Discussion Locked

Fair Competition?

0 helpful
156 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Is it fair for a person who has no degrees in computer science to compete with one who has it for the same job?
Is it fair, when there are those who persevered and toiled to earn a degree in CS, only to find that many of the CS positions are held by individuals who just ventured into the marked because they couldn't find jobs in their own professions or just because they were seeking better income. I would think it's fair, if it worked both ways.
Can you, as a holder of BSCS, apply for a psychology-related position? If not, then why was it OK for a person who majored in psychology to compete with you for a computer job--if not become your boss. Please, exclude exceptions, i.e. don't just focus in your reply on the cases in which the guy with no BSCS is doing a better job than you. I'm talking about the situation where you are just as good (if not much better, which is often the case.)
Shouldn't there be a criterion for computer positions--just as there are ones for most other professions?!
Can I, with no degree in Engineering, go and compete for a job against an engineer with a bachelor's degree in Civil Engineering?
Well, why does it seem that anyone on earth with just 3 or 4 months of study of some certification can come and compete for the same job with someone who has spent at least 4 years of academic education for a Bachelor's degree and experience in computer science? In some instances, they might be working in the cubicle next yours and making MORE money than you do--let alone having your boss as someone who holds a degree in some arts or physical education; or no 4-year degree at all!!! This renders a Bachelor's in Computer Science truely worthless!!!
Often times, it's not really that the guy--or gal--in the cubicle next to oyu is doing a better job than you are that earns them the extra money or authority. How about favoritism, attraction, other preferences that are irrelevant to the job?!
If a degree in CS were a benchmark, then at least, you would be competing against peers in the profession.
Or maybe we should do away with degrees altogether, and one could go and apply for any sort of job as long as you demonstrate the willingness to do it and the enthusiasm to learn!
But then again, I should be allowed to open a car repair shop, without having to become a licensed mechanic; I should be able to be an electrician without needing a license to practice,... how about a doc?!

156 replies

by deadly ernest

All a degree does is say that you spent so many years be taught matters relevant to that subject and supposedly have a certain level of knowledge and skill to justify the issue of the degree. All the material that is taught in those classes is learnt from other people, mostly non degree people, recording what they have learnt in real life situations. Today most organisations recognise that years of experience can teach as much, if not more than, a degree.

Several years back I went for a job in a particular government dept working in a specialised financial administrative area. I had no degree or certificate saying that I knew this material - I was not granted an interview. All the people interviewed had recently finished uni degrees and also done a special course on that subject that another government dept ran. The head of the branch doing the employment refused to even read applications from people whe did not have relevant degrees.

I complained about not being interviewed. In the wash up after the affair that branch head did NOT get a peformance bonus that year. I had no degree or certs in the subject. I had only been the person to introduce it to the government sphere and make it work. Written the three government papers on how to do that work within the government financial structure and was a guest lecturer at the coiurse that certified people. 30 years experience and taught the stuff but, according to the branch head, no degree meant I was no good and knew nothing.

I got fed up with the 'require a degree' garbage in finance and admin and now do tech work where most people will accept knowing how to do the job is more important than framed wall paper.

by cheerstork

Ernest, I completely respect your opinion. From my vantage point, a college degree helps in forming your knowledge; in about 4 years, you learn about many things that will certainly help shape your personality and arm you with many skills, as you go on sailing in the seas of life! Also, if employers repected and valued a computer science degree, I think that computer programs would be more efficient and networks would be more reliable. The reason is, in my opinion, someone who spent years studying CS (generally, that is) would most likely possess broad and comprehensive and science-based knoledge that will render their work more integral and efficient.
I do have a bachelor's in computer science and about 7 years of work experience. Nevertheless, due to various reasons, my work experience is scattered in several areas of IT...programming, networking, databases, project management, security...It makes my resume seem very unfocused and makes it very difficult to get a job counting all of the years of experience!

by deadly ernest

in this issue not the employers. Here in Australia the CS degree has very little relevance to daily IT work but useful if you want to get into big time design work for people like Intel and AMD, research, etc. For normal work stuff you do the college courses.

The reasons for the difference is deeply routed in the academic attitude to education and learning. About 20 years ago the Prime Minister of the day (Bob Hawke)organisd a big conference with employers, unions and educationalists to review the relevance of the modern education system. The outcomes from this were many and varied but centered around the concepts of competency based training and work related courses for higher education. The colleges (TAFEs here) went with it, the unis fought against it as it basically said the academics running the uni courses were out of touch with the workplace realities - they sure got that right. This has resulted in the gap widening in some areas, and in some unis revamping their courses - took them over 15 years to act. The best degrees here are those where a TAFE and uni have combined forces to offer a degree including studies at both - the local employers like it.

The daily reality is that most employers do not care about you ability to understand the basic physics and design new computer circuitry, what they want is your ability to diagnose a fault and set up systems, etc. And that is where your experience will outway the degree. The biggest pity about that is the people offering the CS degrees do NOT tell the prospective students this, otherwise they would have no students.

by onbliss

...I do like the allround experience that you have. In my humble opinion your degree and rich/diverse experience must be an invaluable asset.

by too old for it

I applied for a position that was interviewed by a team lead who was all about certs and degrees. He was a young pup, and was a recently minted college grad himself. Of course, I didn't get the job, and I found out later that he was no longer there, as the frat boys he hired only exacerbated his drinking problem.

I think it is just easier for interviewers to match degrees and certs to a crib sheet rather than determine if a candidate has any real skills.

From what I have seen coming out of the local university, the most common thing learned is how to drink when underage and how to stay looped most of 4 years and still get a degree.

by hellums

If you're saying it's an HR thing, and that the cert is what's important, then just get the cert. To sit on a skill/experience set or a degree, and demand it get recognition you think it deserves, is cutting off your nose to spite your face. If you were the owner of a company, and you needed a Windows programmer, would you hire the MCSD/MCAD or the BSCS? Consider this: the college I just left offers C++, not Java. What does the BSCS tell you, then? If you needed a Windows SQL database manager, would you hire the MSIS with a database specialty, or the MCDBA? Seriously, think about it. A BSCS is not a terminal degree, and you can't stop learning or gaining experience. Part of that new experience is certification. If someone else can get certified without the BS or MS, give them the props, rather than the envy. You could have followed the same route, right? The rules are the same for everyone. Creating a union to protect your choice isn't what the industry needs. It needs problem-solvers. If the problem is you lacking a certification or two, then do the extra work and get the certification. So who do you think they'll hire, the short-track person with certs only, or the person with the certs AND a degree? Hmmm....

by ed woychowsky

Worked in a place where someone with a bachlors in physical education would get the position before someone with an associates in computer science.

by psifiscout

The arguement of degree vs cert is a moot one. A person may have a degree an not know the subject matter, the same is true of the cert holder. However, (in my opinion only) the degree holder is typically the better candidate since the academic environment also demands a bit however small of personal interaction, not necessarliy true of the cert holder. I use my own case as an example. I hold two degrees in IT and both required classroom interaction, I also hold individual certifications from CompTIA and Microsoft, these required nothing more social than sitting alone in a computer lab plying the books then applying the knowledge to the software/hardware. Did I learn any social skills in the certification process? Not really. Did I learn the tech material better through the certification process? Maybe but I also lost the learning by interaction with people with a common interest in the classroom. So if a cert is to be considered better than the degree it would only be true of the cases where the certification exam were preceeded by formal classroom instruction where something more than the individuals interpretation of the material were present. I have met people in the IT industry with every cert in the books and the social skills of a rabid wolverine. I have also met people, very smooth socialites in supervisory IT positions, who have trouble finding the power button on a desktop PC.

Finding the right balance is indeed a rare moment, but there is no magic answer to what works best.

"Hiring managers hone you skills before making the hire."

by deadly ernest

I don't know what things are like in the USA and Canada (where most of you lot are), but here in Australia there are three main ways to get IT qualifications

University degree - CS, BA etc 4 years study in class.

TAFE diploma or certificate (tech college) - 6 months to two years class study and hands on, usually some work experience time.

Manufacturer's certificate - CNA, MSCE etc - usually just pay fee and sit the test, but some people offer classroom training first.

The problem with most of the uni courses is that there is no or very little actual hands on or interaction with the real life situation, it is virtually all theory and sometimes it is behind the times and usually behind current industry practices. The problem with TAFE is that it does not give much in the way of the history or general science theory. The poblem with the certs is that they are over focussed and cover nothng outside the minimum to pass them.

A well rounded IT tech should know some history, some theory, have some practical experience and some sort of way to demonstrate skill and knowledge levels with either a qualification or a good work history. The ideal would have some TAFE qual to which they have added experience, then some manuf certs and a uni degree part-time. The experience would be the most useful.

I once got 6 months contract work by an IT company local office to take 3 uni grads, that were hired by head office, and teach them the practical side of what they needed to do the job they had been hired for. Four years uni training and they had never been in a server room or seen a patch panel - qualified future network and server engineers who had done the history and theory, gone through all the books and had not yet handled any actual hardware or worked remotely on any machine - only live computer experience being their own home computer. Not good. Mind you it was possible to give these guys a network diagram and they could work out the bottle necks and tell you how to improve the network - they just could not do the actual work. HO should have hired one to do the design and then two TAFE techs to do the actual work.

by tony hopkinson

I started learning computers in 77, got into the job in 87 and I've been doing it ever since. So it really depends on how much experience and in what.

Your post is a little confusing, I can't figure out whether you've got the degree or you haven't. Tell me and I'll give you a few tips on how to compete.
Unless you've got some real experience in the subject area (not necessarily in IT), it's very difficult to compete with someone with the bit of paper. If they've got paper and experience, then it comes down to personalities and relevance, or at least it should.

by cheerstork

Tony, I do have a Bachelor's of Science in CS. What I was saying is that it seems quite unfair to spend 4 years studying CS and graduating, only to compete for a job with someone with a High School diploma and an MCSE or CCNA...or a course in C++...
I do respect the hands-on experience, but then, we shouldn't have spent years earning a degree. Why can't we do the same with Engineering, Law, etc? Can I go to work as a lwayer without a degree in law?
I might have the skills and talent to do a certain engineering job, but will the company hire me on that merit only?
I have concluded, that a degree in computer science is completely worthless (from work perspective.) If you want to work in the computer field but still want a university degree, then just get your degree in physical education or in music and then pass an MCSE or a CCNP, and you are good to go! Computer degrees are WORTHLESS! Employers have rendered that degree worthless!

by tony hopkinson

but if you've run into an employer who takes experience over theory, to my mind you've run into one with a brain, as long as of course the experience is relevant and valid. I've gone for jobs stating five years experience (18 for me !) and been beaten out by a chap such as yourself with 18 months in. Not saying you can't do the job, but mst employers will take your degree over experience, a lot of the time people like me don't even get an interview.

Your degree is not worthless, but it's no guarantee of a job, may be the guy without has been doing the job a long time, maybe he married the MD's niece, maybe he's cheaper, maybe he's an ethnic minority and they've gone for a bit of tokenism, may be he did better than you at the interview, may be his cv was better presented.

Work on the things you can work on and try again.
If you've an experience shortage, see if you can get some voluntary work, or some short term stuff.

Learning and working hard didn't stop when you put on your mortar board and cloak and stepped up for your be-ribboned scroll, they started. Buck up matey, I did it on effort and ability alone, so you've got a hell of a head start, come on me catch up.

by hellums

So you're blaming the employer for either your inability (unlikely) to get the necessary certifications or your unwillingness (most likely) to do it? It's not their fault. The degree is worth tons, just not alone. If it's such a good degree, it should be EASY to get the certification. Don't be elitist, or jealous--just be hard-working and willing to do whatever it takes to get the job and pay you want. Own your future, don't expect someone to hand it to you.

by r. neil

Your BSCS opened a door! What happens after you enter that door is dependent on the impression you make with your contribution to the group. Notice that I said "impression". You may be the greatest thing for computers since Adam Osborne but if you can't respect your co-workers and earn their respect -- do you like flipping burgers?

BE AWARE:
1. Do you realize that your degree was obsolete before you obtained it and that you must continually upgrade your knowledge and skills? Are you willing to learn, on your own?

2. Are you flexible enough to learn systems totally foreign to your background? Sure, you know XML, SQL, HTML, C++, Java(script) and J++; but do you know Cobol, Fortran, Pascal, Perl and Unix? (Have you even heard of Polaris?)

3. Do you realize that while you were spending four (3?, 5?, more) years in college, your fellow-workers (now your colleagues) were probably work with the programming you were learning and have developed work habits and resources you can only dream of?

4. Do you want to grow or stagnate?

Your call.

by cheerstork

Hi! I never implied that one should just earn the degree and just bank on it and do no skill upgrading and no learning of new technologies.
My point was that, a bachelor's in cs should be the benchmark and standard; anyone who aspires to work in the IT field, should have a Bachelor's in CS. The rest of upgrading and continual learning is common sense :)

by r. neil

"a bachelor's in cs should be the benchmark and standard; anyone who aspires to work in the IT field, should have a Bachelor's in CS."

I understand where you are coming from; however, I feel that you are mistaking the trees for the forest. do you want to be a worker-bee or do you aspire to higher (more responsible) assignments? A BS/BA is not a worker-bee's requirement -- it is an aspiring manager requirement in most larger businesses.

"[A]nyone who aspires to work in the IT field" must have the ability and knowledge to perform the required work. A Bachelor's degree is not (and cannot be) a benchmark; rather, it is a signal that the person has had a rounded education (in areas besides computers) and has a basic orientation to software/hardware development.

To put a military spin on it, you have the qualifications for Officer Candidate School (OCS), are you ticked because Senior Enlisted personnel may "outrank" you before you complete OCS?

by wayneb4

Seems like you are upset because a smart employer will look for experience over your membership card (degree). I think the degree is a powerful indicator to an employer that you are starting out with more knowledge and hopefully more taught skills than someone without the four or so years in college. Other than that, you have to take the responsibility for getting your experience and knowledge up to a competitive level so you can improve your lot in life. I can tell you from experience that your degree will earn you a faster start in the IT field that someone with no degree or experience. It will not be taken as a substitute for experience in most places. Get your start, then work on keeping your skills competitive.

by oknightowl

Not in the too distant past. Lawyers became Lawyers simply by picking up a worn copy of Blackwells Rules of Law. Granted those days are gone, but how many in prison are able to adequately present a good defense and sometimes win.

I wonder if your attitude would be the same if you had not invested the time to get your degree? I've competed for positions that I know very well I can do an Outstanding Job, becauses of proven experience, only to be told I was not considered because I did not have the BS...

Let's see - How many Pioneers in the Computer World have a Bachelors in CS? Bill Gates - No, Steve Jobs - No, how many others??? Your Degree is only a start - not the end! Count yourself fortunate to have the Experienced Tech Types around you who, are willing to pass on some of their knowledge to you, if you were to ask.

by avid

so those of us who didn't go to college should not be employed before some one with a college degree ? what if we know more than the guy with a cs degree? what if we are more experienced ? while you were away at college memorizing and learning theory, we were in the real world applying real world solutions to real world problems. if you want a benchmark and standard, how about proven ability. you have got to get over this "the world owes me because i went to college" complex or you will never advance.

by cheerstork

Tony, your post is hilarious! :)
OK! Just to restate my point, I think that a Bachelor's in CS should be important. After earning the Bachelor's, one should go on and specialize. You do that by earning a CCNP, MCSD, MCSE, ...or any of the certifications out there.
Isn't that how it works in the medical field? Law? Engineering?...
As I had stated, can I go and apply for, say, an associate engineer position? Why not? I should be able to assisst in the daily activities, and in 4 or 5 years, I would have the experience to apply for a position of an Engineer!
I will take your advice and use them. Thanks a lot.

by cheerstork

Ernest, all that you have said is great makes much sense. However, will you get a more efficient "search" or "sort" algorithims from a programmer without math, data structures ... education or from the one who has that kind of knowledge?
Will you get a reliable network from someone with a Bachelor's in CS, who knows very well what a binary, hexadecimal, octal numbers are or someone who just skimmed through and got just the very bare minimum to pass some sort of a certification?
Will you have better, more formal and eloquent communication from an IT professional who studied college-level english literature, history, speech and psychology or from someone without that sort of education?

Can I be an apprentice for a Doc for 5 years, and then go on to open my own practice?

Better yet, I worked in an IT department, where one of my coworkers had a degree in business, one had a degree in psychology, one had it in physical education and another had a 2-year ed in some sort of thing related to manufacturing. Only 3 people had a Bachelor's in CS!
Now, could I go and compete with my psychology friend for a psychology-related job? How about the business one?
You see, I'm completely over it. I have been advising people to NEVER major in any computer stuff. Have fun with a degree in physical ed, and then take a course or two in computer stuff, if you want to work in the computer arena.

by deadly ernest

to a CS degree holder. A lot really depend upon the person, their attitude and their experience.

I prefer to work with hardware but have worked on code by CS graduates and found it to be as badly put together as you can get, ditto non grads, - lazy is lazy regardless of training level. I have seen brilliant code by non degree people and by degree people as well.

Personally I think the best approach to a job interview in the industry that I have seen was one where they had the test network done up with some faults and the candidates were given an hour to diagnose and identify the faults and then list what they would do to fix and then improve the system. Sorts the 'know its' from the 'know it alls'.

I now have a number of diplomas in IT but only after working in the sidelines of the industry for over a decade and doing my own and family stuff for 2 decades. Whilst studying for the diplomas I got to know most of the teaching staff well, being the oldest of the few mature age students they were intrigued by my inclusion in their classes. In the second year there one of the teachers asked me to help her out - she taught software programming and had to pinch hit for a hardware teacher who called in sick, I had to give her a run down on what the stuff on the lesson plan meant and even teach part of the lesson for her. I was able to do this because I had the experience, I had learnt the more traditional way.

All a degree does is state that you have been taught this knowledge, that same knowledge can be self taught or learnt on the job.

Hey you want a case of degree orientated stupidity - There are many people who think that any degree gives you an advantage over any non-degree, something about have had to learn discipline and research skills. I have worked in office environments with people who got degree level entry with their archealogical degree, I am still trying to find the relevance to the work since it was the department of immigration doing paperwork shuffling.

by tony hopkinson

Set theory and number bases I was doing in maths at at 12 - 13 years old. Boolean algebra, Karnaugh mapping at fourteen . I've studied predicate calculus, group theory, matrices, iteration, 2 & 3D geometry, still without a degree.

All a degree in CS dies is say you've achieved a particular standard of education. That standard can vary massively, you can buy the standard from a diploma mill. In the UK the standard has gone down badly, so schools can validate themselves with a high pass rate.
Even if none of that was true, a degree still doesn't say you can apply those skills, seven years in IT does though.

Do you want to specialise ?
You could say I have as a coder, but as part of my job I've designed and implement databases, networks and web sites.
It's a matter of emphasis, going for a developer spot, I concentrate on the development aspects and mention admin.

Another tip my cv says C since 1992 and then I list things I've done with it in various employments as a grand total it probably comes to about two years.

Don't do yourself down because your experience is spread about, emphasise it.

I built four Db servers a web server, implemented a network, socket interfaced to a vms based system with fortran at one end and delphi at another, ftp interfaced to a HP3000, DDE interaced to eight PLCs, designed ther SQL server databases including triggers and cursors, set up an IIS intranet static pages with CSS pumped from a delphi client server service, interrogation pages via ISAPI dlls written in delphi, ending up with a 24/7 manuafacturing interface system for a business with a turnover in the hundreds of millions by myself. That was 96 - 99 by the way, and it's still working, and the basic design is still in place.

Is that worth something, bet your ass, how many specialists and how much management would you have needed to do that with separate bodies.

Is it the best solution possible, almost certainly not, but when, in the real world does the best technical solution happen ?

It's not master of none, but competent in all !

No degree and five turned up for the courses.

As for the last paragraph, so it's your fault is it?. Did you inherit that responsibility off your dad, I've been sweeping up after that sort of bunny since 1985, and I'm getting really tired of it, so pack it in.

by jdmercha

With a BS in engineering you should be applying for jobs that require a BS in engineering. Unfortunately there are not enough of them. So you must apply for jobs that don't require a BS in engineering and compete with experienced people with no degree.

With a CS degree you should be applying for a programming job with a path to project management. With out the degree project management jobs are very difficult to come by.

BTY - You can be a licensed professional engineer without having a BS in engineering.

by r. neil

Ancient History -- about 15-20 years ago, one could typically substitute "10 years of competent experience" for the "4 years of competent experience and a degree" required by many states. If you were not "grandfathered" in such a state -- basically, "fergit it" today.

Most states require a bachelor's degree for a PE, some for an EIT, ET, etc. The specific degree required will vary by state.
For more details, surf to http://www.ncees.org/ or "google" the terms "PE registration" with the state's name you are interested in.

by tink!

Your degree and education does give you an advantage in certain areas of the industry. So there are specific jobs out there for you. If you are competing for the same job with people that don't have degrees, than you are probably looking in the wrong place.

For those of us who don't have the degrees, but bank on experience in the field, we do best in acquiring the all-round positions that need someone who's dealt with the day-to-day headaches of commonplace IT. Meaning we've met with the common problems/issues that the average company has and therefore know how to deal with them. These type of find and solve problems cannot ALL be addressed in the classroom, as there are far too many to cover.

Your degree allows you to have the platform needed to specialize in a specific area of the industry where your skills would be more used for developing [i]new[/i] situations, programs or setups. And perhaps improving on existing setups. Your education will of course come in to play [i]sometimes[/i] when dealing with a common IT problem. But usually those things are best fixed with experience.

by tmansops

...it were that easy. Without a BS you rarely get an interview. I had been an IT Director for 9 years, when a new CEO cleaned house, brought in her own people and replaced my position with a CIO/MBA. The new person has no management experience, no IT background at all really, but he has an MBA. Since then I've had to settle for a Network Admin position, and back answering helpdesk calls and fixing PC's. It's not only humiliating, it's down right depressing knowing you're qualified, but lack a piece of paper...

by bg6638

I totally agree! Recruiters & employers now seem to be in the set BS, 5 yrs exp. MCSE, RHCE, CCNP, CCIE, CISSP, etc., etc., etc........ Your resume doesn't have the enchanted verbage, and it's to the bit bucket! They won't look past their nose, especially when they want an advanced Cisco cert for a position where it is doubtful you'll ever lay a hand on a router! Although, it was explained that they want their personnel to have a total understanding of the network....

by mandanglo78

First off I think degrees are overrated and so are certifications. A person can spend 1800 dollars go to boot camp walk out a MCSE. It really doesn't prove you can do the job. I know people who got let loose on networks with out ever seeing a windows server operating system. Needless to say they didn?t last nor did the data they lost. The same goes for university if you pay enough and just do the course work you will make the grade and graduate and then you have some nice wallpaper. The most technically savvy person I ever met in my life dropped out of school at the age of fifteen. I have never seen anyone who could do the amazing things he could. The things you learn in school are great and help with theory. However when you need a solution that meets the budget constraints and unrealistic time frames of the real world only experience can give you what you need to survive it. A lesson I learned the hard way. So maybe that?s why the high school drop-out next to you in the cubicle is getting paid more because he can get the job done.

by wayne m.

Tony's point (if my interpretation is correct - don't hang him for what I say!), is that the degree is an accomplishment not a gatekeeper. It counts in your favor, but is only part of the total evaluation. There are a wide range of things to evaluate for a potential hire and I think you will appreciate that fact the more distant you become from your graduation date.

I am also a little confused about the reference to "Engineering." This is a pretty broad category, but having a BSEE, I can say I have worked with perfectly capable engieers who had degrees in other fields and some with no degree at all. I also can assure you that my college coursework covering FORTRAN, BASIC, and assembly language programming on an IBM mainframe provide no direct benefit to my job in 2006 and usually go unmentioned.

There are some occupations where one needs a specific degree to be awarded a specific title, but one can do legal work without a law degree and medical work without a medical degree.

A BSCS is a nice thing to have, but it is only part of the package. If one is beaten out for a job by someone without a degree, one can either blame the world for being unfair, or look inside oneself to understand why he is not the better candidate.

by too old for it

When you don't get a position it is largely because (in small companies) your salary requirements, tho in the range of what should be expected, were more than the owner is willing to pay.

In large companies, they sacrifice a lot on the golden altar of "diversity", qualified staff being among that lot.

Trust me: If you have 15 or so years of IT experience, a touch of grey to the temples, are caucasion and are a vet of the Vietnam Era, you bring NOTHING to the diversity mix. The executive suite is overloaded with folks like you, and it is in the trenches where the diversity points are counted.

by oknightowl

This sounds so much like there is a complex going around, and that having a 4-yr degree should make you better than everyone else. Here is my take. I choose to get a 2-yr Associates Degree to Validate my 30 years of experience. Sure I have the equivilent of 6 years of Electronic Engineering Level training, I know how when you press the A on your keyboard how that gets to your screen (does the 4-yr Grad know that?) I experience the migration from Punched Cards, Paper Tape to Dumb Terminals, the integration of PC's & 3270 protocols and finally networking. Does my experience mean LESS than a 4-yr degree? The classes I took, I had more REAL world experience than the instructors, I had one class that I rotated between 6 teams in order for the class to complete its project, simply because I lived the experience and knew what I was talking about.

Sometimes I envy those who have the 4-yr degree, some of them worked hard to get it, but that does not make them any better than I am. And unless they are Superman, they still put their pants (excuse me ladies) on ONE LEG AT A TIME, just like I do.

I have many aquaitences who have little more than a High School Education, have made MULTI-Million Dollars by working hard, and wisely.

Just because you think that the end of your 4-year journey got you a piece of paper, your Education has just started. Those of us with Silver Hair, will always have something to show you, or offer you, and can usually come up with a solution that is more common-sense that your Degree will allow.

Congratulations on your Graduation - Now get ready to learn something, if you put your ego in your desk drawer and quit acting like a spoiled kid.

by cheerstork

...my comparison was mostly of same age groups.
I never meant those who were in business for 30, 40 or before universities opened computer science departments! RELAX, MISTER!
But then again, if you were in business before there were computer science departments, then a degree in engineering, math, science, philosophy, or even physical Ed was always there! :)

by tmansops

I was a Manager/Director without a BS for 9 years. Is that to say that a person with 2 - 3 year experience and a BS/CS is more qualified than I am?

The problem is that the bar keeps rising, and eventually we'll all need MBA/MBS for entry level positions...essentially a world of educated idiots...

by r. neil

Your statement supports my case which indicated that no recent graduate should expect to know as much as an able, experienced employee.

The fact that "most larger" companies recruit from college graduates for their future management positions is NOT a statement that a college degree is a "requirement" for supervisor or higher positions in all businesses.

My point was that effective and efficient people will rise to responsible positions in many cases, with or without a degree. (Yes, I am ignoring nepotism and other prejudiced/bigoted realities.) However, a degree will make management entry/consideration "easier" for most people.

Please note that a degree is normally NOT an entry requirement for non-management positions. Degreed or not, many do not want the hassle implicit in most management jobs. Or, as in the Army, your Sargent would tell you:
"Don't call me 'Sir', I work for a living."

Also note, many, if not most, companies which prefer degreed management personnel will provide assistance (incentive?) to their employees in obtaining degrees related to the business.

by hellums

Of being an educated idiot, or an uneducated idiot, guess which I'd choose? Your presumption that educated folk are idiots makes more people inclined to believe you'd fall in the latter group. N'est pas?

The bar keeps rising because, as you may have noticed, technology and the world has changed significantly in the past 15 years.

If the new world requires an MBA or MSIS, get off your duff and get what's required. If it requires a certification, then replace the whining with the studying and everything will fall in place.

Choose to rest on your accolades in light of employers clearly stating their preference, and you may be out of a job quicker than you thought :)

Like they say, get 'er done. Whatever 'er is.

by dr dij

Engineers are not usually considered 'IT' or computer people. They often use computers in their jobs, as do police, firemen, actuaries, etc. Your posting is not terribly clear. And in US many 'engineers' need to pass certification exams while 'computer scientists' do not.

by tony hopkinson

senior design engineer. Software engineering, of course, but it was for an engineering company and that was how they layed out their hierarchy. Personally I just describe myself as a senior programmer or devloper. But I've been labelled as an architect, a designer, analyst ....

by rknrlkid

From almost everywhere I have been "in the trenches" a degree in Computer Science is about worthless anyway. At the local state university here, you are still required to learn COBOL and FORTRAN. Why? The class that covers Windows and Windows applications is a freshman level class that is merely a quick overview. If I ran a computer company, I would be leary of anyone with a degree in Computer Science. The only relevant degree I have seen is the Management Information Systems degree, because at least it partially adresses what could happen in the real world. (This discrepancy is also why someone with an Associates degree in Applied Science in Network Technology is a hotter commodity than someone with a BS in Computer Science.)

I heard an anecdotal story at the university, which to me sums up the insanity of college/university mentality:

A man taught at a local college as an adjunct professor in Criminal Justice. A former policeman, he had written the textbook which was the defacto standard for a particular subject. The university wanted to hire him to be a full time instructor, but couldnt because he didnt have a PhD! The compromise was that he could be hired if he had a master's degree. While working on his master's, he had to take a class where the textbook was the book he personally had written.

The instructor, while looking over the class roster, noticed his name and the similarity of it to the textbook author. "Are you related to the author?" he asked.

My point? Life isn't fair, be flexible. This is true for just about every career field. What I have discovered is that while life owes everyone a living, its incredibly stingy with its money. :)

by rknrlkid

Many jobs dealing with computers have nothing to do with computers!

There was a posting on the Microsoft jobs site for Human Interface Developer. What was the requirement? Masters degree in Behavioral Science! Computer knowledge was minimal. Why? Because designing a graphical user interface has nothing to do with computers, it has to do with behavioral science. So the guy with the degree in psychology actually does have an edge over the computer science guys!

by tonythetiger

Maybe the guy who didn't go to school didn't do so not because he wasn't smart, but because he couldn't afford college. Maybe while you were in school getting educated, he was in the real world getting an education. Maybe the employer doesn't care about a degree, else he would have made it a requirement for candidates who apply.

What do you REALLY want, fair competition, or a fair advantage?

by oz_media

First of all, "Or maybe we should do away with degrees altogether, and one could go and apply for any sort of job as long as you demonstrate the willingness to do it and the enthusiasm to learn!"
Damn straight! I've been demonstrating just that for nearly 23 years now. I will take any position from any candidate purely based on drive, presentation and salesmanship. One thing I tell people all the time is that while you FEEL you need certs to find a career, if you can market yourself properly, you can dictate your line of work and even your payscale for every opportunity [i]you[/i] create.

I don't care how much paperwork you have, if you can't market yourself and prove your skills without expecting the world to operate on a 'unionized/seniority basis", then get in the unemployment line while I take your job.

Too rough? Welcome to the working world.

by ericl_w199

I would like to say somthing in my fathers case being he is an electrical engineer.Where he works,to be considered part of the "technical staff" you have to have an engineering degree.You may do the same job without an engineering degree but you will not be considered part of the technical staff or get paid as such.Now he does space related work so im sure things dont change as much as the computer field.But i just wanted to point out where my father works their is a difference between having a degree and not even though you may do the same job.

by Member 30634329

Here's a story from someone (myself) who didn't earn a CS degree, but wound up with a rewarding IT career anyway.

I went to college and got a B.A. in Psychology. I had always been into computers as a hobby.
My Psych degree was getting me nowhere except more school.
Meanwhile, I had to make ends meet, so I started selling computers. Then repairing and upgrading them. Then I graduated to tech support, both phone and corporate.
While grinding away at these low-end IT jobs, I began reading those 2000-page IT books on programming, NT, and Netware administration. I set up labs with old PC's at home during my free time.
Eventually after a couple of years, I got lucky enough to be in a junior network admin position at a smaller company, where I was able to get even more hands-on experience.
Eventually I got my MCSE and CCNA, but I have since let them lapse.
From there my career has taken off in many directions, including management, but it is always my years of hands-on experience ad interviewing skills that have sold employers...not the paper I have earned.

You mention that your resume is not focused. I'm an IT generalist as well, and I find that I write a different resume for every position I apply for.
If I'm applying to be a DBA, then I omit all of my experience and skills except those that relate specifically to the position.
I even go as far as to change my titles on the resume. Everyone knows most IT people wear many hats. For example, lets say my "official" title at my old company was Network Administrator. My duties included being the SQL DBA. If I was applying to be a SQL DBA, my title on the resume would be "Database Administrator". As long as I'm not falsifying or misrepresenting what I did, it's OK. I'm just omitting irrelevant duties. That's the focus your resume needs.

Sometimes small things like that really make a difference when looking for a job.

by bg6638

I have 30 years in IT and only an Associate's degree. Why NOW after 30 years do I need to have a BS in CS/MIS *AND* 30+ acronyms after my name just to be considered for a position?

by r. neil

What disagreement? Apparently, you have been "successful" without a degree. If you are comfortable where you are and how you got there, then "Bravo!"
Are you "competing" for a higher position at your current location? If so, then how are you "marketing" yourself? Are you demonstrating a willingness to expand, be flexible, assume different responsibility? Ways of demonstrating such willingness are: to volunteer for community work (J/A, United Way, etc.), to take related courses, to obtain accredation(s), to obtain a degree, etc. Does your company have a "policy" of wanting certain positions to have a degree? Are you competing, or simply sitting there? (Laurels are pretty, but danged uncomfortable to sit on.)

A germane question -- what size of company (business) are you considering a position in? Why? Smaller (venture?) companies tend to look for ability and ignore "averages" or "standards" when filling a need. Larger (established?) tend to look for standard types which will "fit in" with their norms or can be "trained" to their specifications.

My statement was that a degree will open doors and (like Professional Registration for an engineer) will demonstrate SOME capacity to learn and to accept minimal discipline.

BE AWARE: After 30 years of employment, you MAY have "hit the silver ceiling" where higher levels will only be offered to "younger" persons. [Yes, age discrimination after 40 is against Federal law; however, unless you are already at an "executive-level position", you can PROBABLY forget about geting one in a larger business.]

by bg6638

I am looking for employment, as the result of a strike which forced my last employer to close. I am concentrating on small companies, because in addition to only having an AAB degree, I have only worked as the sole "IT person", the largest employer having only 5 servers and 75 workstations. Larger companies just sneer, my college test lab was way larger than that! The BS degree is out of reach, since no accredited colleges will transfer any of the credits, and they want me to make up over a year of HS college prep courses that I never took, because I went to a vocational HS where I dual-majored in Accounting/EDP. Going full time including summers, it would take almost 6 full years to complete the degree which will put me at nearly 60. I admit, I'm in a very..very deep hole!

From research that I've gathered, most of the positions that I have applied for are receiving 75-100+ resumes, very intense competetion exists for few positions! And consulting has hardly been lucrative, as it seems that a significant number of smaller firms are simply doing without. It is ashame to go in and see total disarray in their shops, but..........

by djsauer

A degree or a certification are just baselines to represent a standard of knowledge that a prospective employee has attained to qualify for the position, it is not the sole criteria for hiring. Having worked with the government, it is readily apparent were managers and supervisors have only hired based off looking at the education criteria as the employees performance and knowledge reflects on their work productivity, or lack there of. Other things that people utilize in their criteria is the period to obtian the degree - if it took you 8 years to get a 4 year degree it does not necessarily demonstrate competent knowledge. Certifications and degrees establish a expectation of knowledge for the applicant, the interview process determines the best qualified, I have had personnel selected for positions that did not meet the education requirements but have demostrated the knowledge - I have also had personnel that applied for a computer support postion that didn't know how to turn on the computer. The employer has to establish an expectation of qualification for employment inorder to get qualified personnel.

by wesleymechler

When hiring I find the non-degreed and specialized candidate is more focused on the application of the system rather than the system. I am in the insurance business not the computer business. My unit is direct support to the business units. I need the computer to support the business functions and the candidates the college system is producing are not ready for the real world of business. Price wise the non-degreed candidate is a bargain also.

by mckinnej

Whew! You're getting lots of input on this one, but I've noticed that the group has missed a couple of important points.

First is the government contracting realm. If the government puts a degree requirement in the SOW, that's it. The employer has no choice. Same goes for certifications. I recently got passed over for a job that I was highly qualified for, but didn't have an obscure certification that the government stuck in the SOW. Unless the government is working with the contractor through a sole-source deal or they already have the contract and are replacing someone, they have virtually zero latitude in this. No degree=no job.

Second, although some posters have skirted around this, no one has actually nailed it down. You often have to look at the level of the job and the needs of the employer. Several posters have remarked that they can beat out anyone because they have zillions of years of experience which makes the degree irrelevant. Almost true, but not entirely accurate. The degree is important for entry- and mid-career positions where they're looking at 10 years of experience or less. Those folks cannot (and probably don't want to) compete for those jobs. The employers have a price range for the ideal candidate and those folks are above it. They probably won't even get an interview. They are past that category. At their senior level, the degree becomes almost like that that summer job you had while in high school. It's ancient history.

Finally, think of the degree as a discriminator. Many companies use them for just that. Two people apply for a job, one with a BSCS, one without. Both have 5 years of similar experience. Unless the person with the degree blows the interview, that person is more than likely going to get the job. They have shown that they can stick to a mind-numbing task all the way to the end (they have paid their dues).

PS. Law is a bad example to use in this case. You can't practice law after just going to school. You have to pass the bar exam in the state first, which is designed to prove that you paid attention and actually learned something. Lawyers are VERY protective of their turf. They won't allow the unwashed masses into their realm. :)

by mrsgarbers

I have no degree OR certs but have been doing this work for about 10 years now. I realize I am part of a very small group and I also realize my lack of "paper" has set my professional ceiling lower than I would like. I came to terms with that a long time ago. Sure I have more experience than some but a degree says more than "I officially learned this". A degree says you have the ability to commit. Even if it was in a non-related field.
Larger companies do require a degree and/or certs.
Booze Allen, SRA, CACI, Unisys just to name a few.
I just finished a 2+yr stint with Homeland Security. My contract drew to a close for compliance issues. Guess what....degrees are a part of that. You have it easier than you think...your just not looking in the right places.

by tony hopkinson

That one always annoys me, it's so much crap it's unreal. Try working shifts, bringing up a family and doing corespondance courses, to take a ?5k drop in take home pay for your first real IT job. That's commitment.
Guy's like us don't get in through the back door, we knock a hole in the wall and step through.

by kphayes710

I am a grad of a technical school. I took some college courses but finished up by going to an accelerated probram. By going through this type of program I obtained several certifications. From what some collegues tell me a lot of them wish they didn't go to college because it wasn't just a focus on computers. I've also been told by other employers that the only thing they are looking for is a CCNA. So I feel it is fair for anyone to compete in the computer industry. The world revolves around computers and if someone, even someone with a different degree or no degree, can do the job better than you then they should get the job.

by cecilagar

I think you've hit the nail right on the head. I have an A+ certification and i would not dream of going for any kind of high paid job in the computing industry because i feel there is still a lot more to learn. I am currently doing a HND in computing and then i go on to a degree in CS now im wondering if it is worth the hassle if some scally with a certification is more entitled to a job than i am. The only thing i can say is that people with certifications do not have as much theory or practical experience as someone with a degree because they did not have enough time as the degree student to master what is needed to know. These certifications are not worth the paper they are written on and anyone with one will soon come undone in the work place.

by jlegoff

Using a degree or certification as a "benchmark" is completely missing the point. While I do agree that there should be minimum requirements for IT positions including a BS. It is not the only criteria.
Skill, aptitude, willingness to learn, experience (where appropriate), etc. are all important aspects for a candidate.
We have all seen the high-school drop out types who are incredible at what they do. I had a supervisor who did not have a college degree and was a member of MENSA but these people are rare. I have also seen people with a 6 month Microsoft certification who didn't have a clue. Unfortunately, these people are more prevalent.
This is why I believe that a minimum standard of a BS degree is required. Please note, degrees in and of themselves do not measure a candidate's success but they do give the candidate the basic tools to be successful and thereby gain much needed experience. Certifications (Microsoft, CISCO, PMI) expand the professional's skill level but should be an add on to a degree not a minimum standard.
As for coworkers that are perceived to be more successful and less qualified (degree or certification not withstanding) this condition in the workplace has always existed and will continue to. The old saying of 'Its not what you know but who you know' still holds true.

by tony hopkinson

part right.
You don't need a degree to learn the basics, in theory the award of a degree means you know the basics. Course we all know that's not true. I haven't got a degree, for me now that would be a useful as an inflatable dartboard.
I didn't get where I am because of who I know, I got here because of who I am.
The basic tools to be sucessful, are enthusiasm , drive, a willingness to learn, application and innate talent. A degree proves none of these things.
If degrees and certs were a standard I might agree with you but I've worked with people with either or both who weren't fit to hold my coaster steady when I reach for a much needed coffee.

by don'tquityourdayjob

Yes, there are "non degreed" engineers working in industry but they usually have a ton of design experience and do not get paid the same (usually a lot less).

Holding a degree tells me more about a person than the attainment of knowledge. They certainly will not retain most of what they learned. Without picking up the phone and talking to the person or interviewing the person, you can reasonably say the following about that person:

1. Goal oriented
2. Ability to follow through
3. Intellectual flexibility (WILLING to be trained in different subjects)
4. Can make a committment
5. Is capable of followiing established guidelines and rules

NOTE: I did not list that a person with a degree is smarter or better than one without the degree.

Also, attaining a certification can demonstrate the same attributes as attaining a degree just on a shorter time frame.

A certification is more "targeted" while a degree is more broad-based.

Usually, HR uses paper (degrees and certificates) to weed out or sort through multiple candidates. In other words, they may get 100 resumes for a posted position and they will not go though each one.

With your degree and background I would think you are getting ready for a management position - MIS Manager, IT Manager, etc where you have people reporting to you.

by tony hopkinson

I wanted to work in IT since I was 14
I 've been working in it since 1987
I done admin, DBA, coding and WEB stuff on four different plaforms and that's just my commercial experience
I go my first job doing corespondance courses and teaching myself, while working shifts and raising my family.
I compose the guidelines and rules and then I lead people along the path they suggest.

Not being picky but there are a lot of graduates posting here who can't get a job in IT or it isn't meeting their expectations, so what goal did they have, and how committed are they ?

I wouldn't say someone who got a degree doesn't have all these attributes, but to say a degree is a reasonable guarantee of them is complete bollocks.

by rickhnelson

In any event earn and save your money now.... because when you get to be 50 YOU HAVE NO CHANCE even if you are a professional. Do you think it is fair for a prospective employer to discriminate against and tell me they don't even want to look at my resume, they want someone younger.....

AND ITS A PROFESSIONAL POSITION AND I HAVE GREAT EXPERIENCE.

by rickhnelson

Thanks for the links..... great on paper...

I have no chance to fight these guys... I will only hurt whatever chances I have Remember, these are Bush days....

by south florida pmp

Having a solid techie/CS background is a great path to being an excellent PM. At the PM level you aren't necessarily expected to be the latest technical mind but you need to be fairly saavy, and be worthwhile in concepts and processes. Take my advice, point for the PM path and surround yourself with energetic sharp young minds. Them along with a good assigned senior tech lead or architecht and you're on your way!!! If you have that kind of interest and background and are interested in South Florida feel free to contact me direct.

by r. neil

Good point! If one is flexible and willing to allow someone else to "play with the computer."

by marley101

In effect, I don't think it is right for employers to degrade the BS in CS. I don't care what they say, a BS should not be comparable to a certification. We talking about a 4 years degree compared to a 4 months certification. One is called degree, the other one is called certification. Evidently we learn more in 4 years that we do in 4 months. 48 months versus 4 months. Do the math. They say it is an experience thing. So the guy with the BS doesn't have any experience. I understand that. But he or she can learn way faster than the certified guy due to his education level. Plus, beside computers, he or she learned a lot of other subjects or discipline such as psychology, management, leadership, human resources, etc... So he should get credits for that. Just think about it... Do not be biased in your jugement.
Marley

by mjmac55

Just because somebody has a BS in computer science doesn't mean he is able to learn faster than somebody with certifications only!!

by deadly ernest

One point that seems to have been missed in this discussion is that many people advertise for specific certifications because they want someone who knows that specific hardware or software that can walk into the job at 9 am and be fully productive at 9.05 am the same day - they want specific experience. While a degree is a more generalised training and will often require some local training to do the job fully.

Use the degree as entry and then get some certs to go with it and you have a very big advantage. I have been working in and out of the computing industry since 1979 and started getting some qualifications to go with the learned skills in 1996. I now have a couple of TAFE (Technical school) diplomas and some certificates to go with my experience. Funnily my last two jobs swung on having a certificate that qualified me to teach adults what I already knew - the employers wanted someone who could educate the users about the simple technical things instead of coming back each week to rebuild a virus laden machine.

No degree or certification is a guarantee of any sort, just a starting indication. You then have to add experience to make it worth while. And what the employer wants will decide what the ask for.

As another pointed out a degree is a big advantage in the government job and contacts and some big business.

by tr

But not exactly worth a fortune either ...

48 months vs 4 months, hmmmm....

48 months? By my math it would be more like 8 mo x 4 = 32 mo (eight months is more than generous).

Still, 32 mo is 8 times greater than 4 mo...

Of course a BS in Computer Science basically consists of 10 CS classes with a load of other tripe thrown in to round out our student. Most people can easily carry 3-4 classes in one semester:

Lets say one semester equals 4 months. Three or four classes per semester would only take 3 semesters, or about a year, to complete.

Now we have 12 mo vs 4 mo.

And that 4 mo. cert is normally targetted at the specific skill the employer is interested in. About 1/3 of the CS portion of a BS degree could conceivably be in this specific area as well.

Now we have 4 mo vs 4 mo.

Hope that helps :)

CS Certs and degrees are required for the same 3 reasons:

1) It indicates that the applicant is capable of learning.

2) It indicates that the applicant has some desire for a position in CS (as she/he bothered to get the cert/degree)

3) But in these more competitive days it is mostly to help winnow down the applicant pool to a manageable level.

by 3_jeeps

You are comparing 4 months of specific learning vs 4 years of what is intended to be well rounded education. First of all, if you want a career in IT, then a CS degree is probably overkill, IMHO. Microsoft has reduced the operations of computers to those who know what windows to bring up, what options to choose, and what cables to plug in. (I have looked through and sat through a few MS certification courses....most of the book pages are screen shots of their programs) If you goal is to be an Access DB programmer, than a CS degree is overkill. UNFORTUNATLY, ppl in hiring positions think that just because you are an ace Access DB programmer, you can just as easily do WEB design without any basic knowledge of how it works or related issues such as security and confidentiality (for example). It also depends on the size of the company. My personal opinion is to hire a degree person in almost all cases because they tend to be more universal in their skill set, and because of that, they can pick things up quicker. Ppl in IT mgmt don't understand that because most of the time, IT mgrs are promoted bean counters. If it were an engineering company, the one-flag wonder would not be hired. I once had the joy of fixing a fairly large real time system that was written in C by a phd music major who was very proud that she had become a 'C' programmer and knew lots of C tricks which she exhibited throughout the program. Unfortunately when very strange and unexplanable (wrong) program behavior was observed 2-3 months down the road, she proclaimed her stuff as 'flawless'....oh to the contrary. If I were king, she would not have been hired in the first place..Another short example, VBasic wonders who do web design - who write pages of monlithic code without the slightest idea that there is a testing activity in parallel with development. Also, these same VB wonders don't ever think if testing their own code..
So, IMHO, I'd take each situation on a case by case basis, but I am predisposed to those with a 4-yr degree.

by fbaez

Cheerstork:
You having studied computer science you have to know that having a degree just means that you put in your 3-4 yrs in general studies, and 2 yrs in computer scienc related courses. In our field (Information Technology, one can pick up a book and learn how to resolve desktop support issues or learn how to code. One can even learn the in's and out's of MS Office and obtain a position in support.
The difference between you and the person who picked up a book to learn to code is that you are a well rounded employee. You took buisiness courses, and are more capable of making not only technical decisions but economical-financial decisions that may apply to your field. There are very few people out there that just picked up a book and know every technical term, and can run and make buisiness like deicisions(mgr, cio, cto, etc). Second you're closer to becoming mgr'ial material once completing your MBA. I doubt someone without those type of credentials will be overlooked for someone without a degree.
Now my last point will hurt. Our field is is somewhere you can get your foot in the door with any degree. Not so much in code. Just in a support helpdesk capacity, and then move up to code with additional training (certifications). But you can't take someone with a computer science degree and ask them to what an electrical engineer, or a civil engineer does without training, or an additional degree in that field.

by r. neil

With your experience, you could "set up shop" as a "guru" -- tutoring students and small business owners; selling network and personal computer solutions; and hiring out as a consultant to schools, local government offices, and local businesses.

I do not know your specialties, I'm sort of Wintel-centric; however, check out MS' Small Business Center at http://www.microsoft.com/smallbusiness/hub.mspx
Special offer from MS in March, see http://www.microsoft.com/smallbusiness/small-business-summit/hub.mspx?xid=C0031

Sell MS, be a Partner, see: https://partner.microsoft.com/explore

Check out your local Small Business Development Center (SBDC), sponsored by the SBA -- see www.sba.gov

by mustang sally

Actually, I personally know 2 guys who worked as Engineers (at Intel) who don't have a degree. One got his preliminary training in the Army and the other worked his way up from being a debug tech.

And if Dr. Laura is any indication, it's perfectly fine to provide psychological counseling on a national tadio call in show & write authoritive books without having a degree (let alone a doctorate) in Psychology. If you, as a BSCS got a simple certificate in marriage, family & child counseling you could do the same.
But if you wanted to prescribe antipsychotic drugs, then yes, you'd need a medical degree to.

Anyone who can pass a Bar exam CAN practice law legally - you don't technically have to have a law school degree. Same with realtors, insurance agents, etc. You don't need a 4 yr criminal justice degree to become a cop, or a prison guard (or attain upper management positions in those fields). Anybody can write a best-selling novel - you don't need a BS in Literature.

My last boss was a woman who only had a 2 yr degree in programming but went on to become an accounting manager and then Controller for a company - with no 4 yr degree at all (least of all in business or accounting).

My point is, the only 4 yr degrees I would say taht provide anything close to a "guarantee" of hirability in today's job market are engineering and nursing.

by hellums

Amen. Absolutely nobody could have said it better. No degree is a guarantee. I like Domino's pizza, but I don't care if the guy making it is a Chef d'Cuisine from a nationally accredited culinary program or some mechanic making money on the side. If he can do the job, I don't care what his training was.

by paul.stinson

There are point that you raise that I agree with it is not fair for someone who has little to no experience and no college degree get the job. I have worked in the IT field for almost 15 years and do not have a degree. I am certified in several areas. I am more qualified them most college student that graduate in Computer science. Do these graduate have experience? I have worked with people who have a degree in CS and still do not know the basic trouble shooting or how to fix there own computers.
Is is fair for a company to hire on thse who have degree???

by crawk

Interesting discussion among what one might consider a bunch of "upstarts" with only a few "geezers" chiming in.

Submitted, for your consideration, an historical perspective:

Though I don't know much about the histories of law and engineering as professions, it's reasonable to assume that they, too, went through growing pains as the early, less-"educated" practitioners aged out and the requirements for new people tightened. It happened that way, too, in osteopathy (D.O.), allopathy (M.D.), pharmacy (R.Ph.), and other now-matured professions. It just took them a lot longer because IT didn't exist yet.

In the Information profession, many of us geezers jumped into an exciting nascent field with little or no higher education (as not much education was available for this stuff even if we'd tried), and figured it out and even invented it along the way.

We were cowboys (and cowgirls), learning and doing and improving every aspect of the field. We were experts in both hardware and software, building s desktop or server from parts and pieces one day, coding an app the next, debugging ROM for a mfgr the next, designing expandable network structures the next, running and terminating cables the next, and many many other things.

We were the proverbial sandaled, suspendered, bearded (well, not all), pizza-guzzling geeks of legend. Many of us had only the merest of business or people skills because we were too busy doing the cool stuff.

It is our very experience and knowledge from which are being developed the standards and the education (such that it be) that are beginning to become necessary for entry into this still-maturing profession. But, in this case, it's happening much more rapidly because of the very success of the profession.

Hang in there, younglings and Cheerstork and others. You're stuck in IT's adolescence at the moment -- and you remember how bad adolescence was, don't you?

The geezers are having it equally bad these days (specialize or die, paper certs, clueless degrees, HR indimidated by gray hair), evolving into other areas; some choosing to overcome or just to survive to retirement; others leaving for greener garages; some forced out and rediscovering lives they'd left behind decades ago or supersizing the fries.

It is this geezer's personal opinion that IT will eventually become a degree-certified profession, perhaps requiring an undergraduate background in industrial psychology, business, or finance, and then post-graduate professional school.

Too bad, methinks, because it'll be taken over by pencilheads (keybaordheads?) and silvertongues who pass the MCAT/LSAT/GRE-type admissions exams.

Then I guess the geeks and nerds will just have to go back to the garage and invent yet another new profession! Can't wait!

by crawk

Funny thing about the "maturing" cowgirls: we have to work hard to keep from resembling the ol' bearded UNIX programmer!

(But I can probably still wield a mean slide-rule. Bet you could, too. :-)

by gdgtgrl

Most jobs in IT don't require a Computer Science degree. I don't think I would hire a Computer Science graduate to fix my computer. Mistakenly a lot of people think that a computer science graduate should know how to diagnose and fix every error on every PC. I think that most people miss the point of what computer science is about. It is not equivalent to information technology. A computer science program is a robust program that teaches in general terms how computers work (not specific architectures), how compilers work, how programming languages work, how operating systems work, algorithms for solving particular programs, efficiency of various algorithms, logic, etc. No other program gives this. Computer Information Systems is about applying technology to business - it works from the standpoint of fixing business problems. Computer Science is more theory (even though it's programming intensive). Vendor/technology specific courses are only teaching you their particular products whether or not they are suited to every situation.

Most jobs in IT require specific skillsets or programming languages so if an employer is looking for exact matches for skillsets and programming languages he may choose a Philosophy major with 2 years programming Sybase over the Computer Science graduate with no experience in Sybase. Many employers are looking to fill specific needs in the cheapest way possible. Don't be fooled. Other employers are looking to invest in new employees and they might choose the CS graduate feeling that the technology they use itself doesn't matter because it would change in a few years anyway. It costs more money to hire someone with no experience at a particular thing because of the learning curve and the costs of any training they may send that person to.

People in computer science programs are always complaining that they are not always learning the latest, greatest thing but that is not the point of the program in the first place. Someone who only knows the latest, greatest thing soon won't have any relevant skills because the latest, greatest thing will have changed to something else in a few short years. Computer science graduates should have the background to work on a variety of things because they understand the theory behind the technology itself.

At any rate, the computer science graduate has more options. You might see a lot of "uneducated" people programming in Visual Basic, but how many do we see inventing new languages? There is a whole research component to Computer Science that most people don't think about. Where do new operating systems come from? Where do new programming languages come from? Where do new encryption algorithms come from? Computer scientists develop things that most people take for granted.

Regarding fairness: Nothing in life is fair. Things are simply how they are. If you feel that you bring more to the table because you have a CS degree then you should be able to verbalize what that is (more than just saying I have a degree). It should also show in the quality of the work that you do. I have a CS degree and a forensic science degree as well. I'm now doing Computer Forensics after 8 years as a programmer. You don't need a degree in computer science to do computer forensics but I am aware that I have an advantage over those that do not. I don't walk around like a snob because of this, however. The advantages that I have should make me more efficient and effective in my work - and that should show up in my paycheck. It's all about knowing your own worth.

by callplus

If I could turn the clock back I think I would try and get myself a couple of crappy PCs and maybe a router and\or a switch. Then do the exmas and get in the job market. I would still do my degree, but I would do it at night. Be nice to be earning money whilst studying instead of scraping by on summer job earnings.

We can't blame employers for picking people with skills they need. I think they could be making mistakes with some choices. There are still the "paper mcse's" out there who are good at exams but crap at solving problems.

Academia have let us down. They have not kept up with the job market demands. Some don't even see it as their responsibilty. They give us education, not training or apprenticships. Wish they tell us this when we are filling out our college appliation forms! Understandable too bc with the changes in technology for uni's and colleges to keep upgrading is very expensive and they just can't afford it. Also finding the staff to teach. Probably why I learned COBOL and RPG in college "it's still huge in the finance sector" instead of visual basic. That said I'm sorry I didn't keep it up and cash in on the Y2K bandwagon! :-(

When all is said and done I'm sorry I didn't get into the trades. Builder, chippie, sparkie, plumber. Even tilers and painters earn a fortune these days. Better pay, hours, strong unions and nothing like the stress or responsibilities.

I think it's the career guidance counsellors that are the real villians!

by camille.bergeron

I beat Tony out in experience...30 years. Here in Phoenix, because there were so few openings with so many applicants, there was a real emphasis on certs. Well guess what they discovered? The paper proves nothing other than the ability to use the buzz words. So us old fogies are teaching each other the buzz words and then interviewing in terms of what we've actually accomplished, how much money we've saved the companies, etc. That is now getting us jobs. What a concept.

by cheerstork

...it's not about complexes, arrogance, or anything like that! It's about the...oh well, I'm too tired now to repeat myself...please, go back and read my post and some other posts. Basically, cs is my field where i invested my time and effort. Another guy/gal spent the same time studying physical ed or just not going to school at all and then coming to undercut me by flooding the market and lowering rates! Let alone, lowering quality!

by avid

you seem to think that you have more quality as an employee than some one without a degree. the simple truth is this. you payed a ton of money and spent four years of your life to get a little paper that will only serve to get you to the interview. the rest is up to you. quality is not determined by degrees. it is determined by your work. "produces quality work" will be on every eval you recieve, not "has a quality degree". so go to work and BE BETTER than the rest. don't just complain.

by jschoonover

Fair? No, it's not fair. It's not fair for someone with 4 years of school to come in and compete with 16 years of experience and expect some type of preference because of their major. Sorry you're not happier with your choice of collegiate endeavor. Sell the atari, move out of your parents basement and take a job that will allow you to build a skill set to match your fine academic achievements.
Look for opportunities that will allow you to focus on TCP/IP routing and/or switching, Microsoft engineering, Solaris, anything to get engaged in the industry.
Build your resume and keep moving upwards. About 8-10 years ago, the trend was to hire "whiz kids" with BSCS degrees to come in and manage IT groups because they had BSCS degrees. More and more, companies are looking for managers with "other" qualifications. In the end, management is management. If you want to work IT, don't get caught in that trap. Stay technical and keep your hands in the dirt, because when the reorg comes, mid-management goes first.

by firstpeter

Think about it from an employer's perspective. If I have an open position for a programmer, who am I going to interview / hire?

It's whoever is the perceived best person for the position, right? Do I really care about the degree? Only to the extent that I need to filter my candidate pool (I have too many) and I believe a degree in CS makes a person better suited for a job.

If I don't believe that a degree in CS is any better than a degree in, say, Bio-Technology (and based on experience I don't) then my criteria becomes "have a degree", not "have a CS degree".

And if I don't believe that a degree has any value at all as a filter then I don't use it as a criteria.

Is that fair? Unquestionably. As an employer, why in the world would I artificially limit my pool of candidates based on an irrelevant criteria? I'm not after "the best CS candidate", I'm after "the best candidate...period". Limiting my candidates based on an irrelevant criteria is a poor business decision, and I'd give strong consideration to firing anyone working for me that utilized that as a criteria.

Same thing in terms of a manager - if I'm really after a manager give me someone that manages people well (degree status - irrelevant) and I'll teach them what they need to know on the technical side (which shouldn't be the nuts and bolts - that's what the folks reporting to him/her are for). Much easier (and effective) to do that than to take my top individual performer who's not a people-person and try to teach him/her people skills.

by deten8

I hold several certifications and am forced to return to college to compete with people who have degrees. I have 10 years of experience and my company does not recognize certifications. I think it is silly to base hiring an individual on either certifications or degrees (solely). There are so many more factors to consider. The most overlooked factor is experience. If I were filling a position I do NOT want a recent grad or cert student without any experience.

I personally value certifications more highly for technical content. College CS curriculums, in my opinion, do not keep up with the speed of technology whereas certifications do. On the other hand, a degree path shows an employer that the candidate can follow through on a long term goal and has a basic knowledge of grammer, math, technology etc.

I think that there has to be a healthy respect for both. There would be no need for having a set starting point "benchmark" if the position criteria was based on who best performed a job. The problem is that some IT managers do not have the technical ability to evaluate skills.

Throughout my department the idea of cert v/s degree is about as bi-polar and strongly opposed, depending upon who is asked. Those with certs tend to be in favor of the certification paths. Those with degrees do not tend to value the certifications very highly. Those with both will not say that either are a bad thing.

by tony hopkinson

Now log tables ...
Tried showing my kids how they work and they said why didn't you use a calculator ?
weren't allowed them
How did you add up
Well ....

by mnoldsea

There are many roads that lead to Rome. Knowledge in this day can be gathered in many different places by anyone who truly seeks it. I went to school in the 70's, but I leaned computer programming on my own. I have a library from the earliest 6508 processor to Oracle 9, and XML. I think in this tech economy you have to be self-taught to a large degree. The only thing that really matters when you load up your code is, does it run, or does it crash. Performance, and ability should be the baseline measurement. I may have limited formal education written on my resume, but in terms of achievements, have developed a number of practical, and functional databases programs, and be a wiz at writing P-SQL, and stored procedures. Would I be a greater asset then say someone with a BS, or MS who?s still fumbling around tweaking their final school project?

by darthstard

As mnoldsea says, "Ability is what counts", and a certain passion for what you are doing. I left school in the early 80's, with good grades in the most basic of qualifications "C.S.E's", my last 2 years at school I was messing around with basic programming on Sinclair ZX80, ZX81, early home computers. It became my favorite hobby, loved the graphics side the most. I went into a plumbing apprenticeship, and continued messing around with Sinclair's (spectrums, wow, colour and lower resolutions lol), I was finding plumbing rewarding, but struggled with one or two employers (young & arrogant I was).

Dropped out, left home at 18, went to London, and walked into a job interview advertised as 'Computer Graphics Assistant', took a few tests on a digitizing tablet and got the job. Two years later I was a shift supervisor, assistant trainer, and later a team leader. What I found strange at the time was that there I was, minimal quals, working with people older than me and well qualified, but more importantly I loved the work. I did'nt appreciate all that at the time, being young and foolish (to say the least), but it proves the point, you can achieve your goals, with or without a degree or even college certs.

In the end you are what you do best, the rest is purely academic and history, focus on your strengths and keep learning, make the most of where you work now, the rest will evolve naturally.

If you must gain a Degree or need to have various Certs to suit your chosen path, thats fine, as you know there are umpteen jobs anything less just won't do, either way you are self taught, self diciplined and obviously motivated, in the end it's all the same. A bit like passing your driving test, once passed, then you learn to drive, and IT like driving conditions, will always be on the change, sit back, relax and enjoy the journey, along the great learning curve that is all of life.

And don't forget, keep reading some good books along the way.

by absolutely

If you know psychology as well as the psychologist in your example, or if you know engineering as well as the engineer, perhaps we can discuss "fairness". Otherwise, it is a fact of life that computers are in use in all professions, and anybody may Google a topic of computing that interests them, which they encountered while doing other research, and become an expert in some aspect of computing, without obtaining a 4-year degree in computer topics. Deal with it.

by cheerstork

...and we deal with them on a daily basis--on the street, in the office, on the train, and sometimes online--that's just a fact of life. Having said that, can one say that we have ample experience in dealing with psychos, therefore, one ought to be able to land a job in the field, eh?!
We deal with medical issues throughout our lifetime, and we get to know and learn quite a bit about medicine, health, and etcetera. Can I open a clinic?!
I, for instance, know quite a lot about health and healthful diet and how to lead a healthful and energetic life style. Can I become a dietitian?!!
I mean, pal, I can't open a shop to repair freakin' cars, even though, by necessity, most of us know a heck of a good deal about cars and car repair! I must be a *licensed* mechanic first, in order to be allowed to open the shop!! The city won't let you work as an electrician (not even an electrical engineer) unless you have earned a license!

Just face it. It isn?t about snubbing those who never bothered to do things the right way and earn a well-rounded and professional education. They chose the easy path. Well, it is just that. They just can't have certain IT positions.
Excluding exceptions, if you hire only those who have the "theory" and who took the long and arduous path to knowledge, maybe, just maybe, you will have better, efficient, robust and reliable systems, in addition to a professional work environment--let alone not having to deal with a single sentence that spans an entire 5-line paragraph!!

"Theory" is the terra firma upon which you can specialize and earn your certifications and formalize your experience. As many mentioned, in most cases, the ones with the "theory" are the more adapt and faster to learn and do things right!
Just so I don't have to repeate this ad nauseam, I'm mainly excluding those folks who got into the field decades ago and before colleges opened computer-related departments. (Although, even those, could have tried to earn a technical degree!)
I had earned a certificate in programming in C/C++/UNIX before earning a BSCS. However, I decided that if I were to work in a field, I ought to know what I'm doing and what I'm talking about. Hence, the long path to a degree was my choice. If it were about just knowing how to program, I never needed the degree!
People "deal with computers on a daily basis" and think that qualified them to go for a job! Some one learned how to write a FOR loop and thought they became programmers!
No wonder, systems fail and drag!!
Yes, Bill Gates dropped out of college. Hey, exceptions make the rule nowadays? By the way, Bill Gates was more of an entrepreneur, in my opinion. Basically, came up with an idea and launched a business and hired (the people who know the technicalities) to materialize it!

Having said that, I am not hoping to convince those who never earned a BSCS or a similar degree. They are just too comfortable having it the easy way and calling themselves "programmers" or "system architects" and not knowing how to do simple binary addition or how to use a mod operator!

Oh, and by the way, I paid for every single class and certification I earned. I never applied for financial aid or any sort of assistance! I worked hard to pay my tuition--day and night and between semesters--and finished college in less than 4 years!

Anybody can "google" how to perform certain surgery. I bet you won't let me operate on you, eh!

by tony hopkinson

I was doing that in 1975 when I was twelve years old in maths. Used it in computing in 77, so I'd have to say if that's what the teach in a CS degree it's abit further behind the times than I thought.
I can still do it, and octal and hexadecimal an good deal of it in my head which most kids can't do with decimal.

I agree that googling a language statement does n't make you a programmer, nor does reading it out of a book, off a drawing board or listening to it. Where you learn FOR is immaterial what when and how you use it defines your ability as a programmer.

by allenhn

I've been programming since 1980. My expertise is scientific/technical/graphics, using Fortran, VB, and Windows API. I have degrees in Physics and Biomedical Engineering. I've applied for >40 programming jobs and had one (unsuccessful) interview. I think you're talking nonsense.

Most of the problem is that tertiary training is so specialisd nowadays that the dummies who do the hiring can't conceive of cross-training, or recognise quick learners. (I've seen ads for engineering positions that demand experience in a particular 3D CAD program -- as if they aren't all the same under the skin! It's like advertising for a chauffeur with Ford experience, stipulating that GM drivers need not apply!) These recruiter bozos seem to think applicants need to be genetically engineered to fit the job description to the letter.

Get some professional advice on your resume writing and interview skills. Maybe you're having crap luck, like me, or maybe you're just not selling yourself very well.

by cheerstork

(This started as a comment on: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11181-0.html?forumID=6&threadID=190118&messageID=1962269
and I just decided to add it to my initial post!)

Psychos are everywhere...and we deal with them on a daily basis--on the street, in the office, on the train, and sometimes online--that's just a fact of life. Having said that, can one say that we have ample experience in dealing with psychos, therefore, one ought to be able to land a job in the field, eh?!
We deal with medical issues throughout our lifetime, and we get to know and learn quite a bit about medicine, health, and etcetera. Can I open a clinic?!
I, for instance, know quite a lot about health and healthful diet and how to lead a healthful and energetic life style. Can I work as a dietitian?!!
I mean, pal, I can't open a shop to repair freakin' cars, even though, by necessity, most of us know a heck of a good deal about cars and car repair! I must be a *licensed* mechanic first, in order to be allowed to open the shop!! The city won't let you work as an electrician (not even an electrical engineer) unless you have earned a license!

Just face it. It isn?t about snubbing those who never bothered to do things the right way and earn a well-rounded and professional education. They chose the easy path. Well, it is just that. They just can't have certain IT positions.
Excluding exceptions, if you hire only those who have the "theory" and who took the long and arduous path to knowledge, maybe, just maybe, you will have better, efficient, robust and reliable systems, in addition to a professional work environment--let alone not having to deal with a single sentence that spans an entire 5-line paragraph!!

"Theory" is the terra firma upon which you can specialize and earn your certifications and formalize your experience. As many mentioned, in most cases, the ones with the "theory" are the more adapt and faster to learn and do things right!
Just so I don't have to repeate this ad nauseam, I'm mainly excluding those folks who got into the field decades ago and before colleges opened computer-related departments. (Although, even those, could have tried to earn a technical degree!)
I had earned a certificate in programming in C/C++/UNIX before earning a BSCS. However, I decided that if I were to work in a field, I ought to know what I was doing and what I was talking about. Hence, the long path to a degree was my choice. If it were about just knowing how to program, I never needed the degree!
People "deal with computers on a daily basis" and think that qualified them to go for a job! Some one learned how to write a FOR loop and thought they became programmers!
No wonder, systems fail and drag!!
Yes, Bill Gates dropped out of college. Hey, exceptions make the rule nowadays? By the way, Bill Gates was more of an entrepreneur, in my opinion. Basically, came up with an idea and launched a business and hired (the people who know the technicalities) to materialize it!

Having said that, I am not hoping to convince those who never earned a BSCS or a similar degree. They are just too comfortable having it the easy way and calling themselves "programmers" or "system architects" and not knowing how to do simple binary addition or how to use a mod operator!

Oh, and by the way, I paid for every single class and certification I earned. I never applied for financial aid or any sort of assistance! I worked hard to pay my tuition--day and night and between semesters--and finished college in less than 4 years!

Anybody can "google" how to perform certain surgery. I bet you won't let me operate on you, eh!

by deadly ernest

It used to be that no one needed any qualifications to do an job. Then people complained about the fact things were done by people without any knowldge of what they were doing and people were getting hurt. So the govt brought in rules that before you could do any job where you might place someone's welfare at risk you had to be properly trained and recognised as such by your peers.

Then other employment categories saw that this was a good way to limit people in the field and pressured the govt to require similar regulations for them. That is the original basis for qualifications, today many use qualifications to simplify their recognition of the peson's level of training. Qualifications do not make them an expert and lack of qualifications does not mean they can not be an expert.

Theory is needed in some work and not required in other work. If I wanted someone to design a new cpu or circuit board I would get someone who has the reevant knowledge to do so, most of this is theory type knowledge. If I want someone to work out wh a computer keeps crashing I find someone with relevant knowledge and very little of the theory taught in a CS or BA would help them there.

I had been working with computers for over 20 years before I got any qualifications, even then I find that I have practical knowledge that extends beyond what they teach in the relevant courses. What I did before they developed the courses can be done by antyone else today if they want to earn that way.

Two of my favourite IT work experiences show how well the practicality is better than the theory.

1. A friend's client's computer keeps restarting for no reason. Checked the cmputer out in the workshop no problems. Checked the computer out in situ - can not find cause, two techs one TAFE trained one uni trained could not find the cause and could not ghive any suggestion for the cause.

I visited the site with my friend one day. Like everyone else we saw it reset itself. At this time neither of us had IT degrees just experience - we turned to each other and said 'brown out'. Then investigated the cause. Client is on the edge of town, last house on the power line, off the town water supply and uses a dam. Everytime smene uses water the pump kicks in to refill the pump, causing a drop in power supply. One UPS problem go away. None of the theory that the qualified techs knew helped them to recognise a 'brown out' restart.

2. Large corporate network with many servers in it. Some email headers get corrupted. Many qualified experts looking into problem could find a cause. Some were had CS degrees some had mnany certs in the software being used. It was quickly proven that the network cabling and design was not at fault. These expets PROVED it was nto the mail servers so it had to be the high security gateway (where I worked). We quickly proved it was not the gateway by checking all email before and after it hit the gateway, all OK at these to points but some wre still being corrupted by the time they got to the recipient.

Using my general knowledge and investigation skills I got full details of the corporate mail servers in the network. Then made a statement as to the cause. The qualified experts with all the theory declared I was wrong that there was no way I could be right as theory said it was impossible.

Some months later a top specialist was imported from the USA and proved that the corruption of the emails ike that was theoretically impossible; either the whole message should be corrupted or not at all with that system. After being appraised of my deductions he said that was theoretically impossibe too but set about proving me wrong. After proving I was right he made the changes I recommended then wote it all up for the company as a known new fault.

All versions of that software could used UUCP or SMTP for mail handling, the early versions used UUCP natively and needed special settings to handle SMTP. Later versions used both natively. This network used vesions from both before and after this change and sometimes the older software was not recognising the message was SMTP and processing the ehaders as UUCP. Theory said it made no difference, not being weded to theory I challenged that and povd it wrong. Upgrade all to the same version of software problem go away.

Quals only mean you have been taught in a classoom what others have learnt outside a classroom.

by cheerstork

Ernest, your points are very well taken! Nevertheless, why do you, and many others, imply that it is either or?!
You are comparing your decades (30+, I believe) of experience to the 5-year experience of a college graduate. How about comparing the 30+ years of experience to 30+years of experience AND a BSCS?!
I NEVER implied anywhere that one could just earn a degree and just bank on it and sit on their butt and wait for the steak served on the golden plate! Why do you seem to impliy that?
Another point, you might very well do better than that hypothetical peer with a 30+ and a degree. In my opinion, exceptions don't make rules! Yes, someone might graduate from college, but be a ver poor performer. Again, why assume that that would make the rule?
On the other hand, it's a fair assumption to say that someone with 30+ years of experience and a BSCS is, on average, and generally, and excluding exceptions, a better performer than one with only the 30+years.

I keep saying this and will say it ad infinitum: I was not particularly alluding to those who had been in the business for so many years; there properly were no computer departments in most colleges, then! Although, I thought that it would demonstrate a lot about the personality of the person, had they bothered to earn a relevant degree.
And, YES! College education teaches you a LOT!
Again, please, don't exclude the possibility that there might (jussssst might) be some folks out there who have the loooooong track of experience AND a Technical 4-year Degree.

by rob.perkins

I've read most of this thread and found everyone's thoughts quite interesting. Both sides have made extremely good points and I can definitely see the advantages of having a degree and the advantages of not having one. The thing I can't see is the disadvantages of either. True, experience is hard to beat in most cases, but it all depends on the person. I know a guy with 20+ years of "experience" in the IT field. Used to tell me stories all about the "old days", but I tell you what, this guy had the drive and ambition of a brick. After ALL his experience, he was working at a help desk, where I was just starting off getting my feet wet in the industry.

But, this also holds true to a person who went to a 4 year school for a Bachelor's degree. Trust me, I know some clowns who have degrees...scary. You guys all know one or two, where you say to yourself, "THAT guy has a Bachelor's??" So, as with ANY profession, it always depends on the individual.

Now, as to the point of a BSCS not being worth anything. Of course that isn't true. BUT, it does depend on the person, AND the company he is working at or trying to land a job with. Yes, there is favortism, nepotism, and choosing the "cheapest" candidate available. What I feel a Bachelors degree SHOULD show a company is the degree holder's willingness and ability to learn a particular field for 4 or more years! This shows dedication and "stick-to-it-ness" and coupled with good grades, shows that the degree holder really put forth his best effort. So, a degree SHOULD tell an employer that this guy is serious about the business, and has learned valuable skills from other subjects required to get the degree, not just the core courses, that makes the candidate extremely well-rounded.

I am finishing up a Bachelors in IT with an emphasis in Computer Systems (whatever that really means) in April. I am doing it more for myself to show that I can accomplish something like getting a college degree, and I hope that it will help me in my career in IT. Although, I am not soley relying on that piece of paper to get me where I need to be. I know I need to gain the experience as well. Having the degree is just another thing that shows my current and any future employers just how valuable I am to their company.

Anyways, great discussion guys! Sorry for the small book I just wrote. :-)

--
Rob Perkins

by cheerstork

"Now, as to the point of a BSCS not being worth anything. Of course that isn't true."

"Although, I am not soley relying on that piece of paper to get me where I need to be."

On the one hand, you say that a BSCS is worth it. On the other hand, you allude to it as that "piece of paper!"

I think that I know what you mean, but the way you put it could be easily exploited by those of the "degrees are just a piece of paper" rhetoric!

That "piece" of paper was not just printed on the spot; it took years and years to EARN.

"Although, I am not soley relying on that piece of paper to get me where I need to be. I know I need to gain the experience as well. Having the degree is just another thing that shows my current and any future employers just how valuable I am to their company."

Now, why is it not clear that YES, a degree alone is not everything, and that you don't just earn it and then sit on your behind?

A degree IS the good and great start and firm foundation upon which you base your experience and hard work!!

Don't try to make it sound as if a degree is just an optional track or an accessory. A doctor is required to earn a degree and some medical licenses to be allowd to operate. Having earned those licenses doesn't make them the best doctors. You still need the degree, though!

Again and agaaaaain: You can't even open a car repair shop, unless you are a licensed mechanic. Nevertheless, somehow, any average Joe is a "Programmer" "Network Admin" "Systems Architect" ...
I, too, had MORE than enough knowledge and certification to call myself a programmer many years ago. However, I decided that it was the professional and right way of conducting business was to validate my knowledge with an accredited 4-year degree.

by hellums

If two people are virtually the same and one has a degree, odds are that additional knowledge will come in handy in one way or another.

It's not critical the person have a degree, only the required experience or skills (however obtained). They can't "venture into the market" and take jobs from people that have specialized skills. But give them credit if they picked up those skills on their own.

Why can a psyche major get a geek job, but not vice versa? Simple--PCs and technology are pervasive in virtually every area of society, including at home. The odds of the psychologist being a good techie are good, whereas the odds of a techie picking up a good bit of psychology are VERY slim. If they have a good technical background and excellent management skills, no reason they shouldn't be your boss (especially if you have great technical skills but poor management potential).

Even if you have better management skills, an employer is better off leaving you technical and hiring a techie psychologist manager. If it were your company, would you promote the techie at the risk of not having anyone to put in the tech position (especially the psychologist)?

Shouldn't there be a criterion for computer positions--just as there are ones for most other professions?!

Don't confuse software/systems "engineering" with Civil/Electrical/Mechanical engineering. Two totally different things.

The BSCS person is going to be placed where they provide the most value, even if it's for less pay. The degree just implies a general set of skills. If it were your company, would you pay the programmer with a MS more than the BS? Odds are they're doing the same job, with the same efficiency. If there's a position that requires the MS skill set, then they can compete for that.

My suggestion? Lose the bitterness :) If you feel you're not competitive, figure out what skills the other person has, acquire those skills, and market yourself for those jobs (in your company or another). That includes tailoring your resume for that skill set too, not leaving all that technical stuff in there and then becoming bewildered by the fact that the new employer tries to covey hole you into the same position you used to be in. Fight for the job you want, but own the responsibility for what you get--it's not someone else's fault, or their responsibility. If you can't get the job you want, or the pay you want, the first step is accepting the blame for it, and the next step is doing something about it.

Best of luck! Hang in there.