education not required?!?!?!?!
to have SENIOR positions in US Government, DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY?!?!?!?
and THE WHITE HOUSE?!?!?!?
IT Employment
to have SENIOR positions in US Government, DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY?!?!?!?
and THE WHITE HOUSE?!?!?!?
by oz_media
1) It is pretty apparent from the "global-big-top" aka The White House that there is a relatively low education level in government, probably around the world and not just the current administration, although I am sure many big foppy clown shoes and red noses run rampant in The White House.
This results in the farce you see every day.
2) By the same measure, why do we value education credentials so? You don't have to have an education to make the best decisions in many cases ,for some people in some positions you do, but not all people in all positions.
For example, some people are born Olympic swimmers or runners. They will train to improve on their natural talents while in the field.
Other people train from scratch with a goal in mind, this takes a LOT more work and coaching, formal knowledge and training to pull it all together.
Some people have a natural engineering sense, they can strip down a car and rebuild a new one in no time. It takes very little school to learn the difference betweene being a backyard mechanic and then become an actual journeyman mechanic.
Someone else may strive to learn automotive but require FAR more training as it isn't a natural skill or one they have been involved with most of their lives, thus they require serious study and certification training.
Same for IT of course, some need very little training, or even just a test to pass a cert, others spend time in school tediously learning the skills.
SO how can a blanket be placed on education levels and be expected to produce the best results?
Some of the most succesful entrepeneurs and businessmen in the world are not high school grads, they just got into business and learned hands on. I would take on one of these people, given the fat chance, in a heart beat.
Yet my advertisement for a "College grad only" wouldn't get their application.
I don't see much of this in Canada, most wouldn't check your information if provided, the proof is in a persons proven ability, not paperwork or that someone stayed in school and extra five years while another went to work in the field.
I am not saying you don't need an education to succeed, but SOME of the most successful people in the world have poor education levels. Placing restrictions on the type of people you will hire, is also placing limitations on your company's ability to hire the right person for the job.
And this would also include political careers.
by jaqui
but the us givernment has a policy requiring the education, and the policy to check the cv out.
so the circus clowns were going to prove another truism.
in government you get promoted to the level of your incompetence. problem was her original post was above her level of incompetence.
by oz_media
Why have such a policy and possibly restrict a better hands-on politician from playing an important role, it just closes doors on your own hiring abilities.
I still can't get the kalaiope music out of my head now, doo-do-do doo-do-do !
.
http://www.usatoday.com/money/workplace/2003-09-28-fakedegrees_x.htm
But with many in government, WE pay for it.
http://www.fcw.com/fcw/articles/2004/0510/web-diploma-05-11-04.asp
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A18845-2004May11.html
And how about teachers?
http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2004-05-04-bogus-degrees_x.htm
by oz_media
Perhaps the root of such issues is a strict requirement that people have a certain education level or to begin with.
IN the case provided the teacher was most definitely inadequate, how many BETTER teachers would have to be overlooked because they didn't have qualifications as impressive on paper?
In this case, the requirement for paper has resulted in a useless degree. Someone that has the ability but not the paperwork may have been a better choice.
Of course I am not saying we should hire just anyone, but such a requirement should be an asset not a need. A proper interview/internship would prove the weak form the able in no time. Certainly at a higher expense but what expense is there to be considered when it comes to educating children?
I am sure I would happily accept some tax trade-off's or reallocation of government funds from other less important issues. What's less important? Many things when compared to educating children.
by salamander
...do background checks anymore? Sheesh.
Here are links to two state offices that track diploma mills, in case anybody's curious:
http://www.osac.state.or.us/oda/about.html
http://www.michigan.gov/documents/Non-accreditedSchools_78090_7.pdf
by dafe2
Holly crap, two mouse clicks and you have the whole history on someone...........a couple more and you've got the credit backround. Even a couple of discreet phone calls.
I know of a few places (In Canada) that require the employee to provide there OWN criminal record check and then they do a CSIS (Canadian Security Inteligence Service) backround check on top of that.
Scary thing to go through too.
Might want to try that at the Whitehouse huh?
Then again.....our Gov's not that far off either. LOL
by bfilmfan
What I find hysterical is the U.S. Department of Education does not accredit educational institutions and/or programs. However, the Secretary of Education is required by law to publish a list of nationally recognized accrediting agencies that the Secretary determines to be reliable authorities as to the quality of education or training provided by the institutions of higher education and the higher education programs they accredit.
Since there is no law specifying an accrediation body truly is, anyone can set up an accrediation board for these diploma mills. The list of commonly accepted national bodies are avaialble here:
http://www.ed.gov/admins/finaid/accred/accreditation_pg9.html#Title%20IV%20Recognition
And does anyone recall that the CIO of the Homeland Security Agency had a diploma mill degree?
With the rise of distance learning, it is becoming more difficult to keep track of diploma mills.
Adding to the confusion are small private colleges. I've attended 2 technical colleges for additional training that were NOT accredited by the Commission on Colleges of the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools; but, were by the IEEE's Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology (ABET). Which leads to a fight over which accreditation makes a college really valuable on your resume.
by salamander
by dafe2
If they're not doing checks & verifying credentials....what's to say they aren't doing 'reliability' checks? These are a little more intense than standard background checks but require no more "effort".
There's more to a person than education & if this person was 'creating' a degree then....what else was she hiding?
What about a criminal, credit & work history? These all prove character & reliabilty & it only takes a phone call or a mouse click and even (most) businesses do them today. Talk about lazy.
Could have a bunch of 'nuts' in there.....Did I say that out loud? LOL
Wow.
by jamesrl
I was hired by a major courier company in Canada, and had to do my own criminal record check before being signed on.
And my next employer required Governement security clearance to Secret.
I have no idea why you would find it scary. For us its comes with the territory.
James
by dafe2
I also maintain CSIS Level 3 Secret......I was being FACETIOUS in that the forms where 45 pages deep in (our) case at least and they (CSIS) also went back 20 years.....some places don't.
It's just part of the business for us too at Nuclear Plants.
by jamesrl
I used to work at AECL. Which plant are you at?
I was under the impression that CSIS only went back 7 for Secret - that was pre- 9/11 though.
Mt boss had to have Top secret.
When we were designing systems to track plutonium, I could be involved up until a certain point, and then I had to absent myself, because plutonium is top secret versus enriched uranium is secret.
James
by dafe2
Were you at chalk river?
I work with Bruce, Hydro Quebec & PLGS mostly these days.
Yes, they increased (these) requirements after 9/11....and a lot of other things ;-).......I also understand from working directly with the CSIS guys that it also depends on what they're 'customer'
wants...........would you believe they recomend 10 years for a RELIABILITY check only?
by jessie
by amcol
Let's get this straight. The article says GAO found 463 employees in the eight agencies it surveyed appearing on the rolls of the diploma factories. There are 2.5 million federal employees, but since this study focused on only eight agencies let's say that GAO actually looked at the credentials of about 16,000 people (the average federal agency employs about 2,000). So statistically the diploma purchasers as a percent of the total population were about 2.9%.
Anybody want to opine how this compares to private industry? I'd guess pretty favorably.
I'm not apologizing for the federal government (despite the fact that I am, myself, a fed) but credential inflation is nothing new. The stakes may be higher at the federal level but no organization is immune.
This isn't about the breakdown of federal bureacracy. This is about one person who had the arrogance and temerity to think she could misrepresent her background, be unqualified for her position, act like a tyrant, and get away with all of it. While the background check (such as it was) may have been flawed, the system eventually worked as it should have...she was found out and dealt with.
Separate issue...some posters are arguing that credentials, especially college degrees, are unnecessary anyway, that there are those with natural abilities who can operate just as effectively as folks who have gone through the formal education process. A good point...some of the very best technicians I've ever worked with have no certs at all other than a high school diploma.
The argument, however, is specious. In this case the job required college level credentials, something that was undoubtedly documented in the formal position description. Whether or not job seekers agree that degrees or certs need be required is irrelevant...if the organization in question has certain credentials listed as fundamental job requirements, then that's what you need to get and keep the job. I find this argument typically advanced by people who lack the credentials, and while I respect those who have made successes of themselves without benefit of formal training no one has the right to shape the rules to fit individual situations, or to use "natural ability" as a justification to circumvent the system.
BTW...there are those of us who DO have credentials who also have some natural ability as well. I'll take street smarts over book smarts anytime, but it's a mistake to underestimate anyone who has a bunch of letters after their name for any reason.
Also BTW...just because a background check isn't thorough or complete prior to an employee's start date is insufficient to condemn that system or the people who administer it. New employees are generally on a three month probation period and can be terminated for any reason (or no reason) during that time without the organization being held accountable. Sometimes it takes a little longer than just a couple of weeks to complete the checks, especially for larger organizations (think the federal government qualifies?) due to the size of the workload.
by dafe2
"but it's a mistake to underestimate anyone who has a bunch of letters after their name for any reason."
It reminded me of a close mentor of mine with a few initials behind his name. He came off as a 'good ol boy' & usually dressed the part.
If you met him on the street he could carry on a conversation with anyone about anything & make you feel like your the most important person alive...............underestimate or cross him in the board room & he'll rip you appart using his brilliant & clear mind.
It used to be comical really. Some new blood would come in all fired up & talk about how this guy wasn't the sharpest pencil in the box....they'd go into meetings half prepared and cocky only to come out looking like they'd just gotten an enema.
They all learned an important lesson about reading people & being prepared no matter what.
by jaqui
of how a company should do it.
a complete security check, criminal record check, everything done by them, before they will let you touch a single computer in the system.
to bad thier office / internet system is all windows.
yup, this telco uses windows for everything but the switching and routing.
by dafe2
Sounds like a fine tuned machine to me........even includes the finest OS available today to boot!! ;-)
It's true though, everybody should do these things
you just never know today.
by oz_media
Telus is by FAR the absolute worst Telco in Canada.
They have the most screwed up routines that it is scary. Being in telecom for quite a few years, I knew and worked with many people at Telus, still hang out with a few that I made friends with.
These guys are the absolute WORST example of how to run a business I have ever encountered. Many long term employees STILL think BCTel (a suposedly Candian company) took over EdTel and AGT in Alberta. Not realizing that once they lost ownersihp of a US company they were merged with Telus to avoid bankruptcy due to Bell. They STILL think and act like a monopoly, can't perform a business install without making the most ridiculous and costly mistakes (at the customers business losses of course), the marketing and sales staff have NO clue what they are talking about and have VERY little technical knowledge about the products, services and partners they work with.
I have been offered SEVERAL positions there over the years, with a grade 11 education and a criminal record. So much for heavy screening, they are simply too divided within themselves to possibly function right.
If it wasn't for US owned BC Tel having a monopoly for so many years, they would never have even got off the ground. They hardly service ANY major businesses in Vancouver, their equipment sales are down by leaps and bounds as businesses realize they are the most unreliable and untrustworty company in the game out west.
Telus is a good example of how NOT to run a business, the background checks and such are pure crap, I am a great example of how they are willing to hire on industry experience and not any qualifications, regardless of records.
Sorry, I assume you work for Telus so I don't mean to degrade your work but no business with any common sense is looking to them for new hardware or services.
That's why three interconnects I worked for pick up more and more Telus business every day, from customers BEGGING to never have to deal with them anymore.
I ran a crntrex program at a call center, after finding out that their digital sales reps were dropping the ball, losing deals that had already had contracts signed etc. We dropped them too.
One small issue was when i was visiting a friend who is an alliance partner representative, we needed a floorplan copied and I wasn't allowed to walk 6' to the copier to make a copy. It had to be sent downstairs, a UNION rep would then come up and make the copies as needed. Otherwise the union raises hell.
So a $20.00 hr employee that JUST MAKES PHOTO copies was needed, when either one of us could have done it in 1 minute, in th eSAME office we were in.
They are simply and industry joke I wouldn't know where to start listing their losses due to bad business practice and incompetency. THis rant doesn't even begin to itarate how they are despised by the province's business sector.
by dafe2
It's not healthy to hold stuff in. LOL
First I'm not defending Telus....I know nothing about them....Nor am I speaking about anything more than HR routines & screening here.
As far as the screening issue it's a tool like any other and the results need to be interpreted much like benchmarks in IT for example.
If you were fortunate ennough to be offered employment at Telus & they new about your history, it is possible that other things weighted in your favour and they were willing to overlook your past. (This is not uncommon) OR the offer was simply an offer to come talk and the formalities would follow (Even more common)
I'm sure a big outfit like Telus has an HR Dept that would SCREAM if someone didn't follow procedure. Industry Joke or not, people are teritorial!
Many people make offers of employment and then follow routine procedure once the offer is accepted. It's a rare event today that someone is offered a job & told to report on Monday Morning without following procedures or filling out all manner of forms not to mention the orientation.
by jaqui
I never said telus was a good company, I only said thier policy of paying for the checks, and the comprehensiveness is good.
haven't all canadians heard about telus almost losing thir license due to lousy service?
using windows to run all aspects of the business not on a mainframe? get real, no responable telco would do that.
shaw cable is another example of how bad windows does with service networks. shaw can't even configure a dhcp server to refresh ip numbers right. ( move so their inet service goes through different center and you have to rebuilt the internet connection it can't release the ip data that they gave your system )
and nope, I'm independant don't work for telus.
by rknrlkid
Here we go, another education bashing.
Let me say first tho -- that woman in the article was WRONG. She obviously misrepresented herself and did alot of backpeddling to get credentialed after the fact. The government also was wrong, because they didn't check, but I know how this works in real life, since I once worked for the government.
Having said that --
This issue simply highlights the foolishness of what goes on in our country regarding education and credentials. Accreditating agencies are private, not supervised by the DOE. The can invent their own criteria in order for a school to be accredited. There are dozens of different types of accreditation agencies, depending on the subject. So who is right?
Colleges/Universities are actually NOT required to have any form of accreditation. In fact, many private schools REFUSE to have these regional agencies involved because the end result is the school being dictated to by the government on what will be taught. This is especially true for religious schools. Does this create a situation for possible abuse? Oh sure. But being accredited doesn't guarantee quality either.
I personally sat in a class at Boston University (an accredited school) where the teacher to student ratio was 1 to 150. Do you think there was much learning going on? Nope. You taught yourself the course. I was soured on college until years later when I went to a smaller school (Cameron University, also accredited) where the student teacher ratio was about 1 to 25.
Higher Education no longer is what it used to be. Since high school has been "dumbed down" so the students can have "good self-esteem" a college degree has become what a high school diploma used to be (and that's not just my opinion either). The one thing I learned from college is that higher education is a business that sells education. Accreditation is another way of selling the school. Somehow an accredited school is "better" than a non-accredited one.
Its also a way to keep the have-nots out of your profession. (Think about it. If you want to be a lawyer, you HAVE to go to an ABA school (except in California); if you want to be a psychologist, you have to go to an APA approved school. By requiring this affiliation and accreditation, you can see why there are not many minorities in certain professions.) If you cannot afford to attend the particularly approved school, you are just out of luck. How many of you could work on computers if the criteria to be a systems administrator was an MS from MIT? How many of you would be?
Some academic disciplines do not require acceditation. Religion is a good example. Unless you are trying to become a military chaplain (or something similar) you don't need to go to an accredited school. (In fact, my guess is that the logic of the previous paragraph applies, because requiring specific course requirements of military chaplains keeps out the "religious riff-raff" who cannot afford to go to the expensive seminaries.) Some non-affiliated religious schools pride themselves on their lack of accreditation. Who knows, they could be right -- they might actually give a better education.
Paying $3500 to get a diploma with no academic work is radically different from attending a non-accredited school. I do have a problem with true diploma mills who SELL diplomas. But accreditation does not automatically guarantee anything. You can graduate from an accredited college or university and still be illiterate (it has happened).
Credential-ism is a part of the problem. Supply is only equal to demand. Diploma mills only exist because of the unrealistic and unreasonable demands of employers and industry (and the desire to make a fast buck). Until hirings and promotions are based on ability and potential, and not on paper trails, this problem will never go away.
by jessie
by oz_media
They know me VERY well, I sat in a board room with the CO's and chewed them out for running such a pathetic business, while my already pisse doff boss just grinned in the background, even though he could have lost his Telus Alliance over it. It turned out that they changed the Alliance Program and retrained staff to do their job as required.
I have since been offered work by C level employees that could would put me to work in a heartbeat, no resume needed. They actually see my hard-assed style as something they need in a pussified union workplace.
I have refused, even when out of work, over and over again. Last week when in Van I met with a client and the Telus Business manager was just leaving (without their business) and he again asked me to take over a territory of field reps, no go, I am just not interested. BCTel was bad enough, these guys are just a laughing stock. If it wasn't for a residential monopoly they would be pushing up the daisies.
As for reportng Monday Morning, that's how ALL of my work has been found. A first with digging and as the years passed I have become known by many and, not too sound TOO arrogant, I have been in demand for quite a few years now. It was hard work but it sure is a nice feeling when you get offered jobs without the process and get in ahead of overtrained College grads.
Are you watching the latest Apprecntice episodes?
Donald Trump is showing the world that high school educations are not such a bad thing afterall.
The latest series, although only just started, has College Grads vs High School grads. basedon combined income, the high school grads earn TRIPLE the salary of the College grads and so far won hte first challengs hands down. I am not saying they will win every challenge, but it was easily seen in the first challenge just WHO had the boook smarts and who had the proven ability.
The college grads spent time crunching numbers for a Burger King promotion! This is Burger King people!!! NO number crunching needed, it WORKS!!!
They missed the one thing that the HIgh School grads really focused on, point of sale. And that's where they lost, too good to work, an ability to delegate but not manage. Numbers, paperwork and education doesn't help you when it comes to reality, at least as proven in the first task anyhow.
As for Telus, they couldn't afford me anyway. I would want a small fortune to sign on with them, and even then I would want to use a different company name to ensure my success, TELUS isn't going to cut it. They are about as popular among people here as GWB is, if not less.
by dafe2
Actually I'm one that never heard about the License trouble.
Tell you the truth we use Aliant for everything so I just thought Telus was kind of a 'joke' but still a big player.
Your right, I would expect a big player to have some kind of mini........even a VAX at the VERY least. Whoda thunk it?
Of course the may only have a corner store customer base too......LOL
by dafe2
So what? Whatever pays the bills.....
I think I mentioned in my post that what your saying is being offered to you is done on occasion.
This usually happens if you have a relashionship in the right place so to speak.
As we all know (or should know) people & selling skills are a very valuable skill to have in todays IT world.
As for Donald Trump.....him & his show are right up there with Paris Hilton.......pretty sad world when those two are given TV shows. aarrrg
I did see the preview of the show you talked about....very interesting.....but no sale for this guy, I'd just as soon pi.ss on him. :-)
by oz_media
I was wondering just how offended you may get at the blatant slams on Telus. :)
Anyhow, like I said, if you have associates inside,no credit or security checks needed. Just lik emost companies they headhunt certain skills too, if someone brings value to the table in their eye, they will close their eyes on the rest.
I'm certainly not the only one who's had a chance to get into Telus, they were digging around several companies I have worked for for all kinds of different people, regardless of education or criminal checks.
Over the last year or two, they have been unsuccessful most of the time, people know what to expect from them now and the paycheque isn't worth the headache, I'd say.
by dafe2
What you say is probably true (for you) BUT MOST companies & certainly high end ones will NOT hire someone with a 'shaky' backround. Even a bad credit rating will stop the process in many places not to mention someone with a criminal background. They'd risk their career by "closing their eyes" as you say. Common.
If Telus is out recruiting that kind of 'talent' as you say, then is Jaqui mistaken in her assertion that these guys are vigilant with background checks? I'm assuming she consults there & would know something about the internal processes?
If you do manage to talk your way in or forge your wa through - you won't stick arround long.................just as in this posts attached story.
I'm saying your situation is 'unique' (to say the least) It's NOT reflective of the real world only 'yours'.
by oz_media
If you look at Telus job postings, yes there are VERY stringent requirements at some levels, even the operators and customer service staff are stringently examined. However, as you know it's not a what you know but a WHO you know world.
I am certainly not unique in my offers by Telus at all, in fact I know a few long term switch programmers with access to very high security areas who were just given the job because they knew somebody or worked for a competitor. Telus has the practice of simply hiring everyone else's people, it simplifies the hiring proces for them. If you are with a competitor, they want you, no questions asked, you start Monday.
You walk in off the street and yes you go through HR, you so much as buy a Telus rep a beer and you're in though. I was offered work there long before I was ever qualified to work there myself, just because I happened to play darts with someone and bought him a drink. With thousands of local employees, even just a good word from someone will get you in and everyone seems to know SOMEone who works there.
Just like jobs working for the city, they are impossible to get by application and screening, but they'll hire anyone based on the word of mouth of a fellow union employee.
As for large companies, I have seen this from a global fortune 100 company that I have worked with, I have been employed by te CRTC with a record and a high school education. Just KNOWING someone works flawlessly in most cases I"ve found, regardless of how hard it is to get in the front door.
I think I Jaqui's case (fomr what I read) she wasn't looking for work there but was hired to work there, in which case I can agree with the security levels. If she knew ANYONE with SOME seniority in the union, she'd be in like flint though, that place is pretty easy to get hired at.
As for understanding how they operate, half of their staff don't know what the other half is doing, this is a BIG company spread throughout many offices in the province. There are senior account managers that don'tknow the people they are marketing against are actually price protected Telus Partners. They are actually selling businesses against their own business, ths costin gthem a LOT of money. That is just ONE of the hundreds of things that makes Telus such a poorly operated company, the left hand doesn't know what the right is doing.
There's no organization to implement a blanket hiring policy properly as the union is too tightly involved and will simply send someone there to work, and Telus has to find them a job somewhere.
So it's not really unique at all, I'm not privaleged, in fact it's very common. And it lays proof to the age old saying that "It's not what you know, it's who you know."
by jaqui
dealings with telus giving me money.
I do have a landline, which is a telus line but that's as a customer. ~l~
telus contracts out thier background checks, I have no idea how well performed they actually are.
I'm sure they have a mainframe or mini hiding somewhere, just used for routing the calls.
thier entire office is windows.
thier webservers are windows
thier billing is windows
and 99.9995% of thier techs would have a heart attack if they had to use a unix box.
by dafe2
I've heard of people contracting out background checks.(More so after 9/11 of course). Kind of a little industry in it's own right.
At least they do them.
Allthough I'm an MS guy......I still expect to see either big Iron or UNIX used in core business processes of more mature Global Companies.
Maybe the just couldn't afford those paddle things they use for heart attack victims huh?
by jamesrl
I worked out of the Mississauga office, but at one point the desktop support team at Chalk River reported to me, so I travelled up there alot.
I was laid off in 2002.
James
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending