Discussion Locked

Ethnic Discrimination in Consulting Job in NYC

0 helpful
115 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I was recently emailed about a contracting assignment for a bank that is looking to upgrade/migrate their existing NT network to AD and Windows 2003. One of their requirement is that the candidate be fluent in Mandarin Chinese. WTF?? If a candidate is qualified technically, why should he/she be fluent in Mandarin Chinese for a company doing business in the United States? Is this a case of ethnic discrimination in which the bank is owned and operated by Chinese and all they want to see are Chinese employees or contractrors working for them? See the last line of the job description below and tell me that it doesn't make you fume in anger.

Windows migration engineer
to migrate Windows NT desktop & apps to Windows 2000.
The initial estimated contract period of performance is 3 months with the possibility of multiple extensions.

Responsibilities:

- Develop and maintain migration plans
- Determine/migrate security requirements for applications/servers.
- Develop and communicate documentation for new platform and architecture to include functional specifications and design documents.
- Determine integration requirements and plans for disparate systems.

Qualifications:

- One person needs to have SQL Server authentication (NT) experience.
- Must have Windows Active Directory experience
- Must have prior experience of migrating from Windows NT to Windows 2000 environment.
- Experience with design, implementation, and migration to a new production Windows 2000 domain w/ Active Directory.
- Knowledge of desktop operating systems - Windows NT/2000/XP
- Experience administering a LAN/WAN - TCP/IP environment using Windows NT, 2000 and 2003
- Experience with VPN software.
- Knowledge of DNS, internet infrastructure, and IP informational tools.
- Experience rebuilding servers and workstations.
- Fluency in English and Chinese Mandarin

115 replies

by faradhi

The first and most likely is that they have their systems running in Chinese languages. Their documentation may be in chinese. They may have key personell that only speak chinese. They may have offices in China.

This is not discrimination as long as they would hire any race that can speak Mandarin.

by why me worry?

But if they are operating on US soil, I would expect their systems to be configured for US locale and English language. It's like going to France and expecting their systems to be setup for English language and locale. Call me too patriotic, but this is just plain wrong.

by faradhi

And if I owned a company in France, I would expect my french employees to speak english as well.

by georgeou

First of all, I know many Caucasians that know Mandarin (some better than me and they can even read/write).

Second, France or any European nation expects all business to be conducted in English. You probably won't get a good job in France without the ability to conduct business with your fellow European nations and English is the official language of the EU.

Third, for all you know this could be an import/export company based in China with a branch office located in NY USA. There are plenty of jobs in the restaurant business that require managers to be able to speak Spanish.

So long as they're not saying "we will only hire Chinese people" then it's NOT racism. If they're saying Mandarin is a job requirement then that's perfectly legitimate.

Personally I can't stand racism or job quotas, but this is NOT racism unless the employers refuse to hire anything other than Chinese people. I have personally been looked over for a job even when the hiring agency in a County job officially rated me as the #1 candidate but I lost out to the #2 candidate who was a female. It doesn't feel good and it isn't right.

Now as for the issue of learning English, I completely agree as someone who immigrated in to this country and learned the language. I would go as far as making English the official language and bar bilingual education in public schools. They did this in California against intense lobbying from some in the Hispanic community but even some of the worst critics of the ban on bilingual education became supporters after the miraculous improvement of English scores among the Latino students. I even believe all government business and all official election material should be conducted in English since it is an official requirement to know English before you can become a naturalized US citizen. However that should NOT exclude the use of other languages in private businesses.

by cuteelf

HSBC is one of the biggest WORLD WIDE banks. And it is also based in HongKong / China area.

So.

If management is living in China/ Bejing, and they have a Large HQ office in NYC, how is this unreasonable for them to request a bilingual speaker?

Information about installs and updates on project will need to be sent to the top of the food chain, I really dont see how this is an issue.

We as Americans require people to speak english, as it's THE business language, and computer programming language! But for a manager to understand it, they need to learn E too...

Why shouldnt we learn C?

Personally, with the way the world is going nowadays, I think learning Chinese would be very helpful. At least to break the ice.

Wan-An.

CuteElf

by cjb996

The Net is global you better get the skills to compete! I'm from the US and have lived in Asia for the past 20 years honing my skills in language & culture. The Chinese are developing their own operating systems in Chinese - they also happen to represent 1/4 of the world's population with a booming economy - big market to overlook!

by georgeou

"This is not discrimination as long as they would hire any race that can speak Mandarin"

Exactly! If you were a French import/export company and you had a branch office in the United States, you might want French speaking employees.

A lot of restaurant manager jobs require the ability to speak Spanish.

This does not mean racism. It would be racism if they said they would only hire Chinese, French, or Mexican people.

by why me worry?

They don't have to explicitly come out and say "Manadarin Chinese candidates need only apply", but like I said, I don't know too many non-Chinese in my field who are fluent in Mandarin Chinese. Basically, they are indirectly discriminating by limiting the position to only Chinese candidates. Not to sound racist or prejudice, but Chinese run businesses in NYC prefer to work with their own people and have a very xenophobic attitude towards those of non-Chinese origin. Don't believe me, try striking up a conversation with one and ask them point blank why they don't employ non-Chinese in their businesses.

by pedwards17

There are likely valid reasons for making the ability to speak Mandarin one of the criteria for the job, but that's all it is--one of the skills needed for the job. I wouldn't read any more into it than that.

by simplejo

I know what you mean. I have a spanish name and have had to get used to adding (US Born, English Speaking) next to my name on my resume. It's either that or not use my name at all on my resume. Unfornuately, there are HR folks that will 86 your resume if it looks like anyone other than a John Smith or Ski applies. In your case, John Lee or Chan would get the job.

by simplejo

I agree, if you want to live in the USA, learn to speak English, maybe even serve in the military - I also served in the USMC. However, getting back to the original point of this discussion, if speaking Chinese is only a preference and not a requirement,

by eddie n

...to even try to pronounce my surname :) They will hear me on the phone and then see me in person and ask, "So where are you from originally?" and when I tell them "the Bronx", they look at me like they were pole-axed :) And after hearing how my name is pronounced, to a man, they just stick with calling me by my first name :)

I don't sweat it, though. I figure that any company that has a hangup over my surname (or is unwilling to take the time to learn how to pronounce it correctly) isn't worth working for. This country needs people who have skills and who are willing to work, and if the person in question has an "exotic" surname but also has the skills and the work ethic, why not take a chance on him/her?

My personal choice, but I will never ever bother putting a "U.S. born, English speaking" disclaimer next to my name. As a matter of fact, JohnSmithez, you may even have a good anti-discrimination case against any company who would 86 your resume simply because of the surname on it. Reminds me of the story about George M. Cohan, who because of his surname was often mistaken for being Jewish (he was Irish). One day, he went into a hotel and was rebuffed because supposedly they didn't cater to Jews. Cohan replied, "You thought I was Jewish, and I thought you were a gentleman. We were both mistaken."

by jmgarvin

They could have a contract with the Chinese or Taiwanese. They also could be working to develop contracts in that area that require that IT experience. Perhaps they are working with an outsourcing company for training.

As long as they would hire anyone of any race, creed, or color, for the job it is not discrimination.

by bkinsey1

IF you know the bank in question is Chinese-owned; IF you speak fluent Mandarin, get an interview, and get rejected in favor of a Chinese candidate, you can claim discrimination. In this case, you don't even know (or at least don't state) that the ownership and/or management are ethnically Chinese.

Judging simply from the advertisement quoted, it could be any bank doing business with China, or working on a joint project with a Chinese bank, or any number of other things. Maybe they're hiring someone they want to send overseas as a technical liason, or someone to interface with an IT team from a Chinese bank they're doing business with, or. . . .

by Former member

It is probably not to discriminate as it is to communicate with the people that actually own the bank. Maybe they do not want to bother with a translator? Their tech head wants to talk to your tech head unfortunately their tech head does not speak ENGLISH!
Personally if you are in AMERICA speak AMERICAN!
Why do you think I don't go visit FRANCE?
I don't speak french! LOL
Ron

by techrep

Crying "discrimination" is lame. A company has a right to hire whomever they want. Work somewhere else. I for one am not interested in a police state so that other people can reach their career goals.

by techexec2

I suggest you spend more time outside of your cube. Have you ever heard of globalization? Walmart? Countless thousands of cheap factory workers in China? The U.S. trade deficit? Offshoring and onshoring of IT jobs?

Many companies operating in the USA today, including the "American" ones, have operations in other countries, especially in China. IT positions at a Chinese bank that require both English and Chinese language skills should be EXPECTED, not a surprise. Count your blessings! The job could probably just as easily be located in Shanghai instead of NYC!

This is opportunity knocking: Learn to speak and write fluently in Chinese and work for multi-national companies.

Read: "The World is Flat" by Tom Friedman
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0374292795/ref=amb_link_974142_2/002-5679488-9337636?n=283155

by techrep

"Friedman says the world is flat because other countries are catching up to compete with the USA. Friedman doesn't do well explaining how the massive growth in government in the USA has driven business out of the USA and promoted business elsewhere. The present government is out-socializing the previous government by more than double and growing (in social spending ALONE). Friedman doesn't think that government in the USA is big enough yet.

People sometimes mistakenly say that Friedman and the NY Times are "liberal" but that is misleading. Friedman criticizes both big-spending democrat-socialists like Clinton, and also republican-socialists who are twice as socialistic as Clinton (in social spending alone). The only way that Friedman and the NY Times can be called biased is that they drone on about the socialists (democrats and republicans) and ignore anyone who wants to cut government (libertarians)."

"You know the schools that Friedman is talking about. The government schools where children robotically chant the Pledge of Allegiance daily for 12 years. Friedman and the NY Times don't seem to have a problem with patriotism and the p. Big problem: Neither Friedman nor anyone in the NY Times arises each morning to gather with neighbors and robotically chant, as they only "love" the pledge when government's schools lead children in robotic chanting upon the ring of a bell, like Pavlov's lapdogs of the state. Friedman and the NY Times are examples of why government schools are unconstitutional and have destroyed a "free press" and why government schools must end.

The book suggests that Friedman doesn't know that the pledge was written by a socialist (Francis Bellamy) in the USA and that the original salute was a straight-arm salute (as shown in web image searches for "original socialist salute"). He doesn't know of the news-breaking discovery by the historian Dr. Rex Curry that the straight-arm salute of the National Socialist German Workers' Party came from the military salute and from the original pledge of allegiance in the USA, and not from ancient Rome. Friedman and the NY Times don't realize that Bellamy put flags in every school to promote a government takeover of education for nationalization and socialism. Or, maybe they do know and they like it."

"Friedman is a reminder that the NY Times and the media are government mouthpieces. They help explain why government in the USA is out-socializing the previous administration by more than double and growing (in social spending ALONE). They help explain how the USSR, PRC, and NSGWP can come into existence, grow so large, last so long and kill so many.

Overall, the book was very educational and worth the time to review."

by techexec2

Well, that was an interesting post...

---

Regarding:

"...The present government is out-socializing the previous government by more than double and growing (in social spending ALONE)..."

This is an interesting comment. You said this in several other places in various ways. This doesn't sound like the Bush Administration I know, but I don't follow it THAT closely. Could you tell me where you get your figures from? Are you saying the Bush Administration is spending twice as much on social programs as the Clinton Administration did? Specifically what social spending are you speaking about that is doubled?

Thanks.

by bergy

If you are really qualified for the job, could you afford to pay for an interpreter to read the manuals and/or participate in meetings with you, somehow if Mandarin was being spoken.

I would think that might work if you are the most qualified candidate. Subcontracting the Mandarin requirement might show real initiative.

Any thoughts?

by techrep

I regularly spend "my own money" to succeed on projects. This regularly annoys my colleauges. I regularly do it anyhow.

by unsanet3ch

The key word is success... If I only used the tools provided for most of my contracts, I would be dead in the water in the first 5 minutes.

by 1toxicavenger

Why should the employer pay for lost productivity? Time spent translating conversations, memos, etc back & forth is presumably time on the clock. In my opinion, there is no difference bw requiring Mandarin as a language and cobol or fortran or basic etc. GET A LIFE. Find a job you are qualified for!

by maevinn

It's not discrimination to require someone to have a particular skill set, as long as that skill set is required to do the job. For example--some positions require that you be able to lift up to 40 pounds. If you can't--for any reason, including that you have no hands--then you don't have the skill set for the job. Here is southern CA, many employers advertise that they are looking for bi-lingual employees. I applied, and found they meant bi-lingual=English & Spanish. They aren't hiring French/ASL/Japanse, since most of the customers who are not fluent in English are fluent in Spanish. Perfectly legal.

by eddie n

I should think that any employer who advertises for their IT staff to be able to speak more than just English is actually doing the potential employee a favor. It will be motivation for the potential employee to learn another (human) language. This not only is a worthwhile endeavor in and of itself, but it also makes the potential employee more marketable. The more languages you learn (whether human or programming) the better for you, I always say.

Which is why I am about to go to Puerto Rico for an immersive Spanish course, and then I will re-up my Alliance Francaise membership.

by dr_zinj

are social skills. It 'may' be immediately evident that a person does not have the right personality fit for a job. Nothing wrong with telling you 30 seconds into the interview that you probably wouldn't like working there.

Ask them why they feel that way. If they aren't going to hire you, at least make them work for it. It may actually be that they are in violation of labor and hiring laws and pushing a little will reveal that. Or they may have a legitimate concern that you really aren't going to fit into their organization.

If they have a legitimate concern, and it doesn't bother you, then you're back to selling yourself as the person that can do the job and make the transition to a successful employee.

by georgeou

I know several Caucasians that speak better Mandarin than me, and they can even read/write. If you were working for a Chinese import/export company and they had their main or major presence in China, what would you expect? If you were applying to be the ambassador of China for the USA, would you find it strange if Mandarin was a job requirement?

by maevinn

Actually, Ambassadors from the US are seldom expected to speak the language of their host country. Stupid, really, but there you have it. Within private industry, that would be intolerable.

by eddie n

If there was one fact about the whole Iranian hostage crisis in the late 70s that stuck with me, it was the fact that almost no one in the US Embassy staff could speak any of the languages spoken in Iran. No wonder they dealt with them so severely.

A reason for the non-language requirement is that a lot of these ambassadorial postings are of non-professional diplomats -- some high profile postings, like the US Ambassador to the UK, are given to political cronies.

by techrep

A master carpenter friend of mine carries several $100,000 worth of material and tools to each home he works on. That's what we do...

by why me worry?

You could be fluent in Chinese all you want, but if you don't know squat about the culture or aren't a native Chinese person, they will look at you like some alien from another planet. Like you put it, 30 seconds into the interview and they are already telling you that you won't like it. That to me is discrimination right there because you can clearly see their intentions to only hire their own.

by bmwwaterman

There are many reasons why they said "you won't like it". Some cultures may not be as open as we are to bringing other people of "different" cultures into their company. In the end, it's their choice to determine if someone will work well in their company.

I would think outside the box and let it go. Unfortunately, it's not a perfect world. By not bringing you onboard could cause them to miss the chance of using a great skilled worker that you can could bring to their company.

I wouldn't let it bother you too much! The negative feelings you have towards it can hurt your health in the long run and might show up in other areas of your life.

Be positive, learn from it, and find the next company that will truly appreciate your skill set.

Have a great day!

by techrep

What is it that you love about America? What is it that makes America different from other countries? Would you fight and die to save America from her enemies? Who are America's enemies?

(PS: I do not have an American passport nor do I live in USA, but I should because I can answer those questions in 20 seconds)

by georgeou

I know plenty of places that would love to have a bilingual white guy. In fact whenever Caucasians go to Asia, getting work is really easy. They absolutely love Caucasians in Asia and they try to emulate them.

by techrep

I've worked for (2) chinese/canadian "owned" companies (really the 2nd one was owned by the Red Army via a front guy).

Almost every day I was racially discriminated against. BECAUSE I was white, i must automatically be inferior in several ways -- and worthy of no respect -- like speaking chinese so I couldn't follow the converstaion -- even though it was about me.

by eddie n

I definitely need to head out to Asia then -- it'd be a cakewalk to get a job (not like the tight NY job market)...only thing is, I can't speak Mandarin! :)

by faradhi

One case makes the whole bunch. That's right, just because tjsanko has had one company that may or may not have been discriminating, then that makes all Chinese companies with this requirement discriminatory.

Yes sir, like I said Iron Clad proof. [/sarcasm]

by x-marcap

That is a sentance I have heard since about 1978.

You may not be old enough to remember that there was a time when soldiers were respected.

Apparently, some ignorant people believe that soldiers are unthinking automations. The one idiot certainly has never heard of issueing a known false statement...

I would bet on the lowest private first class' word over any Democratic Senator except Joe Lieberman. Joe is class.

by bfilmfan

If the clients only understand that dialect of the Chinese language how could it be racism?

Is it racism to require a foreign programmer to develop the help menus in English?

by eddie n

...subtle difference but they are not the same thing. Although they are both bad, of course.

by daveo2000

If you look up the definition of "discriminate" you will find that one of the early definitions (at least in the Pocket OED) is to base differences on race or color (often referred to as racism). One of the later definitions is to "choose carefully".

So if you were choosing the definition that isn't racism then discrimination is actully a good and necessary thing.

Can you discriminate between somebody that understands operating systems and somebody that can't? Is that bad?

To discriminate against a person because of a required attribute of the job is what the HR department is hired to do: discriminate in an appropriate and legal fashion.

To discriminate against a person because of something irrelevant is usually bad [b]but isn't always[/b]. For instance, I can think of one job where the applicant is [i]required[/i] to be at least 35 years of age and must be a U.S. born citizen.

by maevinn

For example, an employer can not prevent employees from speaking another language on the job. They can't require them to speak only English (although they can establish that all official business must be done in English).

As for telling someone they wouldn't like the job--can you prove that it was because of your ethnicity? Honestly, I doubt it. There are a number of reasons why someone would be able to tell you that you wouldn't like the job. I've made the same remark to someone during an interview, based exclusively on the fact that they were applying for a job making less than half their current salary. Racist? Nope--it was a phone interview, the applicant could have been purple or green for all I knew.

I don't think it's unreasonable for a company to require it's employees be able to communicate with the folks at the top--and if that means hiring only those who speak the language. And, with almost every language out there, speaking it means understanding the culture. That's applicable to just about every language out there, since language is WAY more than just noises coming out of your mouth. For instance--American Sign Language. And yes, it is a language, and yes, there is a related culture. Being able to sign without understanding the culture behind it is likely going to result in massive miscommunication.

by tig2

You MUST understand your audience or you WON'T successfully communicate. How I carry myself when sign and, more importantly, the expressions on my face are the context for the signs with my hands.

But something tells me that you already know that, Mavyn...

Bottom line, if you don't have a clear understanding of the person you are communicating to, it is likely that you will not communicate successfully

by maevinn

And that applies to most languages. There are nuances to all languages that are not part of the 'verbal' portion--eye contact and tone of voice are 2 that readily come to mind. Even with regular spoken languages, there is always a non-verbal component that is based in culture. Think of it as a physical accent. With non-verbal languages, those aspects are more structured, and no longer subconcious--you THINK before you raise an eyebrow! Well, at least I had to learn to!

by jamesrl

Both are married to women who immigrated from China.

In Quebec there is a law that states that the official language of business is French. It isn't rigourously followed. Many large corporations with small branches in Quebec ignore the rule. There are a few employees who don't speak english well.

In the Toronto office, we can and do manadate certain jobs to be biligual.

James

by techrep

I was quoting a reviewer of the book. I have actually heard this before from other places. Essentially Bill Clinton was the victim of a VERY successful propaganda campaign and in retrospect all the studies have shown his fiscal house was significantly more in order than the administrations that came just before and just after. In fact it shouldn't be too difficult to find on the net, the information re the current administration who from what I heard has "borrowed more against the future than the sum total of all previous presidents combined". There is a very real possibility that not only will history be unkind to the current administration, several of its top members are heading for jail. I've heard for example that the real death toll from the Plame outing, is in the hundreds -- of operatives that were killed. The old "bad executive decision" slap on the wrist may be a thing of the past. It entirely depends on how friendly the NEXT adminstration wants to be (unless congress gets an overhaul then the prosecutions could start right away early next year)

My interest in this is purely business. If it is true that Republicans are bad money managers, it should be more widely known so people don't vote for them by "mistake" who are fiscal conservatives. I can point to several such anomalies here in Canada as well. For example, the Prime Minster (Mulroney) that brougth us NAFTA and Sales Tax -- and was widely hated for it by the peasants -- just won the "most environmentally friendly PM in history". Sales taxes are almost universally realized to be better than income taxes, and it has been CONSERVATIVE (read: Republican) types that have been now cutting consumtion taxes while simultaneously expanding income taxes to the point where Canada is now #1 or #2 in the G8 in terms of total revenues collected from income tax. I'm worried the USA will go there too, once the Iraq war bill comes in.

Both of our countries DESPARATELY need a party that is fiscally conservative, and socially liberal. So that we can be free living, without being bled to death on the pay stub at work. I have YET to find such a party in either country with any credibility in its leadership team.

by techexec2

Thanks for your reply. Some information for you:

Regarding:

"...I was quoting a reviewer of the book..."

If the reviewer was talking about spending on social programs, he is solidly wrong. The current administration is not spending huge sums on social program and probably less than the Clinton administration did. It is spending huge sums on military, terrorism recovery and defense, and a natural disaster (Katrina).

The Iraq war bill is about US$300 billion so far (with a "b"). That is about $1000 for each man, woman, and child living in the USA.

Unforeseen Spending on Materiel Pumps Up Iraq War Bill
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/04/19/AR2006041902594.html

---

Regarding:

"...borrowed more against the future than the sum total of all previous presidents combined..."

I believe you are correct about this. But, from the "lefty" language you are using, I would recommend you also try to read material that discusses this from a more "righty" point of view. Neither the left nor the right have a lock on truth on this matter.

---

Regarding:

"...If it is true that Republicans are bad money managers..."

In the USA, neither Republicans nor Democrats have shown themselves to be good money managers.

In general: Over the decades, Republicans have tended to spend a lot on military (Reagan, Bush 1, Bush 2...about 18 of the last 26 years), reduce income taxes, and run up budget deficits to pay for it. Democrats have tended to spend a lot on social programs (welfare, public schools, etc.) and raise income taxes to pay for it. These are tendencies only and things will vary.

You're right. The Clinton administration was much more fiscally sound. He should get some credit for that. But, remember that the Congress was controlled by Republicans most of his two terms. Congress controls the budget. And, remember the entire period of Clinton's two terms were an economic boom time fuelled by the Internet explosion and huge stock market appreciation followed by a massive crash. That was very lucky timing.

---

Regarding:

"...it should be more widely known so people don't vote for them by "mistake" who are fiscal conservatives. I can point to several such anomalies here in Canada as well..."

In the last USA presidential election (2004), the big issue was security. Everything else was secondary including the budget deficits. There are a lot of Replubicans who are not happy with the Bush administration right now. But, you can count on them to vote for the next Republican Congressman, Senator, and President when the time comes. They are scared to death of what the Democrats might do.

---

Regarding:

"...it has been CONSERVATIVE (read: Republican) types that have been now cutting consumtion taxes while simultaneously expanding income taxes to the point where Canada is now #1 or #2 in the G8 in terms of total revenues collected from income tax. I'm worried the USA will go there too, once the Iraq war bill comes in..."

It appears you are mistaken about this. In the USA, the federal government collects income taxes and NO sales taxes at all. But, there is a federal gasoline tax. The state governments collect BOTH income and sales taxes (rates vary state-to-state). This approach has been in place for many decades.

---

Regarding:

"...Both of our countries DESPARATELY need a party that is fiscally conservative, and socially liberal. So that we can be free living, without being bled to death on the pay stub at work..."

In the USA, there is a wide range of interests on this subject. But, for nearly everyone, fiscal conservatism is never the highest priority. If you are a worker, your job is more important. If you are a wealthy person, your capital is more important. If you are poor, there isn't much room in your life to be concerned about fiscal conservatism. Being able to worry about fiscal conservatism is a luxury that only a prosperous and conscientious person can afford.

by techrep

"Being able to worry about fiscal conservatism is a luxury that only a prosperous and conscientious person can afford."

Are not MOST Americans right now prosperous? In the relative sense at least? That leaves conscientious -- as I goal I'll take it. That's why I write on these forums at all. Every time someone has a chance to jostle to their mind a little is another potential step on the road from them towards conscienciousness. You see, its less important for me to be right on the details, as it is to be right on the fundimentals.

I understand that position is as counter-intuitive as you can get for IT types. But perhaps here more than any other group, is where the levels of awareness need to get UP QUICKLY -- because it is us that will be asked to build the underpinnings of ANY society -- including a police state for which the plans are well under way.

by x-marcap

The Surplus didn't really exist.

Look it up it was a possible surplus with a $0 Military budget, zero discretionary budget increase 30% reductions in intelligence dollars, and no SS raise (they gotta get it) no free meds for seniors(they don't pay for them now), etc.

There would never be that budget passed. In fact before we hace a zero dollar Military budget we should have zero dollar entitlements. The military is constitutional... Welfare is theft from people who work.

by montgomery gator

"Both of our countries DESPARATELY need a party that is fiscally conservative, and socially liberal."
=====
Well I agree with you half way. I want a party that is fiscally conservative and socially conservative. Unfortunately, we don't have one like that. The GOP used to be fiscally conservative, but now has gone along with wasteful programs like the Medicare Drug Plan and various Pork Barrel schemes that expand the Federal government.

As far as fiscally conservative and socially liberal, you might like the Libertarian party in the USA.

But I do agree with your assessment of both parties. The GOP used to be fiscally conservative, but too many GOP members of congress are spending like drunken democrats (like Ted Kennedy, if you did not get the reference).

How is the new leadership in Canada doing on the fiscal front?

by techrep

Well from what I can see the big parties in both countries are all actually fascist in idealogy. Meaning any fiscal conservation is a trick, and these parties are hostile to social minorities -- such as gay folks and immigrants.

http://www.freedomtofascism.com/

I don't know what exactly is 'wrong' with the Libertarian parties in both countries -- except for the usual bitter in-fighting. Here is where the problem seems to be...

* What happens to your estate after you die?
* Are patents a libertarian supportable idea?
* Is there any legitimate role for government?

I have some ideas to break this, but they remain to be widely tested:

* You forfeit everything when you die
* Patents are bad idea
* Yes

Ultimately you have to get rid of the current international legal system, otherwise we are rearranging deck chairs on the titantic. For this I propose three new types of law:

* Human Law
* Transit Law
* Work-place Law

Human Law trumps -- Transit Law -- Trumps Workplace Law. Human Law is universal, Transit Law is inter-jurisdiction (treaties and so on), Work-Place law is contractual (contracts between people and corporations, and people and people).

Such that say banning or abusing a gay person is universally illegal, but you might prevent the TRAVEL of a gay person to a certain place, and you might even refuse to hire a gay person. In this way Texas could have one scenerio, but California another -- without violating any true human rights or destroying the republic. In this way your personal choices could hurt you (financially and travel wise) but never threaten your being.

This allows for "local flavour" without permitting violence under any circumstances.

by techrep

military people kill blindly on orders...the rest of us refer to that as psychopathy. until the millitary has a code of ethics (like making it a crime to lie) normal people are going to distrust military.

Proof the current millitary is run/operated by psychopaths: Depleted Uranium

see Dorsai! -- Gordon R Dickson for HOW to build a military with human values and deadly potent war-fighting ethics.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0441160255/104-6962485-4768740?v=glance&n=283155

by maevinn

Sorry--this is in response to the comment that the military is trained to blindly kill.

Don't be a complete idiot. No branch of the military is trained to 'blindly kill'. Nor are they trained to 'blindly follow orders'. Heck, most of the 'Armed Forces' aren't armed. Did they learn how to shoot in basic training? Yep. Do they carry a gun day to day? Highly unlikely. It's bigotry on a disturbing level to even suggest, and shows that you know next to nothing about the modern military. Glad they've given their lives to ensuring that you have the freedom to be ignorant.

by jamesrl

I have one ex para working for me, and we both have to deal with a supervisor who is ex infantry. Proof that the military is not immune to human falabilities.....

Funnily enough, their units hated each other, and they dislike each other on the job, but in reality its probably more co-incidence than anything.

I have no complaints with my ex military guy. He is darn loyal and hardworking.

James

by wingedmonkey

Now that you made that kind of generalization, can you back that up with some kind of support?
A good third of the people in my department are vets. I will offer that as a counter to your statement.

by eddie n

What is wrong with requiring that the candidate can speak English and Mandarin? Maybe the company does business in China or Taiwan. And who said that only people of Chinese descent can speak Mandarin? For example, I have a (black American) friend who was tapped for a job with the UNDP mostly because she grew up in Japan (her dad was an Army man) and she speaks Japanese fluently.

All the experience that this job needs is Windows-based. Would you be shouting "discrimination" if you wanted to apply for this job, and you had only Mac experience?

Your concern is totally unfounded. Every (natural) language that one learns improves one's chances of standing out from the normal crowd of over-certified techies looking for employment, and that can only be a good thing. This is a global economy, and if you can speak the langauge of your foreign business partners, it can only be to your advantage. (After all, when it comes to people in China, there are only 230 million of us, and more than one billion of them!) The latent xenophobia shown by the original poster is exactly why this country is going down the tubes so fast. The United States has no official language, and even if we did, it still shouldn't prevent its citizens (who come from all over the world) from learning, speaking, reading, writing, or expressing themselves in any other human language.

One last thought: those people who are so self-righteously saying that the US should make English the official language because of our "history" conveniently forget that the country was discovered by an Italian who was sponsored by a Spanish queen, and most of the early explorers spoke Spanish, Portuguese, French and Italian -- not English. By rights, our official language should be Spanish!

In any event, there are much much more important things going on in this world than the whole official language question.

by jdclyde

If there are a lot of people that YOU would be working with that only spoke Mandarin, then it is perfectly reasonable to hire only someone where there will not be a language barrier.

No discrimination here.

Many government jobs HERE require multiple languages. Just because you were too lazy to take up another language does not mean that only Chinese can/will speak it. Many Chinese learn English, so why is the reverse so out of the question? Because we are too lazy.

by techexec2

Regarding:

"...no free meds for seniors(they don't pay for them now)..."

You must not be talking to seniors about this. If you did, you would find that the new "wonderful" meds program DOES provide additional coverage. But, the seniors have also LOST coverage on the more expensive yet still commonly used meds. So, the net result for those seniors is a LOSS.

There is no free lunch. Ever. Yet, politicians keep taking credit for providing free lunches.

by juleslt

>Not to sound racist or prejudice, but Chinese run >businesses in NYC prefer to work with their own >people and have a very xenophobic attitude towards >those of non-Chinese origin.

Actually, that does sound racist. You're making a generalised assertion, and playing the race card rather than looking for a simple explanation that the job is going to require knowledge of Mandarin.

I've seen UK based IT jobs that have required knowledge of French or German, and unfortunately not been able to apply for them, but I haven't thought that they were trying to protect the jobs for German applicants.

(And my local Chinese supermarket employees non-Chinese staff on the tills).

by aric

Perhaps the bank employees' - especially key project stakeholders and executive management - primary language is Chinese Mandarin. If so, it is important that any contractor is able to 'speak their language' to ensure business & IT objectives are effectively communicated. With this in mind, I personally don't view this a discrimination.

by problemsolversolutionseeker

Discriminating a spoken language should be no different than discriminating a computer language.
I am a proud US citizen who understands the importance of my English and/or European heritage.
But if a business has language needs other than English, they should seek those skills, rather than cater to me. Those skills should be treated the same as the 'languages' of Windows NT and company.
Selah.

by hamilton.teixeira

It is possibly for the same reason why a capable candidate in most of the countries outside the US, looking for a qualified job in an American company, has to speak English, besides his/her native language... This does not look like discrimination to me.

by mmelvis

If the company is owned by an overseas parent company you may have to deal with the home office. Many times the primary IT staff will be based in the other country. Look at this as an opportunity to expand your current skill set and open the door to many other opportunities.

by it & telecom guy

Bottom Line is the employer and boss can hire whomever they want. If they can't find a person that fits the narrow characteristics, they broaden the search. After all they pay - this is a free society.

by woodhead1

Since we do not know the company involved, it may be a company that does a lot of business and have a number of offices in China. This is possible in today's world of Multi-National corporations. If you will have to coordinate with users or staff in China, it is unreasonable to claim "Well since I am in the US, YOU must learn English so YOU can speak to me."

by mollenhourb9

I'm sorry. I have to cut loose on this one as the premise of your complaint is so ludicrous. If ignorance of the real world were corn flakes, you'd be general mills. I say this not because I don't like you (I don't even know you), but to shake you out of whatever bubble you are living in so you can get the kind of job for which you are looking, and keep that job.

You are going to work for a Chinese company. You are in a job that is a service to the rest of the company. You have no reason for existence at that company other than to keep the real business going.

It is not unreasonable to require that a person in your position be fluent in the mother tongue of the company directors and home country of the company. You will likely need to interact with Chinese people who have written requirements for systems you will develop. You need to be able to understand them. Expecting the whole company to turn itself on it's ear so that you, a low level grunt, can be understood by them is not reasonable.

I'm sorry this was so harsh. For the record, I don't speak Mandarin and likely never will.

by gardoglee

Q: What do you call someone who speaks two languages? A: Bilingual.

Q: What do you call someone who speaks three languages? A: Trilingual.

Q: What do you call someone who only speaks one language? A: American.

I would be the last to say that there are no Americans who are multi-lingual, but it is embarrassingly true that multi-lingual Americans have become a rare exception. It has negative impacts in being unable to understand others (e.g., the NSA, FBI and CIA cannot even find enough foreign language speakers, much less businesses), and the not-too-much-subtler impact of making us forget that the entire rest of the world is not just some huge third world ghetto lusting after our American way of life.

The rest of the world might surprise you. That is, if you can get out of the tiny little racist (yes, you are a racist - but you need to figure that out yourself) world.

As so many others have already said, there are many broad categories of reasons why the job posting requires Mandarin, most of which boil down to the simple explanation that the job may involve working with someone who's native language is not American English. What's the problem with that? When you can answer why you think that is a problem, you'll understand a lot more about the world, and about yourself.

In the meantime, I know some atypical Americans who actually speak Chinese, among other non-English languages. I'll pass along the word that there is an interesting job posting out there. Their gain, your loss.

by x-marcap

French, Mais oui! Deutsch! Ya! Da Russ! Chinese, and Spanish are in all of our kits. See earlier post.

The issue becomes racism or discrimination when well qualified candidates are dismissed in 30 seconds and told they wouldn't be happy... People with the skillset but not right appearance have no chance. I understand "Fat round eyed giant"...

by maevinn

[Quote]
You are in a job that is a service to the rest of the company. You have no reason for existence at that company other than to keep the real business going.[/Quote]

This is something that I think many people in the IT industry need to write on their mental chalkboards 100 times. I've seen and worked with entirely too many IT people who consider themselves critical to the business, no matter what that business might be. Get real--most professions have been around since long before the computer.

by tig2

The good thing about it as I was learning ASL was that I became more aware of stance and inflection as well as general body language in spoken communication. I also became more sensitive to nuance- something that many people don't think of.

I find also that my written communication improved somewhat (although there is always room...) as I became more aware of how people read and where one's comprehension level might be.

To the original poster's point, the ability to manage to a variety of cultural needs is a "must have" skill set. If that means fluency in a specific language, that is what it means.

by jamesrl

My company is based out of the US. We have employees in Quebec, where the official language of business is English. Yet for management in that province, they are required, by our US parent, to be bilingual - in order to be able to work within the larger corporate framework. All correspondence to 'all" employees is available in French for those in Quebec. But managers must be able to attend conferences and communicate in English as well.

So are we racist?

James

by x-marcap

Many fine linguists come through the Presidio.

5x5 is perfect fluency written and speech.
4x5 is my French, Spanish, Russian and Greek.
3x5 is my Chinese. (English my native language is also 3x5)

I found it funny how my native born language isn't as "fluent" as the 6 week immersion classes from the Presidio...

by jstuhlmiller

I know a few non asians that speak fluent mandarin. I agree that although its a bummer if you are looking for work and see a posting like that but i believe it is a legitimate requirement especially if all the data hosted is in a mix of english and mandarin windows operating systems etc etc

by blueknight

The bank may be located in the U.S. but how many of them do business solely in the U.S. It could be that you would be expected to be able to work (converse) with individuals in remote offices which could very well be located in the orient. That would justify the language requirement.

Just a thought.

by ddjohn

They may have a legitimate business need for someone who can speak Mandarin. Then again, if it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, tastes like a duck...it must be a duck. The same thing applies to business communications. If they place an add that sounds like they discriminate, then all their customers and employees and candidates will assume that this is how they do business. If they are not intending to be discriminatory in their hiring, and want to avoid bad press, and possible law suits, not to mention government inquiries by EEOC, then maybe they should offer a bit of reasoning as to why the skill is important to them. Down here in Miami we see these ads constantly, but they are looking for spanish. It would be refreshing to see the explanation in the ads. But then they might have to explain why european names do not get call backs or interviews to demonstrate their spanish conversation skills.

by gnbonney

I used to work for companies where you had to be a US citizen. There are still a few of those kinds of jobs around due to security clearances, but the last six years I've worked for IT organizations where US citizens are in the minority. Working with people who have various foreign accents is now the norm.

I haven't had to learn Chinese just yet, but I do have one Chinese friend who once suggested I should have my kids take Chinese. His theory was that so many products are made there now that Chinese could replace English as the international language of business.

Maybe he's right.

by georgeou

Caucasians do very well in Asia in general. That's just a fact of life over there. Just look at how much they try to emulate them by changing their hair color and curling their hair. I don?t know about any other race though, I would tentatively have to say no.

by vshav66

I am a Reservist with over 20 Years in the military which includes multiple combat tours. I will have you know that the vast majority of employers love military experience. While not all, most vets are much more responsible and have a better work ethic than those without the experience. We also tend to be able to think on our feet which is a great plus when working in a fast paced dynamic environment. When I first got our of Active duty I was told repeatedly that I work too hard, in reality it was an easier work environment than I was used to. The Canadian gentlemen should rest assured that his freedom is guaranteed by those better than himself.

by gardoglee

Calling a requirement for fluency in Mandarin ethnic discrimination is like calling a requirement for expert skills in writing Java age discrimination. By the logic in the original post, every time I see a job for a programmer I should sue the company for discrimination if they are not sufficiently impressed with my BAL and FORTRAN skills to give me a fair interview.

by puterwrecker

Where does it say anything about the applicant having to be Chinese? I'm working with many colleagues who speak fluent Chinese, and they are all native born Americans. But they had the forsight to see that since China is our largest trade partner in the world, it might be a good idea to learn Chinese. If the job was given to a native Chinese speaking person, he or she would have to know English fluently, and they would therefore be better qualified for the job than you. They're not talking about racial preferences, just qualifications.

by john2kyle

A business owner in a forgien nation has the right, if not the absolute need and responsibility to have what is happening with their equipment and information explained to them in a manor they can understand. Consider yourself lucky they don't bring thier own techs as some other corporations do.

by techrep

If Joe is to be the man, I hope y'all get behind him quick like! There is a BIG problem in America -- one of the focal points being the electronic voting machines -- a VERY IT related issue. IF X-mililtary IT Types supported say Joe from that angle -- electronic voting machines are not secure -- it could have a huge impact! How about a new electronic voting machine company, that makes a secure version of such a machine. And maybe a "travelling road show" of x-Mil IT people behind him in every camera shot...good stuff.

by pmatamoros

Hi everyone,

I?m from Argentina and lived in New Zealand for the last 3 years.

I think it isn?t a matter of discrimination but a set of skills needed.

When I worked in Argentina most of the advertisements required technical skills and good English. What is wrong in America that someone can?t ask for ?Mandarin?, ?Spanish?, ?French? or any other language? By the way, we speak Spanish in Argentina.

In New Zealand Asia has a big influence, in particular China. If you walk around Auckland you first impression is that you are in China and the ?Caucasians? are tourist. You will find every single day lots of advertisement like the following one:

COMPUTER TECHNICIAN Support. Exceptional opportunity for talented individual with computer qualification and experience. Responsibility for computer hardware, website development, maintenance. Outstanding verbal and written skills both in English and Mandarin are required If you are interested in the positions we are offering, please send your CV to: PO Box 36622, Northcote or icec05@gmail.com

I worked with people from China, and tell you it is not easy. They simply have a different culture. So I guess is fair enough that they advertise that they require Mandarin, whatever is the reason.

I tell you what discrimination is, suffered myself. Discrimination is:

- When they don?t bother to read your CV just because of your name and surname (Pablo Matamoros isn?t it too much Spanish?)
- When you go to interviews, and you are asked ?Do you have NZ experience?? That?s a hot topic for immigrants in this country
- When you pass two or three stages of selection process and in the last meeting the interviewer tells you openly that they prefer a native English speaker because they are afraid that you will get confused and tired, etc., etc?..
I passed all the English exams required for immigrations and my partner is from New Zealand. My accent is obvious, but my grammar and spelling is far better than many kiwis. I?m a teacher, can tell by experience.

You touched my nerve, I could keep writing pages and pages

Regards from the bottom of the world.

by bblacklock

As someone who lives and works in a city where less than one in five people were born and raised here, I commonly see ads for employment which have a language requirement. Even jobs which do not have a mandated language requirement are often offered to multi-lingual applicants.

It is a fact of life in our industry that you will often have to deal with other languages either first or second hand. If your customers are more comfortable in another language, it only makes sense to accomodate them. If the original language of the documentation is something other than your primary language (English in this case), you can experience major frustration in trying to figure out what the programmer was trying to say.

In my working career I have found that the more languages you can work in the better you can do the primary job of the IT department, support the user.

As an example, a major oilfield company I worked for had employees whose primary languages were English, Russian, German, Vietmanese, Arabic, Yugoslavian, Mandarin Chinese, Hindi and Plains Cree. While all of these employees spoke English (to some level) it was easier to get the point across if you tried to use their primary language.

We also had to deal with documentation in Japanese, Russian and German. Again some of the details were lost in translation to English, so it was often useful to read the documents in the original language.

While I would be annoyed to be pushed out a job for not being Chinese (as opposed to being a speaker of Chinese Mandarin), the employer may have a very good reason for that language requirement and I would do some research to find out more about the company before I yelled "discrimination".

As I have worked in organizations where I was not of the specific ethnic or cultural group, I can tell you that sometimes it causes some confusion when a North-American cultural assumption clashes with the local cultures views. The company may be trying to eliminate this sort of problem by ensuring that their IT department can speak (and thus to some level think) in that language.

In the final analysis, research the company to see if the language requirement is a bias or a sensible job requirement. If a job requirement, then either learn Mandarin, if you really want that job. If only a bias, then realize that you may not be comfortable in their corporate structure no matter what you do and pursue other opportunities.

by gardoglee

...one of the most important and uniquely defining things about America is that we are "a culture of immigrants". While that doesn't do a whole lot for Native Americans, being the ones displaced by the immigrants, it is often cited as part of why we are a free, democratic, and supposedly tolerant society, working hard to avoid discriminating on the basis of race, creed, religion, gender, etc. The implicit assumption is that the reason we find discrimination abhorent is because we are so diverse. If one only applies that standard to past immigrants, and then gets bent out of shape over current or future immigrants, then those attitudes are not what at least some of us think of as American.