Good stuff all.
Becky, I agree with what you are saying. Although I do trust those Great leaders I have met, I will not follow them ?anywhere?. I have my own morality, conscience, vision to guide me, and not a ?Jonestown mentality?. Your point is well taken. There are organizations and companies who employ psychological techniques to manipulate their people and maintain control or dominate. That is not leadership that is control, plain and simple. A leader inspires, supports and provides vision to name a few. But a leader is not a servant, at least not to the individual. A servant to the cause, the organization, the entity perhaps.
J.Lupo, you are correct, the debate of leadership will continue, but perhaps we are adding a nano-bit to the understanding or at the very least, helping each other to improve and grow.
Leaders are ascribed by their accomplishments and their legacies; especially those they touch; whether individually or as a society. Leadership is not a natural ability, it a learned behavior. That learning should begin at the very least with a good mentor, and at best with accredited education. I did not intend to suggest that simple courseware would transform a person into a great leader. Education is the starting point of the journey, the formal introduction.
But sometimes promotion (or stagnation) to leadership is based on class or skill and not on ability to lead. Let me give examples: the hotshot tech promoted to team manager often becomes engrossed in solving technical problems and misses the opportunity to help the team learn and grow. Or the Engineer hired for the Director position that becomes distracted by the system details and misses the opportunity to deliver vision to the department. Good leadership from above will identify the situation and provide direction, mentoring, and education as necessary.
Amcol, I wholeheartedly agree with you ?When life with these folks becomes intolerable we move on?. That is a hallmark of a good leader. Principles. Unfortunately its existence appears limited.
Perhaps my reference to emulation should be explained better. It has been my observation that within an organization, there is a common mode of conduct / thought, a corporate / industry sector functional/organizational paradigm. That is to say, there exists a ?culture?. Humans associate in groups, clans, and societies and develop a ?culture?. Group dynamics tend to promote behaviors the group feels meet their ?standards?. Dress, language, attitude, religion. Success, perhaps survival, depends on emulating (adopting) those regional behaviors. ?When in Rome do as the Romans?. At the individual level, some generalities can be drawn if one assumes that leaders are not haphazard in their thinking. A leader is carefully selected to meet specific criteria, one of which is usually ?fit?, and fit usually has a component of being compatible with the boss. If a person wishes to succeed inside an organization, then that person had better understand the necessity of being ?compatible? with the boss. Adopt the boss?s modes. Adapt those modes to their daily regimen. Become adept at those modes, support the bosses ?way? and succeed in the organization. ?Corporate culture? where certain modes are promoted while others are discouraged. Disagree with the existing modes and it will be a whole lot less difficult to find another place to work than to be a lightening rod for change. Lightening rods get burned.
Working the equation backward? very intriguing indeed. Could this indicate the antithesis of great leadership might be dramatic (albeit short lived) growth? Could the measure of Great leadership be sustained growth? A stable foundation? Our iron/industrial economy has faltered, but we continue to grow, only now it is has a foundation on the Information sector, due in no small part to Microsoft, Sun, Oracle et al and their leadership and vision of the mid 80?s / 90?s? There?s an interesting discussion.