In the context of hiring, HR wear two hats.
On the one hand, they act as an internal service provider to whomever in the company needs to hire. They are responsible for advertising for, filtering, and validating applicants.
On the other hand, they act to ensure that the company fully complies with all relevant employment law, such as sex, age, and disability discrimination.
This compliance task is hard (and getting harder) but enormously important. Do you really want a six-figure fine, and an embarrasment of publicity, because a wheelchair using applicant couldn't even get to the interview room?
So let's be wary of dissing HR!
In respect of the first task, clearly HR can only provide a service that's as good as the information provided to them. And as I see it, that's all this download is really emphasising. It's just saying that the more detail you give to HR about what you want, the better the service they'll be able to provide.
In my experience, the biggest stumbling block on the path to recruiting talent is not HR, but the people who write the job specs.
In particular, the way in which a job spec is divided into REQUIRED and DESIRABLE qualifications, experience, etc. This issue is referred to in the download.
For example, I recently saw a job spec for a Technical Support Manager. It required that any applicant have at least 3 years experience as a Tech Support Manager of a department of at least 6 people. In other words, the IT Director (who wrote the job spec) considered that only applicants with this background would be capable of doing the job.
To my mind, this is a nonsense.
There are a great many people, from a wide diversity of backgrounds, who will be capable of doing this job. By artificially restricting the job specification in this way, you prevent these people from applying. In consequence, you will never be able to benefit from the new ideas, different perspectives, and synergisms of these people.
If, on the other hand, you list "3 years experience as a Tech Manager" as DESIRABLE, then you're saying that an applicant with that experience will have a head-start over other applicants, and that other applicants will have to be particularly impressive in other areas in order to compensate for their lack of experience. But you still leave open their ability to apply, and that you'll consider applicants on the basis of their ability to actually do the job.