Discussion Locked

DOWNLOAD: Interview strategies for fighting age bias

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5138-10593-5655482.html

After you take a look at this download, please post your feedback, ideas for improvements, or further thoughts on this topic.

Thanks,
--The TechRepublic Downloads Team

16 replies

by amcol

Since I'm in the age group to which this information has the greatest potential use, I'll add my two cents' worth.

First...this is principally directed at support and development professionals. Middle or higher levels of management aren't immune from age discrimination but the manifestations and proper responses are entirely different.

Taking each of your questions in the order they appear in the download:

1. Good advice for anyone, not just older workers. You need to make this more personal to that age group. For example, talk about the business value your services provided your previous employers...show your potential new employer that you understand the strategic synergy between technology and business, that you understand exactly how you contributed to that, and how you'd do so in the new environment.

2. Trick question, as you point out. Good advice on how to respond.

3. The moment this question is asked, run for the exit. This is not a company you want to work for. I'm not entirely certain you're correct that it's not illegal, but even if it isn't you are correct about one thing...it's monumentally stupid.

4. Another trick question, and the one that interviewers use to weed people out. Depending on how you answer you can come across as desperate or under-confident, neither of which are qualities any company values. You didn't point out that younger hiring managers are also intimidated at the thought they might be hiring their own replacement, you might want their job before they're ready to give it up, or you might fight them for control.

5. Good interview question, and good advice on how to respond.

6. Not relevant to older workers but to anyone who has a recent gap on their resume. It's also not relevant to most IT workers, who typically don't take a long term career hiatus only to return to the fold when old and decrepit. I'd leave this one out.

7. Another monumentally stupid question, another one that's a clear signal it's time to say "Check, please", and another one that I'm reasonably certain is illegal.

8. Not a stupid question but certainly one that sends up a red flag about the organization. Why DON'T they have more older workers? What's wrong with this culture? The question isn't would this bother you, the question is why would you want to work there? You're being told in advance your age and experience are a detriment. Bye bye.

9. Yet another question everyone has to answer regardless of age. Avoid answering at all costs, not only for the reasons you give but also in the event you get an offer you've given away your entire negotiating position.

Here's a couple I'd add:

- Why have you not pursued opportunities to move further up the career ladder? Older workers face this one all the time, especially from the ambitious and suspicious young pups who can't imagine that EVERYONE doesn't want to be Chairman of the Board. The proper response is to say you love what you do, you're extremely good at it, you feel you can provide the highest value to the organization by doing the kind of work for which you're best suited, and be prepared to show specific examples to prove your point.

- What are your retirement plans? One of the trickiest of the trick questions because it throws you off guard. Proper answer...I don't have any. Then shut up.

by advancedgeek

Young people get age discrimination too.

I got my first IT job when I was 18. I had already been working on hardware/software for 5 years (work for free). I came into this job and knew more than anyone else I worked with. I worked there for two years and never got a raise, and never moved up the chain...

Was I not a hard worker? I was the best configuration tech they'd ever had, and they openly admitted it. When it came time for bonuses or raises I was skipped over for people that knew FAR less than me (I showed this guy his first hdd) and he was hired 6 months AFTER me. I came to work on time every day...I was the model employee. He was often late, and complained about working. - But it wasn't just him, there was lots of other employees that got raises, while I was passed over.

I think that b/c of my age I was passed over for better positions/better pay. I even took it to the boss, and he said i was "too young" to get a raise. Oh if I knew then what I know now.

I am now 23, and I still get discriminated on. I am an important person at my job, I have meetings that wait on me, and I have 5 people that work for me, and when they meet me for the first time they always say "How old are you?!" MY GOD it gets old.

I am more professional than you, I know infinately more than you, I deserve respect-despite my age.

by amcol

First, and most important...no one DESERVES respect. You EARN it. Every day, day after day. And make no mistake, it's a lot easier to earn DISrespect than it is to earn respect.

We've all been where you are, which is to say young and just starting out. What you've identified as reverse age discrimination is more likely a reaction to attitude, as in a bad one.

I'm sure you're as good at your job as you say you are. Not the issue. Your attitude comes through your writing loud and clear. And if I have no trouble noticing it, what makes you think you're coming across any differently to the people you work with and for on a regular basis? Not the best way to distinguish yourself.

It's very easy to blame that over which we have no control. Someone at age 55+ doesn't get hired and screams age discrimination. The reality is that for any number of reasons they weren't qualified for the position, but facing that reality and doing something about it isn't as easy and certainly not as much fun as saying the 30 year old hiring manager must've had it in for anyone his or her father's age.

You've got plenty of time to play the age card. Don't start now...you've got other issues you need to deal with.

by advancedgeek

I have a great attitude! Might be a little angry at the fact I just found out I owe $8000.00 in taxes (ouch)...but I am a happy go lucky employee that everyone always loves. That, perhaps, is my problem...I get too close to the people I work for, and they must think they can walk on me.

As for the respect...I do earn it. I say deserve, because I earn it, but do not always receive it. I am a seasoned system administrator with 5 years of experience...i'm not just starting out. I have been through two different wars (Iraq, and Afghanistan), and a nuclear bomb plant doing what I do, and I have worked my way up from the bottom stacking boxes.

What gets me is people that judge a book by it's cover. Yes I am young, but I have been there, and done that. A good example is a commander here at the place I work and I were talking about my experiences and he says "Oh, I thought you were just some punk kid out of college." ...it's that kind of disrespect that I recieve, and it looks like you, amcol, are guilty of it as well.

by bmanf77brc

I have found after 12 yrs in management that the
person with a degree has established athority in their field no matter what age. Having a degree in management will open doors for you. Dont wait until its too late.

Bruce

by amcol

Because what you and I are talking about is not what this thread is about.

You're pretty thin skinned. In no way did I disrespect you, which confirms for me that the reason you're missing out on promotions and rewards has nothing to do with your age. The callouses that come with maturity will do you some good.

by stress junkie

Each of the points in the article presents a valid issue that one is likely to encounter in an interview and some hints about how to respond. I'd say that the article is generally useful. One thing that I would like to have seen done differently was in item 8. Here the article says to know your rights under the ADEA. It would have been nice to have spelled out the words instead of using an acronym, and it would have been even better to include a reference as to where we would find this information. As it stands it represents a research project which I think should be unnecessary, and which would be unnecessary if you had provided the information or a pointer to the information.

by jodygilbert

Excellent point -- I'm going to update the download to include a link to this fact sheet (http://www.eeoc.gov/facts/age.html), which in turn offers a link to the ADEA (Age Discrimination in Employment Act) itself.

Thanks for the suggestion!

Jody Gilbert
TechRepublic Downloads Team

by amcol

There's all different kinds of respect and all different ways one can be respected, but I was obviously talking about professional respect. This thread is about workplace issues, not social or political or anything else. Let's stay in focus.

All human beings should be respected as human beings. You earn that simply by being born. You want to call that deserving respect, fine by me.

by advancedgeek

Great point S J...I agree 100%. I show other people respect no matter the age, and should recieve it back.

/me initiates slow clap

:D

by oded1

1. you have to get to the interview first.
2. the agency will probably not submit you.
3. the agency usually asks for Date Of Birth.
4. salary question hardly ever is asked in interview in UK.
5. young team comes up in the advert when 6 months experience is enough.
I wonder if this was written by a UK or USA person.

Oded Szpiro C.Eng., MBCS

by yeoman

I found these tips useful, particularly the first two, but I am convinced that nothing will overcome age bias in a hiring manager or recruitment agency. In Australia you do not have to provide your age nor will you ever be asked (only fools would ask!) By the experience you state on your resume you will disclose your approximate age. As oded states, you have to get to the interview first.

If you do get to an interview it would suggest there is no age bias, but there may be some apprehension as to how you would fill the role. I was once interviewed by a manager who was recruiting a 2ic, but he was so obviously uneasy that I had much more experience than he had. Perhaps I should have broached the subject with him to help him overcome his fears.
Salary is usually determined by budget. If there is age bias you will not get the job even if you accept half the pay.

My experience in Australia indicates the following are of value.
1. It makes a huge difference if you know someone in the organisation. Because of the intangibles in assessing whether someone is suitable or not, having someone who has worked with you and known your abilities is a great asset, and age does not come into the picture. ?Networking? is the key.
2. Relevant experience. If you have specific experience that an employer is looking for the agents will be pushing you forward urgently. E.g., in IT project work any experience with Sarbanes-Oxley, Basel II or IFRS is currently highly valued. Also experience in an ERP product such as SAP, Peoplesoft, JD Edwards. Of course, this is a Catch-22 situation.
3. Being able to read people (not my strength). It seems to me that ?successful? job applicants can read the interviewer(s) and play to their desires and fears. Although we are encouraged to find out as much as we can about the company we are applying to, a couple of times I think I learnt too much and probed too deeply, thus frightening off the interviewer.
Well, that?s my experience, and after being retrenched over two years ago I have only worked on short-term contracts.

by kyle

I can't tell you how many it management jobs I get turned down for simply because on some days, I still look like I am in high school (and it has nothing to do with my clothing.)

by justjoel99

I have several years of experience and training in management of technologists, and have always received high praise and evaluation around my ability to do so.

I was recently interviewed via phone for a management position at a **major** consumer electronics firm. I was asked to meet the unit director in person for a second interview, and was in her office for no more than 5 minutes before she let me know that she didn't think that my experience and qualifications meet the position' requirements.

Never mind the fact that it wasn't a problem for them to call me for an interview from my resume, or that my experience was discussed with the recruiter during the phone interview.

I went over the interview in my mind to try and determine if I had said or done anything for her to cut the interview so short, when I thought about the three other managers whom I met while waiting for the director to be available. They were all at least 10 years older than I am. I also look much younger than my 30 years, though a quick glance at the education portion of my resume will tip my hand toward my age.

The director recommended that I interview for a tech support position that would be one rung down the ladder from the position I had originally applied for. Wanting to be a team player, I agreed, and was interviewed by three people in my general age range or younger. Needless to say, I was overqualified for the position, the duties would have me bored in a week, and the salary was 1/3 of what I need to support my family.

I joked with some colleagues about needing to dye a touch of gray to my temples when I go in for interviews, but I really need to figure out how I can get past that bias against youth in regard to management positions.

This discussion is closed to new replies.