to manage, direct or lead, you need to have the ability to make good business decisions, setup contracts, work with numbers, manage people, etc...

-Rob

by jimhm

If you want to be good at Management - and move into SR management roles - Directors - VPs - Presidents ... you don't see these guys with CICO / MS cert's on their resumes. You see BA's, BS's and MBA's and MBS's - all college papers.

Get thy to a college and get thy a degree - fast. Tell the boss to save the dollars unless you are one of those Working managers - that does the technical stuff right along with the management stuff. If thats the case - ouch

But - if you are going to do management College - Technical - you can get certs..

by jimhm

Certifications don't prove anything except that a person can take a test. They are the True B.S. (Not the degree) of the industry and vendor hype and money making idea.

If he/she has been in management they don't need Certifications to manage a group - the group should have the talent. The Manager needs talent in people skills and interpersonel skills - organization skills - leadership. I have never seen Certifications in those before - can you tell me where to get them.

What would help this person is to get a BA in business management or BA in Information systems management - Cert's use them in the bathroom..

by slartibartfast

First: I've been doing this 31 years, I've done most jobs in the industry from programmer to CIO of a $13 Billion bank.

1. When hiring people, if you know what you're doing :-) you look at certs for people at an entry level or low level tech.
2. The actual quote related to a manager looking for work - although the certs are fine if he's going to leverage his technical skills in his new job, if he's staying in management then college paper will help more, agreed.
3. What's missing in the US market is IT industry professional certifications (i.e. relating to your ability as a technology professional and manager rather than pure tech skills). They have this in the UK (MBCS, FBCS etc) and these grades are equivalent to those of a lawyer or surgeon. My problem with MBA etc is that I have seen (both as superiors and subordinates) many MBA and business school equipped managers who have no practical idea whatsoever how to manage a technology group or function - because there's more to it than being able to do a budget, as anyone who's managed a development team of 50 object oriented primadonnas will tell you.

As a final word, there have been a lot of comments in this thread about using certs to 'get past' HR screening. Here's a word of advise for IT managers hiring - don't let HR screen the resumes!

Andrew

by oz_media

If he has experience and knows how to target and mine such positions from the C level leaders of the company, then NO he doesn't nee any certas at all.

If he want's to start sending out resumes and applications instead (hopeless), he may as well get the certs because the job hunting skills will need all the support they can get, even with certs it doesn't help if your resume hits mid management, HR or never gets read to begin with.

In fact to find the BEXT jobs, you don't even NEED a resu,e. A good, winning proposal instead is FAR FAR more effective than a resume laced with certs. But that takes more time and efort than most peopl ecare to offer.

For his job and someone with HIS experience it should take 10 phone calls to the right people, with the right presentation, to get 4 interviews and 1 or 2 offers for him to choose from.

This discussion is closed to new replies.