Discussion Locked

Exchange MTA to DMZ or NOT

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi,

I have a ever going discussion with peers. We use to have an exchange server for our internal mail and a pop 3 on unix for internet mail. We are installing a new exchange server to get internet mail (No Outlook web access or mailboxes on this machine just IMS) and we are consern with security. Is it better to put the new exchange inside the firewall ad open only smtp port or put it in a DMZ open smtp to dmz and netbios and all other ports needed from dmz to the internal network. I amwilling to pay 500 points for a complete secure but fonctional Cisco PIX solution.

7 replies

by tony.colgrove

If you can keep inbound internet traffic to the DMZ do it.
One question- Do you need an Exchange Server with the IMS in the DMZ, or will the IIS4 or IIS5 SMTP service work, or even use an AntiVirus SMTP product out there. NAI, Trend, etc.. all have an SMTP service that scans for viruses and can do SPAM blocking, Relay prohibiting, forwarding etc.. for a little less cost then another Exchange Server Licencse, just to do IMS.

by bag

I am looking for a complete solution with access list and open ports.

by nichomach

As noted above, your best solution will be to install an SMTP relay server of whatever type in your DMZ, and then to only allow SMTP traffic from the relay server's address to your Exchange IMS which would be inside your FW. Set your Exchange box to forward all traffic to the SMTP relay server. This would avoid you having to open anything but the SMTP port through the firewall even from your internal network to the SMTP relay.

by bag

I have a problem with this. Some users are not inside the organisation and will need pop3 or IMAP4 connection to the server in the dmz?

by estebandelatorre

The Normal solution will be to keep the mta server inside the lan, but in a different machine, not the same as the postoffice, ONLY with the ip STACK protocol (no more) and the latest service pack available.
To strengh security, not make the machine member of the domain, create a stand alone server, rename the administrator account and create a very strange user and password for the echange services.
You will have to Open ports 25, and 53 both port for I and O, and only for that specific ip address (the mta's ip address)
Probable port 53 is open for everyboy, so open 25 for mta's ip address for i&o

Hope it helps!!!

This discussion is closed to new replies.