Discussion Locked

Employee With Great Skills - Poor Attitude

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I recently accepted a position as manager and knew this person would be my challenge. This individual has great programming skills, however has the attitude that he is the 'best' and no one can code as efficiently as he can. He recently stated that he believes that his salary is below market value. As his manager I told him I would work with him to the make case for salary adjustment, however we needed to quantitate his value so others especially in upper management would be able to see skills.
Recently I asked him to modified a report program but his comment that it could wait until next week . His comment was witnessed by one of other team members. This was second incidence where I asked him to do something and he decline to it. Needless to say I am thinking I should re-evaluate my efforts to support his salary adjustment. Reasonable ? Interested in some comments from others

7 replies

by jamesrl

Not claiming to be the best manager in the world. But sometimes its easier to spot the challenges other people face.

You have to sit down with this employee, and make it crystal clear that YOU set his priorities. He may challenge them and should be welcome to do so, but when you have made a decision, and given a task, he must execute.

Try and put it into context. You and I both do tasks at our Manager's bidding. He needs to do the same. I wouldn't get passive with him - wrong approach. You need to be open about it.

In most high efficiency organizations, people are measured on how they do on the tasks they are assigned, not on the tasks they assign themselves.

Don't re-evaluate. Tell him you need to see some improvement in task and time management. If he shows it consistently over a few months, persue the market adjustment.

James

by debon

I agree totally with James, as a new manager to the organisation you need to set this guy straight. At the same time you shouldn't adopt his arrogant approach, you need to be calm and level headed but establish that you are the one that determine his priorities. Also ask yourself a couple questions, is it that he feels that he should have been promoted to fill the position that you now occupy? Is he really below market for the job he is hired to do or is it that he feels based on his 'ADDITIONAL expert knowledge' he should be paid more? Do the other staff members in your department think he is as good as he believe he is? If not think also of what a pay increase to only him will do to the others. These are answers that you will need to fill in, based on your interactions with him.

Quite some years ago, I was accused of being an arrogant programmer myself; it is something normally associated with youth, so be patient with him but don't let him cost you your job as regardless of what challenges you face, if the work is not being done you will have a problem with your boss. Sometimes you may need to massage his ego a bit, but be careful what you say to him because you don't want him using your words as justification for a pay hike. Don't say things like "you know he is the best or that you are sure he'd be paid more in any other Company etc." If you can, send him on a few personal development courses, these may help him mature a bit. You need also to communicate with the HR department to see what sanctions are involved with the refusal to carry out instructions. Finally you may need to write this guy copied to HR, following which you may ask HR to address the matter. Good luck !!!!

by rajwar2000

Hi,
This needs a two step approach.
1) is the employee underpaid or not to market value?
then pay him what he is worth it.
2) As a manager, tell him that you know the priorities better than him and that when there is a task to be completed on priority, it has to be done. He needs to be educated or mentored so that his attitude will determine his altitude.

all said and done, best skilled people are egoistic in nature and to retain them, we need good patience and practices.

by p3john

I?d agree with the postings so far ? and I have a case like that myself; an extremely bright employee, who is mid-twenties, excited by technology and the concept of wielding it. He?s played the market value card, the ?why should I do that? card, and the ?when I get to it card?. In all instances he was (I sensed) trying to undermine my control of the situation so that he could pursue the challenges he wanted? oh, by the way, maintenance programming is SO below an application developer?s ego? not skill set.
My tact with him was moderate: I explained the priorities to him, asked him to work as a member of a team (which he is), and reminded him that the State of Rhode Island is an employment at will State and his job description clearly states ?And all duties as assigned.?
What has happened is unexpected, instead of rebelling and pushing the issue he conformed and by doing so has found a new channel for his talent ? he?s not just a programmer, he?s also a project manager and someone I depend upon.

by yelesom

Perhaps there is a a reason for his attitude, it very well could be that he isnt motivated enough by his current job. Sit and have a chat with him to try to figure this out. One case could be that he thinks he is undervalued so he does work which he thinks equals what the company values him at...

by a_dangerous_mind

It doesn't sound so much like a refusal to do the work but a disagreement on priorities where more could have been said on both sides. Was his reply really that short? I'm wondering if there were other assignments which you had given to him which he was already up to his neck with handling. The better programmers do tend to get a number of assignments piled on them at once, and sometimes we may 'auto-triage' based upon previous experience. He may have given a better answer if he was being overwhelmed to mention what he was already working on, and then ask you which of the assignments would need to be postponed or lowered in priority.

There is often the feeling among the 'managed' that managers can give directions on what they want done, but need to take into account the when, the why and the how more often. People are not robots; giving direction must be more of a two way street, where managers are willing to discuss and listen to achieve the results that they want. This is especially true with technical people, where the manager may not have much technical understanding of the actual work involved.

What you're characterizing as attitude may be a professional confidence from actually meeting the challenges. It may look like cockiness at times, but believe me, it's necessary when someone puts in front of you a problem which no one else can figure out that you have some confidence to dig into it.

The previous comments to discuss it with him are wise. Be willing to hear any reasons why he gave you that answer. Go over his assignments and priorities again if necessary. Try to understand his job from his perspective. It may be that he was actually doing something which would have justified his desire for a more market rate salary.

by mark vii

Here's my two cents worth on the situation. I can see several sets of circumstances that could be producing what you're running into with this employee.

You might have a developer who's a "legend in his own mind", and is not nearly as good as he thinks he is. He may confuse being a good developer with knowing a lot of obscure "techhie tricks".

On the other hand, you might have a developer who's been called upon to take care of the situations that other folks couldn't, in which case his opinion of himself may be correct.

Relative to deadlines, you may have an employee who doesn't deal well with authority figures.

On the other hand, you may have an employee who (as others have posted) may feel the need to push back on new assignments simply as a case of workload management. As a manager, you may want to look into the local culture as it pertains to workload. Do people get work piled on them until they scream, or is work apportioned based on some reasonable expectations of throughput? Are deadlines realistic, or have the employees come to learn that arbitrary deadlines are imposed that are tighter than really necessary? Is everything #1 priority?

Is this employee used to being actively managed? Your predecessor may not have taken an active role in setting tasks and deadlines.

As other have noted, the best way to sort this situation out is to engage this employee to learn more about why he thinks like he does. Along the way, engaging the rest of the staff to learn more about this person and the local culture will give additional perspective.

Mark

This discussion is closed to new replies.