Discussion Locked

Environmentalists need to get their act together, they look like idiots

0 helpful
102 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.topix.net/tech/alt-energy/2007/07/wind-farm-goes-smaller

A propsed wind farm in Main which 20 conservation, health and other organizations expressed endorse for all of the right reasons, is being disputed by another conservation group.

[i]Jody Jones of Maine Audubon said her organization agrees that wind power should be pursued, but that Black Nubble Mountain is an inappropriate site because of its rare plant and animal species and scenic vistas.[/i]

Ok Jody, screw you. Instead of using something environmentally friendly to power the 20,000 homes. I'll use fossil fuels. Or what you idiot, would you rather they go without power.

This is consistent of both the global warming community and environmental groups. They can't decide what to do, they can't compromise, and they could care less about the fact that what is being done is exactly what they have been pushing this country to do. Move to alternate fuels. They don't want this nation to prosper, they don't want this nation to be self supporting. I swear to god, they are conspiring with terrorists with their disputing everything that is being offered to remove our dependence on these scum bags.

If you read the article, you will see that they cut in half the number of turbines that they were originally proposing. Consideration was given to the twits. You also will notice this is about alternate energy, not even a bloody oil well. I truly can't stand people like this Jody. There is no compromising with aholes like them.

idiots, total freaken idiots. Morons, stupid mothers. Get my drift here? If environmentalists really gave a crap, they would champion cause's like this. And they would do it as a combined voice.

Conservation groups, here is my suggestion. Take your neo nazi section of your groups out back, and shoot them. Bury them in their cherished mother earth. And become one voice so that progress can be made instead of continuously disagreeing on every freaken effort that is put forth.

dan

102 replies

by locolobo

When you think about it the act of turning a fan and generating electricity has to slow down or divert the breeze by some minute fraction. Multiply this by millions of fans and who knows what effect this could have on global climate. Obviously we haven't studied the potential effects thoroughly. We could probably understand the potential risks with another century or two of studies. LOL!

Sorry about that! Sometimes I just can't resist the temptation!

"Or what you idiot, would you rather they go without power"
Sometimes I wonder.

by dr dij

It would be nice if you were a little more rational and less emotional. There's a mix of people on both sides with differing opinions, not one monolithic Borg hive mind.

Why can't we have windmills and not slice up birds also? With a little site planning and checking how many feet off the ground birds are flying at we CAN do that. What's wrong with having your cake and eating it too?

Polluters are more akin to Nazis as their foul coal burning excremetn is not only forced down the airways of anyone downwind, the gases difuse globally and affect everyone. Plus the sulfuric acid they and car emissions create causes acid rain, dissolving the 'wonders' of the world, including the parthenon, the pyramids,...

We tolerate them because the benefit of the machines to society. What's wrong with trying to find a better way? Don't you want to live in a cleaner healthier world?

I agree with you that some scenic vistas likely will have to be compromised.

by locrian_lyric

They want:

1)Totalitarian authority
2)Demonization of all who dispute their claims
3)Draconian treatment of those who disagree (note: the assertion that any metereoligist who disagrees with the global warming crowd be expunged)
4)The shouting down of all who disagree.

All we need now is a nice Kristalnacht...

Hmmm, Mabye the Earth Liberation Front can supply that along with all of their arson.

Now, after those pleasentries...

IF you were serious about not relying on coal, you'd be for more vigerous oil drilling, nuclear power, geothermal power and alternative fuels development.

Ah, but the greenies are also the no-nukes crowd.

by dr dij

like I said, the polluters are the ones forcing their toxic garbage down our lungs, dumping it into oceans so fish soak it up.

Your position is kind of like saying that Police have total draconian control over criminals. Well that's the point, the criminals don't have a right to commit crimes and pollution is a direct libertarian violation of individual property rights.

If I came to Garwood NJ and bought a house next to yours then started spraying toxic chemicals upwind of your place you might get rightfully ticked off. That is what pollution is.

Repeating your inane position doesn't make it so.

by danlm

Or any alternate fuels. My complaint is about the Nazi prick environmentalists that are never happy. If you read the article, they had reduced the number of windmills they wanted to put up. There was some give and take done on that site. But, like always. You have your Nazi section that won't compromise at all.

That is my complaint. I want alternate fuels. I want no more dependance on foreign sources for any type of energy.

I think you misunderstood my position.

Dan

by dr dij

there are the nazi prick polluters who don't give a Senegalese Pouch Rat's ass that they are spewing garbage into the environment.

Except for eco-radicals, who comit vigilante acts, it doesn't really matter what they think does it? We are all entitled to our own opinions. Society in form of laws and EPA enforce pollution laws and get companies to follow the laws, and add pollution controls.

LIke I said not all environmentalists think the same way. they react in their own particular interest. The ones who didn't want windmills because of scenery may have houses nearby or hike there. They are not 'nazis' because they have no force of law. I'm guess they probably reacted to perceptions and reduced # of windmills.

On the other hand, local people should have some power, if it was local zoning. Why should people be able to come in out of the blue who DON'T live there and site a bunch of noisy, unsightly machines there? So they did the american thing and compromised.

To pull the emotional word 'nazi' into this is REALLY STUPID! Apparently you don't know anyone who has been directly affected by the nazis or you wouldn't have said this.

by nicknielsen

Just the radical parts.

[i]Conservation groups, here is my suggestion. Take your neo nazi [b]section[/b] of your groups out back, and shoot them. [/i] (my emphasis)

There are human beings who consider moderation an abomination and with whom negotiation is not possible; it's "their way or the highway." This type of person also gravitates to a cause and has no existence outside that cause, whether it be Democratism, Nazism, environmentalism, Republicanism, or British football (gratuitous cheap shot!).

Thankfully, such persons are not commonly encountered outside these environs. Unfortunately, these persons also shout louder and longer than anybody else, so we are forced to hear them. I just don't listen any more.

FWIW, the planned wind farm is 130 miles from Portland, ME, the home of Maine Audubon and the likely home of their spokesman. It's more likely that the 20k homes that would be powered in that northwest corner of Maine would welcome a non-polluting power source with a minimal environmental footprint.

Also FWIW, some of the other organizations that are complaining include the Appalachian Trail Club and the Appalachian Mountain Club. These organizations sponsor and conduct mountain hiking tours of the area. They are most likely more worried about the effect on the scenery than they are about whether the locals have power.

What do the locals think? I suspect we'll find out at the public hearings, if they aren't shouted down.

by w2ktechman

do not have time right now,
I must dis-agree with you on this. If there are endangered or rare species close by, a power plant of any kind can be harmful. If the group shows that there are rare or endangered species living within close proximity of the planned power plant, they should halt the plans and review the plans again, taking this into consideration.

Just my opinion though.

by danlm

Consideration needs to be given to endangered plants and animals, no argument here. But to completely stop all plans of putting in a means of generating energy in a non polutant manner is cutting off your nose to spite yourself. it's flat out stupid.

If they are so concerned about the environment, then they should look at this as moving forward in improving it. By them totally not wanting this, they have just reversed their position by forcing companies to acquire the energy elsewhere. Fossil burning plants. Bet those fossil burning energy sources kills a hell of a lot more endangered plants/animals then the windmills do.

For someone so worried about the environment, they don't see the tree's from the forest.

Dan

by cactus pete

If moving forward with non-oil energy sources means killing off the last of a species (or several) then THAT is cutting of your nose...

From the citation you provided, the argument was heard, and an agreed upon compromise was struck. Wasn't everyone happy with that?

No single source of energy is the answer, by the way. There will always be a need for oil, though it certainly is currently far over relied upon.

by locrian_lyric

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONG before man ever set foot on earth.

Extinctions happen. Other species THRIVE due to our existance.

by w2ktechman

then should we not try?

I do think that if there is another place, or a way to leave a smaller footprint, it should be considered.

A power plant, even solar/wind will involve power lines. These can interfere with wildlife. There have been many studies about power plants, and the effects of large amounts of power with people living in close range. What makes anyone think that if it is bad for people that it will not be for wildlife?

by thechas

The stark reality is a combination of the NIMBY factor and no desire to compromise one environmental goal for another.

But, why get upset about it?

What conservative goal is the right willing to compromise for another?

I don't have any specific concepts in mind. But part of the problem with politics in the US these days is that people on both side are unwilling to compromise. About the only ground for political compromise is when it comes to spending tax dollars in the home district.

On a personal level, I believe that we need to expand and strengthen the endangered species act. Along with that, we need a strong program to preserve farmland and green space.

Chas

by danlm

I want renewable energy, which means that I am pretty much aligned with the global warming crowd other then I don't believe them. My position is one of national security, it just happens to align with some of the same goals.

Every time I read about some type of alternate energy source wanting to be put into production, I also read the same people that pushed this in the beginning. Not agreeing because of their uncompromising position.

I feel these people don't want people to have a life. Their position is that it's their way at any cost, even if it destroys this country and the lifestyle of it's citizens. That is why I can't stand them. I am for compromise to move forward, they are for uncompromising dictatorship of their position.

Dan

by locrian_lyric

and broken out thusly.

1)Short term needs
2)Transitioning
3)Implimentation of long-term solutions

1)Short term we need more of the fuels we already need.

2)Transitioning solutions could include the incorporation of biodidiesel and other alternate fuel sources into our existing supplies without disrupting the current infrastructure.

3)Long term solutions would include the phasing out of old fuel sources for alternative ones.

but we need to do 1 before 3

by w2ktechman

I believe that alternate sources of energy should be used as well. I think that it should be a dominant source for our country too!

But it depends on where to do it?

And aside from power, I also think that water plants should be put up in the Atlantic and Pacific, it sure would keep us out of 'drought' status...

by retro77

is sometimes off, but we should try to reduce the amount of power we are consuming. Maybe bring the levels of fossil fuel that we need down to a range that the environment can repair itself naturally.

by locrian_lyric

During the Jurassic period, the earth was MUCH warmer had much more life as well as more oxygen AND CO2.

60 million years ago, Antarctica was a temperate zone.

by dr dij

those 30% of dead coral reefs might mystimagically spring back to life!

The animals that go extinct might 'come back from the dead'!

Maybe your expecting aliens like the Taelons to land and save everyone?

the CO2 in the atmosphere will eventually turn into limestone on the sea floor but this will be over thousands of years. we're polluting much faster than that.

the difference is that:
1) it occured gradually then so plants and animals adapted
2) there weren't cities on beaches to be bothered by changes in sea levels

We've overwhelmed the healing processes of the earth.

Hi levels of O2 aren't much fun (tho we're not headed there, we'll probably kill of the ocean plankton with pollution which will make O2 plummet). There were 3' dragon flies because the O2 hi levels diffused into larger bodies. And massive forest fires at times, spurred by the high O2 levels.

by tonythetiger

"We" are steadily increasing in numbers. It's no different than at the dinner table. It takes more food (energy) to feed 6 kids than it does to feed one.

Continuing the analogy, it seems a little disingenuous to hear the family with one really fat kid telling you that you should put your 6 skinny kids on a diet.

by w2ktechman

will hardly allow for those effects that you state.

There are many places that can handle a power plant, that are not intrusive to endangered or rare species.

I have not said to NOT build any, but to be mindful of where they are proposed, and the surroundings.

Would you want to build a big power plant in a national preserve? If so, why not drill for oil there as well?

by locrian_lyric

if there were a MASSIVE deposit of oil in a natural preserve, DRILL DRILL DRILL!

It's already going on, you know.

But, I'd go one better.

I'd put the operation of the power plant or oil rigs in the hands of a HARD GREEN group and let them use the profits to buy as much land to expand the preserve as they could legally purchase.

What makes that particular patch of land so vital that a species will die out if the plant or derrik goes there?

by locrian_lyric

If the Police were like the Greens.

-everyone would be guilty until they proved their innocence.

-You would be arrested BEFORE you MIGHT comitt a crime.

-Mass arrests would begin every time there was a potential victim of any crime.

-You would be arrested for offenses which were not crimes at the time you comitted them.

AND...

If you ever attempted to harm me or my family, you would not see another sunrise.

by dr dij

you were arrested by a green?
They don't have the power of arrest so what do you care what they think?

And you are guilty of EMOTIONAL-NAZIism!
that is comparing people who will never storm into your house and kill you with the actual nazi's.

As the guy on daily show said when someone was comparing someone in senate with nazis, that's unfair to the nazis at they actually worked hard to be horrible killers.

So you're just overusing a word for an emotional reaction. and being vague and general.

Why don't try some rational arguments. Propose specific solutions to how windmills should be sited or if you're being general and just saying vaguely that they're being unreasonable, give examples and solutions, or you're part of the problem.

by locrian_lyric

The mere fact that you consider your ilk to be some sort of police force is nauseauting.

Sorry, my family escaped that kind of police a couple of generations ago.

as to your questions...

Let's see, we've had the Greens confiscate private property without compensation, we've had the greens do WORSE, by ordering that a person can not develop on his own property. We've had the greens help create this energy crisis by opposing both drilling for fossil fuels and expanding the use of nuclear power.

You're the bloody Gestapo and you know it.

by danlm

[i]So you're just overusing a word for an emotional reaction. and being vague and general[/i]

Your right, I am generalizing. Inappropriate use of a vile term. I'll just categorize the extremist's then to what they are. aholes.

Per your points about view, owning land near to these windmills.

Id be proud to say I was contributing to the cleansing of the planet by supporting alternate power sources. Look out my window, there is my proof. Point 2 to this. I would also admit to compromising my position because I knew that the benefits of compromise far outweighed the effects of using more fossil fuels to acquire the same energy needed.

Dan

by dr dij

and I was explaining how greens are NOT police! are you dyslexic or something?

affecting zoning ordinances is hardly police action. Your repeating analogies to nazis is 'emotional naziism' - i.e. trying to bring an emotional response with horrible inappropriate analogies.

You appear to hope to make people think someone is bad by comparing them to someone terrible, tho you have yet to voice a cogent rational reason they are like nazis.

and merely repeating this to drive home your point is, well 'pointless'.

I'm for the environment but I'm not a 'green'. There is a vast spectrum of comples political views. Tho with your 3rd grade analogies you don't seem to recognize this.

by w2ktechman

and these plants/animals have grown and adapted to these habitats.

Often relocating plants/animals can/will cause their demise. That is why they are 'protected' in many cases.

by danlm

1). Environmentalists and Global Warming organization's want the use of alternate/green sources of energy. They also advocate conserving to reduce the demand for energy in general. -- Agree on both points, just different reasons.

2). Radical elements of these groups are damaging the progress that can be made by their uncompromising positions.

3). When advancements are made in their cause of alternate green sources of energy, these radical groups still voice opposition when the overall core organizations have worked out the agreements which achieved this progress.

The radical section of these organizations do nothing but hamper progress due to the negative image that is cast on all organizations as a whole. I for one do not think the environmental community at large is this radical or uncompromising. But I do think there is a large enough percentage of them to alienate a portion of the population that hasn't made up its mind yet. These radicals need to be purged from the environmental community if you wish to ever achieve what you are after. Their idiots, they can't see the tree's for the forest, and they will cause you more harm then they ever will cause good. Their participation does nothing but make environmentalists look like idiots because they can't agree on anything.

Which is the point of this thread. their aholes. Ok? Total bloody aholes.

Dan

by w2ktechman

I agree to a point, but if there are good/valid reasons to hamper, then the plans should be re-reviewed.

Uncompromising is warranted in SOME issues. But I will agree that not all. And I will agree that many find any/all reasons as justification for their cause/agenda. This is just a bunch of crap often.

I am all for green energy. I am also all for protecting environments/habitats of rare or endangered species.
Let us progress, but progress with care and awareness.
We will continue to develop areas that are currently undeveloped. We will continue to expand our usage for land/space/environment. But, we hardly need to destroy every other living species on the planet for this reason!

by danlm

Been extreme in their predictions of what will happen to the earth if we don't do something now?

How can they broadcast such dire warnings and then turn around and protest implementation of measures that will stop this pollution of our planet? On the one hand, the world will be adversely affected in 15 to 25 years. Something must be done right now. But on the other hand, they stop the bus and get off when they can't have everything even though what is being offered is so much better.

Examples like this show how fragmented, disorganized, and how much they are in disagreement with each other. And people wonder why I don't believe a word these organizations say. They can't even agree amongst themselves, and you expect me to believe them? Whats my politically correct word to show my contempt for this. Sh*tttttttttttttttt

Dan

by locrian_lyric

I can list numerous examples where the environuts have gone so far to allow entire farming communities perish from a total refusal to allow ANY water for irrigation.

We had the damn gestapo here in NJ that went so far as to fine a man for filling in a hole on his property as they declared it wetlands.

by cactus pete

All progress should be pursued in as responsible a manner as can be reasonably attained.

The windfarm builder was made aware of likely harm to a fragile ecosystem and both sides compromised such that the farm was given a green light (all puns intended) but was scaled back.

That's responsible growth, isn't it?

by cactus pete

I found a more comprehensive source about the issue and it detailed that the matter is still ongoing. The small snippet in the first source lead me to believe the issue was settled.

Obviously, more debate is necessary. It will be a shame if the wind farm can't be built, but species should not go extinct for it. I sincerely hope they reach a decent compromise.

by dr dij

I can support your right to that point of view.

I'm just saying that because some people opposed the windmills doesn't mean it is some monolithic opposition by 'greens'. There's a good chance that some of the people who lived nearby joined the various 'greens' orgs just to oppose them in their backyard.

If they were going to put a coal plant in same place, probably some people who drive hummers and club seals would oppose it.

They don't have the right of law to stop it tho they can certainly spout their opinions in local media and at zoning hearings. Because we have a democracy politicians sometimes do listen and sometimes have their own vested interest, they may live nearby too.

In the end, zoning is a complicated issue. If we all lived in a vacuum, near no-one else it would not matter. But there are considerations of pretty much anything. sure a windmill is less but it still affects its local environment.

If we forced it on the locals then WE would be commiting powerplant siting nazism, e.g. claiming it was for the collective good as socialism does, and ignoring the debate and alternatives.

Probably the best thing to do is provide standards of siting so that low pollution plants like these can be sited more easily.

It isn't only the 'greens'; the military is guilty of delaying huge wind farms because it was concerned over radar interference, then not doing the studies to absolve the plants. To call the military in the US nazi's would probably be inappropriate also.

by locrian_lyric

of species that thrive due to our existance?

I've got news for you, species will continue to die off, with or without our help.

Darwinism, plain and simple. The fit survive, the weak perish.

by w2ktechman

But, does that mean that we have to help further? If it was a dire need, or survival issue, I would not be arguing. But this is of convenience. A power plant can be put up in another location without the need to destroy the habitat already in place.

How is looking for another location going to kill you or your children off?
Why must it be only in this location?
moving it a few miles away wont work?

by locrian_lyric

Which is why no new refineries or nuclear plants have been built in 30 years.

Any time anyone tries to build a power plant or refinery, the lawsuits start flying.

it's the BANANA philosophy

by w2ktechman

as well. And it is a natural incident that species have dealt with from the beginning.

Some trees do not even reproduce without occasional fires.

by w2ktechman

in many cases. People dont want to see it, but they dont want it far away, and they dont want it to intrude on the environment.

But, that is also not the only reason for no new plants being built. The power companies, in trying to force things their way have decided not to open new plants. Also, they have lobbied to keep existing plants from being put to use, or re-built. For them it is a power play game.

I do agree that concessions need to be made. Do not get me wrong here.
The location should be a good location overall. If it means to destroy rare and endangered species though, I would have to protest that it can be moved to a different location.

by w2ktechman

and be rid of them.
Then we can take all of the fossil fuels for ourselves and not worry cause we are doomed anyway.

Then lets all just quit working and have parties in the streets until we all die.

by sn53

dan wrote, "Take your neo nazi section of your groups out back, and shoot them."

The environmental movement is the home of the socialists and communists that lost their main cause when the Soviet Union was defeated by Ronald Reagan. The Nazis are national socialists. The Soviet Union consisted of international socialists. Today where can one go to be a national or international socialist outside the environmental movement or an American university?

by tony hopkinson

Ronald Reagan defeats the soviets, was that a double bill with Santa vs the martians?

Neither the Nazis, nor the communist party were socialists by any definition.

That being that the community is at least as important as the individual. Despite all the rhetoric from the above two regimes, only a gullible half wit would believe that was true of them.

by danlm

That there are factions of the environmental and global warming groups that are very anti government/business/personal advancement. I think these extremist's would would jump for joy to see industrial nations become third world nations in industrial output and the benefits the citizens receive from that.

I'm sorry, but I think that is their ultimate goal.

dan

by sn53

tony wrote, "Neither the Nazis, nor the communist party were socialists by any definition."

How about their own? From Wikipedia: "Nazism or Naziism, a form of National Socialism (German: Nationalsozialismus), refers primarily to the totalitarian ideology and practices of the Nazi Party (National Socialist German Workers' Party, German: Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei or NSDAP) under Adolf Hitler.

And socialism: "Communism is an ideology that seeks to establish a classless, stateless social organization based on common ownership of the means of production. It is usually considered a branch of the broader socialist movement..."

The Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Russian: Коммунисти́ческая Па́ртия Сове́тского Сою́за, transliterated Kommunisticheskaya Partiya Sovetskogo Soyuza, acronym: КПСС (KPSS)) was the ruling political party in the Soviet Union. It emerged in 1912 as the Bolshevik faction of the Russian Social-Democratic Labour Party created a separate party. The party led the October Revolution, which led to the establishment of a socialist state in Russia."

And today we have the Democratic Party of the United States, a leftist, anti-American party that has largely aided and abetted communists and socialists throughout its history. The environmental movement with is collectivist tendencies and the desire to dominate our lives is the natural home to socialism.

by sn53

drd wrote, "I'm for the environment..."

Cool. Is there anybody that you know who does not want clean air and water?

by w2ktechman

and the sooner the better. I have no problem with that.
The only problem that I have is responsibility. Should we destroy all of our ecosystems to do this if there are viable alternatives?

What harm would come to these endangered species, rare species/and or uncommon ecosystems if they moved the plans a few miles away? 10 miles away??
The companies do not want to do this because it would cost a few hundred thousand more to do it. Which is really not much compared to the cost of building the entire plants.

If we destroy some of the more uncommon ecosystems, it can have smaller environmental impacts that can have much larger effects in the long run.

All I am stating is that ifan alternative location can be used, why not look into its use as an actual alternative.

In this case, I did not read too much, so I am mainly looking at an overall picture here, not getting into specifics abou this particular case.

by cactus pete

I don't know which one it was, I was busy last week when I was trying to find all that info. If I get some extra time today I'll try to reproduce it.

by danlm

Like I said, I am not trying to be smart in anyway when I ask for the link.

Dan

by w2ktechman

so everything will be free. We can just 'do what we want' until doomsday :D
I say we start this practice as soon as possible. First we nuke everyone we dislike. Then we spend the next 12 months gathering up everything we need for the next several years

by tony hopkinson

it's a potential result of achieving what they really want, which is personal power.

Almost any environmentalist is going to treat business with a minimum of extreme suspicion.

Governments because they are effectively run by big business for their benefit.

Other people's personal advancement is of no major interest to anyone, our own personal advancement is of course very important to us.

I'm not a tree hugger as such, I am a real socialist (not a nazi or a communist!)

In the system we have now, you can buy a forest, chop it down, sell the timber, sell the land, put the money in the bank and get better return on your investment depending on house prices and bank rates.

If you wish me to accept that the Magoos who perpetrate this sort of thing, are justified in that they are in pursuit of happiness, holding your breath is inadvisable.

Given that reasonable people like me are completely ignored, you might as well build a training camp and turn out extremists.

I don't live in a tree throwing excrement at loggers, but anyone who says a forest is worth more dead will receive my unmitigated contempt.

by danlm

My position is in compromise and unity in the positions that you hold. The point of this thread was about one group recognizing that a compromise was reached on advancement of renewable energy, and another group supposedly of the same thought process not wanting it because it wasn't perfect.

To cut buy land, cut down tree's, make money on the lumber, and bank the money should be allowed. IF you reseed that forest so that future generations have the same option. Lumber is a requirement for building for housing. Housing is a roof over your head to protect yourself from the environment. Housing is a requirement just as the renewal of the product to construct those homes should be a requirement. The compromise is reached, you cut the tree's to produce the housing to product yourself from the environment. You reseed where you have cut so that future generations have the same option.

There are those that don't see that compromise is needed, and I don't have time for them and treat them with contempt which they deserve.

Dan

by tony hopkinson

the thrust of your posts has been the environmental loonies who don't compromise.

The business loonies don't either, more to the point they are the ones with power in the system.

Nobody compromises with those who won't compromise, and environmentalism is a new thing compared to raping the land for a profit.

Environmental radicals were created by those they oppose.

by sn53

tony wrote, "I am a real socialist (not a nazi or a communist!)."

I am interested in hearing what you think the differences are between real socialists and those who self identified as socialists who were among the greatest of mass murderers, thugs and tyrants, the Nazis and the communists.

by danlm

How many environmental policies infringe on a land owners right to do what they want with their land?

I own 3 acres of land, I want to use that land to build my house on. It's 3 acres, I bought it that large so I could provide my children a large yard to play in. Maybe put in a swimming pool. Finally have the money to do this for my children. I'm not a cooperation. Part of the land is swamp, I want to fill it in to make my dream home come true.

Enviornmental polices wont allow it, its wet lands. Protect the species.

Tony, it's gone to the extreme. They now tell people what and not what to do. hell, I bet if i wanted a wind mill in my back yard. There would be an environmental policy to stop it. And yes Tony, if I could afford the initial cost of putting one up. I would.

I won't own land or a house because of all the laws that take away my rights to do with it as I want. Building codes are one thing, they are for my protection. Telling me I can't dig, build, clear, or what ever to my land when it doesn't affect my nearest neighbors is bull. I have some damn bird that is rare that decided to roost on my land. My rights are now gone, doesn't matter what I think. Bet that bird would not last the night if that was the case.

dan

by tony hopkinson

Why are you telling me, or Stumpy the treehugger.

I suggest you discuss it with the person who sold you the land, for not disclosing. Or perhaps you could draft in a Dr Dolittle to explain to the damn bird who's familiy has lived there for generations that you bought it's ancestral home and now you are evicting it.

Hell, may be it will get a lawyer, at least that would be fair.

Your land, your responsibility.... The fact that some choose to force you to meet it is is only required because of your disregard.

I'm not a mad commie, but land 'ownership' is a very iffy concept in my book.

by danlm

Ever.

there is no point to work hard all your life to own a place you can call your own. That has been a ritual, right, goal that has been sought after through out the age of man.

you've taken away all of that, just in your last statement. Land ownership, iffy?

And my example was of a bird that chose to root on MY land after I moved there. Again, that removes all my rights. There is no point in ever working then under your concept, I might as well go on welfare and be nothing. Live in an appartment, don't buy a car, and squander what money I have away. I have no hope of ever owning anything, the place I live in, which sits on land. It's like playing the stock market in the 30's, it's a crap shoot. Will that bird crap on my land, does it's crap have seeds from a endangered plant life that may decide to take root on my land, this plant has been identified and I am no longer able to do as I want with the land I bought. My life's savings are for nothing, they never were for anything.

Dan

Dan

by thechas

It does not matter what you paid for it, how you acquired it, or even what you had planned to do with it.

You NEVER own the land.

You only borrow the land from the next generation.

What we do with the land today will have an ever larger impact on the lives of our children and grandchildren. We must make wise use of the land in order to provide the best possible future for our nation.

And, while there are environmental reasons for preserving wetlands, an even more important reason for preserving wetlands lives right along with the protections in the building codes. Wetlands are a vital part of controlling run-off and the impact of large rainfall and snowmelt. The result of filling in a wetland is that someone nearby gets flooded out in the next big rain.

Chas

by danlm

Because I want to make the decisions, not you what is done with my hard earned money.

You or others have no idea what I am about or what I want to do with the land. Anyone that buys land already has plans for the next generation, their children not yours. And you are now dictating how I should prepare for my children's life. Neo nazi is not too far from the truth when you listen to opinions such as this. You are now talking about doing with others property or saying it is not property of theirs. You are showing NO consideration for the number of years they have worked to have that land, to live on that land, to change that land as they see fit for the NEXT GENERATION. Their next generation, not yours. I didn't buy it for your children, get the hell off if you think it was. You have done NOTHING to assist them in these choices other then to remove their rights to make those choices. Again, neo nazi's is a very good term to describe what you just said. Statements such as yours shows you are no different then the governments you continuously rant about.

You know, as a follow up to this. The more I think about this, the more I find parallels with Nazi's and the environmentalists. Your policies, your lack of caring about peoples property, the fact you have your own brown shirts who go and destroy property of people that don't agree with them. It's easier and easier to see where environmentalists and Global Warmers will go and what they are after. And the techniques they use to get it.

And by the way, I did make a post earlier in this thread that if my actions were to affect my neighbors. I agree with laws being in place. Your example of filling in wetlands IF it affects my neighbors because of run off. If it doesn't, then that argument is removed.

Dan

by w2ktechman

you made some points. In this kind of case, where the city/state wants to preserve an area for whatever reason, I think you are right. They should instead offer an incentive for you to not develope it, or buy the land from you at fair market value

by danlm

Actually, I was thinking about that when I was food shopping today.

The government has been tromping all over land owners lately with the eminent domain rule. Even though I am of both sides of that argument, meaning I have no idea what I think on that as of yet. They do offer compensation for the land that they take.

Where do you see any of the environmentalists or global warmers offering anything for compensation for loss revenue or property loss when they dictate what is to be done with a persons/companies land. They offer rules, restrictions, but nothing else.

Example, specific to this thread. I own the mountain that those windmills were to be placed. It was the land that was handed down to me from generation to generation, I used it to hunt on. I was offered a specific amount from the energy company to place those windmills on my land. These windmills would have given me a steady income and at the same time provided renewable energy that I am all for. But because of these environmentalist, I have lost this opportunity to increase my revenue. They have not offered anything in return for this, other then to dictate what I can and not do.

The revenue that I would have gained would have been from a source that would place a much smaller footprint on that mountain then any manufacturing plant. It would not have polluted the environment in any way that I know of. It would have added power to an overworked energy grid. It would reduced our dependence on foreign supplies. And because of the environmentalists uncompromising position. This power will be derived most likely from an existing plant that will have to throw more carbon into the environment, and Im out thousands of dollars.

What has these environmentalist done? Walked all over my rights as a land owner. And helped pollute the planet they are trying to save.

Yup, makes a lot of since to me.

Dan

by w2ktechman

They can offer incentives for the non-developement of the land. You should have every right not to have to sell it. Although often this is not the case.

For your specific tale, I would have to say that the city/state or environmentalists should offer something for an incentive. Even if they plan to move it elsewhere on your property, to save the habitat.

Also, you are not entirely correct about environmentalists not ever offering anything in return (other than what you cannot do). In some states they have been working with the state to buy back land for conservation and to keep other lands from being put on the market as well.

Even though it will reduce the power strain, if there is an alternate place to put the power plant that will not harm endangered species/special ecosystems, etc. then we should consider it. Even if it means costing more to build.
It is not only our world, if so there would likely be nothing left here. Plants/animals/land formations do have their part in it.

Edited to corect spelling errors cause of my crappy wireless keyboard

by tony hopkinson

It's a legal fiction invented by communities to stop big booger's with swords taking our stuff.

We only get to keep that illusion when the community chooses to humour our belief.

I belive that bird has a 'right' to nest on my land, your land or anyother f**kers, not respecting that illusion, means you shatter them all.

by danlm

[i]It's a legal fiction invented by communities to stop big booger's with swords taking our stuff.[/i]

Well, tony. Tell that to the bear and the mountain lion that fights to the death to protect his home when another animal try's to take it. But wait, thats back to the bugger swinging his sword. Maybe its about time we took the swords to the environmentalist's for trying to take what isn't theirs. Maybe its time that we go back to the time of the sword, because by your rules. Everyone works all their lives to have nothing. And I think you will find that nobody agrees with that other then the socialists. I don't work to house and feed the people. I work to house and feed MY family. Truthfully, I could care less about anyone else's unless I have an abundance.

So Tony, what are you going to do when the lights go out and you have no heat because the environmentalists have stopped the building of electrical plants(California USA as my example). All electrical plants. How are you going to keep your family warm? How are you going to provide them light to learn by? What are you going to do when the environmentalists cause the relocation of populations on a large scale because they wish to rearrange the eco system to what it use to be. Doesn't matter that you will no longer have a job because of that, and that there won't be enough power to support any industry, its move or else. Thats exactly what they are after. You going to swing your sword to protect your family, yourself, and your home Tony? Or are you going to be the good socialist and just move? Hell, what are you going to do when the environmentalists cause food shortages because the land it is grown on has endangered species or animals? That will be next, no doubt. Hell, I could see the environmentalists protecting the locus at the loss of thousands of human lives from starvation due to crop loss.

Yea ok, I went to the extreme. I know it. But it is a fact that California does not produce enough electricity to sustain its own citizens, and that is because of environmentalist laws. If those type of laws become nation wide/word wide. Then people will be without heat and lights. And that is wrong. And don't tell me that power companies should build eco friendly power plants. They would if the environmentalists got their THUMBS OUT OF THEIR ASS's and came up with standard rules and regulations to build by. But that would require them to agree, which is what this whole post is about. Now isn't it. Or should we be in the cold, the dark? Is that what the environmentalists are saying?

Dan

by dr dij

by opposing a wind farm in Nantucket bay that would provide 75% of the area's power in renewable form.

This because the greedy self centered b*str&# has a house on Nantucket. And 86% of the people in the state are FOR the wind project.

So we should all breath polluted air because it might ruin his view 5 miles away? The pass into Palm Springs has thousands of windmills and the rich people there couldn't care less!

by w2ktechman

I would say, even Windmills can be a view to see. But without knowing too much about it, I thought previously that I read that it was about endangered species? Am I wrong?

by dr dij

such as on a mountain pass. Birds will regularly fly into them if the windmills are at the height the birds fly at. So I suggest that standards for siting land windmills include flyway studies. They can make the windmills taller than the normal flyways easily and get more power in the process. On the ocean tho I don't think this is a problem.

And the nantucket homeowners have a coalition to oppose the windmills based on minuscule part of the horizon they are visible on. (they are near the center of the bay, 5 miles from Nantucket).

They even made fun of it on Daily Show the other day.

by jdclyde

Groups like this are not looking for a solution to a problem, they are looking for a never ending cause that they can stand up for to make themselves look grand at the expense of others.

If it was about energy independence (like they claim ethanol is) we would be digging shale and drilling in the ANWAR. The reasons given for not drilling in the anwar could be applied to ethanol because we could NOT grow enough corn to replace petrol for our cars.

It is just one more in a line of the stupidity of people that feel without thinking.

Oh, and the reports that MARS has increased in temp as well, turns out the Martians are driving gas guzzling SUV's as well...

by danlm

A bloody martian. No wonder when I flipped him off, he just waved with the only finger he had as if he didn't have a care in the world.

Truthfully, I think the radical section of environmentalists and global warmers are out to ruin all industrial output of this nation. There was just an article in Stratfor newsletter I get about plastic bags. Ok, plastic bags are bad. No denying it. But, now they are taking to task companies that are moving away from them. Don't use paper, you are clear cutting. Don't use cloth, you now have sweat shops and the evils of farming. No solution is good enough, all solutions are wrong. They will not meet in the middle.

I will repeat an earlier statement I made. The [b]RADICAL[/b] elements of these groups are out to destroy this nation. They care not about the environment, they care only to ruin lives. Ruin reputations. And ruin everything that is cherished by the people of this nation. They are a security risk to this nation as dangerous as any terrorist.

You see I said radical elements. So for those that think I am against environmental policies, your wrong.

Dan

by jdclyde

like when buildings would get blown up?

When labs would get broken into?

When people try to say a dogs life is equal to that of any human?

People that say to cut our carbon footprint and then spend more on utilities a year than many in the low income brackets MAKE in a year?

Yeah, these people only hurt the efforts they proclaim to support.

by tonythetiger

The last of a particular species of dolphin died. So what. There are other species of dolphin. "Species", by the way, is just an arbitrary label applied by humans. From a natural point of view, it has no particular significance. What would be the difference if a human killed the last of that species of dolphin, or if it was eaten by a Great White?

It all boils down to survival of the fittest. If you don't survive, you're not the fittest!

by jdclyde

There are more "species" that have become extinct before man even walked the earth than we would ever be responsible for.
[i]
"I love dolphins. They taste like chicken"

by tonythetiger

[i]When people try to say a dogs life is equal to that of any human?
[/i]

I related an incident in another thread some time ago where children were living in horrible conditions and was told by a sheriff "If she had a dog in that house, I could remove the animal and arrest her right now, but it meets the minimum requirements for human habitation."

[edited for clarity in subject]

by jdclyde

Right now, here in Michigan, if you have a poached [b]deer[/b] in your freezer, the DNR can walk right in, take the deer, and you away.

If you have a [b]dear[/b] in your freezer, they need to have a search warrant stating what they are looking for, and were they are going to look.

by thechas

The German Nazi government and the Communist governments of the USSR, China, and their satellite puppets were socialist in name only. Just as they were democracies in name only.

All of the above governments had the people working for the benefit of the ruling class.

To claim that any of the above were socialist shows just how far the right wing talk shows have tilted reality.

The closest we have had to true socialism on this planet is in the Scandinavian countries of Northern Europe.

Further, opposing the domestic and foreign policy disasters of our present a-hole of a President does NOT make one anti-American.

IMHO, Nancy Pelosi and the Democratic leaders of Congress are truer Americans and more patriotic than the vast majority of Republicans and every member of GWB's administration.

For the record, I am registered as a Republican. The 2000 election was the first time I did not vote solidly Republican. And, I firmly believe that the Republican party has declared war on the middle class and American values.

Chas

by sn53

thec wrote, "The German Nazi government and the Communist governments of the USSR, China, and their satellite puppets were socialist in name only."

Well you did speak of revisionist history. The nazi party was a leftist party bent upon equality, a typical socialist goal. In fact if the nazis believed you were not fit to be equal they murdered you. In my opinion this must always be the end state of any socialist experiment.

The communists were also socialists. Unlike the nazis who were nationalists the communists were internationalists. The end state was the same. Communists imprisoned and murdered those they could not easily make "equal". A great deal of evil mischief always follows socialists.

Today we have the benefit of another ideology of equality, the political-religion of Islamism. Is it any wonder that so much murder and misery follows it around? I only wonder that Christianity managed to escape the worst ravages of the cult of socialist equality.

by nicknielsen

Check the definitions below for the difference between socialism and fascism.

[b]fas?cism[/b] /ˈf?ʃɪzəm/ fash-iz-uhm
1. (sometimes initial capital letter) a governmental system led by a dictator having complete power, forcibly suppressing opposition and criticism, regimenting all industry, commerce, etc., and emphasizing an aggressive nationalism and often racism.
2. (sometimes initial capital letter) the philosophy, principles, or methods of fascism.
3. (initial capital letter) a fascist movement, esp. the one established by Mussolini in Italy 1922?43.
(from http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=fascism&x=0&y=0)

[b]so?cial?ism[/b] /ˈsoʊʃəˌlɪzəm/ soh-shuh-liz-uhm
1. a theory or system of social organization that advocates the vesting of the ownership and control of the means of production and distribution, of capital, land, etc., in the community as a whole.
2. procedure or practice in accordance with this theory.
3. (in Marxist theory) the stage following capitalism in the transition of a society to communism, characterized by the imperfect implementation of collectivist principles.
Compare utopian socialism.
(from http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=socialism&x=0&y=0)

National Socialists were nationalists and anything BUT socialist; your assertion that they were leftists explains a lot.

by tonythetiger

they only CLAIM to be socialists, but in reality there are those who have more power than others, and where there is power, there is corruption. In a capitalist society, you bribe with money, in a 'faux-socialist' one, your daughter performs sexual favors to the baker so that your family can have an extra loaf of bread.

by sn53

nick wrote, "Nazis were Fascists, not Socialists"

It is not quite pure is it? They described themselves as national socialists. It is true that their political philosophy was an amalgam of ideas taken from a variety of sources. Here are a few examples: they believed in national socialism, the idea that the people owed duty and loyalty to the state (contrast this with international socialism that downplays the importance of the state and seeks revolution everywhere), that the German people were equal and superior to all others. In fact if you were not equal they sterilized you in the early days and murdered you in the later days. They were anti-capitalist. Hitler is quoted as saying, ""We are socialists, we are enemies of today's capitalistic economic system for the exploitation of the economically weak, with its unfair salaries, with its unseemly evaluation of a human being according to wealth and property instead of responsibility and performance". They encouraged promiscuity.

That is enough for now.

by nicknielsen

It's not what they say, but what they do that makes them what they are. Hitler spoke socialist, but did nationalist. As for the encouragement of promiscuity, most of that was eliminated very early. Study the "Night of the Long Knives."