Discussion Locked

DOWNLOAD: 13 useless interview questions... and what you should ask instead

0 helpful
28 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5138-10878-5941882.html

After you take a look at this download, please post your feedback, ideas for improvements, or further thoughts on this topic.

Thanks,
--The TechRepublic Downloads Team

28 replies

by bob gately

Interviewers need not be good at interviewing as the 13 questions demonstrate. A good rule to follow is: If it isn't a job related questions don't ask it. We ask all job applicants 318 questions but none of the 13 are included.

by compguy

What can it possibly take 318 questions to determine? The GMAT manages to get by with 78 questions and two essays.

Assuming it takes an average of 30 seconds per question for you to ask the question and get an answer, you're looking at better than 2.5 hours in the interview. If you start asking questions that require any kind of thought or detailed answer, you're going to stretch into an awful long day. While that may be appropriate for some positions, it's a little over the top for most.

I don't know what your interview procedures are like, but I'd much rather keep interviews shorter (an hour or so) and ask questions that require some thought put into the answer.

One of the best questions we came up with (accidentally) was for a programming position. The database had some historical design idiosyncracies. For one question, we described some of the structure of the database and asked the candidate how he would design a procedure to generate an invoice from that data. Candidates who asked "What is an invoice?" were pretty easy to eliminate. With the others we got to see a little bit of their critical thinking and design skills.

by amcol

You really think he meant literally 318 questions? No chance he was just engaging in a little hyperbole to make a point?

I love the mathematical analysis, however. No matter how flawed your premise.

by bob gately

Hello Compguy:

Thanks for a well-thought out response.

>What can it possibly take 318 questions to determine?<

Which qualified to be hired job applicant(s) will be successful if hired.

>The GMAT manages to get by with 78 questions and two essays.<

But the GMAT doesn't tell us who will become a successful employee.

>Assuming it takes an average of 30 seconds per question for you to ask the question and get an answer, you're looking at better than 2.5 hours in the interview.<

You know the old saying about assuming. It takes about an hour to annswer the questions. Some people do it in less time and some take more time.

>If you start asking questions that require any kind of thought or detailed answer, you're going to stretch into an awful long day.<

These questions are read and answered on the Internet.

>While that may be appropriate for some positions, it's a little over the top for most.<

We find the 318 questions work for all jobs at all levels. Given the cost of a bad hire it cheap insurance against making a bad hire.

>I don't know what your interview procedures are like, but I'd much rather keep interviews shorter (an hour or so) and ask questions that require some thought put into the answer.<

Yes, and face-to-face interviews are notorious for not identifying future top performers.

>Candidates who asked "What is an invoice?" were pretty easy to eliminate. With the others we got to see a little bit of their critical thinking and design skills.<

Why settle for a litle bit?

by amcol

Hard to believe that anyone in a position of authority and responsibility in any organization, someone charged with filling an open position, would be foolish enough to ask any of the questions on this list. Call me naive.

This document is OK as far as it goes but it once again demonstrates TR's negative bias. You're forever issuing missives on how NOT to do something, with only a smattering of the right way to do anything. I'd love to see a better balance.

Here's my contribution to how to do this right. Some useful interview questions I typically ask, which others have told me they don't generally hear at interviews:

1. What does "consultative mindset" mean to you? (I believe almost every technical professional needs to think and act like a consultant in order to be successful and I like to guage what candidates think that means.)

2. Are you a technologist or a business person? (Tells me a lot about how the candidate will operate...do you want to just play with toys or are you interested in participating in achieving strategic goals and objectives.)

3. Tell me about a time when you had to interface with someone difficult to work with. (I ask for specifics...tells me a lot about working style and how the candidate will fit in with established team dynamics.)

4. What?s your idea of the perfect job? (Indicates how much of a disconnect there might be between the candidate's expectations and the opportunity I'm offering.)

5. Tell me about an idea you had and how you sold it to your management. (Great guage of initiative and communication ability.)

6. What do you want to learn? (Most people flounder with this one because it's out of left field, but it says a lot about how entrenched people get in their own comfort zones...or not.)

7. Why do you want this job? (I want to know the candidate has done some research on my organization and wants to contribute to the mission, and isn't just looking for a paycheck or a stepping stone to something else.)

by too old for it

In the last year: 3, 5, and 8. Number 3 seems to be a (Central Ohio) favorite.

There are worse. I had a phone interview mere days ago, where the "interviewer" (a) had called me and (b) had me on speakerphone in a room with an echo. His first question? "I have your resume. May I know who it is I am speaking to?"

Your number 2 is interesting, as your comments would seem to infer that unless you are a business person, you just want to spend the IT budget on "toys" (as opposed to the server that will actually deliver the most reliable performance per watt of electricity used). I think there is a place for both; however I would also keeping the technologists satisfied is a far more difficult task in a large organization, especially if the raises/promotions/respect tend to go to only to the business side. (This isn't new: The aerospace company I worked at right after the Marine Corps in `78 had the same problem. The only way you got a promotion was to go to another firm. Then they would hire you back for a more senior position. Crazy times.)

Number 4, the perfect job? Bill Gates job. I want to drive technology trends, and get paid billions to do it.

by amcol

I don't think folks who define themselves as pure techie only want to buy toys, but I have found that anyone in any professional discipline who thinks of himself/herself as being solely a fill-in-the-blank generally is not in a position to maximize the value they can add to the organization. To do so requires a more well rounded thought process and a mindset for thinking outside the fill-in-the-blank box, to use an overused expression.

by btljooz

Most of those are dumb. ALL are just plain deceitful as worded. Why can't you just come out with the DIRECT POINT??? If you want a DIRECT ANSWER then ask a DIRECT Question!!!

>1. What does "consultative mindset" mean to you? (I believe almost every technical professional needs to think and act like a consultant in order to be successful and I like to guage what candidates think that means.)<

Thank you for explaining that;) This was the ONE question/answer that gave me anything but heartburn!

>2. Are you a technologist or a business person? (Tells me a lot about how the candidate will operate...do you want to just play with toys or are you interested in participating in achieving strategic goals and objectives.)<

uuuhhhmmm....why can't a person want to do BOTH?!?!?!???

>3. Tell me about a time when you had to interface with someone difficult to work with. (I ask for specifics...tells me a lot about working style and how the candidate will fit in with established team dynamics.)<

We are all ONLY humans! Yes, it's HOW we handle certain things that counts! That's a no brainer.:|

>4. What?s your idea of the perfect job? (Indicates how much of a disconnect there might be between the candidate's expectations and the opportunity I'm offering.)<

Do you want the REAL truth or the fantasy you 'just want to hear'???

The REAL truth is one where I can make enough money to survive in this world where I don't have to worry about being fired for ONLY BEING HUMAN!!!

Your fantasies? I don't give a ratz azz about your fantasies! That's the TRUTH!!!

>5. Tell me about an idea you had and how you sold it to your management. (Great guage of initiative and communication ability.)<

DUH!!! THAT'S what an interview is for!!!:|

>6. What do you want to learn? (Most people flounder with this one because it's out of left field, but it says a lot about how entrenched people get in their own comfort zones...or not.)<

EVERYTHING!!!!:D

>7. Why do you want this job? (I want to know the candidate has done some research on my organization and wants to contribute to the mission, and isn't just looking for a paycheck or a stepping stone to something else.)<

I don't care about researching your organization you egotist!!! If I didn't want to contribute to your organization in a meaningful manner I wouldn't be applying for the job! And what the #3|| is WRONG with NEEDING a paycheck to survive in this world in the 'Day of the Moneychangers'??? After all, the only reason YOU are in business is for MONEY!!! Why shouldn't your employees expect a share of that??? Your GREED??? NOT!!! And you're ego is yet again affraid of being stepped on by being a 'stepping stone'??? EVERTHING changes...even Mother Earth, herself.

GET down out of that Zergot you've built and join REALITY!!!!

by albanypmp

A good start, but there must be many more. I know personnally I have been asked some really stupid ones.

by too old for it

(the late 70's) the hippies who made it into industry still asked the tree question: If you were a tree, what kind of tree would you be?

My answer? A pine tree from a manged forest, so I would be at least good for something.

by compguy

I'll agree that it's possible it was hyperbole, but he could have been completely serious. I've dealt with companies where the 318 question scenario wouldn't surprise me.

by compguy

> These questions are read and answered on the Internet.

This changes the context quite a bit. A written set (which is effectively what they're getting) of 318 questions is completely from an in-person interview with 318 questions.

by amcol

For directing my sarcastic disbelief to the wrong person. Allow me to correct my error.

As a hiring manager I have never, ever given an interview in which I came prepared with more than a dozen questions and ended up asking a dozen or two more beyond that for clarification, depending on the answers I got. A small number of on point, thought provoking, information eliciting questions are all that's needed to determine if a candidate is the right fit for any job.

You're asking 318 questions and getting responses to all of them in an hour. You either have a broken clock and you're actually taking a LOT more time than that, or you're getting only the most superficial of answers on which you can't possibly base an intelligent hiring decision.

OK, let's say I'm wrong and you can actually do this. As a candidate for one of your positions your speed interviewing technique says a lot to me about your management style and your corporate culture. No thanks, not interested.

by bob gately

Hello amcol:

>A small number of on point, thought provoking, information eliciting questions are all that's needed to determine if a candidate is the right fit for any job.<

Tha face-to-face interview is not very effective at identifying future successful employees. Here are the correlation coefficients I have seen reported for various methods of selecting future successful employees:
0.00 for a Flip of a Coin
0.14 for an Interview Only
0.26 after adding Background Checks
0.38 after adding Personality Testing
0.54 after adding Abilities Testing
0.66 after adding Interest Testing
0.75 after adding Talent Matching

plus a few random ones...

0.18 for Job Experience (years)
0.38 for Unstructured Interviews
0.41 for Integrity Tests
0.51 for General Mental Ability Tests
0.51 for Structured Interviews
0.54 for Work Sample Tests

>You're asking 318 questions and getting responses to all of them in an hour.<

Some people take more time while some people take less time.

>You either have a broken clock and you're actually taking a LOT more time than that, or you're getting only the most superficial of answers on which you can't possibly base an intelligent hiring decision.<

There is another alternative, you have no idea what we do or why it works.

>OK, let's say I'm wrong<

Keep an open mind.

>and you can actually do this.<

Every day there are more than 40,000 employers doing it as I described, see example below.

>As a candidate for one of your positions your speed interviewing technique<

It is not an interview. Candidates can select the best answer or leave the answer blank.

>says a lot to me about your management style and your corporate culture. No thanks, not interested.<

Yes, it speaks volumes about the culture. It takes a special person to get a job offer. Job applicants who get job offers become successful, long-term employees. For many employers that is worth the risk of losing a few obstreperous job seekers who think they are above being screened for job suitabiity.

A Software Development Example:

The HR Manager for a software development company hired for talent for over two years and then stopped for two years because the two owners thought they could do a better job of selecting successful Technical Support Analysts (TSA) than Sonja, their HR Manager. TSAs go to the client's workplace and identify the programming errors and then reprogram the software.

The owners felt too restricted by the talent selection process. After two years of doing it themselves they went to Sonja's office and told her "Start using the your talent method again, you are much more successful at hiring good TSAs than we are." The owners could not duplicate her success rate, not bad for just an HR Manager. Sonja took a risk when she first tried the talent selection process.

Employers over rely on face-to-face interviews and qualifications. The goal should be to hire competent people, not necessarily the most competent, who will become successful employees. The best I can tell a resume never actually does any work.

by compguy

> It is not an interview.

Precisely. We're trying to compare apples to oranges on this thread.

The original article was about in-person interview questions. Although you ask 318 questions, you're not doing an "interview" as the article describes it.

by amcol

Sometimes I'm a little slow, so help me out here.

Are you saying your interview technique involves administering written tests, with little to no reliance on face to face interviews? That you make hiring decisions on the basis of the results of these tests, again with little to no input from a personal interview?

by too old for it

... wastes of time.

When looking at people in my age range, a background check usually only brings up events from a wayward youth that have no bearing on the position in question.

But since that question was changed on the TOPS employment application from "in the last 7 years" to "ever", HR can just shitcan perfectly good candidates based on that, and no one will be the wiser.

(Disclaimers about a "yes" answer not being an automatic bar to employment notwithstanding. It's a lie; we all know it's a lie.)

If the current president can get drunk in college, the last president can impotune women while governor, and the president of Russia can be a former communist and have tortured people in the KGB, does it really matter if a 40+ year old candidate for a sysadmin job had a little trouble with his checkbook in college?

by bob gately

Hello amcol:

>How long does your entire interview process take?<

I don't get involved in the interviews only the assessments.

by bob gately

Hello amcol:

>Are you saying your interview technique involves administering written tests<

Yes.

>with little to no reliance on face to face interviews?<

Not at all. Only qualified to be hired job applicants, i.e., the job finalists, are tested which means they have been through at least one face-to-face interview if not many more.

by too old for it

The bad part is, I have a copy of an official ruling from the EEOC that allows a local employer to discriminate against someone 50+ as long as they hire somene 35+

I gues the 50-something didn't axe the right questions.

by amcol

How long does your entire interview process take? I'm talking from the time you identify a candidate as a possible by reviewing their resume to the time you're ready to make an actual offer.

While you're at it...you said you administer numerous face to face interviews. How many, and who do you include as interviewers?

by victoree

Well, well, well, now the cover is off for all and sundry to see! So, interviewers are human after all; they don't have all knowledge and they say silly stuff at times. I had a suspicion that some of the stock questions asked in interviews were as useless and misguided as the equally stupid answers I tried to look good giving. It's gamining, isn't it, this interviewing thing...I knew I wasn't crazy! That proves it!

by scott.pletcher

It's true that you cannot ask "Have you ever been arrested?" You *can*, however, ask "Have you ever been convicted of a crime?"

Similarly, you cannot ask "How old are you?" but you can ask someone for their birth date (because birth date is needed for proper record keeping).

Finally, the point of the question about "the last book you read" is not whether they like Stephen King or any other author. It's to see if they do read and, perhaps, if they enjoy reading. Tech jobs still *require* a lot of reading. Hiring someone who replies "Oh, I never read", would be a serious error.

by other_native

why not just ASK if they like to read?

All this weaving and bobbing -- interviews seem more like a sparring match or an a$skissing appraisal.

Personally, I find most job interviews demoralizing. Being a 50+ latin-american woman I can get racists comments that range from icy superiority to veiled inappropriate sexual comments.

How did I get my job? I temped; did the job and was asked to come back on a permanent basis. No interview, except to talk salary. Period. It should always be THAT easy to find a job you love and get paid to do it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.