Discussion Locked

DOWNLOAD: Compression and QoS appliances: Can they speed up your network?

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5138-10594-5649478.html

After you take a look at this download, please post your feedback, ideas for improvements, or further thoughts on this topic.

Thanks,
TechRepublic Downloads Team

4 replies

by jaqui

they also made 2 mistakes with basic concept in the network.
if running something like citrix, you definately do not want to have a multimedia website, you want something much more basic.

also, since the citrix system is a critical system, they should concider having it on it's own dedicated internet connection. ( customer satifaction has to be important, if the site goes down or is real slow then customer not happy )

the limited viewpoint of just plugging a compression device in, instead of looking at things like apache's mod_gzip, that will compress pages being sent whenever the client's browser can inflate the data on receipt. this in not a perfect solution, but it will reduce usage of data transfer automatically, maybe removing the need for further measures.

I just don't understand why you have to track every screen motion in real time across an internet connection.

by ddavis2

Jaqui,
I appreciate your comments and opinions on the article.
Just to clarify some of the points you bring up-
When you said that "if running something like citrix, you definitely do not want to have a multimedia website, you want something much more basic.", I completely agree. Unfortunately, my users are using Citrix, over the Wide-Area network, as their computer. Thus, just like you, they want to surf the Internet. I cannot limit them to going to only websites that have basic text. They want to go to every website on the Internet, just like you and I do. Many websites today use Flash for their basic navigation buttons, thus, I must provide Flash. Even if a company is not doing Citrix in this method, the same concept would apply to an application like VoIP.
Your second point was that we should have a dedicated Internet connection for Citrix. My Citrix is not going over the Internet but going over a private WAN. My customers are my employees. Thus, they might be allowed to suffer a bit more than a company like amazon.com would let their customers suffer with slow network response. Also, buying dedicated bandwidth for every critical application is usually not cost effective- at least for a privately held, family run company like mine. We usually try everything possible to optimize what we have by doing things like compression and QoS.

Thanks for the tip on apache's mod_gzip. I will read up on that. I had not heard of that.

Concerning your question about why I have to track every screen motion- this is how Microsoft's terminal server and Citrix work. It is comparable to something like PCAnywhere or VNC, if you are familiar with those. It doesn't work like a webpage. The program the user is using is actually running on another computer, somewhere else, across a LAN or WAN. The device that the user is on is only VIEWING the program's screen. The user's keyboard input and mouse movement is sent back to the server to change the display on their screen. I have 400 users that do this, daily, to use all Windows applications.

I hope that I have clarified some of your questions and have not sounded like I was being argumentative. Again- I appreciate your comments and your input.

Thanks for reading TechRepublic!
David Davis

by jdhenderson

We have been looking at using hardware accelerators for our remote sites/users to improve Citrix performance over WAN (Internet VPN) connections. I note your comment 'the limited viewpoint of just plugging a compression device in, instead of looking at things like apache's mod_gzip, that will compress pages being sent whenever the client's browser can inflate the data on receipt. this in not a perfect solution, but it will reduce usage of data transfer automatically, maybe removing the need for further measures.' Can you add to this? Do you know how to turn Citrix compression off for some sites but not for others (Presentation Server 3)? It seems to be rather all or nothing ....

Thanks

by ddavis2

I am the author of the article, not the person who commented on using mod_gzip but I wanted to make a comment to your post.

Yes, as far as I know, citrix compression is supposed to be able to be turned off per server but I am not an expert on that.

In my tests of using compression hardware, we were asked by the hardware vendor to disable citrix compression on the server. In our case, it didn't seem to make much difference.

As far as using something like mod_gzip to compress web pages, I don't see how this makes a difference to a citrix client. The web browser isn't really the interface that the client is using for citrix- it is the citrix client.

That is just my $0.02, I welcome anyone else's comments.

-David Davis

This discussion is closed to new replies.