I think this is a good general set of criteria to evaluate on. A further step to make the form more usable and consistent between employees is to create a "rubric" for each score for each area. For example under - Communication
5-Employee's written documents are clear and consise and never need editing.
4-Employee's written documents contain a few erros and minor editing and review is required.
3-Employee's written documents require moderate review and minor restructuring
2-Employee's written documents contain gramatical errors and do not clearly communicate the intended message. Require significant editing.
1-Employee's written documents are confusing, contain extensive gramatical errors and require major revision.
These type of rubrics for each of the 5 areas need to give examples of what each scoring level consist of for that area. Addition of these rubrics significantly ease the process of assigning evaluations and increase consistancy between ratings of different employees.