36 replies

by jdmercha

Why is it that Business managers are capable of running IT, but IT managers are not capable of running a business?

I find it highly insulting.

by bhunsinger

Hire an MBA with risk management training. Cut the IT budget in half. Hire interns and recent college grads, and then complain they don't understand the business aspects. Then outsource security to the lowest bidder. GAAAAHCK!!!!!
While I frequently butt heads with the security folks in here that want to lock it all down all the time, this jerk makes me want to puke. Technology is too important to let the people who understand it run it- just like production, safety, etc.

by tony hopkinson

I aren't goint to read this one , all the others have been complete self serving bollocks.
IT people haven't had the power to dictate to business since the PC and possibly before.

by gralfus

His mantra seems to be:
"Security for a company consists of a firewall; slash IT to the bone and hire a college kid to run the firewall." But he still managed to spend a billion dollars on it. Must be a hell of a firewall.

"Stop being so technical and allow the business to become totally integrated with security"
Can anybody tell me what that means? What the heck does that mean? I have users that don't know how to power off their computers, but they are going to have integrated security magically happen. Documents won't be shredded accidently, blueprints won't walk off the site, USB drives won't be used to store company secrets, ...nah, security will just be there magically.

How about "I don't have to understand TCP thingies, just make it work! And have a cure for cancer by the end of your shift, moron. We business graduates don't have time to wait around for you tech-dorks. Geez!" McFly! I thought I told you not to come in here anymore.

He sounds like another "suit" who wants to be quoted and hired as a consultant.

by hal 9000

Doesn't qualify as a Consultants worst case of cost cutting exercise. It is just ridiculous.

I loved the case he quoted of Z?rich cutting their IT expenses from 2 Billion to 1 Billion and that covers Hardware, Software and wages they have outsourced the Security meaning the main server farm to some country with no Privacy Laws and lost control of their data. Brilliant Step that one is. :^O

What I want to know is how much is it costing them in Down time and lost Data? Not to mention recently a case where one companies Data was being sold on the Black Market by staff at the outsourced company who have no responsibility to secure the Companies Data. And he then goes on to talk about inside security without considering the risks involved in the company that they have outsourced their main front door to. :D

If Z?rich is still spending 1 Billion to run their Firewall which is only the bare minimum in the way of security firstly I want a job there where i can get over paid for very little work and I'll make sure that I never insure with any company associated with them. It would be safer walking around with a bunch of singed blank checks falling out of my pocket as I walked along. :p

Col ]:)

by master3bs

So he says we're supposed to let inexperienced newbies fresh out of college take care of firewall security. He then implies that IT people's minds are so cloudy they can't understand anything outside their area.

Am I the only one who sees the irony here?

by neil higgins

By another "name hacker".Look at me,I'll spout crap,just to get noticed." Certainly not trusting the IT department is asking for meltdown.We're I work,I too have people who have problems logging on,let alone understanding what a firewall does.Okey,get rid of the techi staff,hire a college kid,get em to mumble router,Linux,integration to the upper management,and you might as well be quoting Shakespeare.

by tony hopkinson

As far as I can make out what technical people Gartner does have wouldn't last as a first line junior support tech in a place with no IT.
Whinge like hell about tech's who 'pretend' to know business and then they are guilty of the same stupidity being business heads who pretend to know tech.

Experts! People who know nothing about anything else and yet think there expertise suffices in all other subjects.

by hal 9000

Expert come from the Latin where when broken down means the following X = the unknown amount & Spurt is nothing but a Drip under Pressure. So what this so called Expert really is , is a Dumb Bar-steward who is constantly under pressure to reduce costs so he can justify his outrageous Pay Rises and associated Perks.

Of course as stated in another Thread Trojans are hitting the Cell Phone Market so the outsourced Firewall will be responsible for stopping those as well right? :^O

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

He sounds like an accountant who doesn't understand anything outside of his area MONEY SPENT! In other words a typical CEO. :^O

No brains but lots of income to support their lifestyles. :D

Col ]:)

by amcol

Mostly, but not entirely.

There's a shred of truth in here that's lost in a simplistic articulation due in part to yet another in a series of pompous pundits of profundity who thinks deep thoughts and wants to save us all from ourselves while creating an excessive amount of attention for themselves, coupled with the necessity of framing the aforementioned deep thoughts in a couple of short paragraphs in order to distill them down to a sound bite.

Security should NOT, in fact, be the total purview of IT. Nor should it be owned entirely by the business. What's missing in what passes for analysis in this article is that IT chiefs, both CIO's and CTO's, are increasingly coming from the ranks of the business or are former technical professionals who received training and/or experience on the business side. Security is not something to be trusted to lower level gearheads, because in fact the whole area will be viewed as a firewall lockdown exercise. The highest levels of the IT department MUST have a direct ownership and accountability for security, and MUST work closely with their brethren on the business side to construct a viable and comprehensive disaster recovery plan and business continuity plan. Doing so requires using that business training and experience, and taking a leadership role in pulling together the necessary resources from all parts of the organization. Such plans have equal measures of technology and business imperatives if they are to ensure the business survives a disaster.

The only point of this article that I can see is yet another opportunity to bash IT when something goes wrong. If a company suffers due to the loss of a data center, or an intrusion attack, or the destruction of a key physical location, or the failure of a business process, or the interruption of communication, or any of hundreds of other reasons for normal operations to be suspended, it's a direct result of poor planning. Allowing the IT department to own all aspects of security, not having a comprehensive BCP that goes beyond technology, not having across the board accountability for DRP, not running reasonably frequent fire drills to prove the viability of the plan, abrogating responsibility by taking the political high road when disaster inevitably strikes, are all symptoms of that disease.

by tony hopkinson

Authority increases as you get higher in the organisation, responsibility decreases. Fourteen counter-signatures required to requisition a pencil coupled with total responsibility for network and data integrity. I kept that tee-shirt as a reminder not to be caught that flat-footed again.

by hal 9000

Except instead of the Tee Shirt I'm still having nightmares of the time I worked in places like that and while not as often now they are still disturbing and happening far too often for my liking. ;)

But it's only been about 10 years since I walked away from all of that so I probably haven't given it enough time yet. :^O

Col ]:)

by amcol

You're just describing bureaucracy. While every organization has it, not every organization is weighted down by it. As an example, look at GE.

Besides, I don't agree. Both authority AND responsibility increase as you get higher. What also unfortunately increases is the opportunity to pass off that responsibility. It's human nature to not want to be held accountable. You want different behavior from senior managers than from the rest of us? So do I, but we'd better make sure we're not throwing stones in our own glass houses first.

Let's accept your thesis for a moment, purely on its face. Senior management has the responsibility and the authority to formulate a cohesive, comprehensive, achievable disaster recovery plan. The responsibility for executing that plan necessarily falls to the rank and file, for the most part. So? I fail to see the error in that equation.

If I'm misinterpreting your position, please straighten me out.

by praetorpal

You are right that the article has a valid message to make and it should not be seen just as an opportunity to bash IT.

A major point that is often neglected to be mentioned is that the enterprise must also be protected from its own people. You do not mention internal intrusion, yet it is the most common source of costly breaches, costing companies millions in loss of trade secrets and mission critical data.

A truly excellent discussion of this topic, which is worth reading, can be found at:

The Threat From Within
http://www.itarchitect.com/shared/article/showArticle.jhtml?articleId=166400792&classroom=

There are times when the network must be set up so that IT people can maintain it without being able to access classied data.

The security model can sometimes impair the business model, so a balancing the two requires knowledge of all of the issues that impact(IT, security, risk management and business requirements)

by stress junkie

The first thought that came to my mind when I read this article is "Who was responsible for security and DR in business before IT existed?" This article is, as amcol said, an attempt to define business security (and DR) as a function of IT. That doesn't make any sense at all.

Every component of a business should be required to form their own security (and DR) plans. Those plans may or may not require the cooperation of the IT department. Each department manager should be required to know exactly what steps they would take in order to secure their data and to recover from disaster. For example the accounting department keeps a lot of paper records such as receipts, purchase orders, payment records, et. al. What would the accounting department people do if the building burns down? They should have their own off site storage for paper records.

The same thing holds true for the sales department. They keep paper records of contracts, customer requirements, contacts, et. al. They should know what they need to do to secure the confidential information that they keep. They should also know what they would need to do to reconstruct their department after a disaster.

Business managers cannot slough off their responsibility onto the IT department. Unfortunately the article is simply verbalising the popular attitude in business that the IT department is the sole point of security and disaster recovery. This can only lead to problems when confidential data is compromised and when a business's facilities are destroyed.

by zczc23119

In all the wash up ? IF you company or corporation has a commitment to ISO Quality Assurance and they include ISO3901-2, 9000 and now 14000 and MIS has a clear and defined interlace with a Quality Assured over the entire Corporate Structure ? every IT Manager and their staff of hands on tech?s ? we are all proud people

by tony hopkinson

Every article I've seen by these guys has been lacking from a technical point of view. Haven't really figured out whether they are dumbing down for their audience of they are just f'ing stupid, but everytime I subject myself to one, my response is usually Huh ? or possibly Eh?.
Hope they print this stuff on nice soft paper, at least it will serve a purpose then.

by tony hopkinson

If you've dodged the opportunity to work for complete pratts, congratulations. In bad ones the top echelon have the authority say some one else is responsible and a responsibility to the management team to make sure it doesn't end up with any bucks.

Besides what you semed to be referring to this particular symptom of stupidity in your response.
It wasn't a poke at you anyway your comments on how to manage generally make sense.

I know what managment is supposed to do, I learnt by negative example.

by mjd420nova

The first and foremost aspect to be considered
should be security. And it should be under the control of only one manager. The IT manager has
a large set of boots to fill, so he better be good. It that same manager farms out his job to
others is an indication that he doesn't think it
matters or he doesn't know how. The data that
may or may not be sensitive should only be
accessable by that user only. Not that hard to do
and the manager of whatever department has no
nedd to see it. PERIOD

by jmgarvin

"Jay Heiser, a Gartner vice president, said the fundamental problem with a purely technical approach is that IT security professionals have no understanding of business."

With this catch all statement and meaningless feel good mumbo jumbo, you end up with just that. How in the world can he say that ANY security professional in the IT field will take a purely technical approach. Not only is this NOT done, but any security professional that does it should be fired!

As for IT folks not understanding business, I claim shenanigans. Show me the old school IT guy in the dark room with the "Got Root" shirt any mangy looking pony tail and I'll show you 10 managers that don't have a clue as to how IT works or what it does.

And this statement made me stop reading:
""We don't consider managing the firewall to be our day-to-day job. We don't have people doing that within our organization. We are now working on a strategic level," he said."

WHAT!!?? WTF does "we are now working on a strategic level" mean!??? So what? Now you don't have to maintain your security? Magic security gnomes come in at night and fix everything?

by hal 9000

Those Gnomes are actually called Microsoft Managed Computing and use a MS Server Farm to secure your Data and only charge you a small fee. :^O

Actually the only person who I've ever seen talk that way about Security are those who know absolutely nothing at all about it the Heads of Big Business they know what they want but not how to achieve it. I still remember the "Paperless Office" but as yet haven't seen one. :D

Col ]:)

by jmgarvin

I've yet to see an office that even lets you think about being paperless. All the forms and TPS reports must be filed IN PAPER!

You are right though. Not only do we have the big cheeses spouting out feel good phrases, but they wonder why the synergy isn't flowing to achive a new paradigm! ;-)

by rascal1981

Seriously, is this really that big of a surprise that someone would write this garbage? I understand the concern that techies may not have the best business approaches in mind when designing things but does the solution really reside in outsourcing or a senior manager who has no technical skills or desire to learn? Yeah, that's who I want leading me into battle, the guy with no general experience..... Seriously companies today are more worried about the bottom line dollar now then the future outlook (which would explain why companies like GM are suffering in their respective markets today). But I digress and ask again, does this truly surprise anyone?

by tony hopkinson

I once read a Gartner article. Now if it say's Gartner at the top and isn't followed by 'are crap' , then I assume its crap. They lived up to expectations again with this one.
Harry Potter school of IT, upgrade your f'ing wand.

by jmgarvin

Now, they just spout off about server consolidation and IT streamlining (whatever that means).

Why can't anyone focus on making IT better, not just cheaper?

by tony hopkinson

More like cost effective in the near future in order to maximise shareholder value.

Oh that means cheaper does it. Why didn't they just say so then.

If you carried this philosophy all the way through the business the MD would be on 14k a year and his company car would be a Lada. Bet Gartner don't try to sell that.

by jmgarvin

:-)

Gartner tries to hide their agenda in corporate speak and techy mumbo jumbo.

I think everyone agrees corporations are in it for the money (make more profit), but come on...you have to SPEND money to MAKE money (or so the saying goes).

by hal 9000

But spend it in the right areas at the coal face and not at the top end where no money is actually made. It's the lowerly Techs who are the ones facing the nasty comments and abuse when the MD makes a decision on what the company is going to do and how it is going to do things. For some strange reason they are not the ones facing the constant stream of complaints like the mugs who have to carry out their wishes are even when we all know that they are WRONG and will cost the company market share and eventually send it broke.

Whatever happened to the long term view where the good of the company was put first and profits while important where a secondary consideration as a heap of shares in a non-functioning/Bankrupt company isn't a very good out come for the share holders either is it? ;(

At one place when I heard a complaint I just said "It's not my fault I was told to do this ring So & So and I gave them their phone number the direct one that wasn't covered by his secretary to run interference for him. :D

Could be part of the reason why I was constantly sent to the "Sin Bin" as punishment! And the MD had hin direct number constantl;y changed. :P

Col ]:)

by rwhite

Eventhough IT has been running the "company" and protecting it's productivity tools, also IT has been taking the heat for it's downfall, but no credit for it's success. I think it's time that IT stop taking on this responsibility alone and let the true "Business Managers and Executives take full responsibility for poor budgeting, red tape, and poor vision when the IT dept recomends a good policy to secure or enhance business productivity.

by beads

As it has been said before: The paperless office will come into being right after the "Paperless Toilet"

- beads

by hal 9000

Over here being "Sin Binned" at work means you get all the nasty jobs that no one else wants to even contemplate doing. ;)

IBM had a subsidiary called Martec who supplied Fuel Injection Systems for the then race cars and it was a place that was considered as the worst place to be sent for "Crimes Against the Company" all the electronic engineers could only handle the place for a few weeks so when I started repairing Main Frame Boards as one company was down to less than 50% of capacity instead of slapping me on the wrists for making the company way too much money for virtually no cost I was sent to Martec as punishment. What those that where the Powers That Be 'Namely the Accounting Section' forgot was that I wasn't just an Electronic Engineer but had first got a degree in Mechanical Engineering and had formed a company who designed built and maintained Race Cars so I was in Heaven having to work week ends as an honored guest of all the race teams during the season and basically picking my nose when the season was over as there was very little work to do so I was went around to all of the race teams here and offered assistance as required. They even paid me to do this! I think that they where a bit confused when I wasn't making protests to be returned as QLD Service Manager for the computer section in a few weeks and after 6 months they where getting a bit worried and sent up my immediate Boss to find out what it was that I was doing. Over a few drinks I suggested that he look over my CV and just got drunk with him. :)

Instead of the desired punishment I considered it as a reward as I was back where I loved to be at the sharp end of the Race Scene and being a Honored Guest of all the teams. It's hard work but someone has to do it. :p

I believe that my boss went and kicked some buts back in head office as they couldn't get me back to the position that I once held as I was happier where they had sent me and while the pay was the same the working conditions where way better and I was dealing with friends so why would I want to return to the hard work which they had employed me for and then wrapped me over the knuckles for doing? :)

But it has happened quite a few times now I get given the nasty jobs as punishment for some perceived breach of company policy and end up learning far more from doing that work. While I was working my way through Uni I trod on some toes at a job that I had and was presented with over 700 sewing machines that had been underwater in the 74 Floods to get them into a salable condition for the insurers ever after that I could strip and rebuild these thing's with a blindfold on and just went by feel. That was the start of the whole thing and I learned so much from that single experience that I kept doing things like that just for the fun of it. Things like writing new code for security protocols and the like as things needed to be done what they thought of as punishment I saw as a chance to learn and it made me better at the job so I was all for it. :^O

IBM where just one of the places who lost out badly the accountant who was responsible for sending me away for a term of punishment was given the job of making me return to my old job and he couldn't understand why I wasn't interested and even worse would never give an undertaking never to repair another board again. At the time we had no stock in AU of these boards that where failing and out of trying to keep a customer happy I grudgingly said that I would have a look at one of the boards and see if I could find the problem instead of waiting for the failed units to be sent to the US repaired and returned along with our stock of replacement parts which had all failed. The first one took about 4 hours to find the fault on and all the rest only took a few minutes in replacing a PNP transistor on the Power Regulator side of the board. I was charging them out at the reco cost and when the accountant came up questioned why I was showing a stock level of -65. Well we all know that computers never tell a LIE don't we? Instead of being happy with this he was upset and quite markedly probably because the boards that I fixed didn't break again so in the long term it was costing them money in not being able to sell spare parts, but the customers where so happy that it was generating more sales and once the word got around I was getting service calls from most of the East Coast of AU and being asked on what was needed to upgrade their existing systems. At that time a Tech wasn't supposed to be selling hardware other than a few spare parts and certainly not complete systems. But as I constantly said "you employed me to repair and promote your products so why shouldn't I do my job?" :D

Some people are never happy though. :p

Col ]:)

This discussion is closed to new replies.