Discussion Locked

Extrovert MOther/Adult Introvert Daughter, advice needed from introverts

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Hi, I am 56, divorced since 1985, my daughter is 27. My daughter and I have had a difficult relationship since she was engaged about 3 years ago. She is quite an introvert and I am an extreme extrovert. I didn't know until she had the freedom to "escape" that she didn't like my personality and me. WE still love each other, and I think the help I need is ..... as a blabbermouth extrovert, how can I speak or shut up in a way that is good for her. We truly love each other. Now remember, I can't really become an introvert, but I can learn about how extroverts can slow down, calm down and shut up for a while for introverts. I think, she feels, Myers Briggs. I "think" she avoids me because there is lack of trust of privacy (our levels are extremely different) and I have an aggressive and competitive personality, all the wrong things for her. My friend said I am a dog that married a cat and had 2 cat children, and I think that explains it. I don't feel introverts or extroverts are any better or worse, I just don't know how to learn a language that doesn't hurt her and one that doesnt' hurt me too. I don't know how this site works, but I can be emailed at zaneyzelda2@yahoo.com

20 replies

by zaneyzelda3

Oh, she knows. We try and try, but I think when she got married, she felt a respite. And since my personality is so intense, and she is so reserved, it almost takes a referee to get me quieter and her noisier :) Just thought some introverts can tell me what it feels like to have an extreme introvert and try to talk to them and tell them change is needed. She HATES. conflict and I can debate very well, even without know it. ANy more ideas.

by tig2

When I have to deal with people I would rather not, I set limits from the beginning about the contact- from length of time to acceptable subject matter. This way, we all know what expectations are reasonable.

Starting the conversation from the standpoint that you are seeking ways to improve your relationship will help too. Remember, as much as you are entitled to be a dog, she is entitled to be a cat.

Good luck!

by maxwell edison

If you were a good debater, you'd understand your daughter's position; since you don't, you're not. My guess is that you're confusing debating with brow-beating.

by Member 25348569

And try and learn from it. You state that your daughter doesn't like you and then you proceed to justify this state of affairs with labels - "introvert" and "extrovert" and claptrap such as "I think, she feels". Well, obviously, you DON'T think.

Why are YOU going to "set the limits"? YOU think it will be great. Hello? Get the drift? Leopard...spots - or you will lose your daughter and possibly your grandchildren

Actually, zanyzelda (and the name speaks for itself), I don't think that I like you much either.

Neil

by tig2

And don't know if you are still looking for responses.

I can hear Max's initial response that perhaps you are being controlling. And I think that it could be helpful if you could hear the help he intends.

I hate being told that I can be controlling. But I HAVE to HEAR that input in order to best choose an avenue of communication.

In order to communicate, two sides MUST be present. Both sides MUST have a "common dictionary". A common dictionary is best defined as a glossary of terms that both will use.

One of the biggest blocks to communicating is the way we interpret each other. What you may call debate may easily be called brow beating by someone else. How common is this? VERY!

My father is a really great debater. In adulthood, I appreciate that in him. In younger days, I found it difficult to deal with. I was fortunate in that I discovered his "dictionary" and was able to use it.

Your daughter is simply without a dictionary with which to understand you. Not uncommon.

As you choose to set limits, try to do so WITH your daughter's input. Do so from a neutral atmosphere. Have the conversation from the standpoint of asking her to tell you what she hears you say. HEAR her responses. Let her know that you are simply looking for a way to maintain a positive relationship and that you are willing to try this method- or any other- to improve the relationship. Ask her for HER thoughts and reflect to her what you hear her say.

Be ready for her to say that she needs to have a level of separation. Be ready to be open to that. And be ready to work with her terms.

I regret that I do not have a close relationship with my mother. I feel that hurt especially in the last several years. I dealt with breast cancer alone and now an upcoming wedding- she's willing to accept the odd call from me but not willing to be a support. It hurts.

I wish that she had been willing to recognise that I am different from what she is comfortable with. But I can't change much in the current situation. Too much time, too many events, too much hurt- probably on both sides. Don't make that mistake.

Women will understand what you are saying without a dictionary in many cases. Men may have a more difficult time. Just as I sometimes have a hard time understanding my fiancee's relationship with his son. Some things are just gender specific.

Hang in there!

by maxwell edison

Spare yourself -- and everyone else -- the introvert and extrovert nonsense. Your daughter is an adult capable of free-will and decision-making responsibility. If she's not, you made her that way with your smothering tendencies. When are you gonna' stop? Your "extrovert" comment is just another way of saying you want to control people. Give it up, already. Find something to fill the voids in your own life so you don't have to butt into your daughter's to find it.

by zaneyzelda3

thank you for thoughtful reply. I'm sure the people on this site appreciate your wisdom and insight. Keep up the good work

by maxwell edison

.....and you don't like the song I'm singing. But when ground rules have to be established for two people to maintain a relationship, it usually means one or the other needs to change her tune. But people usually don't like to tinker with a composition they've been writing all their lives, and I see you as no exception. And it's obvious that you want to be a conductor in the type of relationship that requires more improvisation. It's no wonder your daughter wants to sing acappella, your choir has probably been drowning her out. And if you're not willing to consider the fact that it's you who's singing off-key, you'll probably never find good harmony.

by tonythetiger

your daughter probably calls it overbearing. Examine why you want a relationship with your daughter and be honest with yourself. Would you want one if she wasn't your daughter?

by jdclyde

People do things out of guilt that they would not otherwise.

A misplaced sense of obligation?

Or simply refusing to accept that they might have failed in something?

Of course we don't have enough information to make this call, but I have met many mothers and mother-in-laws that are oblivious to the fact that people do not look forward to their visits because they are overly opinionated, judgmental, and overbearing.

On the other hand, I have met many kids that are just unappreciative brats.

A third possibility is new son does not like mother and is the one behind this all?

Look at the harshest possibilities first if you really are looking for a solution, and don't disregard the chance that it is you and your controlling ways that COULD be a problem.

Good luck finding what your looking for.

by maxwell edison

We could have had some fun with this conversation. What's the matter? Can't you handle someone who won't cower to you? Or does the truth hurt that much? Oh well, on to bigger and better things!

by jdclyde

she wanted someone to tell her how to[b] change her daughter[/b], because her [b]daughter[/b] has this big problem........

She didn't for a second think that the problem could be her, or that people here would be brutally honest enough to point it out!

She will run off to find other mothers that have alienated their daughters so they can cluck about what a shame their daughters are the way they are, and there should be a way to fix THE DAUGHTERS, never for a second thinking that it was them that drove their daughters away.

After Neil posted, I bet she never even came back again and is busy telling everyone how mean they are on this nasty web site she had stumbled upon.

by customsunlimited

As the father of 3 sons and 2 daughters, I will answer.

NONE of my kids are the same. My sons were independant of me except for the most basic of needs. They perferred their mothers. I dealt with it by loving them and helping advise them WHEN THEY ASKED FOR IT!

My daughters, by extreme contrast, smother me with constant affection, and basically ignore their mother, except when necessary.

Notice anything there?

Basic biology, Girls need their daddy's to develop normally. Genetically, girls are closer to their daddy's than their mothers, and vice-versa with boys. YOU denied your daughter her basic biological need by choosing the "Single-Mom" lifestyle, for what-ever reason. Very selfish of you! Now you complain of the consequences of that action.

As parents, we have the obligation and necessity, to maintain the basic family group. You cheated your daughter, and most likely her father, of a very fulfilling relationship together, just to satisfy your own self. You lacked the COMMITMENT to the core family, and went your own way.

Live with it, and love her unconditionally. Help her WHEN SHE ASKS FOR IT! You made this bed, now you have to sleep in it for the rest of your life.

by crusher517

I thought this mentality had been eradicated - at least in the world of techies. Who said she CHOSE a single mom lifestyle? We don't always have a choice. There are chronic cheaters, physical & mental abusers, alcoholics, pederasts and worse that women wake up to find they've married. (And yes, sometimes it works the other way too.) No one should have to stay in a sick or dysfunctional relationship. Some people are born broken, and no amount of commitment can fix them. Better to get off the sinking ship than go down with it.

by maxwell edison

There's no way of knowing which it is, or possibly something different (like a death). I'll tell you one thing, however, I wouldn't want to be married to her. But if I was, I'd be persistent enough and smart enough to stick it out until my kids were grown so I could protect them from her and provide an "alternative" relationship that's encouraging rather than discouraging! There's one thing that just as abhorrent to me as a man who wants to dominate a woman and/or his kids -- and that's a woman who wants to do the same thing. Personally speaking, I wouldn't stand for it. And to me, it's clearly obvious -- that lady has a problem.

by johnscott16

Hi Zanezelda3,

I understand and sympathise with your situation. It sounds to me like you care for her very much and you want the best for her. I guess your daughter is the sensitive type and does not like what you have to say re her fiancee / engagement ?

My advice for you is to try to be sensitive when you communicate with your daughter. ie ask your self if you can say what you want to say but soften your language style.
Also encourage her to speak up, chances are she is holding back on you and the avoidance is the worst thing that can happen in any relationship. You may not like what she has to say and it may take a lot of patience on your part to not interrupt.

I can appreciate how difficult this may be.
If you want to read up on communication styles I would recommemd the Impact TDF model. ( Thinker, Feeler, Do'er, )

Another strategy you could try is to spend some quality time or mom/daughter activity with her where you agree to not talk about certain topics.

Sometimes just spending time together without talking can help. Especially if you are both trying to "win" an argument. Our own ego's can be our worst enemies at times.

I hope this is of some use to you.

all the best,
John.

by charliespencer

I'm sure your advice is well-intentioned and worthwhile, but the original post is over a year old and the poster was never heard from again.

This discussion is closed to new replies.