Discussion Locked

Election Season is Here - Sell Your Vote Wisely

0 helpful
28 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Who would possibly condone such a practice as buying and selling votes? Who would actually admit to buying votes? And who on earth would acknowledge that his or her vote is actually for sale? No one, that I can imagine, would concede such a thing. In fact, everyone I know (including my friends hanging around the TR water cooler) would probably express disdain at such a practice. But it happens all the time.

Lobbyists, for example, are constantly accused of trying to buy votes from various members of Congress. Of course, it's usually lobbyists from big oil, or the finance sector, or something along those lines who are the ones being accused of trying to buy votes; while the lobbyists for the public school teachers unions, or environmental causes, or for labor unions, etc. aren't held to the same standards - even though they all do the same thing, which is attempting to influence members of Congress to introduce or vote, one way or the other, for some particular bill. (Which isn't a bad thing, in and of itself; in fact, it's even mentioned in our Constitution as something the government cannot prohibit - some nagging little provision about the right to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.)

Some Lobbyists have even gone to prison for attempting to buy votes. In fact, some members of Congress have also gone to prison for selling their vote. Lobbyist Jack Abramoff comes to mind, as does Congressman Randy "Duke" Cunningham. (Disclaimer: Democrats and Republicans alike both buy and sell their votes with impunity and regularity.)

Members of Congress buy and sell votes amongst themselves every day. Vote for my bill, one Congressman might say, and I'll include that pork-barrel spending ..... I mean that targeted appropriation amendment for your district.

Greenpeace has, in the past, accused Japan of buying votes within the International Whaling Commission. Greenpeace further claims that Japan is disguising their vote-buying as some sort of overseas development aid money. I wonder if any other nations buy and sell their UN votes in exchange for some sort of aid money. No, that would never happen, would it? I also wonder if Greenpeace is concerned about nations selling their global warming vote? For some reason, I doubt it.

If a candidate running for office in your district approached you and offered you a crisp one hundred dollar bill in exchange for your vote, what would you do? Would you take the C-Note, or would you turn him/her in for attempted bribery? What if that same candidate promised you, in exchange for your vote, a $100 tax credit for something or other? Vote for me, a candidate might say, and I'll give you a child tax credit, or an education tax credit, or an energy tax credit, or some other tax credit to go on top of the tax credit you already get; it doesn't matter that you pay no taxes on which a credit can be applied, they'll give you one anyway. (What's that joke about having already determined what you are, but we're only dickering over the price - or in this case, the method of payment?)

Vote for me, a candidate might say, and I'll give your free health care. (The dirty little secret, however, is that the people accepting the bribe ..... I mean the promise, are the same ones paying for it!) Vote for me, and I'll give you this, or that, or the other thing. Heck, tell me what you want to be bribed with, and consider it done!

For a practice that so frowned upon, there sure is a lot of buying and selling of votes going on. Do you know anyone who's ever bought a vote? Do you know anyone who's ever sold their vote? Come on, be honest. Is YOUR vote for sale? If so, here are some rules for buying and selling votes:

On buying votes. There are only two rules for buying votes: The first rule is to never use your own money. Use other people's money to buy votes - no exceptions. If you use your own money to buy a vote, you probably bought yourself a stay in the iron-bar hotel (albeit a low security facility with a fully-equipped health club, a 5-star sushi bar, and an 18-hole golf course). Heck, you can even use the money that belongs to the person who's selling their vote! Just make sure you can baffle them well enough so they don't realize what you're really doing. The second rule is that you have to call it something else. Whatever you do, don't call it buying votes. Call it an entitlement. Call it aid. Call it security. Call it health care. Call it school lunches. Call it anything you want, but don't call it buying votes. Moreover, do it in the name of compassion. That will mask what you're really doing.

On selling votes: Be smart and hold-out for the best offer. This might be a difficult thing to decide, depending on how you look at it. On one hand, you might want to sell your vote to the person who offers you the most. On the other hand, however, you might want to sell your vote to the person who promises to take the least from you so he/she can pay for all those other votes being purchased from other people. It all depends on whether you're on the receiving end or the paying end of the promise. Work it right, and you might receive more than you are forced to pay. To hell with all those other poor saps who don't know how to finagle the best deal.

So there ya' go. You have only one vote. Make sure you sell it wisely.

(P.S. Many thanks to all the people who've sent me emails over the past 8-10 months.)

28 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

how is it I say that my vote ain't for sale, or how will I vote this year, or how is it I am happy to see maxwell edison back on the boards?

edit to add: Or how do I determine for whom I will vote? That one depends. I won't vote for (and haven't since the first time a third party candidate made it to the ticket) either a Democrat or a Republican because each party is as corrupt as the day is long in those areas where it lasts for months. If there is more than 1 third party candidate on the ticket, I look for someone who has the health of the planet 200 years from now in mind, the small business person in mind, is hawkish within reason, appears to support things like personal responsibility, the notion that some speech is detrimental to the social fabric, smaller government, technological innovation, recognizes that life begins at conception, recognizes that being addicted to morphine while in the final stages of incurable cancer is not a big deal, that pot is only addictive to addictive personalities, has a horrifyingly 'classic' idea as to how to change the sad state of education in America, is willing to butt out of other nations affairs unless it really is something that can be detrimental to us, realizes that the US is not the world, is willing to control our borders and immigration, butt out of religious speech and practice, and avoid the lucre of the right and the left and the center. Anybody who thinks the US Constitution is a 'living document' is a no-no. To name but a few things. That being in reality a non-existent candidate I fall back on eenee, meenee, mynee, moe in the 3rd party choices.

by jdclyde

No matter how people like to candy coat it, when you vote, you are buying into that way of thinking.

I would like to think that only a simpleton would vote single issue, especially if it is a self-serving issue like handouts or rebates.

by rfink

When Vincent Price said "Darkness falls across the land. The midnight hour is close at hand." I didn't realize he was talking about the 2008 Election.

My gut feeling tells me that McCain is a non-issue the Democrats will win it. If that's the case my vote is meaningless. Who'd want to buy it?

by jamesrl

Interesting timing.

As you may know, Canadian elections are not fixed in timing. Majority governments usually wait 4 years, and they have to call after 5 years. Minority governements call elections before that time - wheneevr they can't seem to agree to go forward.

Currentlty, the main opposition party, the liberals are afraid to go to the polls because they don't have a big enough war chest and are disorganized. So they often support the government when their guts suggests they shouldn't. They are split on extending the troops in Afghanistan, so they support it to prevent an election. They don't like the budget, but they vote for it so they don't trigger an election.

They added a recent amendment to the budget, somethign that would personally benefit me greatly. Its a provision to make education savings in a registered plan tax deductable. Currently they are tax exempt but not deductable.

The conservative government argues that it would cost too much and would threaten our ability to balance the budget (we have been in surplus for 13 years), and they suggested they will call an election if it passes.

While it would benefit me personally, I would not vote for a party that forced an election to support the change. To me it isn't a big enough issue to bring down a government on. I would have supported an election on an entire budget or the extension in Afghanistan, those are big issues.

But we do have vote buying here, though we have limits on lobbying and pork barrelling here. I think if we were as big an economic power as the US, we would attract the same kind of corruption, honestly.

James

by mjd420nova

I have been disgusted with the poliyics of this country for over two decades now and have not been a registered voter since then. HOWEVER, I will register to vote this year and vote in the national election. WHY, because I feel this country is not ready for either a black or female president. I will register to vote and vote for anyone but those two. Many candidates make campaign promises that at the time they have no idea that they can not do what they propose or promise to do once they are in office. The most worthless body is congress, as they distort their constituents views and impose their own wnats and needs into the proceedings of this nations business. Politics is like religion, it distorts and hijacks the true teachings to extort the people into seeing things in their own manner. The great leaders of this nation who fought so hard to gain independance from the British would surely roll over in their graves to see how this great nations intentions have been distorted to fulfill the politicans agenda and not the true peoples intents, wants or needs. NUF SAID.

by jamesrl

Thats a damning indictment if true.

I could think of many reasons to vote for or against the democratic front runners, but their sex, race, religion, hair style or marital status would have nothing at all to do with it.

James

by oz_media

Without looking for a fight, I have to ask :"WHY, because I feel this country is not ready for either a black or female president."

Now is that a personal feelign that YOU are not ready for a black or female president and feel nay others see it the same way, or do you actually not really care yourself but still feel the country is not ready or wouldn't accept suhch a president.

Because that says a LOT about your country does it not?

Again, I would like to discuss this as constructively as possible as I am quite surprised to hear that from an American after there being such a focus on being 'politically correct' for the last few years.

I've been chastized by Americans just for using the term 'black' on TR, which doesn't offend any black people I know as it is simply descriptive but not used in any form of derogatory fashion.

We had a big 'PC' focus here in the 90's but people seem to have relaxed a bit more in recent years, whereas I see the US pushing to be PC in more recent years.

by delbertpgh

So, I guess I'm a little hard to buy. I'm mostly interested in seeing government do the jobs of government effectively and efficiently, and to stay out of everything else.

Of course, I think Republicans have been off smoking weed for the last 20 years, so there is no major party conservatism that I can trust. Makes me a disgruntled Democrat, for the time being.

by oz_media

First of all, welcome back, I know that doesn't mean squat coming from me, but take it for what you will, it [i]IS[/i] nice to see you around again.

As for buying votes, it sounds very similar to payola. I am sure you know about payola as you are involved in music, but some others may not realize that it still happens, even though laws have been passed to stop such practices now. It happens less frequently now because the artists label usually owns the radio station, thus no need for payola but it is still a regular event in the industry.

As for the $100.00 offer; first of all, if a politician knocked my door, he'd have to deal with me and you know how well that would go. :)

But really it is an issue of morals, so given the following: I would get the $100.00 up front, I could cast a vote for whomever I wanted and nobody would be the wiser. I'd take the $100.00 and send him on his way.

I'd then vote for whomeever I thought was the best candidate (Good luck finding a suitable candidate in Canada ((or any other country when it comes to that)).

Yup, full of morals, just like the politician offering me $100.00

In short, I don't buy into politicians or thier incessant BS, nobody is going to do it the way I would anyway (or how anyone else would for that matter)I understand that unfortunately we have little choice in that respect and must choose the better of two evils. If one of those evils had a lackie stop by and throw $100.00 at me to vote for him I'd do it, would I vote for him? Not due to the $100.00 anyway.

I know, I know, but I'm at least being honest and not just saying what I would LIKE to think I'd do.

by jamesrl

I've never voted for any party but the conservative one in Canada, though at times the party has been pretty centerist.

I've never voted for the party that promises the most programs. Cause I know that will cost me and perhaps my children more in the long run.

I sometimes vote for those who promise me tax cuts, even though I'd like to see that balanced with paying down the debt. I don't like the idea that we are paying interest on debt accumulated long ago. I'm not entirely bought into the Reagonomics argument that tax cuts always generate enough revenue to offset the taxes lost. I think it depends.....

I have stayed home when I didn't agree with some things "my" party was promoting. I've worked thousands of hours on campaigns were I agreed with my party on almost everything.

I never offered anyone a dollar to vote any one way.

James

by drowningnotwaving

Hi James,

Just looking through your interesting post.

You make decisions to vote (and to participate in the vote) according to some issues that are self-interested and some that are of the greater good, so to speak.

Do you think every one should balance on that basis?

Are there situations where self-interest is a valid reason for someone making a decision?

If yes to the latter, is there really a difference between that and someone buying a vote, no matter how strong the issue?

by nicknielsen

Human nature being what it is, most of us think of ourselves before thinking of others. As I see it, the majority of American voters place personal self-interest before the greater good. Pretty much since the 70s, any candidate (from any party!) who has said "We can't continue as we have been, we need to make some sacrifices so our nation will still be here for our children" has rapidly disappeared from the race. The only exception that comes to mind is Ralph Nader, but the sacrifices he's pushing mostly involve government as nanny.

I like the qualification for the vote from Heinlein's "Starship Troopers:" completed military service. Great idea. Not that former military members are more intelligent than others, but many who serve do so out of a feeling of obligation to the greater community.

by drowningnotwaving

LOL ! Very funny!!

Making the positive choice NOT to vote, as such.

But in reality, as with people who in our country CHOOSE to not vote - doesn't it actually make you irrelevant in the electoral scheme of things? Do you seriously think any of the mainstream policy makers look at the informal vote and care about it?

Not of course that that particularly matters, if you have such little faith in them in the first place.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

my purpose in voting 3rd party is to ensure that we keep a third party. I also actively encourage my family, friends, and co-workers to vote 3rd party in an attempt to catch the attention of the established parties. If, in 10 or 20 years the 3rd party finally garners a large enough percentage of the vote, my theory is that this will help to bring about change. I may be wrong, I may be right. But there is no knowing without trying.

The attitude that choosing a 3rd party candidate for whom to vote is akin to not voting is half the problem in this country.

by drowningnotwaving

Certainly the rise where I live of minority parties has been huge in the last 20 years.

From none in parliament, to one or two, to holding the balance of power in certain circumstances.

It does mean that in some cases, huge concessions are made to fringe minority parties in order to gain their vote on large issues.

In recent times in Australia it was to a very right-wing conservative religious person who singularly held the balance. In our newly elected parliament it will be to the Greens.

But that's democracy for ya!!

by nicknielsen

[i]...in reality, as with people who in our country CHOOSE to not vote - doesn't it actually make you irrelevant in the electoral scheme of things?[/i]

No. If I vote it's relevant because I cared enough to participate in the process. The non-voter is irrelevant and, at least in my hearing, has no right to complain about the results.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

The first question I ask when someone starts b*tching is whether or not they voted. If they say no, I tell them to shut up as I don't want to hear it. They haven't the right to gripe as they made no effort to change things. I get some interesting looks with that. Makes me wonder...

by rfink

What effect does a losing vote have? NONE
What effect does a no vote have? NONE

If I'm conviced that my candidate doesn't have a chance, I can have the same effect on the outcome and save the gas, the time standing in line, and the other crap that goes with voting by staying home.

However, since the general election has more to vote on than the Presidental Electors, I will show up to vote on the other issues, candidates, etc.

I will vote for President when I can vote for President.

by the scummy one

No, I would not sell my vote, nor vote a certain way
because of outside influences... Wait a minute. Hmmm, if
the price was good enough I'd think about it before
turning it down!

As for giving me hints for buying/selling... Thanks! :D

by nicknielsen

As I have stated many times here, I don't usually vote for candidates from the major parties and usually base my vote on the candidate's [u]demonstrated[/u] stand on the greater issues: economy, international relationships, national security.

The more buzzwords in evidence, the less likely a candidate is to get my vote.

by ed woychowsky

You make a good point, votes are for sale. The only thing is that most people don't realize that they're selling.

by rfink

In Michigan the results aren't known for 79 of the 83 counties until after 8 PM. But given Michigan turning into a Democratic wasteland, any non-Democratic vote is a loser. MI is a blue state more ways than one and boy do I have the blues.

This discussion is closed to new replies.